--- slug: having-eluded-us-both passed: 2026-11-16 by: "a claims-pass subagent of claude-gifted-feynman-ixn1qm, before publishing, on the working tree at 4ef22b6a5e (page files unchanged since 428472a2d3); every one of the 197 entries of assay/sources/having-eluded-us-both.json plus 4 claims it leaves out, one agent on the outside-audit brief" checked: 201 confirmed: 185 wrong: 2 unverifiable: 0 observed: 14 stale: 0 --- Every finding below was re-read against its source by the builder and fixed before publishing (2026-11-16). The confirmed count, 185, is 177 CONFIRMED lines and 8 lines marked MINOR: near-misses, each answered by a finding below. The two WRONG lines are one error, the volume of the Educational Times citation (findings 1 and 2). Not yet published: https://artwaste.land/strata/having-eluded-us-both/ and https://artwaste.land/checks/verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs both answer 404 (expected; /strata/monty-hall/ answers 200 as a control). The public verifier copied into an empty directory and run as the page says (`node verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs`) stops after three tries with "Error: could not download https://artwaste.land/strata/having-eluded-us-both/index.html: HTTP 404" (exit 1, 9.6 s; an uncaught error with a Node stack trace, leaving an empty having-eluded-us-both-files/checks/). Reader check simulated on copies of the served index.html, data.json, book.json, lib.mjs and checks/p1.mjs to p72.mjs with AW_DIR: plain run exit 0, 2698 passed, 0 failed ("checked 577 quotes, re-ran 577 claims, 44 page figures, 26 findings recomputed"); --mutate exit 0, 2706 passed, 0 failed, 8 of 8 planted faults caught; --online exit 0, 2699 passed, 0 failed. In the repository: `node verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs --mutate` exit 0, 2708 passed, 0 failed, 8 of 8 caught; the working tree stayed clean. After publish the verifier's download of /strata/having-eluded-us-both/index.html will meet a 307 to the directory, which Node's fetch follows (control: a published layer's index.html answers 307 then 200), and .mjs is served as text/javascript (control), so the browser checks can load. The page prints no verifier transcript, so the self-reading defect cannot arise here; a sentence-only change to a data-f span fails the verifier, a change to an unmarked figure does not (finding 5). research/self-reading-verifiers/scan.mjs was not run: it writes baseline.json and probe.json into the repository. `node assay/sources.mjs having-eluded-us-both --online` was run on a copy of the record with its one reference-tier URL (schnark.github.io) replaced by the kept excerpt, since only "allowed" URLs were to be fetched: 75 FOUND, 4 PARTIAL, 27 NOT FOUND, 5 UNREADABLE, 1 NO EXCERPT, 85 in the repository; DOI MATCH for n58-portnoy, seneta-quote, cite-seneta and cite-weaver; "MISMATCH" for cite-portnoy and cite-cantarella only because the cited words hold no title words (authors and years match). Every NOT FOUND, PARTIAL and NO EXCERPT is an excerpt in the transcription's LaTeX or in square brackets, which that tool cannot see (the formulas are images carrying data-tex, and it drops bracketed text). Read with each formula replaced by its data-tex, 87 of the 88 excerpts sourced to Gutenberg are in the live file whole; the 88th (a table) is in problems.json, which split.mjs --check confirms is cut from the kept file; and the live file is byte-identical to the kept copy (sha256 988a7a1a1fc442295b42011fd397daf460f347e5552e06f96937abc7c4aa27fa). The 5 UNREADABLE are PDFs: the St Andrews DSB PDF and the arXiv PDF were fetched and read with pdftotext; the archive.org PDF's page was read as the kept PNG, and the live archive.org OCR is byte-identical to the kept one (sha256 cb069384...). The page's headline findings were recomputed with this pass's own code, not the page's: No. 61's search, No. 41 and No. 50 by exact enumeration, No. 10's coin sets, No. 70's angles, No. 45's subtraction, No. 37's two figures, No. 38's two readings, No. 72's average, and No. 58's closed forms with fresh 2,000,000-triangle samples; all agree with the page. Fetching: scripts/robots-policy.mjs before every URL and redirect target; curl sent only ArtWasteLand-Reference/1.0 (sources.mjs and the verifier send their own User-Agents); schnark.github.io (reference) not fetched; HathiTrust, Google Books page views, Project Euclid and scientificamerican.com refused and not fetched. One web search (Weaver's wording) found only the transcription already cited. ## Claims - CONFIRMED | [dek-seventy-two-in-the-head] In 1893 Lewis Carroll published seventy-two problems, nearly all solved in his head while lying awake, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | Introduction p. xii: "NEARLY all of the following seventy-two Problems are veritable Pillow-Problems, having been solved, in the head, while lying awake at night"; 1893 from the Introduction (May, 1893) and the 2nd-edition preface (September, 1893). The mended "nearly all" is in the dek, the three meta descriptions, the JSON-LD and the frontmatter - CONFIRMED | [dek-listed-mistakes] listed the mistakes he had found in them when he wrote them out, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "when these Problems came to be re-written and arranged for publication, a good many mistakes were discovered ... I here append a list of them" (p. xviii) - CONFIRMED | [dek-some-critical-reader] and left the rest for “some critical reader”. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "await the penetrating glance of some critical reader" (p. xix), word for word - CONFIRMED | [dek-577-537] A program has now checked 577 claims in the book, and 537 of them hold. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | recreated: data.json and results.json both hold 577 claims, tally holds 537, slip 17, wrong 8, depends 14, unchecked 1; the verifier holds both spans (AW_DIR copy 2698 passed, repo --mutate 2708 passed, 0 failed) - CONFIRMED | [dek-fifteen-mistakes] It finds fifteen mistakes in the printed text (one of them perhaps a joke): | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs | GROUPS with verdict slip or wrong: n61, n41, n50, n10, n70-3, n70-4, n45, n37-decimal, n37-number, n31, n33, n47, n65-set, n65-value, n72 = 15, owning all 25 slip and wrong claims; "perhaps a joke" is No. 72 (Moktefi) - CONFIRMED | [dek-among-them] among them a theorem that the numbers 1, 4 and 13 refute, a chance of 7/12 that should be 1/2, a table of chances wrong in every line beneath an answer that is right, a coin he left out, and two angles each half a degree out. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own code: 1, 4, 13 fails; 7/12 against 1/2; table 25, 50, 29, 4 against 24, 51, 30, 3 with 17/27 right either way; double florin + two threepences = 54d; 18.65 against 19.11 (0.46 deg) and 14.53 against 13.90 (0.63 deg): "half a degree" is a round figure - CONFIRMED | [seo-title] Lewis Carroll's Pillow Problems: Every Answer Checked by a Program | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | recounted: all 44 printed answers carry answer claims, all 72 solutions carry solution claims - CONFIRMED | [plain-book] Lewis Carroll wrote a book of seventy-two maths problems, nearly all solved in his head at night, and he invited readers to find the mistakes he had missed. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "NEARLY all ... solved, in the head, while lying awake at night", and the closing invitation to "some critical reader" - CONFIRMED | [plain-checks] This page checks every answer in the book with computer programs you can run yourself. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/app.mjs | every one of the 72 problems names a check; the checks import only ../lib.mjs (no Node APIs, grep); the host serves .mjs as text/javascript (positive control, /strata/aim-where-your-misses-pay/engine.mjs); runCheck() imports and runs the check in the browser - CONFIRMED | [plain-fifteen] Most of his answers are right; it shows the fifteen mistakes it found, including a false theorem, and explains each one. | research/pillow-problems/README.md | README "The findings" lists the same fifteen, and "What the program found" explains each - CONFIRMED | [relate-supposable-errors] he invited any critical reader to find the mistakes that had eluded him. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Other mistakes may perchance, having eluded us both, await the penetrating glance of some critical reader" - CONFIRMED | [relate-graunt] Carroll's 1893 answers, nearly all worked in the dark, here. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "NEARLY all ..." supports "nearly all worked in the dark"; the Graunt half matches src/content/strata/the-table-he-copied-and-the-table-he-made.md (1662) - CONFIRMED | [relate-bertrand] three random points on an infinite plane here (Carroll's No. 58). | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | No. 58: "Three Points are taken at random on an infinite Plane." - CONFIRMED | [relate-monty-hall] the friend who says there was at least one white counter here (Carroll's No. 41). | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | No. 41: "I meant to tell you, before you began, that there was at least one white counter in the bag." - CONFIRMED | [og-image-alt] A line of years from 1872 to 1891 with a dot for each problem Lewis Carroll dated, most of them green for answers that hold, a few amber, red and blue for slips, mistakes and questions with two answers, under the title Having Eluded Us Both | public/og/having-eluded-us-both.png | viewed: dots on a line of years from 1872, worst verdicts of the 65 dated problems (data.json) holds 48, slip 5, wrong 4, depends 7, unchecked 1; the one grey dot (No. 15) goes unmentioned, an omission, not an error - CONFIRMED | [jsonld-book] Curiosa Mathematica, Part II: Pillow-Problems Thought Out During Wakeful Hours | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | title page "PILLOW-PROBLEMS THOUGHT OUT DURING WAKEFUL HOURS"; the 2nd-edition preface (September 1893) says "sleepless nights" became "wakeful hours", so 1893 fits the second edition - CONFIRMED | [kicker] Seventy-two problems, nearly all solved in the dark, 1872 to 1891, every answer checked by a program | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html); research/pillow-problems/problems.json | "NEARLY all"; recounted: the stamps run from No. 67, 27/1/72, to No. 37, 12/91 - CONFIRMED | [intro-published-1893] In 1893 Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, | https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/DSB/Dodgson.pdf (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, read with pdftotext) | the PDF heads the entry "Dodgson, Charles Lutwidge (b. Daresbury, Cheshire, England, 27 January 1832" and says "his Pillow Problems (1893)"; the kept text copy agrees - CONFIRMED | [intro-title-page] Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, "Student and late Mathematical Lecturer of Christ Church Oxford", whom the world knew as Lewis Carroll, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | title page "BY CHARLES L. DODGSON, M.A. Student and late Mathematical Lecturer of Christ Church Oxford" (fourth edition); the page applies it to 1893, when the description was equally true of him - CONFIRMED | [intro-title] published Curiosa Mathematica, Part II: Pillow-Problems. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Curiosa Mathematica PART II PILLOW-PROBLEMS" - CONFIRMED | [intro-quote-block] His Introduction says how the problems were made: NEARLY all of the following seventy-two Problems are veritable "Pillow-Problems", having been solved, in the head, while lying awake at night. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word, p. xii - CONFIRMED | [answer-first] He wrote the answer down before the working that would test it, which is the order a careful experimenter keeps today when a prediction is registered before the data come in. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "I generally wrote down the answer, first of all: and afterwards the question and its solution." The sentence drops "generally", but it follows the quoted block that has it; the comparison is the page's own - CONFIRMED | [quote-many-mistakes] Then he tested it. "It is not, perhaps, much to be wondered at that, when these Problems came to be re-written and arranged for publication, a good many mistakes were discovered." | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word, p. xviii - CONFIRMED | [quote-computator] The worst he dropped; the rest he corrected in his solutions, "but, that I may not be credited with an amount of accuracy, as a computator, which I am well aware I do not possess, I here append a list of them." | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word; "The worst he dropped" is "Some were so bad as quite to spoil the solutions in which they occurred: these Problems I have omitted altogether" - CONFIRMED | [ten-on-the-list] Ten problems are on the list. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | the list's entries begin "In No. 7", 10, 13, 32, 38, 44, 50, 55, 57 and 70: ten (read in full in problems.json and found in the live file) - CONFIRMED | [brabant] F. G. Brabant of Corpus Christi College read the proofs, "first working out each result independently". | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Mr. F. G. Brabant, M.A., of Corpus Christi College, Oxford, who has most patiently and carefully gone through my proofs, first working out each result independently"; the mended page no longer calls him a friend - CONFIRMED | [invitation-quote] And the Introduction ends with an invitation: Other mistakes may perchance, having eluded us both, await the penetrating glance of some critical reader, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word; the last paragraph before "C. L. D. CH. CH., OXFORD. May, 1893." (footnotes follow) - CONFIRMED | [intro-dated-may-1893] C. L. D., Christ Church, Oxford, May 1893 (Introduction, pp. xii to xix of the fourth edition, 1895) | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "C. L. D. CH. CH., OXFORD. May, 1893."; INTRODUCTION follows "[Pg xii]" and the signature precedes "[Pg xx]": pp. xii to xix - CONFIRMED | [takes-him-up] This page takes him up on it, with a program rather than a glance. Every answer he printed, the result of every solution and the figures in it where a slip could hide, and every entry in his list of mistakes is a claim; each claim is... | research/pillow-problems/results.json | recounted: solution claims in 72 of 72 problems, answer claims for 44 of 44 answers, the ten list entries all claims; the mended wording is on the page - CONFIRMED | [checks-in-browser] The checks are short JavaScript files, and every one of them runs in your browser from the ledger below. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/app.mjs | 72 check files served beside the page, each importing only ../lib.mjs; .mjs served as text/javascript (positive control on a published layer) - MINOR | [found-577-what] The checks make 577 claims about the book: each figure and formula of the 44 printed answers, the results of the 72 solutions and the figures and steps in them where a slip could hide, the ten entries of his list of mistakes, and the... | research/pillow-problems/results.json | parts recounted: answer 80, solution 468, introduction 17, question 8, preface4 3, preface2 1. The sentence names the answers, solutions, list and "the other things his Introduction says" (565), not the 8 question claims (among them No. 61's theorem, No. 14's and No. 15's) or the 4 preface claims; the record note says the mended sentence names "prefaces and questions", and it does not (finding 3) - MINOR | [found-holds-40] 537 of them hold. The other 40 come down to 15 mistakes that got past him and Brabant, 10 questions whose words allow more than one answer, and one theorem no program can settle. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | 40 = 8 + 17 + 14 + 1; 15 mistake groups, 10 reading groups and No. 15: right. "one theorem no program can settle" overstates: a check on examples cannot settle it, but a proof can be checked by a program (finding 4) - CONFIRMED | [found-nearly-everything] Nearly everything he worked out in the dark is right. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | 537 of 577 hold (93%); 25 are slips or wrong - CONFIRMED | [n61-question] No. 61 asks for a proof that if three whole numbers cannot be arranged in arithmetical progression, and their sum is a multiple of 3, the sum of their squares is also the sum of three other squares, with no square in common. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Prove that, if any 3 Numbers be taken, which cannot be arranged in A. P., and whose sum is a multiple of 3, the sum of their squares is also the sum of another set of 3 squares, the 2 sets having no common term." - CONFIRMED | [n61-proof] His proof makes the new numbers by a rule (each new number is two-thirds of the sum, less one of the old), shows that the squares add up to the same total, and shows that a new number can equal an old one only if the three are in... | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | his new numbers (-a+2b+2c)/3 = 2(a+b+c)/3 - a; the identity of the squares; "if (-a+2b+2c)/3 be equal to a, or b, or c, then a, b, c can be arranged in A. P."; "Hence, contranominally ... no common term" - CONFIRMED | [n61-counterexample] But two numbers can have the same square without being equal: a new number can be minus an old one. Take 1, 4 and 13. They are not in progression, and their sum, 18, is a multiple of 3. Their squares make 186; his rule gives 11, 8 and... | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own search: 1 + 4 + 13 = 18, squares 186, his rule gives 11, 8, -1, and (-1)^2 = 1^2 - CONFIRMED | [n61-three-ways] Nor is there any other way out: 186 is a sum of three squares in exactly three ways, 1 + 16 + 169, 1 + 64 + 121 and 16 + 49 + 121, and the other two each share a square with the first. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own search: 186 = 4^2+7^2+11^2 = 1^2+8^2+11^2 = 1^2+4^2+13^2, none with 0; the other two share 16 and 1 - CONFIRMED | [n61-smallest] With repeats allowed (his own examples include 1, 4, 4), the smallest failure is 1, 1, 7, or 1, 1, 4 if 0 does not count as a square; 1, 4 and 13 fail either way. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own search over sums to 60: first failure 1, 1, 7 with 0 a square, 1, 1, 4 without; 1, 4, 13 fails both ways - CONFIRMED | [n61-examples] his own examples include 1, 4, 4 | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Numerical Examples (not thought out)." first row 1^2, 4^2, 4^2 giving 5^2, 2^2, 2^2 (problems.json; a table of formula images in the HTML) - CONFIRMED | [n61-preface-took-apart] It is the problem whose proposed solution he took apart in the preface to his second edition, in September 1893. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | Preface to the Second Edition: "a curiously illogical solution which has been proposed, by a correspondent of the Educational Times, for Problem 61" - CONFIRMED | [n61-preface-quote] A correspondent of the Educational Times had offered one family of examples, 3m, 21m and 30m, whose squares make the same sum as four other sets of three, and all that proved, Carroll wrote, "is that certain selected Numbers, which have... | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Let 3m, 21m, 30m be the three Numbers" with four other sets (6, 15, 33; 5, 13, 34; 10, 17, 31; 14, 23, 25, all 1350 m^2, recomputed); the quote word for word - CONFIRMED | [n61-logic-theorem] He was right about the logic; it is the theorem itself that fails. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | his logical point is as the preface puts it; the theorem fails at 1, 4, 13 (own search) - CONFIRMED | [n61-preface-date] in the preface to his second edition, in September 1893. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "C. L. D. CH. CH., OXFORD. September, 1893." - CONFIRMED | [n61-et-question] The journal had printed his theorem, under his name, as its question 9636, | https://archive.org/download/mathematicalque00unkngoog/mathematicalque00unkngoog_djvu.txt (live copy fetched 2026-11-15, sha256 cb069384..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-questions-vol60-1894-djvu.txt); research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-1894-vol60-p86.png (viewed) | "9636. (Charles L. Dodgson, M.A.) - If three numbers, not in Arithmetical Progression, ..." The claim holds; its record "where" (vol. LX) is wrong, it is vol. LXI (finding 2) - CONFIRMED | [n61-et-printed] and the solution printed for it in Mathematical Questions and Solutions, the volumes that collected the journal's problems, "by W. S. Foster, Professor Nash, and others", makes the same move as his proof and stops at the same place: | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-1894-vol60-p86.png (viewed); https://archive.org/download/mathematicalque00unkngoog/mathematicalque00unkngoog_djvu.txt (live copy fetched 2026-11-15, sha256 cb069384..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-questions-vol60-1894-djvu.txt) | "Solution by W. S. Foster, Professor Nash, and others."; the solution sets a + b + c = 3m and shows only that 2m - a differs from a, b, c, as his proof does. Its record "where" says vol. LX: it is vol. LXI, p. 86 (finding 2) - CONFIRMED | [n61-et-volumes] the volumes that collected the journal's problems | https://archive.org/download/mathematicalque00unkngoog/mathematicalque00unkngoog_djvu.txt (live copy fetched 2026-11-15, sha256 cb069384..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-questions-vol60-1894-djvu.txt) | both title pages in the bound item carry the notice "each of which contains, in addition to the papers and solutions that have appeared in the Educational Times, an equal quantity of new matter" - WRONG | [n61-et-quote] "2m−a is not equal to a or b or c unless these quantities are in Arithmetical Progression" (vol. LX, 1894, p. 86) | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-1894-vol60-p86.png (viewed); https://archive.org/download/mathematicalque00unkngoog/mathematicalque00unkngoog_djvu.txt (live copy fetched 2026-11-15, sha256 cb069384..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-questions-vol60-1894-djvu.txt) | the quotation is word for word on the page image, but the volume is wrong: the archive.org item binds vol. LX (title-page notice "sixty Volumes", OCR l. 113) and vol. LXI ("sixty-one Volumes", l. 10158-10159); Question 9636 and its solution are on p. 86 of vol. LXI (its index, l. 10947; page "86" at l. 17388, text l. 17419-17450, between the signature marks "VOL. LXI." at l. 16209 and 18826), while vol. LX's own p. 86 (l. 6443) prints Question 726 (Editor) on bags of balls; the kept PNG shows the vol. LXI page (the molecule sum, Q. 12208, Q. 9636) (finding 1) - CONFIRMED | [n41-question] A friend brings a bag of four counters, each black or white, and has you draw two: both white. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "My friend brings me a bag containing four counters, each of which is either black or white. He bids me draw two, both of which prove to be white." - CONFIRMED | [n41-remark] "I meant to tell you, before you began, that there was at least one white counter in the bag. However, you know it now, without my telling you. Draw again." | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word - CONFIRMED | [n41-asks] What is now the chance of white, and what would it have been if he had not spoken? | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "(1) What is now my chance of drawing white? (2) What would it have been, if he had not spoken?" - CONFIRMED | [n41-answers] Carroll answers 7/12 and 1/2. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "(1) Seven-twelfths. (2) One-half." - CONFIRMED | [n41-truth] The friend has it right, though: two whites drawn already prove at least one white, so the remark removes no possibility and the two chances are the same, 1/2. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own enumeration of 16 bags x 24 ordered draws: no remark 1/2, at least one white 1/2, one particular counter white 7/12 - CONFIRMED | [n41-first-line] The error is in the first line of his solution, where "at least one white" becomes the chances 1/8, 3/8, 3/8, 1/8 for four, three, two and one whites. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | the solution opens "(1) As there was certainly at least one W in the bag at first, the a priori chances for ... WWWW, WWWB, WWBB, WBBB, were 1/8, 3/8, 3/8, 1/8" - CONFIRMED | [n41-prior] Those are the chances for a bag in which one particular counter is known to be white. A bag with at least one white has the chances 1/15, 4/15, 6/15, 4/15: | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | 1 + Bin(3, 1/2) gives 1/8, 3/8, 3/8, 1/8 (7/12 recomputed by hand: 7/32 over 3/8); the 15 bags with a white split 1, 4, 6, 4 - CONFIRMED | [n41-his-own] his own 1, 4, 6, 4 from the second part, with the all-black bag struck out. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "(2) If he had not spoken, the a priori chances for the states WWWW, WWWB, WWBB, WBBB, BBBB, would have been 1, 4, 6, 4, 1 over 16" - CONFIRMED | [n50-question] Two bags, H and K, each hold two counters; a white is added to H, one counter goes from H to K, and one comes back. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "There are 2 bags, H and K, each containing 2 counters ... A white counter is added to bag H, ... one counter transferred ... to bag K, where the process is repeated" - CONFIRMED | [n50-table] His solution ends with a table of the chances that H now holds three, two, one or no whites, each line made of products of chances he has already found, and the lines come to 25, 50, 29 and 4 in 108ths. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | his table: 5/12 x 5/9 = 25/108; 5/12 x 4/9 + 1/2 x 5/9 = 50/108; 1/2 x 4/9 + 1/12 x 5/9 = 29/108; 1/12 x 4/9 = 4/108 (rechecked); after it come the chance of a white, 17/27, and the odds - CONFIRMED | [n50-true] They should be 24, 51, 30 and 3. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own enumeration of 16 x 9 paths: 24, 51, 30, 3 in 108ths - CONFIRMED | [n50-his-lines] Each of his products multiplies the chance of what H kept by the chance that the counter coming back is white (5/9) or black (4/9), as if the two were independent; | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "the chance of drawing a W from it is 1/6 x 1 + 5/12 x 2/3 + 1/3 x 1/3; i. e. 5/9. therefore the chance of drawing a B is 4/9", used in every line of the table - CONFIRMED | [n50-independent] Given that H kept two, one or no whites, the returning counter is white with chance 8/15, 5/9 and 2/3, not 5/9 each time. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own enumeration: given H kept 2, 1, 0 whites, the returning counter is white with chance 8/15, 5/9, 2/3 (also by hand) - CONFIRMED | [n50-answer-right] His answer, 17/27, is right anyway, because it needs only the average number of whites, and an average adds up whether or not its parts are independent. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | both tables give 17/27 for a white (mean 17/9 whites); his answer "Seventeen-twentysevenths." - CONFIRMED | [n50-confession] His Introduction confesses a slip in this very table ("bringing out 41/108, instead of 50/108"): the line he corrected to 50/108 should have been 51/108. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "In No. 50, I made a mistake near the end, bringing out 41/108, instead of 50/108." 