--- slug: each-devouring-the-tail-of-another passed: 2026-11-16 by: one agent on oversight/claims-pass.md for the whole source record and the page, dispatched by claude-epic-gates-wpqedf, who re-read each finding against its source before fixing checked: 284 confirmed: 194 wrong: 13 unverifiable: 1 observed: 76 stale: 0 --- The pass checked commit 749d9bb (227 record entries) plus 20 claims the record left out, after running scripts/robots-policy.mjs on every URL it fetched (no refusals; two reference-tier hosts read once). It recomputed the census from catalogue.json (59 cards, 0 differences in form, date, title, quotation, translation or citation), every figure of the pit and the strings by its own code, and the five earliest securely dated Egyptian witnesses; it found the verdicts on P1 to P5 and H1 to H3 follow the registration's own words. All 18 MINOR lines are counted as confirmed. **The pictures pass (2026-11-16, later the same day).** The page gained public-domain and openly licensed pictures, each with an apparatus of where it comes from. One agent on oversight/claims-pass.md, who did not make them, looked at every picture against its caption, its alt text, the catalogue witness and the provenance record, and read the rights of 37 pictures again at 30 sources (robots policy first). Its first report found fifteen things; all were fixed, a re-check found each fixed and three small new points, which were fixed, and a final check of the last commit confirmed them. The lines below the earlier ones are that pass: one per entry the pictures added to assay/sources, and the first pass's wrong and near-miss findings that were not marked claims. ## Claims - OBSERVED | We wrote down what would count before reading a single source | git show 0afcbba --stat (0afcbba 00:08:41Z adds PREREGISTRATION.md; first logged fetch 00:20:55Z (provinces/*/robots.tsv)) | [c001] registration precedes every fetch - OBSERVED | Rings of several serpents are real, in traditions that never met. | recreated: census from catalogue (59, 0 differences) | [c002-1] Susa, Moundville, Meigle are plural serpent rings in unconnected traditions - CONFIRMED | Rings of several serpents are real, in traditions that never met. | https://archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre/page/n105_w1400.jpg | [c002-2] Harper et al. 1992 p.85 (page image viewed by me): "two intertwined serpents with their tails in their mouths" - CONFIRMED | Rings of several serpents are real, in traditions that never met. | https://archive.org/download/artinshellofanci00holm/page/n171_w2200.jpg | [c002-3] Holmes 1883 p.278 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me); genuineness doubt of 1883 withdrawn by 1905 (Moore p.137) - MINOR | Rings of several serpents are real, in traditions that never met. | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | [c002-4] excerpt verbatim (page image viewed by me); but the ring is pig, cock and one snake (catalogue: "S2 by analogy only"), so it does not support "several serpents"; the claim stands on Susa and Moundville - OBSERVED | But the oldest securely dated rings are single snakes, no early text describes the woven knot, and the first writers we found who read the … | research/ouroboros/SYNTHESIS-NOTES.md (07 and P3 notes) | [c003-1] notes record Flamel 1612 and Maier 1618 as the first readings of the single ring as plural; nothing earlier in the catalogue does so - CONFIRMED | But the oldest securely dated rings are single snakes, no early text describes the woven knot, and the first writers we found who read the … | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | [c003-2] Flamel 1612 p.68 (page image viewed by me), verbatim - CONFIRMED | But the oldest securely dated rings are single snakes, no early text describes the woven knot, and the first writers we found who read the … | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | [c003-3] Maier 1618 p.66 (page image viewed by me), verbatim; "this dragon" = the tail-devouring dragon - CONFIRMED | This page tests an idea about it, put to the site by the person who keeps it: that the emblem is a fairly poor visual representation of an … | research/ouroboros/COMMISSION.md | [c004] COMMISSION.md and PREREGISTRATION.md (00:08:41Z) quote the same words - OBSERVED | So before a single source was opened, the idea was written down as three claims the record could bear out or not, with five predictions and… | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md at 0afcbba/9e72cfd | [c005] three readings, five predictions, fixed verdict words; committed before any fetch - OBSERVED | Then eighteen Claude agents, each holding one province of the record, read it in the original languages where they could, from a spell carv… | research/ouroboros/provinces/*/PROGRESS.md; briefs/continuation.md | [c006] 18 provinces; after the 00:35 stop the "same agent resumed with context intact" - MINOR | Every ring the agents found was sorted into one of eight forms, fixed in the registration before they began. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json (form.category) | [c007] eight forms fixed before launch (true), but a few rings were left between two forms or open: "S1 or S0" x2, "S3 ... or S4", "S5 with the rings interlinked ... S4 or S6", "S2?" x3, "contested", "unknown" - CONFIRMED | Whatever chance does, the snakes end up in closed rings: follow any snake to the one whose tail it holds, then to the one whose tail that o… | https://algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/book.pdf | [c008] Flajolet-Sedgewick p.120 (kept; PDF text 79% six-word runs, hyphenation) - CONFIRMED | The number of rings is on average 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + … + 1/n, the harmonic number, which grows only like the logarithm of n: a pit of a thousa… | https://algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/book.pdf | [c009-1] F&S p.160 (kept; PDF FOUND); H_1000 = 7.4855 recomputed - CONFIRMED | The number of rings is on average 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + … + 1/n, the harmonic number, which grows only like the logarithm of n: a pit of a thousa… | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; recreated: my exact recomputation | [c009-2] engine harmonic(n) agrees; verifier A2 to n=60 - CONFIRMED | The emblem’s own ring, one snake with its own tail, turns up on average exactly once, whatever the size of the pit: each snake takes its ow… | https://algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/book.pdf | [c010] F&S p.175: mean number of r-cycles is 1/r, so 1 for r=1 (PDF FOUND) - WRONG | And one ring is nearly always far bigger than the rest. The largest holds, on average, a share of the snakes that settles towards 0.6243, t… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/1303.1856 | [c011-1] limit 0.6243 and Shepp-Lloyd 1966 confirmed (Lagarias Thm 3.10.2, PDF read). "nearly always far bigger than the rest" is not: exact, 12 snakes: largest holds more than half 65.3% of nights, at least twice the next 66.7%, at least 1.5x the next 78.5% (strictly bigger than the next 92.9%); n=60: 68.5%/63.2%/77.1%; limit for "more than half" ln 2 = 0.693 (F&S p.176, kept) - CONFIRMED | And one ring is nearly always far bigger than the rest. The largest holds, on average, a share of the snakes that settles towards 0.6243, t… | https://oeis.org/A084945/internal | [c011-2] OEIS A084945 digits 0.62432998...; "Golomb-Dickman constant" (FOUND online). "nearly always" clause: see c011-1 - CONFIRMED | Pieces of string have two ends alike, and any end can be tied to any end. Tie them at random and the pit makes fewer loops, 1 + 1/3 + 1/5 +… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0408031 | [c012-1] Pippenger p.3 (PDF read): expected cycles of a cyclation = sum 1/(2m-1); the formula itself was trimmed from the kept copy. Brute force n<=6 and recursion n<=60 agree with engine - CONFIRMED | Pieces of string have two ends alike, and any end can be tied to any end. Tie them at random and the pit makes fewer loops, 1 + 1/3 + 1/5 +… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0408031 | [c012-2] Pippenger p.2: 2^(n-1)(n-1)!/(2n-1)!!; n=8 gives 2048/6435 = 0.318 - CONFIRMED | Pieces of string have two ends alike, and any end can be tied to any end. Tie them at random and the pit makes fewer loops, 1 + 1/3 + 1/5 +… | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; recreated: my brute force and recursion | [c012-3] engine rope figures right for n=1..60 (not recomputed by the verifier except n=8) - CONFIRMED | Nicholas Pippenger, who worked both out side by side, called the string version random cyclations. | https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0408031 | [c013-1] Pippenger abstract (PDF, 60% runs, hyphenation): random pairing of interval ends - CONFIRMED | Nicholas Pippenger, who worked both out side by side, called the string version random cyclations. | https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0408031 | [c013-2] Pippenger p.1: oriented version gives permutations; worked side by side - CONFIRMED | Nicholas Pippenger, who worked both out side by side, called the string version random cyclations. | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.37236/3643 | [c013-3] Crossref: "Random Cyclations", Pippenger, EJC 20(4) P9 (2013) - CONFIRMED | Where two tracks cross, the strand either goes over and then under in turn, as in a plait, a basket’s rim or the sailor’s Turk’s head knot,… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106 | [c014-1] Di Prisa-Savk p.5: Th(p,q) alternating (PDF FOUND); "basket rim" is decoration - CONFIRMED | Where two tracks cross, the strand either goes over and then under in turn, as in a plait, a basket’s rim or the sailor’s Turk’s head knot,… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106 | [c014-2] Di Prisa-Savk p.2 torus links; coil weaves checked against torus-knot Alexander polynomials by the verifier - CONFIRMED | The readout counts the closed strands, which always number the greatest common divisor of tracks and repeats. | https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106 | [c015-1] Di Prisa-Savk p.2: gcd(p,q) components; verifier C checks all 168 weaves - CONFIRMED | The readout counts the closed strands, which always number the greatest common divisor of tracks and repeats. | https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106 | [c015-2] same - CONFIRMED | It names the knot