--- slug: its-tail-in-its-mouth passed: 2026-11-16 by: two agents on oversight/claims-pass.md, one for each half of the source record (c001 to c126, and c127 on), dispatched by claude-epic-gates-wpqedf, who re-read every finding against its source (the 1566 and 1577 page images included) before fixing checked: 417 confirmed: 375 wrong: 20 unverifiable: 1 observed: 21 stale: 0 --- The pass read every entry of assay/sources/its-tail-in-its-mouth.json against its kept copy, and the live source where the copy could not settle it, after running scripts/robots-policy.mjs on every URL (one refusal, the Glasgow Alciato site, not fetched; one reference-tier host, not fetched). Ids are those of the record the checkers were given (commit 749d9bb131); a span added later moved every id from c072 on up by one. Of 18 MINOR lines, 16 are counted as confirmed and 2 (the "steps before it" and "every claim is marked" sentences) as wrong. Both checkers independently found that the page's headline year was wrong: the same reading of the ring as eternity is in Alciato's emblems as glossed at Lyon in 1566 and in Claude Mignault's full commentary of 1577, which the research had missed. **The pictures pass (2026-11-16, later the same day).** The page gained public-domain and openly licensed pictures, each with an apparatus of where it comes from, and a drawn figure, the ring of meanings. One agent on oversight/claims-pass.md, who did not make them, looked at every picture against its caption, its alt text, the catalogue witness and the provenance record, and read the rights of 37 pictures again at 30 sources (robots policy first). Its first report found fifteen things; all were fixed, a re-check found each fixed and three small new points, which were fixed, and a final check of the last commit confirmed them. The lines below the earlier ones are that pass: one per entry the pictures added to assay/sources, and the first pass's wrong and near-miss findings that were not marked claims. ## Claims - CONFIRMED | c001-1: Its oldest words are an order to a hostile snake. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/faulkner1969_pt393.txt | Faulkner p.129 renders PT 393 as a jussive: "Your tail be on your mouth, O šnṯ-snake!"; Allen (c006) reads it as a statement, which the body says - CONFIRMED | c001-2: Its oldest words are an order to a hostile snake. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/maspero1894_teti_snake-spells.txt | Maspero p.134: the paragraphs after l.315 "ne renferment que de courts exorcismes"; Allen 2013 concordance puts PT 393 at Teti ll.316-317 - OBSERVED | c002-1: For more than a thousand years the writers who explain it say it means the year, the world or time. | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/dossier.md | dossiers 04 (synthesis table: world, year, time, king; "Eternity is never what these texts say") and 08 (Isidore, Eriugena, Notker, Boccaccio, Erasmus, Valeriano, Cartari: year/world/time); c. AD 400 to the 1520s-1580s is >1,000 years - OBSERVED | c002-2: For more than a thousand years the writers who explain it say it means the year, the world or time. | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/dossier.md | as c002-1 - WRONG | c003-1: Eternity, the meaning later scholars wrote back onto the oldest rings, is in no source’s own words that we co… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/selection.mjs | selection.mjs makes Mignault 1584 the first own-words eternity, but the same sentence is in Mignault's full commentary, Antwerp: Plantin 1577 p.450 (archive.org omniaandreaealc00alciat, page image n453), also 1581 p.477 and Paris 1583 pp.442-443 (OCR), all readable; there it ends "ut docet Orus Niliacus in ipso Hieroglyph. principio" (credited to Horapollo 1.1, as the page treats Erasmus) - WRONG | c003-2: Eternity, the meaning later scholars wrote back onto the oldest rings, is in no source’s own words that we co… | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/sources/alciato-ex-literarum-studiis-1534-1548-1550.txt | excerpt is really on 1584 p.290, but the 1584 book is "Excerpta ex eiusdem ... maiorum vigiliarum commentariis" (kept transcription of its title page); the full commentary printed it by 1577 with the Horapollo credit; see c003-1 - CONFIRMED | c003-3: Eternity, the meaning later scholars wrote back onto the oldest rings, is in no source’s own words that we co… | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | supports the "later scholars wrote eternity back" half (P&R 1957 p.73; King 1887 p.433; Cumont 1902 p.5 n.3 = TMMM mon.25); the "before 1584" half is WRONG, see c003-1 - CONFIRMED | c003-4: Eternity, the meaning later scholars wrote back onto the oldest rings, is in no source’s own words that we co… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/king-1887-gnostics-coiled-serpent.txt | as c003-3 - CONFIRMED | c003-5: Eternity, the meaning later scholars wrote back onto the oldest rings, is in no source’s own words that we co… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1902-revue-archeologique-modena-relief.txt | as c003-3 - MINOR | c004: Eighteen lines of research read what they could reach, and recorded 348 objects and passages, each with the w… | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | recounted: catalogue.json has 18 provinces and 348 witnesses, 0 problems; but 8 witnesses (Sutton Hoo buckle, Eddison tailpiece, two Harley amphisbaenas, four Norse/interlace images) carry a kept picture and no words, so "each with the words of its source" overstates - CONFIRMED | c005-1: The oldest words we found are carved in the pyramid of Teti, first king of the Sixth Dynasty, among the Pyram… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Pyramid_Texts.txt | Wikipedia Pyramid_Texts and Teti (kept; live text FOUND today); Allen 2013 concordance lists PT 393 for Teti (T) only - CONFIRMED | c005-2: The oldest words we found are carved in the pyramid of Teti, first king of the Sixth Dynasty, among the Pyram… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Teti.txt | as c005-1 - CONFIRMED | c006: In James Allen’s translation, spell 393 says Your tail is in your mouth, shunned snake. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/allen2005_pt_teti_pt393.txt | Allen 2005 p.91 (kept from OCR; no page image checked by the investigation) - CONFIRMED | c007: Raymond Faulkner made it an order: Your tail be on your mouth, O šnṯ-snake! | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/faulkner1969_pt393.txt | Faulkner 1969 p.129, kept from page image - CONFIRMED | c008: Gaston Maspero, in his edition of 1894, said the spells in this stretch contain only courts exorcismes, short… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/maspero1894_teti_snake-spells.txt | Maspero 1894 p.134 note; quote exact; PT 393 sits in the stretch after l.315 per Allen 2013 - CONFIRMED | c009-1: The words are said to a dangerous snake, to stop it. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/mercer1952_pt393.txt | Mercer: "combat-serpent"; Maspero: exorcisms - CONFIRMED | c009-2: The words are said to a dangerous snake, to stop it. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/maspero1894_teti_snake-spells.txt | as c009-1 - MINOR | c010-1: About nine centuries later, in the tomb of Thutmose III, the Amduat (the Darnells call it the Book of the Hid… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/bucher1932_mifao60_hour6_kv34_kv35.txt | Bucher p.44 says "serpent à 5 têtes", but the same claim's other source, Darnell & Darnell 2018 p.192, describes Scene 65 as "surrounded by a four-headed serpent"; the page states five without noting the disagreement - CONFIRMED | c010-2: About nine centuries later, in the tomb of Thutmose III, the Amduat (the Darnells call it the Book of the Hid… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | Darnells 2018 p.26: "the Book of the Hidden Chamber appears in full in the burial chamber" - CONFIRMED | c010-3: About nine centuries later, in the tomb of Thutmose III, the Amduat (the Darnells call it the Book of the Hid… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Teti.txt | Teti d. c.2333 BC, Thutmose III d. 1425 BC: 908 years, "about nine centuries"; live Wikipedia FOUND - CONFIRMED | c010-4: About nine centuries later, in the tomb of Thutmose III, the Amduat (the Darnells call it the Book of the Hid… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Thutmose_III.txt | as c010-3 - CONFIRMED | c011: Its caption, in John and Colleen Darnell’s translation: He of Many Faces as protector. He exists in this fash… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | Darnells 2018 p.192, verbatim - CONFIRMED | c012: Erik Hornung, as John Darnell reports him, called this serpent ein ikonographischer Vorläufer of the ouroboro… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell2004_obo198_second-shrine.txt | Darnell 2004 p.380 n.33: Hornung 1977 "suggests only the five-headed serpent ... as 'ein ikonographischer Vorläufer' of the uroborus" - CONFIRMED | c013-1: About a century after that, on the second gilded shrine of Tutankhamun, two serpents ring a giant figure, one… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/maravelia2018_oriental-studies.txt | Darnell 2004 p.374: "Two uroboroi, the upper one labeled Mehen"; 1425 BC to 1332 BC = 93 years - CONFIRMED | c013-2: About a century after that, on the second gilded shrine of Tutankhamun, two serpents ring a giant figure, one… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell2004_obo198_second-shrine.txt | as c013-1 - CONFIRMED | c013-3: About a century after that, on the second gilded shrine of Tutankhamun, two serpents ring a giant figure, one… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Thutmose_III.txt | as c013-1 - CONFIRMED | c013-4: About a century after that, on the second gilded shrine of Tutankhamun, two serpents ring a giant figure, one… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Tutankhamun.txt | as c013-1 - CONFIRMED | c014: John Darnell reads the cryptic caption as Adoration of the circling one—the circling one is Re/the sun disk. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell2004_obo198_second-shrine.txt | Darnell 2004 p.78 (there the label of the standing figure; Darnells 2018 p.541 give it as the upper uroboros's label) - CONFIRMED | c015: The tails do literally touch the mouths of the serpents, the Darnells write; they are not inside them. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | Darnells 2018 p.192 n.97 verbatim; "they are not inside them" is the investigation's reading of the photographs (catalogue form note), not the Darnells' - CONFIRMED | c016-1: The shrine is often called the first known ouroboros | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/maravelia2018_oriental-studies.txt | Maravelia 2018 p.5 n.3; Wikipedia caption (live FOUND); Commons description says the same - CONFIRMED | c016-2: The shrine is often called the first known ouroboros | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/wikipedia_ouroboros_egypt.txt | as c016-1 - MINOR | c017-1: but the Amduat in Thutmose III’s tomb is older, and its caption already says his tail in his mouth. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | true of the caption, but the same page of the same source (Darnells 2018 p.192 n.97) says "the depiction is not that of a true uroboros as described in the annotation": the drawn tail is only near the mouth; the page omits this while using the scene against "first known ouroboros" - CONFIRMED | c017-2: but the Amduat in Thutmose III’s tomb is older, and its caption already says his tail in his mouth. | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Thutmose_III.txt | Thutmose III d. 1425 BC, before Tutankhamun's reign 1332-1323 BC - CONFIRMED | c017-3: but the Amduat in Thutmose III’s tomb is older, and its caption already says his tail in his mouth. | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Tutankhamun.txt | as c017-2 - CONFIRMED | c018-1: The giant figure on Tutankhamun’s second shrine, its head and feet each ringed by a serpent. Photograph by A.… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/commons_shrine_files_licences.txt | Commons: author A. Parrot, 31 December 2015, CC0; the display-glass reflections are visible - OBSERVED | c018-2: The giant figure on Tutankhamun’s second shrine, its head and feet each ringed by a serpent. Photograph by A.… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/media/provenance.json | media/provenance.json records the file, the CC0 statement and "through display glass (reflections)" - CONFIRMED | c019-1: The ring could also be a punishment. A papyrus copied in the twelfth year of Alexander, the son of Alexander … | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/budge-1890-archaeologia52-nesi-amsu.txt | Budge 1890 p.394: "written ... in the twelfth year of Alexander, the son of Alexander" - CONFIRMED | c019-2: The ring could also be a punishment. A papyrus copied in the twelfth year of Alexander, the son of Alexander … | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/faulkner-1938-jea24-bremner-rhind-iv.txt | Faulkner 1938 p.44 (col. 30, 16-17), kept from page image - CONFIRMED | c020: Its instructions, in Wallis Budge’s translation of 1890: Make a figure of a serpent having his tail in his mo… | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/budge-1890-archaeologia52-nesi-amsu.txt | Budge 1890 p.455 ll.44-45, joined across the line break - CONFIRMED | c021-1: On a papyrus made for a woman called Her-Uben, the sun’s disk is ringed by a serpent biting its tail, and the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | P&R 1957 p.73: "the solar disk surrounded by a serpent biting its tail"; the caption is, in the kept copy's words, "the Egyptian caption before the baboon" - CONFIRMED | c021-2: On a papyrus made for a woman called Her-Uben, the sun’s disk is ringed by a serpent biting its tail, and the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/niwinski-1989-obo86-catalogue-cairo-89-91.txt | Niwinski 1989 n.22: mummy linen "Year 8 of King Siamun"; the zora landing page cannot show the PDF text (online check could not see it; kept copy is the evidence) - CONFIRMED | c021-3: On a papyrus made for a woman called Her-Uben, the sun’s disk is ringed by a serpent biting its tail, and the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | P&R 1957 p.73, verbatim - CONFIRMED | c022: The same editors, describing the picture in 1957, called the serpent the symbol of eternity. | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | P&R 1957 p.73: "—the symbol of eternity" - CONFIRMED | c023: Dana Reemes, who wrote a dissertation on the Egyptian ouroboros, concluded that the icon was never a discrete… | https://api.core.ac.uk/v3/search/works?q=title%3A%22The%20Egyptian%20Ouroboros%22&limit=5 | abstract verbatim (live CORE API FOUND); a kept copy exists, research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/reemes2015_abstract_core.txt, but the record entry names none - CONFIRMED | c024-1: Carved for Teti, first king of the Sixth Dynasty, who died about 2333 BC and was buried at Saqqara | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Teti.txt | Wikipedia Teti: d. c. 2333 BC; "buried at Saqqara" - CONFIRMED | c024-2: Carved for Teti, first king of the Sixth Dynasty, who died about 2333 BC and was buried at Saqqara | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Teti.txt | as c024-1 - CONFIRMED | c025: Your tail is in your mouth, shunned snake, your surrounding has been surrounded, great bull. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/allen2005_pt_teti_pt393.txt | Allen 2005 p.91 (kept from OCR; no page image checked by the investigation) - CONFIRMED | c026: Your sycamore be your grain, your grain be your sycamore! Your tail be on your¹ mouth, O šnṯ-snake! Turn, tur… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/faulkner1969_pt393.txt | Faulkner 1969 p.129, kept from page image - CONFIRMED | c027-1: Painted in the tomb of Thutmose III, fifth king of the Eighteenth Dynasty, who died in 1425 BC | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Thutmose_III.txt | Wikipedia: fifth pharaoh of the 18th Dynasty, d. 11 March 1425 BC; Darnells 2018 p.26 - CONFIRMED | c027-2: Painted in the tomb of Thutmose III, fifth king of the Eighteenth Dynasty, who died in 1425 BC | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Thutmose_III.txt | as c027-1 - CONFIRMED | c027-3: Painted in the tomb of Thutmose III, fifth king of the Eighteenth Dynasty, who died in 1425 BC | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | as c027-1 - CONFIRMED | c028: He of Many Faces as protector. He exists in this fashion—his tail in his mouth. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell-darnell2018_netherworld-books.excerpt.txt | Darnells 2018 p.192, verbatim - CONFIRMED | c029: Made for Tutankhamun, who ruled about 1332 to 1323 BC | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Tutankhamun.txt | Wikipedia: "who ruled c. 1332 – 1323 BC" - CONFIRMED | c030: Adoration of the circling one—the circling one is Re/the sun disk. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell2004_obo198_second-shrine.txt | Darnell 2004 p.78 (there the label of the standing figure; Darnells 2018 p.541 give it as the upper uroboros's label) - CONFIRMED | c031: Two uroboroi, the upper one labeled "Mehen," encircle the head and feet of this giant figure. | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/darnell2004_obo198_second-shrine.txt | Darnell 2004 p.374 verbatim - MINOR | c032: time, which eats what it brings, given by English Wikipedia, as read in 2026: the beginning and the end of ti… | research/ouroboros/provinces/01-egypt-early/sources/wikipedia_ouroboros_egypt.txt | Wikipedia's words are verbatim, but they say "The whole divine figure represents the beginning and the end of time"; the pill gives Wikipedia the lane gloss "which eats what it brings" and gives the ring a meaning Wikipedia gave the figure - CONFIRMED | c033-1: Its owner’s mummy linen is dated Year 8 of King Siamun, sixth king of the Twenty-first Dynasty | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/niwinski-1989-obo86-catalogue-cairo-89-91.txt | Niwinski 1989 n.22: mummy linen "Year 8 of King Siamun"; the zora landing page cannot show the PDF text (online check could not see it; kept copy is the evidence) - CONFIRMED | c033-2: Its owner’s mummy linen is dated Year 8 of King Siamun, sixth king of the Twenty-first Dynasty | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Siamun.txt | Wikipedia: "the sixth pharaoh of Egypt during the Twenty-first Dynasty" - CONFIRMED | c034: The new year of Re in the barge of Re in the sky. | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | P&R 1957 p.73, verbatim - CONFIRMED | c035: eternity, given by A. Piankoff and N. Rambova, 1957: the symbol of eternity | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt | P&R 1957 p.73: "—the symbol of eternity" - CONFIRMED | c036: Copied in the twelfth year of Alexander, the son of Alexander | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/budge-1890-archaeologia52-nesi-amsu.txt | Budge 1890 p.394: "written ... in the twelfth year of Alexander, the son of Alexander" - CONFIRMED | c037: he shall triumph over thee, thy tail shall be placed in thy mouth, and thou shalt chew thine own skin | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/faulkner-1938-jea24-bremner-rhind-iv.txt | Faulkner 1938 p.44 (col. 30, 16-17), kept from page image - CONFIRMED | c038: Make a figure of a serpent having his tail in his mouth, and a knife stuck in his back, and cast it upon the … | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/sources/budge-1890-archaeologia52-nesi-amsu.txt | Budge 1890 p.455 ll.44-45, joined across the line break - CONFIRMED | c039: The Greek word is an adjective, οὐροβόρος, devouring its tail, said of a δράκων, a serpent. | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/lsj-1940-ouroboros.txt | LSJ 1940 p.1274: "οὐροβόρος, ον, (οὐρά) devouring its tail, δράκων" - CONFIRMED | c040-1: The great Greek lexicon cites it from two magical papyri and an alchemist, and misses a third papyrus, in Ber… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/lsj-1940-ouroboros.txt | LSJ cites PMag.Lond.121, PMag.Osl.1, Olymp.Alch.; PGM I.145 (Berlin) "δράκοντα οὐροβόρον" (Preisendanz 1928 p.10) is not cited; 1968 Supplement adds nothing - CONFIRMED | c040-2: The great Greek lexicon cites it from two magical papyri and an alchemist, and misses a third papyrus, in Ber… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/preisendanz-1928-pgm1-144-148.txt | as c040-1 - CONFIRMED | c041: In 1866 Gustav Parthey, editing two magical papyri of the Berlin museum, noted that οὐροβόρος fehlt den Lexic… | research/ouroboros/provinces/18-historiography/sources/parthey-1866-zauberpapyri-ourobos.txt | Parthey 1866 p.143, verbatim - CONFIRMED | c042-1: In a London papyrus the word is an instruction. A recipe for a φυλακτηριον σωματοφυλαξ προς δαιμονας, a bodyg… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | Kenyon 1893 pp.102-103 ll.579, 586-587; translation checked: accurate ("□□" = ὀνόματα per Kenyon 1899) - CONFIRMED | c042-2: In a London papyrus the word is an instruction. A recipe for a φυλακτηριον σωματοφυλαξ προς δαιμονας, a bodyg… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | as c042-1 - MINOR | c043: and the papyrus concludes with a diagram of a serpent with his tail in his own mouth, enclosing magical signs… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | Kenyon p.84: "This group [the 28 recto charms, ll.300-592] ... concludes with a diagram"; the page makes "the papyrus" the subject (the verso carries more text) - CONFIRMED | c044: The drawing that ends the phylactery in London magical papyrus 121, from Kenyon’s facsimile plate of 1893 (pu… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | plate 59 of the 1893 Facsimiles (media/provenance.json); "public domain" is the investigation's judgement, marked there "for review" - CONFIRMED | c045: A papyrus in Leiden makes the ring a sign for a sound: in place of the hiss, draw δράκοντα δάκνοντα τὴν οὐράν… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papW-serpent.txt | Leemans 1885 p.85, Pap. W; translation checked: accurate - CONFIRMED | c046-1: Another Leiden recipe, for a ring cut in heliotrope, wants a serpent στεφάνου σχήματι, in the shape of a wrea… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papV-rings.txt | Leemans 1885 p.29 col. 8; translation follows Leemans's emendation ἔστω; accurate - MINOR | c046-2: Another Leiden recipe, for a ring cut in heliotrope, wants a serpent στεφάνου σχήματι, in the shape of a wrea… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papV-rings.txt | words verbatim, but the sentence precedes the serpent and Leemans (the edition cited) renders ὁ κύκλος as "annulus" (the finger-ring): "the circle is unfailing" said "of it" (the serpent) is one reading; the papyrus states the ring is for success, favour and victory, so the timeline's own-words "guard" is the page's inference - OBSERVED | c047: None of the magical papyri we read says the ring means time, or eternity. | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/dossier.md | dossier 03 F18: "the texts never say in words what the tail-devouring serpent is"; αιων in PGM VII l.584 is a name not drawn in the ring (F12) - CONFIRMED | c048: In 1891 Albrecht Dieterich said the many gems with tail-biting serpents were meant to show den Sonnenlauf, th… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/dieterich-1891-abraxas-p52.txt | Dieterich 1891 p.52, verbatim; said of "the many gems", not of the Met gem itself (the pill says so) - CONFIRMED | c049: in 1887 C. W. King called the coiled serpent round the names Iao and Abraxas an emblem of Eternity. | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/king-1887-gnostics-coiled-serpent.txt | King 1887 p.433 (woodcut 4, a Bosanquet jasper), verbatim; not the Met gem (the pill says so) - CONFIRMED | c050-1: Outside Egypt, a gilt silver bowl buried at Palestrina in the first half of the seventh century BC has a serp… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/curtis-1919-bernardini-tomb-bowl-25.txt | Curtis 1919 p.16: "first half of the VIIth century B. C." - CONFIRMED | c050-2: Outside Egypt, a gilt silver bowl buried at Palestrina in the first half of the seventh century BC has a serp… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/curtis-1919-bernardini-tomb-bowl-25.txt | Curtis 1919 p.39, verbatim; bowl no. 25, silver gilt inside, 19 cm (same object as Clermont-Ganneau's) - CONFIRMED | c051: Helbig compared it, Charles Clermont-Ganneau reports, to the Egyptian and Phoenician serpent that bites its t… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/clermont-ganneau-1880-palestrina-serpent.txt | Clermont-Ganneau 1880 p.8, verbatim; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c052-1: In Rome a pedestal dedicated to Mithras, dated by its inscription to AD 194, is ringed by a bearded serpent s… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1896-tmmm2-mon25-ouroboros-pedestal.txt | Cumont 1896 p.208 mon.25, verbatim; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c052-2: In Rome a pedestal dedicated to Mithras, dated by its inscription to AD 194, is ringed by a bearded serpent s… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1896-tmmm2-mon25-ouroboros-pedestal.txt | Cumont 1896 p.99 inscr.29 (CIL VI 724): "Année 194 ap. J.