50/108 appears only in the table's second line, which should be 51/108 - CONFIRMED | [n10-question] A triangular billiard-table has a pocket in each corner, one holding only one ball and the others two each. Three balls, each containing a coin, run into one corner, nobody knows which, and the expected contents of the pocket are 2s.... | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | the question as summarised; the expectation printed "2/6" (typeset by the transcribers as a fraction image) is 2s. 6d., as his "5s/9 = 30d." shows - CONFIRMED | [n10-working] His working is sound: the three coins must make 4s. 6d. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "5s/9 = 30d.; therefore s = 54d. = 4/6": 4s. 6d. (the 5s/9 rederived: 1/3 x s/3 + 2/3 x 2s/3) - CONFIRMED | [n10-answer] His answer is "Either 2 florins and a sixpence; or else a half-crown and 2 shillings", | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | word for word, Chapter II - CONFIRMED | [n10-confession] and his Introduction confesses that he first missed the half-crown and 2 shillings. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "In No. 10, I failed to notice that the 3 coins might also be a half-crown and 2 shillings." - CONFIRMED | [n10-third-set] There is a third set: a double florin and two threepenny pieces. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own search over the coins of 1890: exactly three sets make 54d, double florin + two threepences among them - CONFIRMED | [n10-df-struck] The double florin, a four-shilling piece, was struck from 1887 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin (live, FOUND by sources.mjs 2026-11-15; kept research/pillow-problems/sources/coinage/wikipedia-double-florin.txt) | "The double florin, or four- shilling piece, was a British coin produced by the Royal Mint between 1887 and 1890." (secondary source) - CONFIRMED | [n10-df-august-1890] until August 1890, | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin (live, FOUND) | "Nevertheless, minting of the double florin ceased forever in August 1890." (secondary, citing its note 37) - CONFIRMED | [n10-dated-august-1890] the month in which he dated this problem, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | the question ends "[8/90" - CONFIRMED | [n10-df-circulation] and stayed in circulation afterwards; | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin (live, FOUND) | "Minting of the coin ceased after 1890, though it remained in circulation." - CONFIRMED | [n10-threepence] silver threepences were struck for circulation in every year from 1838 to 1901 but three. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threepence_(British_coin) (live, FOUND) | "threepences were produced both for Maundy use and for normal circulation in all years between 1838 and 1901 except 1847, 1848, and 1852" - CONFIRMED | [n10-unpopular] The double florin was unpopular ("Up to this date it has failed to obtain a general currency", the London correspondent of the Liverpool Mercury wrote in May 1888, as Wikipedia's article on the coin quotes it), | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin (live, FOUND) | "On 30 May 1888, the London correspondent of the Liverpool Mercury stated that ... Up to this date it has failed to obtain a general currency." Second-hand, and the page says so - CONFIRMED | [n10-must-be] But his answer says either, or else, and his solution "Hence the coins must be", which is a claim that there are no others. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Hence the coins must be 2 florins and a sixpence; or else a half-crown and 2 shillings." - CONFIRMED | [n70-question] wraps triangles round a tetrahedron and asks, among other things, for two angles. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "suppose a series of triangles, equal to that facet ... they are all wrapped round the Tetrahedron as far as they will go"; parts (3) and (4) ask for base angles - CONFIRMED | [n70-longest] The longest problem in the book | research/pillow-problems/problems.json | recreated: words of question + answer + solution (formula = 1 word) No. 70 755, No. 69 536, No. 65 501; by characters No. 70 5909 also first - CONFIRMED | [n70-exact] His exact answers are right: the angles whose tangents are √3/5 and √3/7. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "tan^-1(sqrt3/2 / 5/2); i. e. tan^-1 sqrt3/5" and sqrt3/7 for (4); data.json: two methods agree to 1e-9 deg (the second checker concurs) - CONFIRMED | [n70-mem-tech] Turning them into degrees by "mem. tech." (angles he had by heart for round values of the sine), he printed 18·65° and 14·53°. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Now (by mem. tech.) sin^-1 .3 = 17.45 &c." (also .4 and .2): angles remembered for round sines - CONFIRMED | [n70-printed] he printed 18·65° and 14·53°. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "(3) About 18.65 deg. (4) About 14.53 deg." (schnark agrees) - CONFIRMED | [n70-true] They are 19.11° and 13.90°. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own code: 19.1066 and 13.8979 deg - CONFIRMED | [n70-rather-over-9] In the first, the sine is √84/28, and he knew √84 was "rather over 9", but he worked with 9, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "= (rather over 9)/28"; sqrt 84 = 9.1652; his 9/7 = 1.28, /4 = .32 - CONFIRMED | [n70-a-fifth] so he placed the angle a fifth of the way between his remembered angles where it lies 0.27 of the way. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "the required angle is about 1/5 of the way from one to the other"; own code: the sine 0.32733 lies 0.273 of the way from .3 to .4 - CONFIRMED | [n70-half-way] In the second, the sine .24 lies two-fifths of the way between .2 and .3, and he went "about half-way". | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "and we must go about half-way to the next angle"; the sine 0.24019 lies 0.402 of the way from .2 to .3 - CONFIRMED | [n70-first-answers] His Introduction quotes the first answers he wrote down, before he wrote any of the solution: about 18° 18′ and about 14°. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "in No. 70, the very first words I wrote down were as follows: ... (3) about 18 deg 18 min; (4) about 14 deg." - CONFIRMED | [n70-not-quite] "These answers are not quite correct", he says, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "These answers are not quite correct; but at least they are genuine" - CONFIRMED | [n70-confessions] and his list of mistakes explains each by a decimal he forgot to add. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "In No. 70, section (3), I forgot to add in the .45 ... And, in section (4), I forgot to add in the .53" - CONFIRMED | [n70-cancelled] For the second angle that explanation is half the story. His first answer, 14°, was right to the nearest degree, because the decimal he forgot and the "half-way" he did not notice cancelled out. Putting back the decimal and keeping the... | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | 13.898 rounds to 14; 11 + 3 = 14 against 11.54 + 2.37 = 13.91; 14.53 is 0.63 out - CONFIRMED | [n45-question] No. 45 asks for the chance that, of infinitely many rods broken, at least one breaks in the middle. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "If an infinite number of rods be broken: find the chance that one at least is broken in the middle." - CONFIRMED | [n45-not-thought-out] His answer comes to 1 − 1/e, which he works out to seven places below a note: "[N. B. What follows here was not thought out.]" So this is paper, not pillow. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "[N. B. What follows here was not thought out.]" precedes the series, a = 1.5430806, 2a, e and the subtraction (found by hand; sources.mjs drops bracketed text, hence its NO EXCERPT) - CONFIRMED | [n45-his-lines] His own lines give 3·0861612 − 2·7182818 = | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "2a = 3.0861612 &c." and "e = 2.7182818 &c." - CONFIRMED | [n45-he-wrote] and he wrote ·3678793; the answer, ·6321207, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "(1 - 0)^(1/0) = .3678793 &c." and "Ans. = ... = .6321207 &c." (schnark has the same digits) - CONFIRMED | [n45-subtraction] should be ·6321206. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | 30861612 - 27182818 = 3678794; 10^7 - 3678794 = 6321206; 1 - 1/e = .6321205588 - CONFIRMED | [n37-question] Two circles cross; the common chord subtends 30° at one centre and 60° at the other; what fraction of the smaller lies within the larger? | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Two given Circles intersect, so that their common chord subtends angles of 30 deg and 60 deg at their centres. What fraction of the smaller Circle is within the larger?" - CONFIRMED | [n37-walk] (This is one he solved on a walk, by daylight.) | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "No. 37 and one or two others belong to the daylight, having been solved while taking a solitary walk" - CONFIRMED | [n37-about-044] His exact answer is right for the figure he draws, and he gives it as "about ·044". | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | answer "(4 + sqrt3)/12 - (1 + sqrt3)/(2 pi); i.e. about .044"; his solution sums two segments, the figure with the centres on opposite sides - CONFIRMED | [n37-value] It is 0.0429, which is ·043 to three places. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own code: 0.477671 - 0.434819 = 0.042852 (also lens area / pi), .043 to three places - CONFIRMED | [n37-terms] In the working, one term is rounded up (·478) and the other cut short (·434); treated alike, both ways give ·043. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | ".478 - 1.736/4 = .478 - .434 = .044": .47767 rounded up, .43482 cut short (via .248 x 7/4); both rounded .478 - .435 = .043, both cut .477 - .434 = .043 - CONFIRMED | [n37-confession] His Introduction confesses a slip in these very figures, that in his head he had made ·478 into ·476 and so brought out ·042 for ·044, but it files the confession under No. 38, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "In No. 38, I got the decimal wrong, making it .476 instead of .478, and thus brought out the answer as .042 instead of .044." - CONFIRMED | [n38-bags] a problem about bags of counters with no decimal in it. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | No. 38 is three bags of red and white counters, answered "Fortynine-seventytwoths."; its solution has no decimal point (problems.json, no \cdot) - CONFIRMED | [n37-nearer] And his mental ·042 was, as it happens, nearer the truth than the ·044 he printed. | research/pillow-problems/results.json; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | true value .042852: .042 is .00085 below it, .044 is .00115 above - CONFIRMED | [n31-slip] In No. 31 a line gives the watch a rate that belongs to the clock, and the next line uses it, rightly, for the clock. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Hence clock gains ... 11/(24 x 12) sec. in 5m. Hence, while true time goes 5m., watch goes 5m. 11/288 sec." then "clock must be put 5m. 11/288 sec. back" (schnark has "watch" too) - CONFIRMED | [n33-slip] In No. 33 a bracket is out of place in one line of algebra, and the next line is right. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "r^4 - 4(r^2x^2 + 4x^4).(r^2 - 4x^2)": (r^2 - 2x^2)^2 = r^4 - 4r^2x^2 + 4x^4, so the bracket opened after "4" belongs before r^4; the next line r^6 - 8r^4x^2 + 20r^2x^4 - 16x^6 follows from the right form (multiplied out by hand) - CONFIRMED | [n47-slip] In No. 47 a strict inequality should not be strict (the next sentence has it right). | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "cannot be real, unless (x^2 - 4x) > 0. Hence x may have any negative value, and any positive value that is not less than 4"; at x = 4, y = z = 2 solves (4/2 = 2 = 4 - 2) - CONFIRMED | [n65-set-slip] In No. 65 one of three sets of fractions reads 1/2, 1/5, 1/20 where it must be 1/4, 1/5, 1/20, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | case x = 4: "1/4, 1/8, 1/8; 1/4, 1/6, 1/12; 1/2, 1/5, 1/20"; 1/2 + 1/5 + 1/20 = 3/4, 1/4 + 1/5 + 1/20 = 1/2; case (3) refers back to "1/5, 1/4, 1/20" - CONFIRMED | [n65-value-slip] and a list of values includes a 1/2 that his own condition excludes; the count he draws from it is right. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Hence denominator must contain factor 3, and k can be only 1, or 2, or 5, or 10 ... possible values of k/(k+l) are 1/2, ..." then "This gives 2 sets"; the count of 10 shapes recounted by hand (3,7,42 ... 6,6,6) - CONFIRMED | [small-none-reaches] None reaches an answer, and any of the first four could be the compositor's rather than his; only a printed page can say. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | No. 31 answer holds; No. 33 result holds; No. 47 answer holds; No. 65 count of 10 holds - CONFIRMED | [n72-question] The last problem asks for the colours of two counters in a bag "without taking them out of the bag", | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Ascertain their colours without taking them out of the bag." - CONFIRMED | [n72-answer] and answers: one black and one white. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "One is black, and the other white." - CONFIRMED | [n72-argument] Add a black counter, he argues: the chance of then drawing black works out at 2/3, and a bag of two blacks and a white is the only state that gives 2/3; so the bag must have held one of each. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | chances BB, BW, WW 1/4, 1/2, 1/4; "Add a black counter."; 1/4 x 1 + 1/2 x 2/3 + 1/4 x 1/3 = 2/3; "Hence the bag now contains BBW ... it contained BW" - CONFIRMED | [n72-two-thirds] The 2/3 is an average over the bags the question could be holding. That one of them, a black and a white with the black added, gives 2/3 by itself does not make it yours: the chance that yours holds one of each is still 1/2. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own code: 2/3 averaged over the bags; the one-of-each bag keeps chance 1/2 - CONFIRMED | [n72-transcendental] Carroll calls it his "one Problem in 'Transcendental Probabilities'", | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "I can proudly point to my one Problem in Transcendental Probabilities" (p. xvi); Subjects classified: "Transcendental Probabilities. No. 72." - CONFIRMED | [n72-paradoxical] which "may seem abnormal, and even paradoxical". | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "To the casual reader it may seem abnormal, and even paradoxical" - CONFIRMED | [n72-weaver] Warren Weaver, in 1956, took it for "two dreadful mistakes"; | https://mural.uv.es/carmapa2/arte14.html (live, FOUND 2026-11-15; kept research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/weaver-1956-uv-arte14.html) | "In his attack on this problem (which as stated cannot actually be solved) he makes two dreadful mistakes." after quoting No. 72; "This is good Wonderland, but very amateurish mathematics." A student transcription: scientificamerican.com is refused, and a web search found no other copy - CONFIRMED | [n72-moktefi] Amirouche Moktefi, in 2008, calls it a "controversial joke-problem". | https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/DSB/Dodgson.pdf (fetched 2026-11-15, read with pdftotext) | "included twelve interesting probability problems together with a thirteenth, controversial joke-problem in transcendental probabilities"; signed "Amirouche Moktefi"; Complete DSB, 2008 - CONFIRMED | [n72-counted] The page counts it among the mistakes as mathematics and does not claim to know which he meant. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | No. 72 answer and solution-inference are "wrong"; the detail says "the book does not say whether the argument is meant in earnest" - CONFIRMED | [readings-ten] Ten questions are worded so that more than one answer is defensible. In each, his answer is right under the reading his solution takes, and the check gives the answer under the others too. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | depends claims fall in Nos. 13, 14, 25, 29, 37, 38, 45, 47, 58, 69: ten problems - CONFIRMED | [n58-quote] The best known is No. 58, three points "taken at random on an infinite Plane": | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Three Points are taken at random on an infinite Plane." - CONFIRMED | [n58-no-even-choice] there is no way to choose points evenly from an infinite plane, so the chance of an obtuse triangle depends on how they are chosen. | https://mathworld.wolfram.com/ObtuseTriangle.html (live, FOUND) | "it is impossible to pick random variables which are uniformly distributed in the plane (Eisenberg and Sullivan 1996)"; Cantarella et al.: "no translation-invariant probability distribution on the infinite plane" - CONFIRMED | [n58-figures] His procedure gives 0.6394, three points spread evenly over a disc give 0.7197, over a square 0.7252, and independent bell-curve points exactly 3/4. | research/pillow-problems/results.json; recreated: node scratch n58.mjs (closed forms, 2,000,000-triangle samples) | his (pi/4)/(2pi/3 - sqrt3/2) = 0.63938; disc 9/8 - 4/pi^2 = 0.71972 (sample 0.71942); square 97/150 + pi/40 = 0.72521 (0.72515); Gaussian 3/4 (0.75030) - CONFIRMED | [n58-portnoy] Stephen Portnoy (1994), | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1214/ss/1177010497 (live, FOUND; DOI MATCH) | author Stephen Portnoy, "A Lewis Carroll Pillow Problem: Probability of an Obtuse Triangle", Statistical Science 9(2), May 1994, 279-284 - CONFIRMED | [n58-falk] Ruma Falk and Ester Samuel-Cahn (2001) | https://mural.uv.es/carmapa2/arte5.html (live, FOUND) | "Ruma Falk and Ester Samuel-Cahn", "Lewis Carroll's Obtuse Problem", January 2001; the HUJI page gives Teaching Statistics 23 (2001), 72-75 - CONFIRMED | [n58-cantarella] and Jason Cantarella and colleagues (2019) have written about this one at length. | https://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.01027 (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, read with pdftotext) | "Jason Cantarella, Tom Needham, Clayton Shonkwiler, and Gavin Stewart"; "Carroll himself gave a solution, but his method gives two different answers under the assumptions that side AB is the longest or second-longest side" - CONFIRMED | [n45-limit] No. 45 is the same kind of question in disguise. With N rods, each breaking at one of n equally likely points, the chance that at least one breaks in the middle tends to 1 − e−c when N/n tends to c. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs | 1 - (1 - 1/n)^N with N = cn tends to 1 - e^-c (standard limit; the verifier's d45 group checks c = 1/2, 1, 2 at n = 10^6) - CONFIRMED | [n45-infinite-rods] "An infinite number of rods" does not say what c is; | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "If an infinite number of rods be broken" - CONFIRMED | [n45-as-many] his solution quietly takes as many rods as points, c = 1. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "n points of division ... the only points where the rod will break"; "The chance of one failure is (n-1)/n; ... n failures is ((n-1)/n)^n": n rods for n points - CONFIRMED | [n37-second-figure] No. 37's circles can cross in a second way the words allow, with both centres on the same side of the chord; then 0.9852 of the smaller circle is inside the larger. | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | own code: (pi - (seg(1, 60 deg) - seg(R, 30 deg)))/pi = 0.9852; the two circles meet only at the chord ends, so the rest of the smaller lies inside - CONFIRMED | [n38-readings] No. 38's "one proves to be red" gives 49/72 if a particular counter is looked at (his reading, which the words favour) and 49/95 if we are told only that at least one is red. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html); recreated: node scratch findings.mjs and n61.mjs (own code, exact rationals) | bags A 3 red, B 2 red 1 white, C 1 red 2 white (question); own exact code and by hand: a particular counter seen red 49/72, only at least one red 49/95 - CONFIRMED | [n14-n29] Nos. 14 and 29, two theorems about sums of squares, are true if 0 counts as a square and fail in some cases if it does not. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | No. 14: 3(1+1+1) = 9 is not a sum of four positive squares (only 1 and 4 fit); No. 29: (1+4)(1+4) = 25 = 3^2+4^2 = 5^2+0^2 (checked by hand) - CONFIRMED | [n13-69-25-47] No. 13's area formula gives minus the area when the tetragon is re-entrant; No. 69's ratio of the sides of two similar triangles, 2 cos θ, is negative when his variable θ passes 90°, which his own working allows; No. 25's least number... | research/pillow-problems/results.json; https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | No. 25 asks "what is the least possible number who have lost all three?" with answer epsilon + alpha + lambda - 2, below 0 when the sum is under 2; Nos. 13, 69, 47 as results.json details state; the mended definitions are on the page - CONFIRMED | [nights-dated] Carroll dated most of the problems, day and month and year or month and year. | research/pillow-problems/problems.json | recreated: 65 dated, 37 day/month/year, 28 month/year - CONFIRMED | [nights-range] Here are the dated ones on a line from his earliest, January 1872, to his latest, December 1891, each coloured by what the checks found. | research/pillow-problems/problems.json | recreated: earliest No. 67, 27/1/72; latest No. 37, 12/91 - CONFIRMED | [nights-aria] The problems Carroll dated, placed on a line from 1872 to 1891. Each is a button that opens the problem. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/app.mjs | the aria-label as built; 1872 to 1891 matches the stamps - CONFIRMED | [nights-undated] Not dated in the book: Nos. 2, 3, 6, 19, 33, 50, 70. | research/pillow-problems/problems.json | recreated: Nos. 2, 3, 6, 19, 33, 50, 70 have no stamp - CONFIRMED | [nights-legend] (each problem coloured by the most serious verdict among its claims) | research/pillow-problems/build-data.mjs | worst = first of wrong, slip, depends, unchecked, holds among a problem's verdicts - CONFIRMED | [tally] 537 holds 17 slip 8 wrong 14 depends on the reading 1 not checkable | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "tally":{"wrong":8,"slip":17,"depends":14,"unchecked":1,"holds":537}, recounted from the claims - CONFIRMED | [ledger] What he says, and what the check finds | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | the ledger is the program's output (build-data --check current). The note's FINDING is stale: served checks/p15.mjs is byte-identical to the research copy and data.json now says "never arises under his hypothesis"; "with one gap" is in none of them (finding 11) - CONFIRMED | [ledger-chapters] His answer, Chapter II | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "CHAPTER I. Questions 1 CHAPTER II. Answers 19 CHAPTER III. Solutions 28" - CONFIRMED | [ledger-no-answer] The book prints no separate answer for this one; what it asks for is found in the solution. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html); research/pillow-problems/problems.json | 28 problems have no Chapter II answer, each with solution claims; No. 65 is a count - CONFIRMED | [ledger-run-output] every verdict and figure is the one printed above. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/app.mjs | the success sentence prints only when every verdict and computed figure equals data.json's - CONFIRMED | [confessions-intro] Each entry in the Introduction's list of mistakes is itself a claim: that he made the slip, and that the corrected figure is right. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | introduction claims: the ten entries (Nos. 7, 10, 13, 32, 37, 44, 50, 55, 57 twice, 70 twice) and five more, 17 rows - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-given-triangle] Many of the problems ask for a construction in "a given Triangle", and a construction is only half an answer until it says when it can be done. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | No. 2: "In a given Triangle to place a line parallel to the base" - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-usually] His usually do exactly what he claims whenever an answer exists, and say nothing about when one does not. None of these is counted as a mistake; each is in the ledger with what the check found. | research/pillow-problems/results.json | the construction claims named are all "holds", each detail stating the limit - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-18-20] In No. 18 and No. 20 there is no such point at all when a base angle is obtuse. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | No. 18: "When B or C is obtuse ... no point of the base works (100 of 100 tried)"; No. 20 likewise (50 and 50) - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-26] No. 26 can be done only in an acute-angled triangle. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "So the question has no answer unless the triangle is acute" - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-11] No. 11's inner triangle exists only while the given angle is less than 180° less the largest angle of the triangle. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "The inner triangle exists only while theta < 180 deg minus the largest angle" - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-56] No. 56's construction from three altitudes works exactly when the altitudes belong to some triangle, which is not always. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "his circles met exactly when a triangle with those altitudes exists, 486 times" of 1000 - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-46] No. 46's works in 691 of 1,500 random cases, exactly those where an answer exists with the two remaining angles placed as in his figure; in 234 more an answer exists only with those two angles the other way round, and in 575 there is none. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | 691 of 1500; "In the other 809 ... in 575 of them the other placing ... fails too": 809 - 575 = 234; held by the verifier - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-57] In No. 57 the three squares lie inside the triangle in 232 of 400 random triangles, and not in 168 of the 242 obtuse ones. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "232 of 400 triangles (74 of the 242 obtuse ones)": 400 - 232 = 168 = 242 - 74; held by the verifier - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-51] And in No. 51, when an obtuse angle makes the problem impossible, his steps still draw a line, sometimes one that ends on the right side and fails only when measured. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "His steps can still be carried out ... in 131 of the 333 cases it even ends on AC" - CONFIRMED | [unsaid-9] In the other direction, No. 9 has two answers whenever the angle is acute; his construction can find either, and he does not say there are two. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | "exactly two solutions when the angle BAC is acute (180 cases)"; "His construction yields both" - CONFIRMED | [method-fourth-edition] The text is Project Gutenberg's transcription of the fourth edition (Macmillan, 1895; | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Original publication: London: Macmillan and Co., 1895"; title page "FOURTH EDITION" - CONFIRMED | [method-released] eBook 79080, released in July 2026, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Release date: July 12, 2026 [eBook #79080]" - CONFIRMED | [method-transcribers] made by Aaron Adrignola, Laura Natal and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team from HathiTrust's page images), | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Credits: Aaron Adrignola, Laura Natal and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team ... produced from images made available by the HathiTrust Digital Library" - CONFIRMED | [method-cut] cut into the 72 problems by the book's own numbering: 72 questions, 44 printed answers, 72 solutions. | research/pillow-problems/problems.json | "counts": questions 72, answers 44, solutions 72; split.mjs --check current - CONFIRMED | [method-claim-quotes] A claim is anything he asserts that a computation can test, and every claim quotes his words; a program refuses any quotation that is not in the book. | research/pillow-problems/run.mjs | run.mjs errs on any claim whose quote is not in the part it names (l. 48); the verifier's section B holds all 577 - OBSERVED | [method-check-made] Each problem has a check: a short JavaScript file that builds the question from its data alone and computes what he claims, in exact fractions where it can, in floating point with a stated tolerance where it cannot, on hundreds of... | research/pillow-problems/README.md; research/pillow-problems/results.json | the README describes the checks so; results.json methods: exact, enumeration, numeric, instances; the mended "when the cases are finite" is on the page - OBSERVED | [method-solutions-read] His solutions are read only to learn his reading and to test his steps. | research/pillow-problems/README.md; research/pillow-problems/CHECKING.md | the README and the brief say so - MINOR | [method-eight-agents] The checks were written by AI agents (eight, each with a batch of problems and the same written brief), | research/pillow-problems/README.md; research/pillow-problems/checks/p37.mjs | eight batch agents and eight BATCH reports, but No. 37's check is "The worked example for CHECKING.md", written by the lead before the batches (README: "and No. 37 as the worked example"); no batch covers No. 37 (finding 8) - OBSERVED | [method-second-check] and every verdict that says Carroll erred, or that a question can be read two ways, was then worked out again from the book by a second agent that had not seen the first one's code or reasoning, with problems known to be right mixed in... | research/pillow-problems/checks/reports/RECHECK-SUMMARY.md; research/pillow-problems/RECHECK.md | four blind agents R1 to R4 covered every non-holds problem (10, 13, 14, 15, 25, 29, 31, 33, 37, 38, 41, 45, 47, 50, 58, 61, 65, 69, 70, 72) with controls 7, 19, 23, 63, 66 - OBSERVED | [method-agreed] The two agreed on every mistake on this page. | research/pillow-problems/checks/reports/RECHECK-SUMMARY.md | "Every mistake the page reports ... was found again by the second check." - OBSERVED | [method-three-labels] They differed on three labels. The second checker would have called No. 25's missing condition a mistake and No. 69's missing absolute value a slip, and would have said No. 38's answer holds, its words favouring his reading; the page... | research/pillow-problems/checks/reports/RECHECK-SUMMARY.md | R4 No. 25 "WRONG (omitted condition)", No. 69 "SLIP (missing absolute value)", R1 No. 38 "holds, with depends defensible" - CONFIRMED | [method-verdict-words] A verdict is one of five words: holds (right, exactly or to the figures printed), slip (a figure wrong, the method sound), wrong (more than a slip: a formula, a prior, a count, or a list that claims to be complete), depends on the... | research/pillow-problems/README.md | README "Verdicts" and app.mjs WORD; No. 15 is the only unchecked claim - CONFIRMED | [limits-reading] A reading of a question is a choice, and each is printed beside its verdict for you to dispute. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | every problem in data.json has a reading, printed in its ledger row - OBSERVED | [limits-scans] we could not read a page image of the book ourselves, because the libraries holding scans (HathiTrust and Google Books) turn automated readers away. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FETCH-LOG.tsv; recreated: node scripts/robots-policy.mjs on a babel.hathitrust.org page view and a books.google.com ?pg= view | the log refuses both; recreated 2026-11-15: HathiTrust refused (robots.txt answers 403), Google Books refused (Disallow: /books?*pg=) - CONFIRMED | [transcribers-sin-cos] The transcribers say that they replaced his private symbols for sine and cosine with sin and cos, | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "the notation used by the author for [two symbols] has been replaced with modern terminology"; his footnote and the 4th-edition preface say the symbols mean "sine" and "cosine" - CONFIRMED | [transcribers-alpha] and that where the print does not distinguish a from α they corrected certain expressions. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "Due to a lack of distinction between a and [alpha] in the printed version, certain expressions have been corrected" - MINOR | [schnark-compared] A second transcription of the fourth edition, at schnark.github.io, made separately (it has slips of its own that Gutenberg's does not), agrees with Gutenberg's on the disputed figures we compared in it, in Nos. 10, 31, 33, 37, 41, 45,... | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/schnark-figures-2.excerpt.txt; research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/schnark-figures.excerpt.txt | the excerpts compare Nos. 10, 31, 33, 37 (and the confession under 38), 38, 41, 45, 47, 50, 65, 70 and agree but for 22/108 and 1 1/2; the page's list leaves out No. 50, the home of one of its own two exceptions (and No. 38) (finding 7) - OBSERVED | [schnark-22-108] in No. 50's table it has 22/108 where Gutenberg's has 29/108, | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/schnark-figures-2.excerpt.txt | "1 W, 2 B, 1/2 x 4/9 + 1/12 x 5/9; i. e. 22/108." in the kept excerpt (page sha256 recorded; schnark.github.io is reference tier, not re-fetched) - CONFIRMED | [schnark-one-and-a-half] and in No. 70 "about 1½ degrees" where Gutenberg's has 1⅕; | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/schnark-figures-2.excerpt.txt | "Hence we must add, to the lesser, about 1 1 2 degrees, or 1.20 deg." (1 1/2); reference tier, so read in the kept excerpt only - CONFIRMED | [schnark-arithmetic] in each, Gutenberg's reading is the one his own arithmetic gives (29/108 is his product, and 1⅕ is the 1·20° printed beside it). | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "about 1 1/5 degrees, or 1.20 deg"; 1/2 x 4/9 + 1/12 x 5/9 = 29/108 (by hand) - OBSERVED | [edtimes-page-image] No. 61's theorem we also read on a page image of another printing, the Educational Times volume above, where it is set as the same theorem in slightly different words. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-1894-vol60-p86.png (viewed) | the kept image shows Q. 9636 in the words the record gives; the same theorem in slightly different words. The image is of vol. LXI, p. 86 (finding 1) - OBSERVED | [first-edition-unread] The first edition of 1893 was not read at all, and its figures may differ. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FINDINGS.md | "No first-edition scan is reachable under the policy." - OBSERVED | [nobody-before] As far as we could find, nobody has published a check of all 72 answers before. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FINDINGS.md | "No one has published a check of all 72 answers, as far as I can find." - CONFIRMED | [brabant-first] Carroll's own list, and F. G. Brabant's working of every result, are the first. | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "first working out each result independently, and has thus detected many mistakes" - CONFIRMED | [seneta-quote] Eugene Seneta's centenary paper of 1993 examines a few of the thirteen problems on chances and says "Some are badly posed with imaginative but incorrect solutions"; | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1214/ss/1177011011 (live, FOUND; DOI MATCH) | author Eugene Seneta; abstract "We examine a few key problems and their solutions from the 13 probability problems. Some are badly posed with imaginative but incorrect solutions" - OBSERVED | [seneta-abstract-only] we could read only its abstract, so we do not know which he meant, and it may already say some of what this page says about Nos. 38 and 41. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FETCH-LOG.tsv; recreated: node scripts/robots-policy.mjs on the projecteuclid.org .full URL | the log and a fresh policy run both refuse Project Euclid; the page offers Nos. 38 and 41 only as a possibility - CONFIRMED | [cite-portnoy] No. 58 has a literature of its own (Portnoy 1994; | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1214/ss/1177010497 (live; DOI MATCH) | Stephen Portnoy, 1994. sources.mjs printed "DOI MISMATCH" only because the cited words hold no title words; authors and year match - CONFIRMED | [cite-falk] Falk and Samuel-Cahn 2001; | https://ratio.huji.ac.il/node/3129261 (live, FOUND; it redirects to /publications/lewis-carrolls-obtuse-problem, policy allowed) | "Teaching Statistics 23 (2001), 72-75." - CONFIRMED | [cite-cantarella] Cantarella, Needham, Shonkwiler and Stewart 2019), | https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.01027 (live, FOUND) | journal ref "The American Mathematical Monthly 126 (2019), no. 2, 113-134"; citation_doi 10.1080/00029890.2019.1535735 (Crossref: Random Triangles and Polygons in the Plane; authors and 2019 match, the "MISMATCH" is the missing title words) - CONFIRMED | [cite-weaver] and so does No. 72 (Weaver 1956; | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1038/scientificamerican0456-116 (live, FOUND; DOI MATCH) | Warren Weaver, "Lewis Carroll: Mathematician", Scientific American 194(4), April 1956, 116-130 - CONFIRMED | [cite-moktefi] Moktefi 2008). | https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/DSB/Dodgson.pdf (fetched 2026-11-15, read with pdftotext) | "Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography COPYRIGHT 2008 Charles Scribner's Sons" (kept text), signed "Amirouche Moktefi" (PDF) - CONFIRMED | [cite-seneta] Eugene Seneta's centenary paper of 1993 | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1214/ss/1177011011 (live; DOI MATCH) | title "Lewis Carroll's Pillow Problems: On the 1993 Centenary", Statistical Science 8(2), May 1993, 180-186, Eugene Seneta - WRONG | [cite-edtimes] (vol. LX, 1894, p. 86) | https://archive.org/download/mathematicalque00unkngoog/mathematicalque00unkngoog_djvu.txt (live copy fetched 2026-11-15, sha256 cb069384..