from the table of all 249 prime knots of up to ten crossings that this site checked for another layer | public/strata/.../knots.json; research/perko-pair/data/census.json | [c016] 249 knots: 1,1,2,3,7,21,49,165 by crossing number; cut exactly from perko-pair census (verifier D, in-repo) - CONFIRMED | Three tracks plaited twice round make the figure-eight knot; three times round, the Borromean rings; four times, the knot 818; five times, … | https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106 | [c017-1] Di Prisa-Savk p.15: Th(3,2)=4_1, Th(3,4)=8_18, Th(3,5)=10_123 (PDF FOUND); Th(3,3) = Borromean rings by the engine and verifier - CONFIRMED | Three tracks plaited twice round make the figure-eight knot; three times round, the Borromean rings; four times, the knot 818; five times, … | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; recreated: verifier run | [c017-2] engine identifies all four (verifier E) - CONFIRMED | The Borromean rings are the strangest member of the family. Three snakes, each with its own tail, can be woven so that no two of them are l… | https://archive.org/details/proceedings1318841886roya | [c018] Crum Brown p.383 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - CONFIRMED | The chemist Alexander Crum Brown gave them their name in 1885, in a footnote saying the rings occur in the armorial bearings of the Italian… | https://archive.org/details/proceedings1318841886roya | [c019] footnote verbatim (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me); paper read Monday 7 December 1885 (Proc. RSE 13 contents) - CONFIRMED | These are exactly the things a mathematician uses to tell woven rings apart: how many strands there are, the knot of each, and how they are… | https://arxiv.org/pdf/1103.4222 | [c020-1] linking number as invariant (Micheletti et al. p.71, PDF FOUND); component count and knot types are standard; "which snake is which" is not an invariant, a loose mapping - CONFIRMED | These are exactly the things a mathematician uses to tell woven rings apart: how many strands there are, the knot of each, and how they are… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linking_number | [c020-2] Wikipedia "Linking number" (FOUND) - MINOR | The census holds 59 witnesses: 27 of form S2, 5 of S3, 22 of S4 and 5 of S7. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; recreated: node census-check.mjs on catalogue.json at 749d9bb | [c021-1] counts right (59: 27/5/22/5); but the 27 S2 include three texts the catalogue marks "S2?" ("Words do not say tails or ring"), while the registration counts a text "only by what its words say" - OBSERVED | The census holds 59 witnesses: 27 of form S2, 5 of S3, 22 of S4 and 5 of S7. | recreated: same | [c021-2] DUPLICATES (2) excluded correctly - CONFIRMED | The registration set a positive control: if the alchemical figures of two beasts biting each other’s tails exist, the same search must find… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n14_w1400.jpg | [c022-1] Eleazar 1735 part 2 plate N.3 (page image viewed by me): winged crowned dragon's mouth holds the wingless one's tail and vice versa - OBSERVED | The registration set a positive control: if the alchemical figures of two beasts biting each other’s tails exist, the same search must find… | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md (positive control) | [c022-2] control as registered; met (Eleazar N1, N3, Clavis Artis, Senior birds) - CONFIRMED | The oldest object in the census is a bitumen plaque from the temple of Ninhursag at Susa, in Elam, where two intertwined serpents with thei… | https://archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre/page/n105_w1400.jpg | [c023-1] Harper et al. p.85 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | The oldest object in the census is a bitumen plaque from the temple of Ninhursag at Susa, in Elam, where two intertwined serpents with thei… | https://archive.org/details/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre | [c023-2] p.86 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 67% runs): "on the basis of the treatment of the two main figures" - CONFIRMED | The oldest object in the census is a bitumen plaque from the temple of Ninhursag at Susa, in Elam, where two intertwined serpents with thei… | https://archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre/page/n105_w1400.jpg | [c023-3] heading "Acropole, temple of Ninhursag; Sb 2724" (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | Paul Toscanne, drawing it in 1911, wrote of deux serpents enlacés qui se mordent la queue, which can mean each its own tail or each the oth… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n230_w1400.jpg | [c024-1] Toscanne p.207 (page image viewed by me); "se mordent la queue" is reflexive or reciprocal - OBSERVED | Paul Toscanne, drawing it in 1911, wrote of deux serpents enlacés qui se mordent la queue, which can mean each its own tail or each the oth… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/dossier.md F8, F17 | [c024-2] tracing of Toscanne fig. 394, four crossings, own tails, medium confidence - CONFIRMED | Sigmund Oehrl counts it among the earliest true ouroboroi. | https://archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-altertum/page/n10_w1400.jpg | [c025] Oehrl 2013 p.455 (page image viewed by me); identity with Sb 2724 is by description (dossier: "very probably") - CONFIRMED | From the same site, a small undated terracotta table has serpents round a rosette, and l’un d’eux mord la queue de l’autre: one of them bit… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n241_w1400.jpg | [c026] Toscanne p.218 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | In Scotland, a carved stone at Meigle has three serpents bent round spirally, so that each serpent bites the tail of the next one to it. | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c027] Allen 1903 p.304 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - CONFIRMED | On the foot of the Tassilo chalice, at Kremsmünster, three snakes form a triquetra and, in Oehrl’s words, sich gegenseitig in die Schwanzsp… | https://archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-altertum/page/n15_w1400.jpg | [c028] Oehrl p.460 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | At the hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life, as Waddell described it in 1892, a pig, a cock and a snake each hold the next one’s tail. | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | [c029] Waddell 1892 p.136 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | In the Americas, a stone disk from the Black Warrior River in Alabama has two horned rattlesnakes knotted, forming a circle | https://archive.org/download/certainaborigin00moor/page/n19_w2400.jpg | [c030] Moore 1905 p.136 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 88% runs) - CONFIRMED | and on the Aztec Sun Stone two serpents run round the rim from a square at the top to the bottom, where their two heads meet. | https://archive.org/download/fundamentalprinc00nutt/page/n260_w1500.jpg | [c031-1] Nuttall 1901 p.257 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 78% runs) - CONFIRMED | and on the Aztec Sun Stone two serpents run round the rim from a square at the top to the bottom, where their two heads meet. | https://archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n112_w1800.jpg | [c031-2] León y Gama p.103 (kept transcription; OCR garbled, image not viewed) - CONFIRMED | And in American newspapers from the 1830s to the 1950s, the plural ring is a joke: two snakes that seized each others’ tails and devoured a… | https://archive.org/download/sim_maine-farmer_1839-12-21_7_50/page/n0.jpg | [c032-1] Maine Farmer 21 Dec 1839 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me: "snakes that seized each others' tails and devoured all of both bodies but the head") - CONFIRMED | And in American newspapers from the 1830s to the 1950s, the plural ring is a joke: two snakes that seized each others’ tails and devoured a… | https://archive.org/download/hope-star-1951-08-09/page/n0_w1400.jpg | [c032-2] Hope Star 9 Aug 1951 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | Real tail-in-mouth rings, the herpetologists’ reports we read, are always one animal. | research/ouroboros/SYNTHESIS-NOTES.md, 14 notes | [c033] "Real tail-in-mouth: always one animal; four autophagy notes" - OBSERVED | ca. 2600-2500 BC (Harper, Aruz and Tallon 1992); Toscanne 1911: not dated; Mundkur 1983 (ca. 3500 BC) and Oehrl 2013 (3000 BC) reported by … | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c034] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | tous deux sont fortement musclés et lèvent le bras à hauteur de la tête, comme pour soutenir les deux serpents enlacés qui se mordent la qu… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n230_w1400.jpg | [c035] excerpt in kept copy, supports claim - OBSERVED | early 5th century BCE (museum); Chinese Bronze Age (Eastern Zhou) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c036] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | "objectDate": "early 5th century BCE" | https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/44518 | [c037] Met API object 44518 (FOUND online) - OBSERVED | 1st century AD; Roman natural history (on Gallic Druids) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c038] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | angues enim numerose convoluti salivis faucium corporumque spumis artifici conplexu glomerant; urinum appellatur. For snakes, coiled togeth… | https://archive.org/download/cplinisecundina01mayhgoog/page/n402_w1400.jpg | [c039] Mayhoff p.386 (page image viewed by me) - OBSERVED | 'originally created c. 700' (Commons description, not checked); Insular manuscript illumination | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c040] date line = catalogue date + tradition - OBSERVED | Five fields of animal interlace round a roundel of plain knotwork. Horizontal bands: long-jawed beasts with round eyes, broad red or yellow… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c041] agent's description of a picture, as the card says; image not re-viewed - OBSERVED | probably 777 (Oehrl: the chalice 'dürfte' be a gift for the foundation of Kremsmünster in 777); Anglo-Carolingian animal style (insular and… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c042] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Als eine Art