-C." - CONFIRMED | c053: Franz Cumont, in 1902, called that serpent the image bien connue de l’éternité, the well-known image of etern… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1902-revue-archeologique-modena-relief.txt | Cumont 1902 p.5 and n.3 "Mon. 25, fig. 36" = this pedestal - CONFIRMED | c054: Buried in the first half of the seventh century BC | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/curtis-1919-bernardini-tomb-bowl-25.txt | Curtis 1919 p.16: "first half of the VIIth century B. C." - CONFIRMED | c055: Between the outer frieze and the rim is coiled a serpent, with head and tail slightly overlapping. | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/curtis-1919-bernardini-tomb-bowl-25.txt | Curtis 1919 p.39, verbatim; bowl no. 25, silver gilt inside, 19 cm (same object as Clermont-Ganneau's) - CONFIRMED | c056: the world, or what lies round it, given by Helbig, as Clermont-Ganneau reports: symbole bien connu de l’unive… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/clermont-ganneau-1880-palestrina-serpent.txt | Clermont-Ganneau 1880 p.8, verbatim; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c057: Dated by the museum to the second century CE | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/met-api-248222-serapis-gem.txt | Met API record 248222 (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c058: "title": "Jasper intaglio: Seated Serapis on crocodile" | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/met-api-248222-serapis-gem.txt | as c057 - CONFIRMED | c059: the sun, or its course, given by A. Dieterich, 1891, of the many gems with tail-biting serpents: den Sonnenla… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/dieterich-1891-abraxas-p52.txt | Dieterich 1891 p.52, verbatim; said of "the many gems", not of the Met gem itself (the pill says so) - CONFIRMED | c060: eternity, given by C. W. King, 1887, of the coiled serpent round Iao and Abraxas: emblem of Eternity | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/king-1887-gnostics-coiled-serpent.txt | King 1887 p.433 (woodcut 4, a Bosanquet jasper), verbatim; not the Met gem (the pill says so) - CONFIRMED | c061-1: Kenyon dated the hand to the third century; the British Library catalogue gives the fourth | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | Kenyon p.84 "probably of the 3rd century"; BL record "Date Range: 4th century" (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c061-2: Kenyon dated the hand to the third century; the British Library catalogue gives the fourth | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/bl-catalogue-papyrus121.txt | as c061-1 - CONFIRMED | c062: ουροβορος τα δε □□ μεσον του δρακοντος και οι χαρακτηρες tail-devouring, and the [names] in the middle of the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | Kenyon 1893 pp.102-103 ll.579, 586-587; translation checked: accurate ("□□" = ὀνόματα per Kenyon 1899) - CONFIRMED | c063: φυλακτηριον σωματοφυλαξ προς δαιμονας προς φαντασματα Phylactery, a bodyguard against daimons, against phanto… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/kenyon-1893-pap121-579-590.txt | as c062 - CONFIRMED | c064: Its Greek hand dated to about AD 300 to 350 | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/daniel-1991-leiden-photographic-edition.txt | Daniel 1991 p.x: "ca. 300-350 AD" - CONFIRMED | c065: δράκων ἑστὼς ⁽¹⁸⁾ ενκύμων ⁽¹⁹⁾ στεφάνου σχήματι οὐρὰν ἐν τῷ στόματι ἔχων, ἔστω δὲ ἐντὸς τοῦ δράκοντος κάνθαρο… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papV-rings.txt | Leemans 1885 p.29 col. 8; translation follows Leemans's emendation ἔστω; accurate - MINOR | c066: ἀδιάλιπτος ⁽¹⁶⁾ ὁ κύκλος· ὄνομα περιέχει κάλλιστον [sign] ⁽¹⁷⁾ the circle [is] unfailing; it contains the mos… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papV-rings.txt | words verbatim, but the sentence precedes the serpent and Leemans (the edition cited) renders ὁ κύκλος as "annulus" (the finger-ring): "the circle is unfailing" said "of it" (the serpent) is one reading; the papyrus states the ring is for success, favour and victory, so the timeline's own-words "guard" is the page's inference - CONFIRMED | c067-1: One of the Greek magical papyri, whose materials date from the 100s BC to the 400s AD; its editor judged this… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Greek_Magical_Papyri.txt | Wikipedia GMP (live FOUND); Leemans p.79 Latin, translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c067-2: One of the Greek magical papyri, whose materials date from the 100s BC to the 400s AD; its editor judged this… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papW-serpent.txt | as c067-1 - CONFIRMED | c068: Ἀντὶ δὲ τοῦ συριγμοῦ δράκοντα δάκνοντα τὴν ⁽⁷⁾ οὐράν, ὥστε εἶναι τὰ δύο ποππυσμόν, καὶ συριγμόν, ἱερακοπρόσωπ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/sources/leemans-1885-papW-serpent.txt | Leemans 1885 p.85, Pap. W; translation checked: accurate - CONFIRMED | c069: Dated by its inscription to AD 194 | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1896-tmmm2-mon25-ouroboros-pedestal.txt | Cumont 1896 p.99 inscr.29 (CIL VI 724): "Année 194 ap. J.-C." - CONFIRMED | c070: entouré d'un serpent à longue barbe, se mordant la queue, sculpté en relief. Six rayons se dressent sur sa tê… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1896-tmmm2-mon25-ouroboros-pedestal.txt | Cumont 1896 p.208 mon.25, verbatim; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c071: eternity, given by F. Cumont, 1902: image bien connue de l’éternité | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/sources/cumont-1902-revue-archeologique-modena-relief.txt | Cumont 1902 p.5 and n.3 "Mon. 25, fig. 36" = this pedestal - CONFIRMED | c072-1: From about AD 400, writers start to explain the ring. | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/servius-aen-5-85-thilo.txt | Servius c.400; dossier 04 finds no earlier writer explaining a tail-biting ring (Philo of Byblos's figure is not a ring) - CONFIRMED | c072-2: From about AD 400, writers start to explain the ring. | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Servius__grammarian_.txt | as c072-1 - CONFIRMED | c073-1: Servius, a grammarian writing around AD 400, says that among the Egyptians, before letters were