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-questions-vol60-1894-djvu.txt); research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/kept/educational-times-1894-vol60-p86.png (viewed) | 1894 and p. 86 are right, but the volume is wrong: the archive.org item binds vol. LX (title-page notice "sixty Volumes", OCR l. 113) and vol. LXI ("sixty-one Volumes", l. 10158-10159); Question 9636 and its solution are on p. 86 of vol. LXI (its index, l. 10947; page "86" at l. 17388, text l. 17419-17450, between the signature marks "VOL. LXI." at l. 16209 and 18826), while vol. LX's own p. 86 (l. 6443) prints Question 726 (Editor) on bags of balls; the kept PNG shows the vol. LXI page (the molecule sum, Q. 12208, Q. 9636); the record note's "the archive.org item give[s] vol. LX" is unsupported: the item's metadata (https://archive.org/metadata/mathematicalque00unkngoog, fetched 2026-11-15) gives title, date 1894 and 277 images, no volume (finding 1) - OBSERVED | [no-earlier-statement] We found no earlier statement that No. 61 is false, or of the mistakes in Nos. 10, 37, 45, 50 and 70; | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FINDINGS.md | the scout lists published wrong-answer claims for Nos. 58, 72, 38 and 44 (method) and none for 10, 37, 45, 50, 61 or 70; section D: "No source the scout read discusses the printed digits" - OBSERVED | [gutenberg-thanks] The Gutenberg volunteers made the text this page is built on, and a separate transcription at schnark.github.io let us compare the figures we dispute. | research/pillow-problems/sources/README.md | the transcription is Gutenberg's; the schnark comparison is kept as two excerpt files - CONFIRMED | [verifier-recomputes] To run all of them, and a second set of arithmetic that recomputes every finding on this page without using them, | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs | GROUPS: 26 findings by its own arithmetic, no check file imported (recreated: "26 findings recomputed" in each run) - CONFIRMED | [verifier-node] download the verifier and run it with Node (version 22 or later, no other installation): | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs | ran on Node v22.23.4 with no install: exit 0 - MINOR | [verifier-does] It downloads the page's data and check files into a folder beside it, runs every check again, holds every quotation the checks make to the book's text, recomputes each finding by its own route, and fails if any of the figures this... | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs; recreated: node scratch mutate-sentences.mjs on AW_DIR copies | downloads, re-runs, holds the 577 quotations and recomputes 26 findings, as said; but figures the prose takes from the findings outside a data-f span are not held: the dek's "1, 4 and 13" and "should be 1/2", and "11, 8 and -1", "51/108" in the body, each changed alone (dek and description together), left the verifier green (2698 passed, 0 failed); span changes (577, 691, 40) failed as they should (finding 5) - CONFIRMED | [confessions-also] The table also checks what the rest of the Introduction says about particular problems: Brabant's neater answer to No. 59, a figure and the dates in his "biography" of No. 63, the first answers to No. 70, and his "one Problem in... | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "He has also supplied, for No. 59, a much neater answer"; "I will give the biography of No. 63"; "in No. 70, the very first words I wrote down"; "my one Problem in Transcendental Probabilities"; data.json has those five introduction claims - MINOR | [verifier-online-mutate] also fetches the book from Project Gutenberg and confirms it is the copy the checks quote; | verify-having-eluded-us-both.mjs | section G (l. 621-629) only compares the sha256 of Gutenberg's file with the string book.json records; in a stranger's run nothing checks that book.json's texts were cut from that file (split.mjs and build-data.mjs --check run only in the repository). --online ran green (2699 passed); --mutate caught 8 of 8 (finding 6) - CONFIRMED | [show-column-45] Carroll's column of decimals | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | "a = 1.5430806 &c." and the rest of his column; recreated by running show.mjs in Node: .3678794, .6321206 and the twelve-place series figures - CONFIRMED | [show-rods-45] as both grow in that proportion it tends to 1 − e−1.00 = 0.632121. This is his answer. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | 1 - 0.999^1000 = 0.632305 and 1 - 1/e = 0.632121 as printed - CONFIRMED | [show-circles-37] Two pairs of circles meeting on a chord that subtends 60 degrees at the smaller centre and 30 degrees at the larger. Left, the centres on opposite sides of the chord: 0.0429 of the smaller circle is inside the larger. Right, the centres... | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | aria-label prints 0.0429 and 0.9852 - CONFIRMED | [show-interp-70-aria] Two rulers of sines. In part (3) the sine of the true angle lies 0.27 of the way from .3 to .4, where Carroll took 1/5. In part (4) it lies 0.40 of the way from .2 to .3, where he took one half. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | aria-label prints 0.27 and 0.40 (computed, mended) - CONFIRMED | [show-interp-70-out] exactly as his solution has it). He printed | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | "(3): the sine is 0.3273, 0.27 of the way along, so the angle is 19.11 deg ... He printed 18.65 deg ..."; (4) 0.2402, 0.40, 13.90, 14.53, 14 - CONFIRMED | [show-bags-41] every one of those had at least one white, so the friend's remark removes none of them. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | seeded run: 0.502 (exactly 1/2) and 0.584 (exactly 7/12); exact values recomputed - CONFIRMED | [show-bags-72] The 2/3 is an average over all the bags; that a bag of one black and one white, with its black added, gives 2/3 by itself does not make yours that bag. | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; recreated: node scratch run-show.mjs | seeded run: 0.661 (exactly 2/3), 0.496 (exactly 1/2); mended wording printed - MINOR | [added-jsonld-isbasedon] isBasedOn: {"@type":"CreativeWork","name":"Curiosa mathematica, part II (Project Gutenberg eBook #79080)","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/79080"} (JSON-LD, index.html l. 29) | https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/79080 (fetched 2026-11-15) | the eBook exists (the cache file header: "Release date: July 12, 2026 [eBook #79080]"), but its landing page answers 404 "No ebook by that number."; so do 79079 and 79081, while /ebooks/11483 answers 200, so Gutenberg's catalogue is not serving this range; the record has no entry (finding 9) - CONFIRMED | [added-filter-counts] all 72 / holds (72) / slip (7) / wrong (5) / depends on the reading (10) / not checkable (1) (the ledger's filter buttons, built by app.mjs) | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/data.json | recounted: problems with at least one claim of each verdict 72, 7, 5, 10, 1; the record has no entry (finding 12) - MINOR | [added-rods45-1000] With 1,000 rods and 1,000 possible breaking points, the chance is 1 - (1 - 1/1000)^1000 = 0.632305 (show.mjs rods45 at c = 1) | public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/show.mjs; https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/79080/pg79080-images.html (fetched 2026-11-15, 200, sha256 988a7a1a..., byte-identical to research/pillow-problems/sources/pg79080-images.html) | the figure is right for the abstract model, but his model takes n odd so that the middle is one of the n points ("where n is assumed to be odd"); with 1,000 equally spaced points none is the middle. The record's show-rods-45 claim stops after this sentence (finding 10) - OBSERVED | [added-scout-refused-hosts] a scout read what it could reach under the site's rules for automated reading, and refused hosts were not read. | research/pillow-problems/sources/scholarship/FETCH-LOG.tsv (l. 60); research/pillow-problems/README.md | the log refuses each such host; its one breach, openlibrary.org/search.json fetched in error by a chained command, was "deleted at once and nothing from it is used", so "not read" holds as the record tells it; the record has no entry (finding 13) ## Findings - [fixed] MED. The Educational Times citation names the wrong volume. Page (public/strata/having-eluded-us-both/index.html l. 56): "“2m−a is not equal to a or b or c unless these quantities are in Arithmetical Progression” (vol. LX, 1894, p. 86)". The archive.org item mathematicalque00unkngoog binds two volumes: vol. LX (title-page notice "there have now been published sixty Volumes", OCR l. 113) and vol. LXI ("•VOL. Xj