Uroboros-Variante könnte auch eine Triquetra am Fuß des Kelches angesprochen werden. Sie wird von drei Schlangen gebildet, die… | https://archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-altertum/page/n15_w1400.jpg | [c043] Oehrl p.460 (page image viewed by me) - OBSERVED | 10th century (composition); Arabic alchemy | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c044] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | abgeschnitten, der andere besass beide Flügel, und jeder der beiden Vögel fasste mit seinem Schnabel den Schwanz des anderen, ihn packend, … | https://archive.org/details/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2 | [c045] Ruska 1936 p.313 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, umlauts damaged) - OBSERVED | Voluspa disputed (Bellows: middle of the 10th century); Snorri about 1220-1225; manuscripts about 1300 and later; Old Norse Eddic poetry an… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c046] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | for that hall was woven with serpents' backs. | https://archive.org/details/elderorpoeticedd01brayuoft | [c047] Bray 1908 p.289 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | early 14th century (composition of the Inferno); medieval Italian literary vision (Dante, Commedia) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c048] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | con serpi le man dietro avean legate; quelle ficcavan per le ren la coda e ’l capo, ed eran dinanzi aggroppate. they had their hands tied b… | https://it.wikisource.org/wiki/Divina_Commedia/Inferno/Canto_XXIV | [c049] it.wikisource Inferno XXIV (FOUND online) - OBSERVED | 739 H / 1339, probably Baghdad (as the Commons file page gives it); Arabic alchemy (painted manuscript) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c050] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | The lower right shows two birds top is male facing right, bottom female facing left, they signify "two in one". | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ibn_Umayl_The_Silvery_Water.jpg | [c051] Commons file page (fetched by me): sentence and "739H/1339, probably in Baghdad" present - OBSERVED | Mississippian (by style); found 1870; published by Holmes 1906; Mississippian (lower Mississippi valley), Southeastern Ceremonial Complex | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c052] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | On one face is engraved in shallow lines the representation of two interlocked rattlesnakes with heads in reversed order, facing the center… | https://archive.org/details/jstor-659168 | [c053] Holmes 1906 p.104 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | Mississippian; about AD 1300-1450 according to secondary web pages (not read as sources); first published 1883; Mississippian (Moundville, … | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c054] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | while on the other there is a well-engraved design which represents two entwined or rather knotted rattlesnakes. | https://archive.org/download/artinshellofanci00holm/page/n171_w2200.jpg | [c055] as c002-3 - OBSERVED | pre-Hispanic (no date given); published 1904; Pre-Hispanic north-western Argentina (Calchaquí region bronze) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c056] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | La cara externa presenta, dentro de una zona formada por dos líneas que deja el centro del disco libre, á dos serpientes gruesas onduladas … | https://archive.org/download/arqueologaargen01ambrgoog/page/n132_w1400.jpg | [c057] Ambrosetti 1904 p.288 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | 15th century; Latin alchemy (illuminated manuscript) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c058] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Parchment · 100 ff. · 20.4 x 13.9 cm · St. Gall · 15th century | https://www.e-codices.unifr.ch/en/list/one/zbz/Ms-Rh-0172 | [c059] e-codices page (fetched by me): caption present - OBSERVED | 15th century (Druce); English church carving (as described by Druce 1910) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c060] date line = catalogue date + tradition - MINOR | In the middle are two with their bodies crossed. | https://archive.org/download/amphisbaena-images/amphisbaena-images_djvu.txt | [c061] words confirmed in the item's OCR at archive.org/download/amphisbaena-images/Amphisbaena_djvu.txt (200); the record's and page's source URL .../amphisbaena-images_djvu.txt returns 404 - OBSERVED | pre-Hispanic (date not given in the sources read); facsimile 1898; commentary 1906; Central Mexican (Borgia group), pre-Hispanic | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c062] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Ueber dieser Feuererzeugung sieht man ein von einer weissen (rothgestreiften), einer gelben, einer blauen, einer rothen Feuerschlange gebil… | https://archive.org/details/codex-borgia_20220902 | [c063] Seler 1906 p.75 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | pre-conquest Mexica (carving date not established from a source read); found in Mexico City's main square in 1790; Mexica (Aztec), Tenochti… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c064] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | One point about the twin serpents is clear; they are represented as springing from a square enclosing the symbol Acatl accompanied by 13 wh… | https://archive.org/download/fundamentalprinc00nutt/page/n260_w1500.jpg | [c065] as c031-1 - OBSERVED | 16th century, undated edition (Ruska: 'ohne Angabe von Drucker und Jahr'); Latin alchemy (printed illustration of an Arabic text) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c066] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | ohne Angabe von Drucker und Jahr without indication of printer and year | https://archive.org/download/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2/page/n10_w1400.jpg | [c067] Ruska pp.315-316 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me): "ohne Angabe von Drucker und [p.316] Jahr" - OBSERVED | printed 1612; French alchemy (printed under Nicolas Flamel's name) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c068] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Celuy, dit Haly, qui en tuera l'vn, il tuera aussi l'autre, parce que l'vn ne peut mourir qu'auec sõ frere. He who kills one of them, says … | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n70_w1400.jpg | [c069] Flamel p.69 (kept; same transcriber exact on p.68; OCR poor) - OBSERVED | 1612; French alchemy (printed illustration) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c070] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Their heads meet in the middle of the cut, mouths open, each biting at the other's head or jaw. No tail is in any mouth. | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | [c071] woodcut p.68 (page image viewed by me): heads bite heads, no tail in a mouth - OBSERVED | printed 1622 (Theatrum chemicum V); first printed in Ars chemica, Strasbourg 1566 (not verified here); date of composition not established;… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c072] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Prima sphæra ex duabus auibus pectoribus inclinatis: quarum vna habebat alas abscissas scilicet masculus: alia vero super istam erat alata … | https://archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n523_w1400.jpg | [c073] TC V p.495 (page image viewed by me) - OBSERVED | composition 10th century (Ibn Umayl); this witness printed 1622; Arabic alchemy in Latin translation | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c074] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | imago duarum avium in inferiore parte ejus pectore inclinato, quarum avium una habebat alas abscissas, & altera habens alas duas, & utraque… | https://archive.org/details/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05 | [c075] TC V p.219 (kept; page image not fetched; OCR of 1622 Latin unusable) - OBSERVED | composition 10th century; printed 1622; Arabic alchemy in Latin translation | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c076] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Et radix huius aquæ sunt ambæ aves colligatæ, quarum utraque retinet caudam alterius, & radix harum avium est luna plena, & hæc est Magnesi… | https://archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n252_w1400.jpg | [c077] TC V leaf n252 (page image viewed by me) - OBSERVED | 1622 (this printing); Latin alchemy (printed illustration of an Arabic text) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c078] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Left leaf of the tablet: two disks above, a ring-shaped figure made of two animal bodies in the middle, one disk below. | https://archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n244_w1400.jpg | [c079] agent description of the woodcut on leaf n244 (kept; image downloaded, not re-described) - OBSERVED | 1678 (Latin text and plate seen); 1893 (Waite); Latin alchemy (emblematic tract, engraving) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c080] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | In qua duæ aves sunt colligatæ: Vna est colore albissimo, altera rubro, Hæ se invicem mordendo interimunt, in which two birds are bound tog… | https://archive.org/download/musaeumhermeticu00meri/page/n373_w1400.jpg | [c081] Musaeum hermeticum p.356 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, damaged but legible) - OBSERVED | 1735; German alchemy (printed engraving) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c082] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | die flüchtige Schlange wird die Fixe fressen, und wird aus beyden ein feuriger kriechender Drache werden. the volatile serpent will eat the… | https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb10912551_00057/full/900,/0/default.jpg | [c083] Eleazar part 1 p.17 (kept; BSB image not viewed) - OBSERVED | 1735; German alchemy (printed engraving) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c084] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Upper right: a dragon with two feathered wings, two clawed legs and a crown; its open mouth holds the tail of the second dragon. | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n14_w1400.jpg | [c085] as c022-1 - OBSERVED | 