--- slug: i-have-not-counted-them passed: 2026-11-16 by: claude-gifted-feynman-28rsk3, one agent on oversight/claims-pass.md, before publish, at commit 7828b145c6 (the whole page, not a sample: all 109 source entries read against their kept copies, every cited page image opened, 44 claims added); every finding then re-read against its source by the instance before the edit checked: 153 confirmed: 111 wrong: 25 unverifiable: 1 observed: 16 stale: 0 --- # Claims pass: I Have Not Counted Them Live: not checked. The layer is not published yet, so the live page and the /checks/ download could not be fetched; that is a fact about timing, not a finding. Reader-side check run inside the repository instead, at 7828b145c6: `node verify-i-have-not-counted-them.mjs` 1290 passed, 0 failed; `--mutate` "planted faults caught: 17 of 17", 1291 passed. `node assay/sources.mjs i-have-not-counted-them --online`: 67 FOUND, 34 NOT FOUND, 3 UNREADABLE (PDFs, checked against their kept text), 3 in the repository; all 34 NOT FOUND are archive.org page images the tool cannot read (finding 25), and each was opened from its kept copy. The pass began on the 107-entry record (27f27d66dd, 185 claims, 147 hold); the author moved to 109 entries and 186/148 during it, and every line below is against 7828b145c6. In the notes, "line N" is the Nth claim line below. **After the pass (2026-11-16).** Every finding below was re-read against its source before anything changed: the true 1728 edition (archive.org `bim_eighteenth-century_arithmetica-universalis_newton-sir-isaac_1728`, now kept), Hinz and Petr's talk and the Crossref record of their 2016 paper, Selmer's 1951 paper (pp. 306 and 342), Dickson vol. II p. 574, Lehmer's note and the 1748 Melmoth were all opened by the instance and kept under `sources/world/`. The "except 66" sentence is now two claims, so the page has 187 (148 hold, 7 fail); the source record has 104 entries, each paired with the sentence its source supports; `node verify-i-have-not-counted-them.mjs --mutate`: 1314 passed, 0 failed, 17 of 17 planted faults caught. ## Claims - CONFIRMED | intro-tulliver-1: George Eliot: "This was a puzzling world, as he often said"; Mr. Tulliver himself: "This is a puzzlin' world." | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/6688/pg6688.txt | both in Book First, ch. III (kept lines 491, 623); "It's a puzzling world" occurs nowhere in the novel - CONFIRMED | intro-tulliver-1n: the habit is in the novel (Book First, chapter III); the words in his quotation marks are not | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/6688/pg6688.txt | as stated; "quoted loosely" is fair - CONFIRMED | intro-solomon-1: the words are the King James Bible's, Proverbs 30:18-19, word for word | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/8020/pg8020.txt | 30:18-19 match Dudeney word for word (punctuation aside) - CONFIRMED | intro-solomon-1n: the chapter opens "The words of Agur the son of Jakeh" | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/8020/pg8020.txt | 30:1 verbatim; the rabbinic half rests on line 6 - MINOR | intro-solomon-2: the KJV wording, paired with the Jewish Encyclopedia | https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/927-agur-ben-jakeh | the JE excerpt does not bear on the KJV wording; true by line 3 (record pairing, finding 23; counted confirmed) - MINOR | intro-solomon-2n: Solomon's only on the rabbinic reading of Agur as one of his names (Jewish Encyclopedia, 1906) | https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/927-agur-ben-jakeh | substance confirmed ("interpreted by the Haggadah as epithets of Solomon"); but the kept excerpt says "Images of pages V:1 P:276": vol. 1, published 1901 (archive.org b29000488_0001: "Vol. 1", 1901); the set ran 1901 to 1906. Finding 11 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | intro-fitzosborne-1: Melmoth's letter has "making and solving riddles" and "the education of both sexes"; the book has puzzles and meditation | https://archive.org/download/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748_djvu.txt | as stated - WRONG | intro-fitzosborne-1n: Letter V, "To Timoclea" (1748 printing); the closing maxim is his word for word; "two sentences are cut without a mark" | https://archive.org/download/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748_djvu.txt | letter, title and maxim confirmed (pp. 7-8, images read); but three whole sentences are cut, not two: "Those of yours may by this means ... disturbance to the publick." (between the extract's first and second sentences), "For as it consists in discovering truth ... false connections." and "In short, Timoclea, ... a prudent disguise?" (between its second and third), plus the end of the logic sentence (", and might therefore be introduced ... places of education."). Finding 6 - CONFIRMED | intro-fitzosborne-2: the same, read from the page image | https://archive.org/download/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748/page/n10.jpg | image read: "LETTER V. To Timoclea." ... "making and ſolving riddles. It is a ſcience, undoubtedly, of moſt neceſſary acquirement, and deſerves to make a part in the education of both ſexes." - MINOR | intro-fitzosborne-2n: the same note, paired with the p. 7 image | https://archive.org/download/bim_eighteenth-century_letters-on-several-subj_melmoth-william_1748/page/n10.jpg | p. 7 itself shows the first unmarked cut ("Thoſe of yours may by this means ..."), which the note's count leaves out; same error as line 8 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | intro-samson-1: Judges 14:12: "then I will give you thirty sheets and thirty change of garments" | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/8007/pg8007.txt | verbatim - CONFIRMED | intro-samson-1n: a wager both ways (14:13) | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/8007/pg8007.txt | "But if ye cannot declare it me, then shall ye give me thirty sheets and thirty change of garments." - CONFIRMED | intro-magic-5-1: 275,305,224, counted by Richard Schroeppel's program in 1973 | https://oeis.org/A006052 | "a(5) computed by Richard C. Schroeppel in 1973"; data 275305224 - CONFIRMED | intro-magic-5-1n: Schroeppel's 1991 letter "4 * 68826306"; Gardner published it in 1976 (per Walter Trump) | https://oeis.org/A006052 | the kept scan of the email: "The number of magic squares of order 5 is 4 * 68826306." and "I wrote a program to count them in 1973"; Trump (kept): "published in Scientific American in January 1976" - CONFIRMED | intro-knight-magic-1: finished on 5 August 2003, 140 semimagic tours and no magic one | https://mathworld.wolfram.com/news/2003-08-06/magictours/ | "the project was completed on August 5, 2003 ... 