invented, the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/servius-aen-5-85-thilo.txt | Thilo 1881 p.603 from page image; translation accurate ("secundum Aegyptios") - CONFIRMED | c073-2: Servius, a grammarian writing around AD 400, says that among the Egyptians, before letters were invented, the… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Servius__grammarian_.txt | as c073-1 - MINOR | c074-1: Martianus Capella gives Saturn a fire-breathing serpent devouring the end of its tail, quem credebant anni nu… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/martianus-capella-1-70-eyssenhardt-kopp.txt | Latin and card are right, but the prose renders "quem credebant anni numerum nomine perdocere" as "which, they believed, taught the number of the year", dropping "nomine" (by its name); the card has it - CONFIRMED | c074-2: Martianus Capella gives Saturn a fire-breathing serpent devouring the end of its tail, quem credebant anni nu… | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/sources/eriugena-annotationes-in-marcianum-33-8-lutz1939.txt | Eriugena (Lutz 1939) "DRACO Saturni solarem annum significat": the holder is Saturn - CONFIRMED | c075: The poet Claudian puts a serpent round a cave, consuming all things with quiet power, and caudamque reductam … | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/claudian-stilicho-2-424-440-platnauer.txt | Platnauer/LacusCurtius (live FOUND); see the c085 note on the line the quote leaves out - CONFIRMED | c076: Macrobius says the Phoenicians made the serpent in orbem redactum caudamque suam devorantem, bent into a circ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/macrobius-saturnalia-1-serpents-lacuscurtius.txt | Macrobius Sat. 1.9.12, Jan 1852 p.70 (page image) and LacusCurtius (live FOUND); translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c077: Horapollo’s book of hieroglyphs says that to write the universe the Egyptians paint ὄφιν ... τὴν ἑαυτοῦ ἐσθίο… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/horapollo-hieroglyphica-cory-1840.txt | Cory 1840 pp.7-8, page images - CONFIRMED | c078: The same book’s serpent for eternity is another animal: its tail is ὑπὸ τὸ λοιπὸν σῶμα κρυπτομένην, hidden un… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/horapollo-hieroglyphica-cory-1840.txt | Cory 1840 pp.5-6: the uraeus "with its tail covered by the rest of its body" - CONFIRMED | c079: A third serpent, with its tail in its mouth and the king’s name written in its coil, stands for a king. | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/horapollo-hieroglyphica-cory-1840.txt | Cory 1840 p.80 (1.59) - CONFIRMED | c080: In the sixth century John Lydus wrote that the Egyptians carve δράκοντα οὐρηβόρον on their pyramids, because … | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/lydus-de-mensibus-3-4-wuensch.txt | Wuensch 1898 p.39; accurate as far as it goes, but the sentence before (ὅθεν, "hence") ties the carving to time "nowhere bounded" and the year; see the Lydus MINOR finding - MINOR | c081: Every one of these writers gives the tail-biter a meaning: the year, the world, time, or a king. None of them… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/dossier.md | matches dossier 04's synthesis, but Claudian's serpent rings the cave of "inmensi ... aevi" (aevum = Aion, eternity; Platnauer's own note: "Eternity, in the sense of endless time") and Lydus's time is "nowhere bounded": "none of them gives it eternity" rests on reading both as time - CONFIRMED | c082: Servius, a grammarian of the late fourth and early fifth centuries | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Servius__grammarian_.txt | Wikipedia Servius (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c083: annus enim secundum Aegyptios indicabatur ante inventas litteras picto dracone caudam suam mordente, quia in … | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/servius-aen-5-85-thilo.txt | Thilo 1881 p.603 from page image; translation accurate ("secundum Aegyptios") - CONFIRMED | c084: Claudian, about 370 to 404 AD | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Claudian.txt | Wikipedia Claudian "c. 370 – c. 404 AD" (live FOUND) - MINOR | c085: [427] suppeditat revocatque sinu. complectitur antrum, [428] omnia qui placido consumit numine, serpens [429]… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/claudian-stilicho-2-424-440-platnauer.txt | the card cites 2.424-430 but the quotation starts mid-sentence at 427, leaving out l.426 "inmensi spelunca aevi, quae tempora vasto": the cave the serpent rings is the cave of boundless aevum (eternity) - CONFIRMED | c086: Martianus Capella, active about 410 to 420 | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Martianus_Capella.txt | Wikipedia "fl. c. 410–420" (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c087: praetendebat dextera flammiuomum quendam draconem caudae suae ultima deuorantem, quem credebant anni numerum … | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/martianus-capella-1-70-eyssenhardt-kopp.txt | Eyssenhardt 1866 p.21 from page image; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c088: Macrobius, active about AD 400 | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Macrobius.txt | Wikipedia date line (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c089: Hinc et Phoenices in sacris imaginem eius exprimentes draconem finxerunt in orbem redactum caudamque suam dev… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/macrobius-saturnalia-1-serpents-lacuscurtius.txt | Macrobius Sat. 1.9.12, Jan 1852 p.70 (page image) and LacusCurtius (live FOUND); translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c090: Horapollo, active about the fifth century AD | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Horapollo.txt | Wikipedia date line (live FOUND) - MINOR | c091: Κόσμον βουλόμενοι γράψαι, ὄφιν ζωγραφοῦσι τὴν ἑαυτοῦ ἐσθίοντα οὐρὰν, ἐστιγμένον φολίσι ποικίλαις. When they w… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/horapollo-hieroglyphica-cory-1840.txt | the Greek stops at "ποικίλαις." but Cory's English printed beside it runs on into the next clause ("by the scales intimating the stars in the universe"): the translation says more than the quoted original - CONFIRMED | c092: eternity, given by Erasmus, in the Adages, crediting Horus: non annum, sed aevum | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/sources/erasmus-adagia-2-1-1-festina-lente-1520.txt | Erasmus 1520 f.119v: "Etiam si Horus ... serpentis scalptura non annum, sed aevum repraesentari tradit", in the context of the tail-biting serpent; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c093: The same book | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Horapollo.txt | Wikipedia date line (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c094: ὄφιν ζωγραφοῦσι κοσμοειδῶς ἐσχηματισμένον, οὗ τὴν οὐρὰν ἐν τῷ στόματι ποιοῦσι· τὸ δὲ ὄνομα τοῦ βασιλέως ἐν μέ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/horapollo-hieroglyphica-cory-1840.txt | Cory 1840 p.80 (1.59) - CONFIRMED | c095: John Lydus, AD 491 to about 565 | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/John_the_Lydian.txt | Wikipedia date line (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c096: δράκοντα οὐρηβόρον ταῖς πυραμίσιν ἐγγλύφουσιν. ἄβυσσον γὰρ ὑποτίθενται καὶ δράκοντα ἐν αὐτῇ, ἐξ οὗ τοὺς αἰσθη… | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/sources/lydus-de-mensibus-3-4-wuensch.txt | Wuensch 1898 p.39; accurate as far as it goes, but the sentence before (ὅθεν, "hence") ties the carving to time "nowhere bounded" and the year; see the Lydus MINOR finding - CONFIRMED | c097-1: In a Venice manuscript of probably the tenth century, a page of alchemical drawings has the serpent round the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/roberts-2022-bz-marcianus-299-date.txt | Roberts 2022 p.342 "probably the tenth century" (zenodo landing page cannot show the PDF; kept copy is the evidence); Pinakes "s. 10" - CONFIRMED | c097-2: In a Venice manuscript of probably the tenth century, a page of alchemical drawings has the serpent round the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/pinakes-marcianus-gr-299.txt | Pinakes: f.188v "Sequuntur diagrammata" (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c097-3: In a Venice manuscript of probably the tenth century, a page of alchemical drawings has the serpent round the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-introduction-figures.txt | Berthelot 1887 Introd. p.134: "Ἓν τὸ πᾶν; le tout est un"; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c098: The alchemist Olympiodorus says certain Egyptian sacred scribes, wishing to engrave the cosmos on obelisks, c… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-II-iv-18-olympiodorus-ouroboros.txt | CAAG II.iv.18, Texte grec p.80 ll.9-12; translation accurate - MINOR | c099: and he ties τὴν ἀρχὴν ἐν τῷ τέλει, putting the beginning in the end, to the tail-eating serpent. | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-II-iv-18-olympiodorus-ouroboros.txt | in the Greek (p.80 ll.1-3) it is Agathodaimon, as Olympiodorus reports him, who puts the beginning in the end and "wants it to be" the tail-eating dragon; the card says "(as Agathodaimon too)", the prose gives the tie to Olympiodorus - CONFIRMED | c100-1: An untitled text, in a manuscript copied in Crete in 1478, explains the figure as the work itself: ὁ οὐροβόρο… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-I-v-vi-serpent.txt | CAAG I.v, Texte grec p.21 l.20, "Transcrit sur A, f. 196 r. — Texte sans titre"; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c100-2: An untitled text, in a manuscript copied in Crete in 1478, explains the figure as the work itself: ὁ οὐροβόρο… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/pinakes-paris-gr-2327.txt | Pinakes: "s. 15 (1478) Lieu : Krete, Candia" (live FOUND); Berthelot: "écrit en 1478" - CONFIRMED | c101: Its four feet are the four bodies, its three ears three sublimates. | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-I-v-vi-serpent.txt | CAAG I.v p.22 ll.1-3; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c102: The work is done οὐχ ἑτέρᾳ καὶ ἑτέρᾳ, ἀλλ’ αὐτῇ μιᾷ: not with one thing and another, but with itself alone. | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-I-v-vi-serpent.txt | p.22 ll.4-8; the feminine datives refer to φύσις (nature), "not with one [nature] and another but with one and the same"; "the work is done" is a fair gloss of δι' οἰκονομίας - CONFIRMED | c103: In a manuscript of probably the tenth century | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/roberts-2022-bz-marcianus-299-date.txt | Roberts 2022 p.342 "probably the tenth century" (zenodo landing page cannot show the PDF; kept copy is the evidence); Pinakes "s. 10" - CONFIRMED | c104: 7° Vers le bas à gauche, est figuré le serpent Ouroboros, avec l'axiome central : Ἓν τὸ πᾶν; le tout est un. … | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-introduction-figures.txt | Berthelot 1887 Introd. p.134: "Ἓν τὸ πᾶν; le tout est un"; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c105: Not dated in what we read; quoted from Berthelot and Ruelle | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-II-iv-18-olympiodorus-ouroboros.txt | the kept CAAG pages give no date for Olympiodorus - CONFIRMED | c106: Ἱερογραμματεῖς γάρ τινες τῶν Αἰγυπτίων βουλόμενοι κόσμον ἐγχαράξαι ἐν τοῖς ὀβελίσκοις ἢ ἐν τοῖς ἱερατικοῖς γρ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-II-iv-18-olympiodorus-ouroboros.txt | CAAG II.iv.18, Texte grec p.80 ll.9-12; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c107: τὴν ἀρχὴν ἐν τῷ τέλει θεὶς, καὶ τὸ τέλος ἐν τῇ ἀρχῇ. Δράκων γὰρ οὐροβόρος βούλεται εἶναι, οὐ φθονῶν ὡς δοκοῦσ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-II-iv-18-olympiodorus-ouroboros.txt | p.80 ll.1-3; translation accurate (follows Berthelot's French) - CONFIRMED | c108: Copied at Candia, in Crete, in 1478 | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/pinakes-paris-gr-2327.txt | Pinakes: "s. 15 (1478) Lieu : Krete, Candia" (live FOUND); Berthelot: "écrit en 1478" - CONFIRMED | c109: Τοῦτο γάρ ἐστιν τὸ μυστήριον ὁ οὐροβόρος δράκων, τουτέστι συμφαγώνεται καὶ συγχωνεύεται, λειώνεται καὶ μεταλλ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-I-v-vi-serpent.txt | CAAG I.v, Texte grec p.21 l.20, "Transcrit sur A, f. 196 r. — Texte sans titre"; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c110: οἱ τέσσαρες αὐτοῦ πόδες ἐστὶν ἡ τετρασωμία· τὰ δὲ τρία ὦτα αὐτοῦ εἰσιν αἱ τρεῖς αἰθάλαι. its four feet are th… | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/sources/caag-I-v-vi-serpent.txt | CAAG I.v p.22 ll.1-3; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c111-1: In Pistis Sophia, a book