1738 (Commons); German alchemy (illuminated manuscript) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c086] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Immagine del manoscritto Zoroaster Clavis Artis, MS. Verginelli-Rota, Biblioteca dell'Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma, vol. 2, p. 18 D… | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Rota.V2.018.jpg | [c087] Commons file page (fetched by me): text and "Date 1738" present - OBSERVED | 1776; Welsh folk belief, recorded by a naturalist | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c088] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Our modern Druidesses give much the same account of the ovum anguinum, Glain Neidr, as the Welch call it, or the Adder-Gem, as the Roman ph… | https://archive.org/download/britishzoology31penn/page/n49_w1400.jpg | [c089] Pennant 1776 p.32 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, long s) - OBSERVED | reported 1833 (object undated); Mexican (Aztec), as reported in 1833 | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c090] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | But the most remarkable of all is the Mexican symbol. Here the two serpents, intertwining, form the circle with their own bodies, and in th… | https://archive.org/download/worshipofserpent00dean/page/n79_w1400.jpg | [c091] Deane 1833 p.54 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | April 1835; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c092] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Really this exceeds the story of the two vipers, which, in a violent contest, swallowed each other entire, so that nothing was left of eith… | https://archive.org/download/sim_methodist-review_1835-04_17_2/page/n89_w1400.jpg | [c093] Methodist Magazine Apr 1835 p.210 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | 21 December 1839; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c094] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | it is well known that they would soon neutralize each others power, like the two snakes that seized each others' tails and devoured all of … | https://archive.org/download/sim_maine-farmer_1839-12-21_7_50/page/n0.jpg | [c095] as c032-1 - OBSERVED | made before June 1847 (claimed by the Count as his late wife's mother's); platinum jewellery argued in court to be of 1810 or later; 19th-c… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c096] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Außer diesem Stück Gold hatte er noch bei sich ein Armband aus verschlungenen Goldfäden mit einem sogenannten gordischen Knoten, die golden… | https://archive.org/download/derneuepitavale10vollgoog/page/n187_w1400.jpg | [c097] Pitaval 1860 p.169 (kept; Fraktur OCR 23%, not verified online) - OBSERVED | 18 February 1848; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c098] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | nor should we greatly mourn if they should illustrate the story of the Kilkenny cats, or that better one of the snakes which entirely swall… | https://archive.org/download/sim_anti-slavery-bugle_1848-02-18_3_27/page/n2_w1400.jpg | [c099] Anti-Slavery Bugle (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 95% runs) - OBSERVED | 7 October 1871; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c100] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Each snake had commenced swallowing the other's tail, and they continued the operation until their heads met. | https://archive.org/download/sim_appletons-journal-a-magazine-of-general-literature_1871-10-07_6_132/page/n26_w1400.jpg | [c101] Appletons' Journal p.419 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | 1886 (session dated 20 September 1886; article signed 'Im Mai 1886'); 19th-century chemistry (German), parody | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c102] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Denkt man sich nun eine Gruppe von sechs Angehörigen dieser Familie, z. B. Macacus cynocephalus, welche unter sich einen Ring bilden, indem… | https://archive.org/download/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft/InternetArchiveBerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaftDankHarvard-googleAu… | [c103] Durstige PDF text (fetched; OCR variants, words present) - OBSERVED | 1886 (session dated 20 September 1886; article signed 'Im Mai 1886'); 19th-century chemistry (German), parody | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c104] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Nun aber besitzt der genannte Macacus cynocephalus ausser seinen eigentlichen vier Händen noch ein fünftes Greifwerkzeug in Form eines caud… | https://archive.org/download/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft/InternetArchiveBerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaftDankHarvard-googleAu… | [c105] same - OBSERVED | December 1887; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c106] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Suppose three snakes, each of which is swallowing another by the tail, so that the three form a circle—then, as the swallowing process cont… | https://archive.org/download/sim_temple-bar_1887-12_81_325/page/n79_w1400.jpg | [c107] Temple Bar p.484 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | 1892 (publication); describes Tibetan paintings current in his time; Tibetan Buddhist (Wheel of Life, bhavacakra), as reported by a British… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c108] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | The three original sins or 'chief Causes of Demerit' are depicted as (1) a pig which has hold of the tail of (2) a cock which has hold of t… | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | [c109] as c029 - OBSERVED | 1895 (plate); the Tibetan painting it reproduces is undated (Waddell: 'alleged ... to be a copy of one brought to Tibet by the Indian monk … | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c110] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | The broad tire is occupied by the Causal Nexus, and the nave by the three vices or delusions, "The Daughters of Desire," the three vices—Rā… | https://archive.org/download/cu31924023203288/page/n138_w1400.jpg | [c111] Waddell 1895 p.109 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 86% runs) - OBSERVED | c. 1931/32 (book's preface dated December 1931); English recreational mathematics (puzzle books) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c112] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | lowing one another simultaneously, each getting the tail of the other in its mouth, so that the circle formed by the snakes becomes smaller… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.19463/page/n116_w1400.jpg | [c113] Dudeney (kept; no OCR file; image downloaded, not viewed) - OBSERVED | June 1948 (told by Mrs. Louis Winkler from her grandfather George Washington Swearingen); American oral tall tale (folklorist's record) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c114] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | I was walking along one day, saw two snakes in a fight. I stopped to watch. All at once they swallowed each other—nothing left but a blue f… | https://archive.org/download/hoosier-folklore-june-1948/page/n24_w1400.jpg | [c115] Hoosier Folklore p.55 (page image viewed by me) - OBSERVED | 9 August 1951; American tall tale (prospector's yarn in a syndicated column) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c116] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Finally they all just swallowed each other up—and the circle disappeared. | https://archive.org/download/hope-star-1951-08-09/page/n0_w1400.jpg | [c117] as c032-2 - OBSERVED | English 1955 (The Mysteries) and 1958 (CW 11); German 'Das Wandlungssymbol in der Messe' as revised in Von den Wurzeln des Bewusstseins, Zu… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c118] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Mostly the pictures show two lions eating one another. The uroboros, too, is often pictured in the form of two dragons engaged in the same … | https://archive.org/services/search/beta/page_production/?service_backend=fts&user_query=%22often%20pictured%20in%20the%20form%20of%20two%20dragons%2… | [c119] archive.org full-text search (fetched): same sentence in five printings 1955-1963 - OBSERVED | March 1961; modern art (M. C. Escher) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c120] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | And yet apparently it consists of one single strip, made up of three fish, each biting the tail of the one in front. They go round twice be… | https://escherinhetpaleis.nl/escher-today/mobius-strip-i/?lang=en | [c121] Escher in Het Paleis page (FOUND online) - OBSERVED | July 1969; modern art (M. C. Escher) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c122] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Snakes. July 1969, Woodcut, printed from three blocks. | https://mcescher.com/gallery/most-popular/ | [c123] mcescher.com caption (kept; the live page builds its text by script, so the fetch could not show it) - OBSERVED | September 1979; modern literature (Michael Ende) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c124] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | ein großes goldenes Amulett, auf dem zwei Schlangen zu sehen waren, eine helle und eine dunkle, die einander in den Schwanz bissen und ein … | https://archive.org/services/search/beta/page_production/?service_backend=fts&user_query=%22eine%20helle%20und%20eine%20dunkle%22%20Oval&hits_per_pag… | [c125] archive.org full-text search (fetched): snippet "sehen waren, eine helle und eine dunkle, die einander in den Schwanz bissen und ein Oval bildeten. Bastian" attests the ending; the kept copy lacks that snippet (its assembly looks spliced from another sentence with "so ein Oval") - OBSERVED | 1984; modern film (Wolfgang Petersen, 1984) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c126] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Das Amulett besteht aus zwei Schlangen (eine silberne und eine goldene), die einander umschlingen und in die Schwänze beißen. The amulet co… | https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Die_unendliche_Geschichte_(Film) | [c127] de.wikipedia (FOUND online); a tertiary description - OBSERVED | field seasons May 1997 and May 1998 (Shine et