140 distinct semimagic knight's tours ... no 8 x 8 magic knight's tour is possible" - CONFIRMED | intro-knight-magic-1n: J. C. Meyrignac's program; MathWorld reported it on 6 August 2003 | https://mathworld.wolfram.com/news/2003-08-06/magictours/ | "The software for the computation was written by J. C. Meyrignac"; dated August 6, 2003 - CONFIRMED | prologue-leland-1: "hinc ingenioſus mathematicus" (ed. Hall, 1709, p. 420) | https://archive.org/download/commentariidesc01hallgoog/commentariidesc01hallgoog_djvu.txt | in the chapter on Chaucer - CONFIRMED | prologue-leland-2: the same, from the page image | https://archive.org/download/commentariidesc01hallgoog/page/n171.jpg | image read: p. 420, "hinc gravis philoſophus, hinc ingenioſus mathematicus" - CONFIRMED | weaver-arms-1: Eleanor, daughter of Ferdinand III, married Edward I in 1254 | https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography,_1885-1900/Eleanor_of_Castile | "daughter of Ferdinand III of Castile ... married to him in the monastery of Las Huelgas in October 1254" - CONFIRMED | weaver-arms-2: his first wife | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eleanor_of_Castile | "Queen of England as the first wife of Edward I" - CONFIRMED | weaver-arms-3: Ferdinand quartered the castles of Castile with the lions of León | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coat_of_arms_of_Castile_and_Le%C3%B3n | "In 1230, Ferdinand III united the two kingdoms and quartered the arms" - CONFIRMED | doctor-legendre-1: Legendre "stated that the equation is impossible for A = 3, 5, 6" | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft_djvu.txt | OCR: "impossible for A. = 3, 5, 6, whereas for A = 6 it has the solutions" - CONFIRMED | doctor-legendre-1n: Legendre's own Théorie des nombres (1798) was not read | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft_djvu.txt | a statement of scope; the 1798 citation is Dickson's note 184 (line 25) - CONFIRMED | doctor-legendre-2: the same, from p. 573 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/page/n602.jpg | image read: "He stated that the equation is impossible for A = 3, 5, 6, whereas for A = 6 it has the solutions x = 37, y = 17, z = 21." - CONFIRMED | doctor-legendre-2n: the same note, from p. 573 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/page/n602.jpg | note 184: "Théorie des nombres, Paris, 1798, 409" - CONFIRMED | doctor-lucas-1: Lucas published 17³ + 37³ = 6 × 21³, "contrary to Legendre", in the Nouvelles Annales of 1878 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft_djvu.txt | OCR: "contrary to Legendre.184"; note 198 "Ibid., 425-6" after note 197 "Nouv. Ann. Math., (2), 17, 1878" - CONFIRMED | doctor-lucas-1n: Dickson credits the same answer to Lamé, Comptes Rendus 1865 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft_djvu.txt | p. 573 note 185: "G. Lamé, Comptes Rendus Paris, 61, 1865, 924." - CONFIRMED | doctor-lucas-2: the same, from p. 575 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/page/n604.jpg | image read: "For x = 1, y = 2, we get 17³+37³ = 6·21³, contrary to Legendre." - MINOR | doctor-lucas-2n: the Lamé note, paired with p. 575 | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/page/n604.jpg | Lamé is on p. 573 (note 185), not on p. 575 (record pairing, finding 23; counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | plough-pious-1: OEIS A006065 gives 15 rows of four for sixteen trees | https://oeis.org/A006065 | data "... 12, 15, ..." with OFFSET 1, so a(16) = 15 - CONFIRMED | plough-pious-1n: computer searches by Zhao Hui Du and the eMath forum (2008 to 2010); no refereed paper found | https://oeis.org/A006065 | "a(13)-a(15) from Zhao Hui Du, Aug 24 2008" to "a(20) from Zhao Hui Du, Feb 01 2010"; "Code to verify a(13) to a(16)"; the eMath account is kept beside it - MINOR | squire-1387-1: Skeat's reckoning (1868), from the "eighteenth day of April" in the Man of Law's Prologue; Chaucer names no year | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/43016/pg43016.txt | substance confirmed (Skeat: "definite mention of the 18th day of April ... in l. 822 to April 17"), but the words in quotation marks are neither Chaucer's ("He wiste it was the eightetethe day / Of April", vol. IV) nor Skeat's ("the 18th day of April"). Finding 12 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | squire-1387-1n: Skeat: "The year may be supposed to be 1387"; a fact at No. 23, a supposition at No. 29 | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/43016/pg43016.txt | verbatim; pg27635 lines 1238-1239 ("set out ... on 17th April 1387") and 1438 ("they are supposed to have set out") - CONFIRMED | squire-edward-1: Edward III died on 21 June 1377 | https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography,_1885-1900/Edward_III | "EDWARD III (1312–1377)"; "On 21 June ... shortly afterwards died" - CONFIRMED | haberdasher-fewer-1: no dissection into three or fewer polygonal pieces without flipping (Demaine, Kamata and Uehara, 2024; ITCS 2026) | https://drops.dagstuhl.de/storage/00lipics/lipics-vol362-itcs2026/LIPIcs.ITCS.2026.47/LIPIcs.ITCS.2026.47.pdf | kept text: "Theorem 1. There is no dissection with three or fewer polygonal pieces between a square and an equilateral triangle, when we forbid flipping pieces."; arXiv v1 5 Dec 2024 - CONFIRMED | haberdasher-fewer-1n: with flipping, or curved pieces, three is open; "remains unclear" whether Dudeney's or McElroy's | https://drops.dagstuhl.de/storage/00lipics/lipics-vol362-itcs2026/LIPIcs.ITCS.2026.47/LIPIcs.ITCS.2026.47.pdf | both open problems listed; "It remains unclear whether this solution was originally invented by Dudeney or McElroy" - CONFIRMED | haberdasher-rs-1: "36. Exhibited by Mr. H. E. Dudeney. A new Problem on Superposition." | https://archive.org/download/yearbookroyalso13britgoog/yearbookroyalso13britgoog_djvu.txt | OCR: "36. Exhibited by Mr, H, E, Dudeney." - CONFIRMED | haberdasher-rs-1n: the conversazione at Burlington House on 17 May 1905 (p. 140) | https://archive.org/download/yearbookroyalso13britgoog/yearbookroyalso13britgoog_djvu.txt | OCR: "AT THE CONVERSAZIONE HELD IN THE SOCIETY'S APARTMENTS AT BURLINGTON HOUSE ON MAY 17," 1905; p. 140 image read too - CONFIRMED | haberdasher-rs-2: the same, from p. 144 | https://archive.org/download/yearbookroyalso13britgoog/page/n152.jpg | image read, verbatim - MINOR | haberdasher-rs-2n: the date and place, paired with p. 144 | https://archive.org/download/yearbookroyalso13britgoog/page/n152.jpg | p. 144 shows neither; they are on p. 140 (kept as -p140-n148.jpg, cited by no entry). Record pairing, finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | chaucer-libra-1: "Ther-with the mones exaltacioun, I mene Libra, alwey gan ascende": the sign Libra rises; the moon is not put in it | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/22120/pg22120.txt | Parson's Prologue ll. 10-11 verbatim - MINOR | chaucer-libra-1n: "In mena Libra", Skeat's "rotten basis", paired with the text volume | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/22120/pg22120.txt | those words are in Skeat's notes, vol. V (line 44), not here. Record pairing, finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | chaucer-libra-2: the same reading of the lines | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/43016/pg43016.txt | Skeat: "Therewith Saturn's exaltation, I mean Libra, kept on continually ascending above the horizon" - CONFIRMED | chaucer-libra-2n: the moon in mid-Libra comes from a manuscript slip ("In mena Libra"), a "rotten basis" | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/43016/pg43016.txt | "this reading is evolved out of a mistake in MS. Hl., which (after all) has not In mene, but In mena (!) ... All calculations founded on this rotten basis are necessarily worthless." "fails" is fair: "exaltacioun" is astrological, not altitude - CONFIRMED | amulet-deity-1: the earliest use, Serenus, prescribes the word against a fever and names no god | https://archive.org/download/quintus-serenus_1916/quintus-serenus_1916_djvu.txt | ch. LI "Hemitritaeo depellendo ... inscribes chartae quod dicitur abracadabra"; no deity - MINOR | amulet-deity-1n: the Britannica, Wiktionary and Brewer statements, paired with Serenus | https://archive.org/download/quintus-serenus_1916/quintus-serenus_1916_djvu.txt | not in Serenus; they rest on lines 48 and 50 and on Wiktionary (kept, cited by no entry; line 131). Record pairing, finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | amulet-deity-2: Serenus against fevers, paired with the 1911 Britannica | https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Abracadabra | "Serenus Sammonicus gave precise instructions as to its mystical use in averting or curing agues and fevers generally" - CONFIRMED | amulet-deity-2n: the 1911 Britannica ties it to Abraxas | https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Abracadabra | "ABRACADABRA, a word analogous to Abraxas (q.v.), used as a magical formula by the Gnostics" - CONFIRMED | amulet-deity-3: Serenus's use, paired with Brewer | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.94189/page/n13.jpg | image read: "Q. Sevērus Sammon'icus recommended the use of the word as a powerful antidote against ague, flux, and toothache" - CONFIRMED | amulet-deity-3n: Brewer: "It is said that Abracadabra was the supreme deity of the Assyrians." | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.94189/page/n13.jpg | image read, verbatim; "fails" is fair - CONFIRMED | stamps-current-1: his seventeen values are the Guide's list of 1 January 1902 | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1902/page/n41.jpg | image read, p. 33: "POSTAGE STAMPS of the following values are now issued by the Post Office: ½d. 1d. 1½d. 2d. 2½d. 3d. 4d. 5d. 6d. 9d. 10d. 1s. 2s. 6d. 5s. 10s. 1l. 5l." - MINOR | stamps-current-1n: the 1904, 1919 and 1915 facts, paired with the 1902 page | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1902/page/n41.jpg | not on this page; they rest on lines 54, 56, 58. Record pairing, finding 23 (counted confirmed) - MINOR | stamps-current-2: the 1902 list, paired with the 1904 page | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1904/page/n41.jpg | not on this page; and the "excerpt" ("the same values without the 5l.") is a description, not the source's words. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | stamps-current-2n: the £5 off the list by July 1904 | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1904/page/n41.jpg | image read: the list ends "2s. 6d. 5s. 10s. 1l.", then "BOOKS OF STAMPS" - MINOR | stamps-current-3: the 1902 list, paired with the 1919 page | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1919-3/page/n146.jpg | not on this page. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | stamps-current-3n: in July 1919 fifteen values, without the £1 or £5 | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1919-3/page/n146.jpg | image read, p. 140: "Postage Stamps of the following values are issued: ½d. 1d. 1½d. 2d. 2½d. 3d. 4d. 5d. 6d. 9d. 10d. 1s. 2s. 6d. 5s. 10s." - MINOR | stamps-current-4: the 1902 list, paired with Hansard | https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/written-answers/1926/nov/11/queen-victoria-stamps | not in Hansard. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | stamps-current-4n: every Victorian stamp invalid since 30 June 1915 | https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/written-answers/1926/nov/11/queen-victoria-stamps | "the last issues of the stamps of this reign were invalidated on the 30th June, 1915" - MINOR | kayles-quilles-1: Skeat's etymology, paired with Strutt | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/48983/pg48983.txt | Strutt does not give it. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | kayles-quilles-1n: the book follows Strutt almost word for word | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/48983/pg48983.txt | "Kayles, written also cayles and keiles, derived from the French word quilles, was played with pins, and no doubt gave origin to the modern game of nine-pins" - MINOR | kayles-quilles-2: Skeat's etymology, paired with Wiktionary | https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/kayles | Wiktionary neither quotes Skeat nor derives quille from German. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | kayles-quilles-2n: Wiktionary gives Middle English keyle, akin to Dutch kegel | https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/kayles | "From Middle English keyles, plural of Middle English keyle (see Dutch kegel, German Kegel, Danish kegle, and Swedish kegla)." - CONFIRMED | kayles-quilles-3: Skeat (1910): "Of O. Low Ger. origin; Du. kegel", French quille from the German word | https://archive.org/download/etymologicaldict00skea/page/n366.jpg | image read, p. 319 as quoted. "fails" is fair: DOST "prob. f. MDu. keghel" (https://dsl.ac.uk/entry/dost00071420); SND "appar. from Mid.Du. keyl-, keghel, a skittle, from which the Fr. form is orig. a borrowing" (https://dsl.ac.uk/entry/snd00075169); Merriam-Webster "akin to Middle Dutch kegel" - MINOR | kayles-quilles-3n: the Strutt, Wiktionary and OED note, paired with Skeat | https://archive.org/download/etymologicaldict00skea/page/n366.jpg | not on Skeat's page. Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - MINOR | chessboard-hayward-1: Hayward has Louis "lying at Conflance", and Louis "called him the sonne of a bastard", a clause the quotation drops | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/textcreationpartnership/A02861/master/A02861.xml | the dropped clause is confirmed; but "lying at Conflance" is the French King, not Louis: "These went together to visit the French King, lying at Conflance: where ... Henry played with Louis then Daulphine of France at Chesse". The page never says what Dudeney printed ("Constance"). Finding 7 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | chessboard-hayward-1n: The Lives of the III. Normans, not a Life of William the Conqueror | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/textcreationpartnership/A02861/master/A02861.xml | "The liues of the III. Normans, Kings of England William the first. William the second. Henrie the first." (1613); the passage is in the life of William the First - MINOR | chessboard-hayward-2: the same, paired with the Gutenberg text | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/38513/pg38513.txt | as line 65 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | chessboard-hayward-2n: the title | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/38513/pg38513.txt | as line 66 - CONFIRMED | longbow-1: six rows of four is the most for eleven points | https://oeis.org/A006065 | a(11) = 6 - CONFIRMED | longbow-1n: no source found says who first proved it | https://oeis.org/A006065 | the entry names no one for a(11) - CONFIRMED | porkers-jaenisch-1: Ahrens: "Die Angabe bei Jaenisch, l. c., p. 260, es gebe 21 Stammlösungen ... ist jedenfalls unrichtig." | https://archive.org/download/mathematischeun01ahregoog/mathematischeun01ahregoog_djvu.txt | OCR as excerpted - CONFIRMED | porkers-jaenisch-1n: Jaenisch's page not reached; Ahrens counts 17 | https://archive.org/download/mathematischeun01ahregoog/mathematischeun01ahregoog_djvu.txt | "folgende 17 Stamm- lösungen"; "Jaenisch ... t. 3 (1863), p. 214-271" - CONFIRMED | porkers-jaenisch-2: the same, from p. 290 | https://archive.org/download/mathematischeun01ahregoog/page/n302.jpg | image read: footnote 2 verbatim - CONFIRMED | porkers-jaenisch-2n: the same note, from p. 290 | https://archive.org/download/mathematischeun01ahregoog/page/n302.jpg | "17 Stammlösungen"; footnote 1 "Jaenisch, 'Traité', t. 3, p. 260 u. 271" - CONFIRMED | motorcars-pope-1: Essay on Man, Epistle I: "All chance, direction, which thou canst not see;" | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/2428/pg2428.txt | verbatim, under EPISTLE I - CONFIRMED | princes-montucla-1: Hutton's Montucla-Ozanam (1803), vol. I, p. 54, as quoted | https://archive.org/download/recreationsinma05montgoog/recreationsinma05montgoog_djvu.txt | OCR as excerpted - MINOR | princes-montucla-1n: four triangles share the area 341,880, paired with Hutton | https://archive.org/download/recreationsinma05montgoog/recreationsinma05montgoog_djvu.txt | not in Hutton; it rests on the page's check and OEIS A055193 (kept, cited by no entry). Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | princes-montucla-2: the same, from p. 54 | https://archive.org/download/recreationsinma05montgoog/page/n111.jpg | image read: "No more than three rightangled tringles, equal to each other, can be found in whole numbers; but we may find as many as we choose in fractions or mixt numbers" - MINOR | princes-montucla-2n: 341,880, paired with p. 54 | https://archive.org/download/recreationsinma05montgoog/page/n111.jpg | as line 77 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | princes-carroll-1: Collingwood (1898) prints the diary for 19 December 1897 | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/11483/pg11483.txt | "Dec. 19 (Sun.).--Sat up last night till 4 a.m., ..." among the last entries of 1897, as quoted - CONFIRMED | princes-carroll-1n: the book writes out "3" and "rt.-angled", ends on "!", marks its omission | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/11483/pg11483.txt | compared with pg27635 lines 7120-7124 - CONFIRMED | ovid-mention-1: Ars Amatoria III.365-366, as quoted | https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/ovid/ovid.artis3.shtml | verbatim, numbered 365 - CONFIRMED | ovid-mention-1n: Ovid says nothing of moving the stones or of nine men's morris | https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/ovid/ovid.artis3.shtml | the couplet is all there is - CONFIRMED | morris-scene-1: Act II, Scene 1, Titania: "The nine men's morris is fill'd up with mud" | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1514/pg1514.txt | under "ACT II / SCENE I. A wood near Athens" (kept lines 665-667, 796); "fails" is fair - CONFIRMED | oxen-newton-1: Newton adds the 7 oxen of the growth to the 8 of the grass without growth | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/b30538579_djvu.txt | Problem XI; the words verified on the p. 80 image (line 89) - WRONG | oxen-newton-1n: "Newton's example asks about 36 acres and answers for 24, in the 1720 and 1728 editions both" | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/b30538579_djvu.txt | true of 1720; the 1728 second edition asks about 24 acres (p. 80: "to find how many Oxen will eat up 24 Acres in 18 Weeks? Anſwer 36"). See line 107 and finding 1 - MINOR | oxen-newton-2: the 7 and the 8 oxen, paired with p. 79 | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n92.jpg | "Add theſe 7 Oxen ..." is on p. 80 (n93). Finding 23 (counted confirmed) - MINOR | oxen-newton-2n: the same note as line 86, paired with p. 79 | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n92.jpg | p. 79 shows "36 Acres ... Anſwer 36"; the 1728 half is line 86's error (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | oxen-newton-3: the same, from p. 80 | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n93.jpg | image read: "Add theſe 7 Oxen, which the Growth of the Graſs alone would ſuffice to feed, to the 