al. 2000); published 2000-2001; modern herpetology (observed behaviour) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c128] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Most courtship and mating occur in small groups (‘mating balls’) consisting of one animal being courted plus several suitors. | https://masonlab.ib.oregonstate.edu/sites/masonlab.ib.oregonstate.edu/files/044transvestiteserpent.pdf | [c129] Shine et al. 2000 PDF (reference tier; FOUND; deleted after reading) - OBSERVED | README as fetched 2026-11-16; first version 'for Ubuntu 13.04' (50 languages); computing (programming curiosities) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c130] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | It explains how to write a quine, an ascii-art quine, and an uroboros quine like this quine-relay. | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | [c131] quine-relay README (FOUND online) - OBSERVED | not given in what I read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c132] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails and their bodies forming knot No. 250 (as also at Cossins). | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c133] Allen 1903 p.312 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | not given in what I read; Insular sculpture (Iona, Scotland) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c134] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | three pairs of beasts (biting each other's tails, which are twisted together), arranged one pair below the other | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c135] Allen 1903 p.382 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me) - OBSERVED | not given in what I read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c136] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | a pair of beasts placed symmetrically facing each other, with their bodies crossed, and biting each other's tails. | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c137] Allen 1903 p.224 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 85% runs) - OBSERVED | not given in what I read; Allen places it among the symbol-bearing (Class II) monuments; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c138] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | three serpents arranged symmetrically, with their heads at angles of 120° apart and their bodies bent round spirally, so that each serpent … | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c139] as c027 - OBSERVED | not dated in what I read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c140] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | After innumerable crossings under and over, the tails again diverge at three other points round the base of the boss, and finally terminate… | https://archive.org/details/cu31924030654879 | [c141] Allen 1904 p.293 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 85% runs) - OBSERVED | not dated in what I read; Anglo-Saxon metalwork (Germanic Style II) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c142] date line = catalogue date + tradition - OBSERVED | Interlaced ribbon bodies stippled with niello cover the plate round three domed bosses; at least five heads with round eyes at the peripher… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c143] agent's description of a picture, as the card says; image not re-viewed - OBSERVED | not dated in what I read; Viking-Age runestone (Sweden) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c144] date line = catalogue date + tradition - OBSERVED | A pink rune-band round the edge; inside, a large pink beast with long jaws and lappet, a pink serpent in figure-of-eight loops, and thin wh… | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c145] agent's description of a picture, as the card says; image not re-viewed - OBSERVED | Saturnalia: date of composition not yet sourced in this dossier; Latin antiquarian writing (claims an Egyptian origin) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c146] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | Mercurio consecrandum. Hi dracones parte media voluminis sui invicem nodo quem vocant Herculis obligantur, primaeque partes eorum reflexae … | https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Macrobius/Saturnalia/1*.html | [c147] LacusCurtius Saturnalia 1.19.16 (FOUND online) - OBSERVED | found 1898; "Il n'est pas daté" (Toscanne 1911); Elamite (Susa) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c148] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | deux énormes serpents servent de rebords à la table et en font ainsi une sorte de longue cuvette au bassin plat. two enormous serpents serv… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n240_w1400.jpg | [c149] Toscanne p.217 (kept; image downloaded, not viewed; OCR file HTTP 500) - OBSERVED | not dated by Toscanne; unknown to us; Elamite (Susa) | recreated: node cards-vs-catalogue.mjs (59 cards = catalogue at 749d9bb, 0 differences) | [c150] date line = catalogue date + tradition - CONFIRMED | au centre est une rosace à neuf branches; tout autour, des serpents encerclant la partie principale. L'un d'eux mord la queue de l'autre; n… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n241_w1400.jpg | [c151] as c026 - OBSERVED | The search found two. August Kekulé, telling in 1890 of a reverie by the fire, saw long rows of atoms twisting like snakes until Eine der S… | research/ouroboros/provinces/15-visions/dossier.md F25 Table 1 | [c152-1] two P4-A reports: Kekulé, Amaringo - CONFIRMED | The search found two. August Kekulé, telling in 1890 of a reverie by the fire, saw long rows of atoms twisting like snakes until Eine der S… | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | [c152-2] Berichte 23 p.1306 PDF text (fetched): "Ich drehte den Stuhl nach dem Kamin ... Eine der Schlangen erfasste den eigenen Schwanz" - CONFIRMED | The painter Pablo Amaringo describes a sorceress who carries her talents in a coffer in the form of a serpent holding its tail: one serpent. | https://archive.org/download/ethnobotany.-harner-1972-hallucinogens-and-shamanism/DMT.%20amaringo%20%281999%29%20ayahuasca%20visions_djvu.txt | [c153] Amaringo compilation OCR (FOUND online) - CONFIRMED | Many serpents are common in the vision reports we read, above all from ayahuasca: snakes in crowds, in a bunch, in a heap, entwined like ro… | https://archive.org/download/ethnobotany.-harner-1972-hallucinogens-and-shamanism/ethnobotany.%20harner%20%281972%29%20hallucinogens%20and%20shamanis… | [c154-1] Harner 1973 p.164 PDF (FOUND online) - MINOR | Many serpents are common in the vision reports we read, above all from ayahuasca: snakes in crowds, in a bunch, in a heap, entwined like ro… | research/ouroboros/provinces/15-visions/dossier.md F25 Table 2 | [c154-2] true of the ayahuasca reports listed; but Kekulé's report, in the paragraph before, is itself a many-serpent report in which one serpent takes its tail - CONFIRMED | In the oldest tradition (Egypt), among the five earliest securely dated witnesses that are S1 to S7, at least one is S2, S3, S4 or S7. | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md | [c155] registration text, verbatim - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://archive.org/details/the-ancient-egyptian-pyramid-texts_202103 | [c156-1] Allen 2005 p.91 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me); catalogue S1, archaeological context, -2300 - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://www.sbl-site.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Netherworld.pdf | [c156-2] Darnell & Darnell 2018 Scene 65 (reference-tier PDF read; passage kept, file deleted); catalogue S1, KV34, -1425 - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://archive.org/details/MIFAO-60 | [c156-3] Bucher 1932 p.161 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me); catalogue S1, KV35, -1400 - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://www.zora.uzh.ch/server/api/core/bitstreams/b98aa8f3-f5a3-468e-bb04-437a6d0e0a7d/content | [c156-4] Darnell 2004 p.374 (PDF FOUND); catalogue S5, KV62, -1327 - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://archive.org/details/alabastersarcoph64shar | [c156-5] Sharpe 1864 p.24 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me); catalogue S1, owner's sarcophagus, -1285 - CONFIRMED | In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); tw… | https://archive.org/details/egyptianheavenhe0002budg | [c156-6] Budge 1906 II p.122 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me, 76%); catalogue S6, -1285. No securely dated plural Egyptian witness omitted; CT 136 (contested) and Budge's Amduat 6 copy (S1, -1290, scene source unstated) left out, neither plural - CONFIRMED | The Susa plaque is older than all of them but is not Egyptian, and is dated by style, which the registration does not count. | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md | [c157-1] registration: style-dated witnesses "listed and not counted" - CONFIRMED | The Susa plaque is older than all of them but is not Egyptian, and is dated by style, which the registration does not count. | https://archive.org/details/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre | [c157-2] as c023-2 - OBSERVED | None found, by a search that did find the plural figures where they exist. | research/ouroboros/SYNTHESIS-NOTES.md (P2: "Keep strict") | [c158] no pre-500 text describes the ring itself as plural or knotted; see the added line on "Neither is the tail-biting ring" - CONFIRMED | The nearest miss is Macrobius, on a different figure, the caduceus: two serpents tied at the middle nodo quem vocant Herculis, in the knot … | https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Macrobius/Saturnalia/1*.html | [c159-1] Macrobius 1.19.16 (FOUND online) - CONFIRMED | The nearest miss is Macrobius, on a different figure, the caduceus: two serpents tied at the middle nodo quem vocant Herculis, in the knot … | https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Macrobius/Saturnalia/1*.html | [c159-2] Macrobius 1.19.17 (FOUND online) - CONFIRMED | Pliny the Elder tells of snakes numerose convoluti, coiled together in numbers, rolling a ball, and derives the caduceus from that entwinin… | https://archive.org/download/cplinisecundina01mayhgoog/page/n402_w1400.jpg | [c160-1] Mayhoff p.386 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | Pliny the Elder tells of snakes