8, which the Graſs without Growth after 4 Weeks would feed" - MINOR | oxen-newton-3n: the same note as line 86, paired with p. 80 | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n93.jpg | p. 80 shows "24 Acres would ſuffice 36 Oxen"; the 1728 half is line 86's error (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | book-1907: first appeared in 1907 | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/pg27635.txt | "First Edition, 1907" - CONFIRMED | book-1919: again, with fuller solutions and new notes, in 1919 | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/pg27635.txt | "Second Edition (With Some Fuller Solutions and Additional Notes)", Nelson, 1919; preface dated July 2, 1919 - MINOR | reve-bousch: "was not proved the fewest until Thierry Bousch did it in 2014" | https://www.imo.universite-paris-saclay.fr/~bousch/preprints/revespzl.pdf | Bousch's proof is confirmed (kept text), but his own paper says computer calculations "ont vérifié la conjecture jusqu'à N = 30", and Korf (AAAI 2004, kept): "We also verify the presumed optimal solution lengths for up to 24 disks". The 21-cheese case was settled by search in 2004. Finding 9 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | stamps-1902: seventeen values, exactly the Guide of 1 January 1902, the £5 included | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1902/page/n41.jpg | as line 51; the item's document is "Post Office Guide 1902 (1st January)" - CONFIRMED | stamps-1904: by July 1904 the Guide had dropped the £5 | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1904/page/n41.jpg | as line 54 (the record's "(no 5l.)" is a description) - CONFIRMED | stamps-1919: in July 1919, the year of the second edition, fifteen values | https://archive.org/download/BPOG1919-3/page/n146.jpg | as line 56; the 1919 preface is dated July 2, 1919 - CONFIRMED | stamps-4half: the 4½d. was a Victorian stamp of 1892 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_Issue | "the 4+1⁄2d value on 15 September 1892" - CONFIRMED | stamps-1915: every Victorian stamp invalidated on 30 June 1915 | https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/written-answers/1926/nov/11/queen-victoria-stamps | as line 58; hence "still good for postage in 1907" - CONFIRMED | coins-florin-struck: double florins struck only from 1887 to 1890 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin | "produced by the Royal Mint between 1887 and 1890"; "struck in only four years" - CONFIRMED | coins-florin-legal: legal tender then and never called in | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin | "the double florin was not demonetised, and remains legal tender for 20 p" - CONFIRMED | lock-scott: Scott's Last Expedition (1913) has "many cwms on the lower ranges" | https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/cwm | and at the primary, vol. I (https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/11579/pg11579.txt): "Otherwise, although there are many cwms on the lower ranges, the mountains themselves seem little carved." - CONFIRMED | selmer-66-list: 66 is not the sum of two rational cubes | https://oeis.org/A185345 | 66 in the data ("Numbers that are not the sum of two rational cubes") - MINOR | selmer-66-ref: "Ernst Selmer settled it in 1951" | https://oeis.org/A185345 | the OEIS only links Selmer's paper. Selmer himself, Acta Math. 85 (1951) p. 342 (https://archive.ymsc.tsinghua.edu.cn/pacm_download/117/5734-11511_2006_Article_BF02395746.pdf): "except perhaps A = 66 (which is insoluble by Table 4b; also proved by Cassels [1])", Cassels [1] being Acta Math. 82, 1950. Finding 10 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | r19-hoppe: the 1919 printing kept the sentence and added a footnote on Hoppe | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/pg27635.txt | marker [A] at line 471 ("See footnote on page 198"); footnote [B] at line 5560: "he succeeded in proving the number to be a prime" - CONFIRMED | orchard-searches: right, by computer searches of 2008 to 2010, though no refereed paper proves it | https://oeis.org/A006065 | as line 31 - CONFIRMED | newton-1720: the 1720 example asks about 36 acres and answers 36 | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n92.jpg | image read, p. 79: "to find how many Oxen will eat up 36 Acres in 18 Weeks? Anſwer 36"; Wellcome Library copy (archive.org metadata) - WRONG | newton-1728: "Both the 1720 and the 1728 editions print it so" | https://archive.org/download/universalarithm00hallgoog/page/n92.jpg | that scan is not 1728: the item's title page (leaf n10) reads "LONDON, Printed for J. Senex ... 1720." (metadata: date 1728, year 1720) and its p. 79 is set line for line like the Wellcome copy. The real second edition, https://archive.org/details/bim_eighteenth-century_arithmetica-universalis_newton-sir-isaac_1728 ("The second edition", 1728), p. 80: "to find how many Oxen will eat up 24 Acres in 18 Weeks? Anſwer 36", substituting "12, 3⅓, 4, 21, 10, 9, 24, and 18". The slip goes back to the Latin of 1707, p. 90: "quot boves depaſcant 36 jugera in 18 ſeptimanis? Reſp. 36." Finding 1 - MINOR | newton-54: "someone has pencilled 54 above the printed answer" (alt text: "in pencil") | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n92.jpg | the 54 is there; zoomed, its strokes are brown like the ink of an old hand, not grey graphite, and no source says pencil. Finding 8 (counted wrong) - CONFIRMED | newton-split: Newton splits the oxen in two, and the page says so | https://archive.org/download/b30538579/page/n93.jpg | as line 89; "holds" is fair (the 1720 split is grass grown by week 4 plus the growth after it) - WRONG | (added) "with five stools, his table is still unproved past ten cheeses" (prose); "still unproved beyond ten cheeses" (ledger) | https://doku.lrz.de/files/10746622/10746632/5/1721986246983/Hinz_Petr_Eccentricities_in_Hanoi_Graphs.pdf | Hinz and Petr, SuperMUC-NG workshop, 10 May 2023: "Frame-Stewart conjecture has been confirmed for p = 5 and n ≤ 20, p = 6 and n ≤ 16, p = 7 and n ≤ 21", and citing their "Computational Solution of an Old Tower of Hanoi Problem", Electron. Notes Discrete Math. 53 (2016) 445-458 (https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1016/j.endm.2016.05.038), a computer proof for 5 pegs and 20 discs (its abstract seen only in a search summary; ScienceDirect is refused by the robots policy). His 20 cheeses in 111 moves is proved; 35, 56 and 84 are not. The paper is on the Hinz list kept at