numerose convoluti, coiled together in numbers, rolling a ball, and derives the caduceus from that entwinin… | https://archive.org/download/cplinisecundina01mayhgoog/page/n402_w1400.jpg | [c160-2] Mayhoff p.386, 29.54 (page image viewed by me) - CONFIRMED | A book printed in 1612 under the name of Nicolas Flamel says the Egyptians painted ces Serpens & Dragõs, these serpents and dragons, in a c… | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | [c161] as c003-2 - CONFIRMED | Michael Maier, in 1618, says the philosophers mean by the tail-devouring dragon serpentem, qui alium sui generis devoret, a serpent that de… | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | [c162] as c003-3 - CONFIRMED | A Greek alchemical text copied in 1478 makes the ring’s four feet four bodies and its three ears three sublimates. | https://archive.org/details/collectiondesanc01bert | [c163-1] Berthelot-Ruelle I.v p.22 (kept; OCR of Greek unusable; the I.vi variant on p.23 is in the OCR: "οἱ δὲ πόδες αὐτοῦ οἱ τέσσαρές εἰσιν ἡ τετρασωμία ... τὰ δὲ τρία ὠτία αὐτοῦ εἰσιν αἱ τρεῖς αἰθάλαι") - CONFIRMED | A Greek alchemical text copied in 1478 makes the ring’s four feet four bodies and its three ears three sublimates. | https://pinakes.irht.cnrs.fr/notices/cote/51958/ | [c163-2] Pinakes (FOUND online); Berthelot too: MS 2327 "a été écrit en 1478" - OBSERVED | Two reports found. | research/ouroboros/provinces/15-visions/dossier.md F25 | [c164] "Count: two reports, below P4's threshold of four" - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre/page/n105_w1400.jpg | [c165-1] as c002-2 (Elam) - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/details/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre | [c165-2] as c023-2 (third millennium, by style) - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n241_w1400.jpg | [c165-3] as c026 - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/download/artinshellofanci00holm/page/n171_w2200.jpg | [c165-4] as c002-3 (Mississippian) - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/details/jstor-659168 | [c165-5] as c053 - MINOR | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | [c165-6] Waddell verbatim, but pig, cock and one snake: "S2 by analogy only" in the catalogue; S2 is "two or more serpents". P5 still holds on Elam, Mississippian and Pictish Scotland - CONFIRMED | At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Tibetan Wheel of Life; and Pictish Scotlan… | https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle | [c165-7] as c027 (Pictish Scotland, three serpents) - CONFIRMED | The alchemists who read the ring as several serpents in one wrote nearly four thousand years after the oldest ring we found. | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | [c166-1] as c003-2 - CONFIRMED | The alchemists who read the ring as several serpents in one wrote nearly four thousand years after the oldest ring we found. | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | [c166-2] as c003-3 - MINOR | The alchemists who read the ring as several serpents in one wrote nearly four thousand years after the oldest ring we found. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teti | [c166-3] Teti died c.2333 BC (Wikipedia, FOUND): 1612 is about 3,945 years later; but the page calls the Susa plaque (ca. 2600-2500 BC) older, and from it the gap is over 4,100 years. Say "after the oldest securely dated ring" - CONFIRMED | The oldest image in the record that looks like it is the Susa knot of two serpents, dated by style to the middle of the third millennium BC… | https://archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre/page/n105_w1400.jpg | [c167-1] as c002-2 - CONFIRMED | The oldest image in the record that looks like it is the Susa knot of two serpents, dated by style to the middle of the third millennium BC… | https://archive.org/details/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasuresintheLouvre | [c167-2] as c023-2 - CONFIRMED | The oldest image in the record that looks like it is the Susa knot of two serpents, dated by style to the middle of the third millennium BC… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teti | [c167-3] Teti c.2333 BC; Susa ca.2600-2500 BC is earlier - OBSERVED | on our reading each holds its own tail. | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/dossier.md F17 | [c168] tracing: own tails, medium confidence - CONFIRMED | The alchemists ran the idea in both directions: two birds that form das Bild von Zwei in Einem, the image of two in one, and a single drago… | https://archive.org/details/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2 | [c169-1] as c045 - CONFIRMED | The alchemists ran the idea in both directions: two birds that form das Bild von Zwei in Einem, the image of two in one, and a single drago… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n13_w1400.jpg | [c169-2] Eleazar part 2 p.8 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me: "und hat ein Wurm . andern gefreſſen") - CONFIRMED | The alchemists ran the idea in both directions: two birds that form das Bild von Zwei in Einem, the image of two in one, and a single drago… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n16_w1400.jpg | [c169-3] Eleazar part 2 p.9 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me: "dieſe 2. in eins gebracht") - CONFIRMED | the Tassilo chalice is reported so | https://archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-altertum/page/n15_w1400.jpg | [c170] as c028 ("reported": Oehrl after Haseloff) - CONFIRMED | and the cleanest S3 we found was made for a film in 1984, an amulet of two snakes that einander umschlingen und in die Schwänze beißen, twi… | https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Die_unendliche_Geschichte_(Film) | [c171] de.wikipedia film article (FOUND online); tertiary - OBSERVED | No text we read argues that the single ring descends from, or poorly draws, a woven knot or ring of many serpents. The search that came bac… | research/ouroboros/provinces/18-historiography/dossier.md 3.13 | [c172] search log; positive control: the auroral theory found by Crossref, OpenAlex, citing literature and web search - CONFIRMED | Carl Jung, in a seminar given between 1934 and 1939, speaking of the alchemists’ pairs of beasts that devour each other, said, as a blog qu… | https://carljungdepthpsychologysite.blog/2020/08/18/uroboros/ | [c173] blog page (FOUND online); context "the winged dragon and the wingless dragon that devour each other" precedes; book not read, as the page says - CONFIRMED | In print he wrote that The uroboros, too, is often pictured in the form of two dragons engaged in the same process. | https://archive.org/services/search/beta/page_production/?service_backend=fts&user_query=%22often%20pictured%20in%20the%20form%20of%20two%20dragons%2… | [c174] archive.org full-text search (fetched): five printings carry the sentence - CONFIRMED | John Bathurst Deane, in 1833, described a Mexican sign in which the two serpents, intertwining, form the circle with their own bodies, and … | https://archive.org/download/worshipofserpent00dean/page/n79_w1400.jpg | [c175-1] as c091 - CONFIRMED | John Bathurst Deane, in 1833, described a Mexican sign in which the two serpents, intertwining, form the circle with their own bodies, and … | https://archive.org/details/worshipofserpent00dean | [c175-2] Deane pp.51-54 (item OCR (archive.org _djvu.txt) found by me): the tail-biting ring (p.51), the ring between two serpents, the Mexican pair and the caduceus are all forms of his "ophite hierogram" - CONFIRMED | Ananda Coomaraswamy, in 1944, read the endless knots of Leonardo and Dürer as the coils of a cosmic serpent, and a wire whose point re-ente… | https://www.themathesontrust.org/papers/art/AKC-Durers_Knots.pdf | [c176] Coomaraswamy reprint pp.24-26 (PDF read): note 45 "coils of a cosmic serpent" (hedged "from certain points"); fibula wire whose "point ... re-enters the eye; ... and a snake with its tail in its mouth" - CONFIRMED | And in 2025 an essay on the open web offered the idea’s image as a new symbol, the torouroboros: Unlike traditional depictions of a single … | https://eleprocon.substack.com/p/torouroboros-archetype-of-the-regenaissance | [c177] Substack post (fetched): dated Jun 09, 2025; "a contemporary sciencemythic archetype"; claims no priority for the knot - WRONG | The registration was committed to the repository before any agent was launched or any source fetched, and the commit is its date; one form,… | git log -- research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md | [c178] commits 0afcbba 00:08:41Z and 9e72cfd 00:16:56Z: S7 came 8 min 15 s later, not "an hour later" (the file's own "an hour after" is also wrong); the rest is true (first fetch 00:20:55Z) - MINOR | Every excerpt the eighteen agents kept is checked against the copy saved in the repository before the census is built from it. | research/ouroboros/build-catalogue.mjs | [c179] checks witness and claim-check excerpts (958 found, 0 missing); the 123 scholarship excerpts are not checked by it (27 have no kept copy). The three this page quotes are checked by the site gate - WRONG | The pit’s figures are recomputed by a second route for every pit up to sixty snakes, and every weave the page can draw is traced through it… | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs (749d9bb) | [c180] largest ring recomputed only to n=22 (A3); string mean loops never recomputed, string one-loop only at n=8; diagram checks consume the engine's rosetteCrossings. Engine figures are nonetheless right (my recomputation n<=60) - MINOR | Two errors of ours, both caught: gathering dates for the companion page, we fetched about fifty pages from a path of Wikipedia that its rob… | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; commit 3c799c73a7; SYNTHESIS-NOTES.md 04 | [c181] first error confirmed; second: the brief itself asked for REPORT.md in the repository ("My brief asked for REPORT.md"); the agent used the shell after the Write tool refused, so the route broke the harness rule, not the brief - MINOR | “Each devouring the tail of another” is already a precise rule. Each snake takes exactly one tail, and each tail is taken by exactly one snake. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; index.html l.148; COMMISSION.md | [added] "another" excludes a snake's own tail (a derangement); the pit's rule is a permutation that allows it, and the page then counts self-biters ("on average exactly once"). Say the pit relaxes "another". - MINOR | Three facts about the pit hold whatever its size, and the instrument recomputes them as you move the slider. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; recreated: exact counts over cycle types | [added] the third "fact" ("one ring is nearly always far bigger than the rest") does not hold at the slider's sizes (12 snakes: the largest holds more than half on 65% of nights); see c011-1 - MINOR | Each prediction, in the words the registration gave it before the evidence | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md P4, P5 | [added] at 749d9bb P4 and P5 were paraphrased (P4 dropped "Collect every ... we can source" and "in its mouth"; P5 dropped "with every member shown, and we set no threshold for calling it support"); fixed at HEAD 4852244217 - MINOR | Neither is the tail-biting ring. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; PREREGISTRATION.md P2; catalogue 16-macrobius-caduceus-knot-circle (form S4) | [added] P2 says "the encircling or tail-devouring figure"; NOT MET rests on reading that as the serpent ring itself (SYNTHESIS-NOTES: "Keep strict"), a fair reading the page should state, since its own census counts Macrobius's knotted two-serpent circle (c. AD 430) as plural (S4). H1's verdict would not change - MINOR | No line of borrowing between Bronze Age Susa, medieval Alabama and nineteenth-century accounts of Tibetan paintings is plausible; that is our judgement, as the registration said it would be. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; catalogue: 10-south-east-asia-waddell-1892 ("S2 by analogy only"), moundville date ("secondary web pages (not read as sources)") | [added] one of the three is a ring of pig, cock and one snake, and "medieval" rests on dates not read; P5 holds anyway on Elam, Mississippian and Pictish Scotland (Meigle 26, three serpents), which the judgement could name instead - MINOR | CANNOT BE JUDGED FROM WHAT WE COULD READ Two reports, where the registration asked for four. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; PREREGISTRATION.md verdict words; provinces/15-visions/dossier.md "What we could not read" | [added] the registration's wording is "cannot be judged from what we could read (naming what was unreadable)"; nothing unreadable is named (dossier: Reichel-Dolmatoff 1975 and 1978, Shanon 2002, Mavromatis 1987, Luna's introduction, Jung's Red Book and Visions seminars, Erowid HTTP 403, DreamBank refused by robots.txt) - WRONG | (the registration reproduced on the page) A witness in a book we could not open is not in the census, and the page will list what we know we could not open. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; index.html, whole visible text searched | [added] the page has no such list; the dossiers have one (e.g. Louvre record for Sb 2724 HTTP 429; Mundkur 1983; Hornung's Amduat; Piankoff MIFAO 74.1 HTTP 500; Reemes 2015 full text; Jung's Zarathustra seminar book; Leisegang 1939; Deonna 1952; Orlov 2020 HTTP 403) - CONFIRMED | H1, historical ... PARTLY SUPPORTED P3 held. It was registered as the weak test, and the two predictions that bore on where the ring came from, P1 and P2, did not hold | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md | [added] the registration's own rule: "partly supported (naming which prediction held)"; P3 "Counts for, weakly" - CONFIRMED | H3, formal ... PARTLY SUPPORTED P5 held as a count, and the registration set no threshold for calling a count support, so we do not call it more. | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md P5 | [added] a judgement the registration left open; stated, not overstated - MINOR | The census below holds every witness the eighteen provinces found with more than one creature in one closed figure, in the order of their dates; undated ones come last. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json at 749d9bb | [added] (a) 18-quedlinburg-frieze-via-oehrl (pairs of serpents "linked through each other like chain links") is left out because it is filed "S5 with the rings interlinked", though by the page's Susa reasoning that is S4; (b) cards whose own date line says no date was given (Calchaquí disc, Codex Borgia p.46, Sun Stone) sit by assigned sort-years 1400/1500, not last - CONFIRMED | None is plural. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json (01-, 02- witnesses) | [added] no Egyptian witness in the catalogue is S2, S3, S4 or S7 - CONFIRMED | The registration is reproduced at the foot of the page, as it was before the first source came back. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; git: 9e72cfd 00:16:56Z last change, first fetch 00:20:55Z; verifier F byte comparison (HEAD) | [added]
 = PREREGISTRATION.md
- CONFIRMED | None of them says the knot came first. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs; kept copies; fetched blog, CW 11 snippets, Deane OCR pp.51-54, Coomaraswamy PDF, Substack post | [added] none claims priority for a plural or knotted figure
- CONFIRMED | The idea under test is S3: several serpents, woven, each with another’s tail. | research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md S3 | [added] "This is the hypothesis's own image"
- MINOR | (weave readout, app.mjs) In the record’s terms below: S5, several single rings on one object, here woven through one another. | public/strata/.../app.mjs l.88-93; render.mjs formGlyph('S4'); PREREGISTRATION.md S4, S5 | [added] for linked own-tail rings (the "Two rings linked" and "Three, no two linked" presets) the readout says S5, while the forms legend draws S4 as exactly that (two linked rings) and the record calls the linked Susa pair S4; the registration's S5 is "separate" rings
- WRONG | (the check's own header) Every figure the page states in its own text is asserted in its own sentence, and a residual sweep finds any number in the visible text, meta description, share tags or structured data that nothing here accounts for. | verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs l.29-31 (749d9bb and HEAD) | [added] no residual sweep exists in the code; at 749d9bb planted changes to the harmonic and string formulas, "sixty", "Two thousand nights", "1966", "1885" passed (1176/0); at HEAD the in-repo record check catches marked sentences, but unmarked figures ("Two thousand nights", og/twitter "five predictions", dek "four thousand years") still pass, and the published copy passes a changed formula (1176/0)
- WRONG | (frontmatter body) verify-each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.mjs at the repository root recomputes every figure by a second route that shares no code with it. | src/content/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.md l.22-23 | [added] string figures never recomputed (except the n=8 single loop), largest ring only to n=22, diagram checks consume the engine's rosetteCrossings
- MINOR | (frontmatter body) research/ouroboros/catalogue.json, every excerpt checked against a copy kept in the repository | src/content/strata/...md l.25-26; build-catalogue.mjs | [added] as c179: scholarship excerpts are not checked
- UNVERIFIABLE | An agent that did not write the page read every marked claim against its source before it was published. | this pass | [added] true only once a pass is recorded in assay/records/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another.md; this report is one such reading
- CONFIRMED | then read four thousand years of the record | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | [added] Susa ca. 2600-2500 BC and Teti c. 2330 BC to AD 2025
- CONFIRMED | c021-1: Fig. 2 of Alexander Crum Brown’s paper “On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces”, in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, vol. 13 (1884-1886), p. 383: three rings, no two of them linked, that cannot be pulled apart. | research/ouroboros/provinces/17-mathematics/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c021-2: Fig. 2 of Alexander Crum Brown’s paper “On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces”, in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, vol. 13 (1884-1886), p. 383: three rings, no two of them linked, that cannot be pulled apart. | https://archive.org/details/proceedings1318841886roya | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c037: “P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 206, fig. 394: 'Fig. 394. — Plaque de bitume.'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c040: “Bell (niuzhong), detail of the lower panel of interlaced decoration” | research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c045: “Book of Durrow, Dublin, Trinity College Library MS 57, fol. 192v (carpet page with animal interlace)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c046: Six fields of animal interlace round a roundel of plain knotwork. Horizontal bands: long-jawed beasts with round eyes, broad red or yellow ribbon bodies with green teardrop hips, thin pale legs and tails; bodies cross in a chain. Side panels: beasts stacked vertically, each head's long jaws reaching to the hindquarters of the beast above. No head visibly takes a tail. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: six fields counted in the picture (two bands above, two below, one each side); was "Five fields"
- CONFIRMED | c062: “Pl. LXVI ('The Serpent'), fig. 6: 'Stone disk, Carthage, Ala.' (the Moundville 'Rattlesnake Disk'), line drawing” | research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c071-1: Codex Borgia, page 46: the square of four serpents, cropped from the Duc de Loubat’s facsimile of 1898. | research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c071-2: Codex Borgia, page 46: the square of four serpents, cropped from the Duc de Loubat’s facsimile of 1898. | https://archive.org/details/codex-borgia_20220902 | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c074: “Lámina II: the 'second stone' (Piedra del Sol), shaded engraving” | research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c093: “Engraved plate N. 1, 'Vereinige sie': two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its jaws” | research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c096: “Engraved plate with figures N. 3 (two dragons, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth) and N. 4 (one crowned dragon, 'Der Fixe', 'Rothe Drache', its own tail in its mouth)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c099: “Two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth” | research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c116: “Fig. 1 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': six monkeys (Macacus cynocephalus) forming a ring, 'ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé'schen Benzolsechsecks'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/12-kekule/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c119: “Fig. 2 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': the same six monkeys joined also by their tails ('caudaler Appendix'), the 'zweite Form des Kekulé-schen Sechsecks'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/12-kekule/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c126-1: The hub of the plate “The Wheel of Life, Picturing the Buddhist Theory of the Universe”, facing p. 108 of L. A. Waddell’s The Buddhism of Tibet (1895). | research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c126-2: The hub of the plate “The Wheel of Life, Picturing the Buddhist Theory of the Universe”, facing p. 108 of L. A. Waddell’s The Buddhism of Tibet (1895). | https://archive.org/download/cu31924023203288/page/n138_w1400.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes
- CONFIRMED | c148: not given in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c149: “Detail of fig. 327A, Fragment of upright cross-slab from Carpow, front: the panel described as a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c151: not given in the sources the research read; Insular sculpture (Iona, Scotland) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c153: not given in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c154: “Detail of fig. 236, Upright slab with sculpture in relief at Kettins: the pair of beasts with crossed bodies biting each other's tails (line drawing)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c156: not given in the sources the research read; Allen places it among the symbol-bearing (Class II) monuments; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c157: “Detail of fig. 318A (top of Meigle No. 26): the whorl of three serpents” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c159: not dated in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c161: not dated in the sources the research read; Anglo-Saxon metalwork (Germanic Style II) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c162: “Great gold buckle from Sutton Hoo, British Museum 1939,1010.1 (photograph in the gallery)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c164: not dated in the sources the research read; Viking-Age runestone (Sweden) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass, final check: the date wording now names the research as the reader (records.json, dated note); the facts unchanged
- CONFIRMED | c165: “Runestone U 871 (Upplands runinskrift 871), at Skansen, Stockholm; the carving is painted in modern colours” | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- CONFIRMED | c172: “P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 218, fig. 442: 'Fig. 442. — Petite table en terre cuite (Suse).'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title)
- WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass] the Book of Durrow (CC BY 4.0) and the Sutton Hoo buckle photograph (CC BY-SA 4.0) were shown without the licence link and the credit the licensors ask for | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:IE_TCD_MS_57_f.192v.jpg; https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Great_gold_buckle_sutton_hoo.JPG | fixed: licence links, credit ("The Board of Trinity College Dublin"; Geni), what this copy changed, and for BY-SA that this adaptation is shared under the same licence
- WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass] each apparatus entry printed "Rights, in the source’s words" over the research’s own notes; the three Early Christian Monuments entries had never been read at the source | https://archive.org/metadata/earlychristianmo03alle | fixed: rights read again at each source and quoted (this item states none), our reading apart
- WRONG | [first pass] the Durrow census card: "Five fields of animal interlace" | the picture; research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/records.json | fixed: six (two bands above, two below, one each side); record corrected with a dated note
- MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] the Pictures intro: "Every picture in the census" (the Crum Brown plate is not), "word for word", "smaller copies", and share-alike said to cover copies | public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/index.html; https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ | fixed: "on this page"; share-alike covers adaptations, "this resized copy is"
- MINOR | [first pass] census captions that did not say what the picture is: the Codex Borgia crop of the 1898 facsimile, the Waddell hub, Toscanne fig. 442 "as above" | research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json; research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json; research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json | fixed: two captions written (CARD_CAPTION) and the fig. 442 title given in full
- MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] alt texts made from the first sentence of a description ("Tree on a grassy mound", "Broken across the top") | public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/ | fixed: hand-written alt texts, each after looking at the picture
- MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] public domain in the United States only (Toscanne 1911) said without the region, with "Flag for the orchestrator" printed | https://archive.org/metadata/mmoires12franuoft | fixed: copyright-region "US" quoted; our reading says Toscanne’s death date is unknown so French status cannot be shown

## Findings
- [fixed] MED: the registration promised to name what was unreadable for "cannot be judged" and to list what we could not open; the page did neither. The H2 verdict now names the unread vision sources, and a section "What we could not open" lists, from the dossiers, what could change the record (the Louvre's record and Pottier's plate of the Susa plaque, Mundkur; the vision literature; the Arabic Ibn Umayl; Leisegang, Deonna, Sheppard, Orlov and the Jung seminar; the body of van der Sluijs and Peratt; Needham and the Astana painting).
- [fixed] MED: the check said the pit's figures are recomputed by a second route for every pit up to sixty and that the verifier sweeps every number; neither was true. The verifier now checks the string figures for every pit up to sixty by a recursion of its own and by listing every pairing up to six strings, the "two nights in three" figure, the button's two thousand nights, the registration's counts and the dek's four thousand years; the page, the .md body and the verifier's header now say exactly what is recomputed and how (the largest ring by cycle types up to twenty-two), and name the house's digit sweep as the residual check.
- [fixed] MED: "one ring is nearly always far bigger than the rest" was false (the largest holds more than half the snakes on about 65 to 69 nights in a hundred). Now: "usually ... on about two nights in three, the largest holds more than half the snakes", sourced to Flajolet and Sedgewick's H_n - H_floor(n/2) and asserted by the verifier; "hold whatever its size" removed.
- [fixed] MINOR: S7 was added eight minutes after the registration, not an hour; the page says so, and a dated note at the end of PREREGISTRATION.md corrects the registration's own sentence (the only change made to it).
- [fixed] MINOR: linked own-tail rings were labelled S5 by the weave's readout; they are S4 under the registration (S5 is separate rings). The readout now says S4, and the Quedlinburg frieze (two rings linked, filed S5 by its province) is refiled S4 and joins the census, now 60.
- [fixed] MINOR: P5's four traditions and the no-borrowing judgement no longer rest on the Tibetan wheel (a pig, a cock and one snake): they are Elam, the Mississippian peoples, the Mexica and Pictish Scotland, and the wheel is named as a fifth by analogy only; "medieval Alabama" dropped.
- [fixed] MINOR: P2's NOT MET now says it rests on reading "the encircling or tail-devouring figure" as the serpent ring, and that on a loose reading Macrobius's knotted circle would meet it without changing H1.
- [fixed] MINOR: "In none of them does a serpent take a tail" narrowed to the ayahuasca reports (Kekule's is a many-serpent report with one ring).
- [fixed] MINOR: the second error is now told as it happened: the first brief asked for report files, the tools refuse them, one agent wrote its file with the shell; the file was removed and the brief changed.
- [fixed] MINOR: "every excerpt the agents kept is checked" narrowed to the excerpts of witnesses and claim checks, on both pages and in both .md bodies.
- [fixed] MINOR: "four thousand years after the oldest ring we found" now says "the oldest securely dated ring" (the Susa plaque is older, by style).
- [fixed] MINOR: the census wording now says the order follows the catalogue's dates (some only by period), the summary says how many S2 are the catalogue's uncertain "S2?", and the forms sentence admits rings left between two forms.
- [fixed] MINOR: the Druce 1910 OCR link returned 404; province 14's records and kept copy now name Amphisbaena_djvu.txt, the item's actual OCR file.
- [fixed] MINOR: the pit now says it relaxes "another" so that a snake may draw its own tail.
- [fixed] MINOR (already at HEAD when reported): the verdict table quotes P4 and P5 in the registration's own words.
- [fixed] HIGH (pictures pass): the CC BY and CC BY-SA pictures lacked the licence link and the credit their licences ask for; both now carry them.
- [fixed] HIGH (pictures pass): apparatus entries put the research's own notes under "Rights, in the source's words"; every picture's rights were read again at the source and are quoted from there.
- [fixed] MED (pictures pass): the Durrow card said five fields of interlace (six); US-only public domain was stated without the region.
- [fixed] MINOR (pictures pass): census captions that did not say what the picture is; alt texts made from first sentences; the intro's wording; the Senior woodcut, too small to read at card size and under a licence asking for a date we could not find, was left out.