research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/math/hinz-lmu-tower-of-hanoi-publications.html. Finding 2 - WRONG | (added) the verdict "settled since" on "We can say of any number up to 100 whether it is possible or not to express it as the sum of two cubes, except 66." | https://archive.ymsc.tsinghua.edu.cn/pacm_download/117/5734-11511_2006_Article_BF02395746.pdf | Selmer 1951, p. 342: Sylvester's statement (the one Dudeney repeats, and Dickson in 1920, p. 575) "is partly based on the inaccurate communication from Pépin ... there is one insoluble value of A ≤ 100, namely A = 73 ..., which has never been noticed in earlier papers"; p. 306: Pépin held 31 and 67 insoluble, "which are both soluble ... (But the insolubility of these was "verified" by Sylvester!)", and of 60, "I doubt if Pépin possessed a valid proof". PARI/GP (recreated): analytic rank 1 for 31 and 67, 0 for 60, 66 and 73; the page's own table has 31 and 67 as sums. The page presents the sentence as right but for 66. Finding 3 - WRONG | (added) ribbon caption: "The figure before the last 3617 should be an 8." | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/scans/1919-nelson-p230-ribbon.png | the print reads "...553191439-" / "3617": the figure before 3617 is the 9, which is right; the misprint is the 3 before it, the forty-first figure (1/47 has ...914893617). Finding 4 - WRONG | (added) dek: "held every one of its 186 testable claims to a program or to a kept source"; plain: "tests every claim in it that can be tested"; prose: "pulled out every statement that can be tested" | public/strata/i-have-not-counted-them/index.html | the page itself: "Four claims were not tested at all". And testable statements are missing from the register: No. 86 "it cannot be done in accordance with the conditions as he at first understood them" (its map transcribed by both readers, research/i-have-not-counted-them/transcribe/a/p86.json and b/p86.json), No. 89's BLUEBELL and PEARTREE moves (p89 transcribed), No. 72 "two or three positions", No. 65 "two different ways", the four-piece cross of No. 19, the six-piece carpet of No. 84, the Samson "answer" Dudeney puts in quotation marks. Finding 5 - MINOR | (added) "as printed it survives no multiplier at all" (prose); "as printed it works for no multiplier past 1" (ledger) | research/i-have-not-counted-them/engine/numbers.mjs | recreated: every multiplier 1 to 46 tried on the printed 46 figures, rotations compared: 10 also gives the same ring (the leading 0 moves to the end), so 1 and 10 survive; every other fails, 2 first. Finding 13 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) frogs ledger note: "Printed so in the 1919 edition (page 202)" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/scans/ia-1919-uoft-djvu.txt | the paragraph follows the running head "200 THE CANTERBURY PUZZLES"; the caption's "page 200 of the book" is right and 202 is the scan's file page. Finding 14 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "The drawings a check needs were transcribed twice" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/transcribe/RECONCILED.md | "No. 7 (the Clerk of Oxenford) ... has one reading only"; the page says so in its last section. Finding 15 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "every source below was fetched, kept beside the page, and checked again by the verifier for the words quoted from it" | verify-i-have-not-counted-them.mjs | line 307: "if (ev.read) continue; // a page image, read by eye"; Brewer's "It is said", the three Post Office Guide lists and Newton's 36 and 54 rest on images the verifier never reads. Finding 16 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "Twenty-three ones: D. H. Lehmer proved it prime in 1929 (Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 35)." | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/math/lehmer-1929-bull-ams-35-p349.jpg | true, but Lehmer's note opens with Kraitchik, who "attempted to factor N arriving at another negative result that N had no factors and therefore was a prime" (Mathesis 42, 1928, p. 386), and credits "the method by which Kraitchik was able to identify this sixth largest prime known". Finding 17 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "a proof for every number below 3,317,044,064,679,887,300,000,000" | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller%E2%80%93Rabin_primality_test | "if n < 3,317,044,064,679,887,385,961,981, it is enough to test a = 2, 3, ... and 41"; the engine holds it exactly (engine/util.mjs line 33) but the page prints Number() of it, rounded. True as printed (lower) but not the figure. Finding 18 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "Dudeney says 145 and warns that most people answer 185" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/pg27635.txt | line 4741: "A great many people will give the answer as 185". Finding 19 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) frontmatter relates note: "Sam Loyd's fifteen puzzle there" | public/strata/the-half-you-can-never-reach/index.html | that layer: "the puzzle was really invented by Noyes Chapman c. 1874, not Loyd". Finding 20 (counted wrong) - MINOR | (added) "Of the 85 cube-free numbers up to 100, 49 are sums of two rational cubes and 36 are not" | https://oeis.org/A159843 | right only if 1 = 1³ + 0³ counts as "not" (research/i-have-not-counted-them/curves/RESULTS.md: "nonzero rational cubes"); A159843 lists 1, giving 50 and 35. Finding 21 (counted confirmed) - MINOR | (added) Dudeney "found by trial a negative fundamental solution"; "there is one, 919 cubed less 271 cubed is nine times 438 cubed" | https://archive.org/download/historyoftheoryo02dickuoft/page/n603.jpg | true; Dickson vol. II p. 574: "E. Lucas noted that a solution x, y, z yields the solution ... For A = 9, we get 919, −271, 438" (Nouv. Corresp. Math. 2, 1876; Bull. Bibl. Storia 10, 1877). His trial solution was in print thirty years before. Finding 22 (counted confirmed) - CONFIRMED | (added) Hoppe's proof "given to the London Mathematical Society in 1917 and 1918 (Dickson, History, vol. I, p. 179)"; "Nineteen ones: Oscar Hoppe, 1917-18" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/math/dickson-1919-vol1-p179.jpg | image read: "O. Hoppe proved that (10¹⁹−1)/9 is a prime." Note 153: "Proc. London Math. Soc., Records of Meeting, Dec. 6, 1917, and Feb. 14, 1918, for a revised proof." - CONFIRMED | (added) "x^3 + y^3 = 9 is the curve 243a1 in Cremona's tables, of rank 1" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/math/lmfdb-elliptic-curve-243.a1.html | "Elliptic curve with LMFDB label 243.a1 (Cremona label 243a1)", "y^2=x^3-48", "Rank 1"; PARI/GP gives conductor 243 (recreated) - CONFIRMED | (added) "OEIS A185345 lists 66 among the numbers that are not, citing Ernst Selmer (1951)" | https://oeis.org/A185345 | 66 in the data; Selmer's 1951 paper among the links - CONFIRMED | (added) "L(E,1) = 3.934373 is not 0 (Coates and Wiles)" | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birch_and_Swinnerton-Dyer_conjecture | "Coates and Wiles proved that if E is a curve over a number field F with complex multiplication by an imaginary quadratic field K of class number 1, F = K or ℚ, and L(E, s) is not zero, then E(F) is a finite group" - CONFIRMED | (added) ledger coinage note: legal tender in 1907 and 1919, never called in, "by 1914 some seventy per cent had been withdrawn" | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_florin | "By 1914, some 70 per cent of the issued double florins had been withdrawn"; not demonetised - CONFIRMED | (added) "(2.1.101 in the Folger edition)" | https://www.folger.edu/explore/shakespeares-works/a-midsummer-nights-dream/read/2/1/ | kept excerpt: "Act 2, scene 1" ... "0464 100 And crows are fatted with the murrain flock. 0465 The nine-men's-morris is filled up with mud," - CONFIRMED | (added) "Also Tristia II.481-482" | https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/ovid/ovid.tristia2.shtml | "parua sit ut ternis instructa tabella lapillis, / in qua uicisse est continuasse suos;" are the 481st and 482nd verse lines of the kept page (my count) - CONFIRMED | (added) "Wiktionary calls its origin unknown" (abracadabra) | https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/abracadabra | Latin: "Unknown. Relationships have been suggested with Abraxas ... but there is little supporting evidence." - CONFIRMED | (added) "Skeat's reckoning (1868)" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/letters/gutenberg-45027-skeat-chaucer-works-vol3.txt | "(pointed out by me in 1868) that the year 1387 suits the scheme of days"; Furnivall's Temporary Preface (1868, kept OCR) reprints Skeat, Notes and Queries 19 Sept. 1868: "The exact day of April to which Chaucer refers is most probably the 17th" - CONFIRMED | (added) "Ahrens counts 17, as the book does, and so does OEIS A002567" | https://oeis.org/A002567 | 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 17, ... (offset 1) - CONFIRMED | (added) the ribbon slip is in "the 1908 American printing and the 1919 London one"; caption "page 228" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/scans/1908-dutton-p179-ribbon.png | 1908: "...042553191-" / "4393617"; 1919: "...553191439-" / "3617", after the running head "228 THE CANTERBURY PUZZLES" in the 1919 OCR - CONFIRMED | (added) frogs: "The paragraph is new in 1919; the 1908 printing ends before it"; caption "page 200 of the book" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/scans/ia-1908-dutton-djvu.txt | the 1908 solution ends "...in the positions stipulated." and No. 49 follows; the 1919 scan has "If, instead of 11 and 12 changing places" - CONFIRMED | (added) "his answer was sure of itself: 'It is the only way within the conditions laid down.' In the second edition, in 1919, the same answer goes on" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/scans/1908-dutton-pdf191-plum-puddings-only-way.png | the 1908 scan has the sentence; the 1908 OCR has no "not counted" paragraph - UNVERIFIABLE | (added) "Henry Ernest Dudeney set it in 1907" (the Plum Puddings) | tried: a web search for the first appearance of "The Merry Monks of Riddlewell"; the book's press notices say it collects "puzzles of his which have appeared in many journals"; Aumann et al. (kept) date the Reve's Puzzle to The London Magazine, May 1902 | true of the book; whether No. 59 appeared before 1907 was not established - OBSERVED | the page's check passes and its planted faults are caught | recreated: node verify-i-have-not-counted-them.mjs, then --mutate, at 7828b145c6 | 1290 passed, 0 failed; "planted faults caught: 17 of 17", 1291 passed (at e5d4f5d36c with the author's edits: 1284, and 17 of 17) - OBSERVED | plum puddings: 2,184,565 routes; fourteen of 21 strokes; 76 of 22 and 220 of 23; the commonest 38 strokes, 208,394 routes; none corner to corner; one with the tenth stroke at the steaming pudding | research/i-have-not-counted-them/heavy/plum/out/A_1-1_8-7.txt | the DFS (A) and frontier DP (B) histograms agree; A_1-1_8-8: "hamiltonian_paths 0"; both readers put the hollies at [1,1], [8,7] and the steam at [8,5] (transcribe/a/p59.json, b/p59.json) - OBSERVED | with only the stamps on his list the first stamp puzzle has no answer | recreated: a brute force of every ninepenny magic square with one two-stamp cell and one repeated value | 0 with his seventeen values; 8 (his answer and its seven rotations and reflections) once 4½d. is allowed - OBSERVED | Shipman: 528 years of voyages from one island, 264 with reversals paired | recreated: enumeration of Eulerian circuits of K5 from a fixed vertex | 528 and 264 - OBSERVED | Cellarer: 99^30 has 60 figures and 100^29 has 59; his 58 decimals are all right | recreated: exact integer arithmetic | 60 and 59; the quotient ends at 58 decimals and equals his figure - OBSERVED | spider: 41.231 ft at 2 ft, 41.785 ft at 3 ft, 42 ft from 4 ft on | recreated: the four-face unfolding sqrt((36+a)²+(18−a)²) and five-face sqrt((30+2a)²+24²) against 42 | √1700 and √1746; √1796 exceeds 42 from 4 ft - OBSERVED | the mug: 1.98e-7 cubic millimetres; a drop about 253 million times it | recreated: ΔV ≈ πa⁴H/(4R²), a = 40 mm, H = 4,000 m, R = 6,371 km | 1.981e-7 mm³; 50 mm³ / 1.98e-7 ≈ 2.53e8 - OBSERVED | nineteen and twenty-three ones prime; thirty-seven ones = 2028119 × 247629013 × 2212394296770203368013 | recreated: Miller-Rabin on the first thirteen prime bases, every number below 3,317,044,064,679,887,385,961,981 | all true - OBSERVED | 919³ − 271³ = 9 × 438³, and his twelve-figure pair cubes to 9 | recreated: exact rational arithmetic | both true - OBSERVED | for 36 acres it is 54 oxen (24 acres, 36) | recreated: grass G = 10.8 and growth r = 0.9 ox-weeks per acre from Newton's data | 1.5 oxen per acre for 18 weeks - OBSERVED | archive.org has no Weekly Dispatch for 1902 to 1905 | recreated: archive.org advancedsearch, title:"weekly dispatch" | 3 items, dated 1852, 1867 and 1869 - OBSERVED | the two readings agreed on nineteen of twenty puzzles, the twentieth settled by reading the picture again | research/i-have-not-counted-them/transcribe/RECONCILED.md | "Twenty puzzles were compared ... The two readings agree on nineteen of them"; No. 34 settled at 800% - OBSERVED | five searches, each by two separately written programs | research/i-have-not-counted-them/heavy/RESULTS.md | plum (DFS = DP), wood block (CBC, CP-SAT, weighting certificate), Reve (C BFS = numpy BFS), Romeo and Romeo 2 (segment search = square search) - OBSERVED | 186 claims from 92 of 114 puzzles and the introduction; 148 hold, tally 6/2/3/2/8/4/8/1/4 | recreated: a count of research/i-have-not-counted-them/data/results.json | 186 claims, puzzlesWithClaims 92, the summary as printed; dek, tally and prose agree - OBSERVED | "Who first split thirty-seven ones was not found" | research/i-have-not-counted-them/sources/world/math/FINDINGS.md | section 4 lists what was read and searched; the factorization itself recreated (line 145) - OBSERVED | "This layer's check reads the bytes this page serves and asserts against them" | recreated: AW_DIR= node verify-i-have-not-counted-them.mjs, one sentence figure changed at a time | the dek's "148 hold" and "fourteen" are caught; prose figures outside data-v pass: "76 take twenty-two" to 77, "38 strokes" to 39, "894,348" to 894,349, "92 of its 114" to 93, "settled it in 1951" to 1952, the ledger's "49 are sums" to 48 (851 passed each). The page prints no transcript of its verifier, so this is not the self-reading HIGH case. Finding 24 ## Findings - [fixed] (MED) Newton's 1728 edition: the scan kept as "1728" is a 1720 printing; the true second edition asks about 24 acres. The page now says "The English edition of 1720 prints it so ... the second edition, of 1728, asks about 24 acres"; the world note, the source record and sources/world/letters/FINDINGS.md (corrections) say the same, and the 1728 text is kept as archive-bim-arithmetica-universalis-newton-1728_djvu.txt. - [fixed] (MED) Five stools: the page now says his table "is proved by computer up to twenty cheeses (Hinz and Petr, 2016) and is still unproved beyond"; data/heavy.json's reve-5-table found and note say 1, 7, 31 and 111 are the fewest and 351, 1023 and 2815 unproved; the LRZ talk and the Crossref record are kept. The verdict stays "still open", for 35, 56 and 84. - [fixed] (MED) "except 66": split into two claims on the same sentence. doctor-66 (66 open in 1919) stays "settled since", now credited to Cassels (1950) and Selmer (1951); the new doctor-100 ("every other number up to 100 had been decided, and rightly") is "fails": Sylvester's list had 31 and 67 impossible and 73 possible, all three the other way round (Selmer pp. 306 and 342; the curves here agree, and the build and the verifier now check that they do). - [fixed] (MED) The dek and the plain line no longer claim every testable claim: "pulled 187 claims from it and tested 183 against programs and kept sources"; the prose says "pulled out the statements a program or a source could settle ... (a few it did not take up are named at the end)", and "What it cannot see" names Nos. 86, 89, 19, 65, 72 and 84. The verifier checks the dek's three counts against the data. - [fixed] (MINOR) The ribbon caption now reads "In “553191439-3617” the 3 after the 4 should be an 8." - [fixed] (MINOR) Fitzosborne: "three sentences and the end of a fourth are cut without a mark". - [fixed] (MINOR) Hayward: the French King is "lying at Conflance" (the book prints Constance). - [fixed] (MINOR) Newton's 54: "written 54 above the printed answer by hand", in the prose and the image's alt text. - [fixed] (MINOR) Four stools: "confirmed by Richard Korf's computer search in 2004 and proved, for any number of cheeses, by Thierry Bousch in 2014", in the prose and in data/heavy.json. - [fixed] (MINOR) 66: "J. W. S. Cassels (1950) and Ernst Selmer (1951) proved that 66 is not the sum of two rational cubes", in the prose and data/curves.json, with Selmer's p. 342 kept. - [fixed] (MINOR) The Jewish Encyclopedia is cited as "vol. I, 1901". - [fixed] (MINOR) The quotation marks round "eighteenth day of April" are gone: "from the eighteenth day of April named in the Man of Law's Prologue". - [fixed] (MINOR) The ribbon: every multiplier from 2 to 46 is now tried (engine/numbers.mjs, printedKeeps); the page says it keeps its ring "under no multiplier from 2 to 46 but 10, which only carries the leading nought round", and the verifier checks the 10. - [fixed] (MINOR) The frogs note says page 200, the book's page. - [fixed] (MINOR) "The drawings a check needs, all but one, were transcribed twice". - [fixed] (MINOR) "checked again by the verifier for the words quoted from its text copies; page images were read by eye". - [fixed] (MINOR) Twenty-three ones: "Kraitchik found no factor in 1928, and D. H. Lehmer proved it prime in 1929". - [fixed] (MINOR) The Miller-Rabin bound is printed exactly, 3,317,044,064,679,887,385,961,981 (formatted from the string, not through Number()). - [fixed] (MINOR) "warns that a great many people answer 185". - [fixed] (MINOR) The relates note no longer gives the fifteen puzzle to Sam Loyd: "Two puzzles held to what can actually be done: the fifteen puzzle's unreachable half there, Henry Dudeney's Canterbury pilgrims here." - [fixed] (MINOR) The cube-free counts now say how 1 is counted: "counting 1, which is 1 cubed plus 0 cubed, as not a sum of two nonzero cubes; the OEIS counts it, giving 50 and 35". - [fixed] (MINOR) "919 cubed less 271 cubed is nine times 438 cubed (Lucas had printed it in 1876)", with Dickson vol. II p. 574 kept. - [fixed] (MINOR) The source record: each piece of evidence in data/world.json now says which sentence it supports (found or note), and build/sources-record.mjs pairs only those; image excerpts quote the page, not a description; entries added for Korf, Hinz and Petr, Cassels and Selmer, Lucas, Kraitchik, Hoppe's dates, 243a1, OEIS A002567, Tristia, the Folger line, Skeat's 1868, the two ribbon scans and the 1908 frogs text. 104 entries, gate clean. - [fixed] (MINOR) Verifier coverage: 894,348, 76, 220, 38, 208,394 and 92 are now data-v figures, the ribbon's 10 too; the cube-free counts in the 66 note are checked against curves/results.json; "settled it in 1951" is no longer on the page. - [fixed] (MINOR) assay/sources.mjs now reports a page image as UNREADABLE, like a PDF, instead of NOT FOUND. - [fixed] (UNVERIFIABLE line) "Henry Ernest Dudeney set it in 1907" now reads "printed it in 1907", which the book's first edition supports.