possibly written in the third or fourth century, the outer darkness is a dragon: sou… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.268, ch.127, page image - CONFIRMED | c111-2: In Pistis Sophia, a book possibly written in the third or fourth century, the outer darkness is a dragon: sou… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.271, ch.130 - CONFIRMED | c111-3: In Pistis Sophia, a book possibly written in the third or fourth century, the outer darkness is a dragon: sou… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Pistis_Sophia.txt | Wikipedia rev. 1373670277 "possibly written between the 3rd [2] and 4th centuries AD" (live: present; a footnote marker splits it, so the matcher reported NOT FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c112: Release is the same act reversed: he will draw his tail out of his mouth and let go that soul. | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.271, ch.130 - CONFIRMED | c113: The same book makes the disk of the sun a great dragon whose tail was in his mouth. | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.296, ch.136 - CONFIRMED | c114: In the Greek Acts of Thomas a serpent says it is kin to the one outside the ocean, οὗ ἡ οὐρὰ ἔγκειται τῷ ἰδίῳ… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/acts-of-thomas-32-bonnet-1903-james-1924.txt | Bonnet 1903 p.149 ll.1-3, page image; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c115: the Syriac version has instead whose mouth is closed. | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/acts-of-thomas-32-bonnet-1903-james-1924.txt | Wright 1871 II p.171 "whose mouth is closed"; Wright's Syriac (Add. 14,645) has no word for tail - CONFIRMED | c116-1: The Talmud tells of a cave closed by a snake, an akhna, that would not open its mouth; Rashi, in the eleventh… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/jewish-sefaria-leviathan-akhna-zohar.txt | Bava Kamma 117b (live Sefaria text present; the matcher's 20% was a JSON-escape artefact): the akhna "did not open" - CONFIRMED | c116-2: The Talmud tells of a cave closed by a snake, an akhna, that would not open its mouth; Rashi, in the eleventh… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/jewish-sefaria-leviathan-akhna-zohar.txt | Rashi s.v. הדרא ליה עכנא (live FOUND); translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c116-3: The Talmud tells of a cave closed by a snake, an akhna, that would not open its mouth; Rashi, in the eleventh… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Rashi.txt | Wikipedia Rashi 1040-1105 (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c117: Possibly written between the third and fourth centuries AD | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Pistis_Sophia.txt | Wikipedia rev. 1373670277 "possibly written between the 3rd [2] and 4th centuries AD" (live: present; a footnote marker splits it, so the matcher reported NOT FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c118: have been led into the outer darkness into the jaws of his tail, he turneth his tail into his own mouth and s… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.268, ch.127, page image - CONFIRMED | c119: if it indeed is in the dragon of the outer darkness, he will draw his tail out of his mouth and let go that s… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.271, ch.130 - CONFIRMED | c120: The same book | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Pistis_Sophia.txt | Wikipedia rev. 1373670277 "possibly written between the 3rd [2] and 4th centuries AD" (live: present; a footnote marker splits it, so the matcher reported NOT FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c121: And the disk of the sun was a great dragon whose tail was in his mouth and who reached to seven powers of the… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/pistis-sophia-mead-1921.txt | Mead 1921 p.296, ch.136 - CONFIRMED | c122: An early third-century text; this is its Greek wording | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Acts_of_Thomas.txt | Wikipedia "an early 3rd-century text" (live FOUND); it also says the Greek reflects the earlier tradition - CONFIRMED | c123: συγγενὴς δέ εἰμι ἐκείνου τοῦ ἔξωθεν τοῦ ὠκεανοῦ ὄντος, οὗ ἡ οὐρὰ ἔγκειται τῷ ἰδίῳ στόματι· and I am kin to hi… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/acts-of-thomas-32-bonnet-1903-james-1924.txt | Bonnet 1903 p.149 ll.1-3, page image; translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c124: Rashi, 1040 to 1105 | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Rashi.txt | Wikipedia Rashi 1040-1105 (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c125: הדרא ליה עכנא - נחש גדול עשה עצמו כגלגל ומקיף את פי המערה ונותן זנבו לתוך פיו ואין אדם יכול ליכנס: An akhna e… | research/ouroboros/provinces/05-gnostic-jewish-christian/sources/jewish-sefaria-leviathan-akhna-zohar.txt | Rashi s.v. הדרא ליה עכנא (live FOUND); translation accurate - CONFIRMED | c126-1: In the Edda of Snorri Sturluson, who lived from 1179 to 1241, a serpent thrown into the deep sea grows until … | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/sources/brodeur-1916-prose-edda-p42.txt | Brodeur 1916 p.42, page image - CONFIRMED | c126-2: In the Edda of Snorri Sturluson, who lived from 1179 to 1241, a serpent thrown into the deep sea grows until … | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Snorri_Sturluson.txt | Wikipedia Snorri 1179-1241 (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | c127: A skaldic poem in Finnur Jónsson’s edition calls the serpent Umbgjǫrð allra landa, the girdle of all lands. | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/sources/skjaldedigtning-B1-bragi-olvir-ulfr-thor-fishing.txt | Skjaldedigtning B I p.6, Ǫlvir hnúfa: "Umbgjǫrð allra landa œstisk", FJ "Hele Jordens omspænder [Midgårdsormen]"; this entry was c126 when the share was assigned - CONFIRMED | added (dek, unmarked): The serpent with its tail in its mouth, read source by source from the pyramid of Teti to a program in 128 languages. | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/sources/dates/Teti.txt; research/ouroboros/provinces/13-modern/sources/quine-relay-readme.txt | README: "...(through 128 languages in total)..."; PT 393 is a Teti spell - WRONG | added (meta description, index.html line 16): For two thousand years the writers who explain it say it means the year, the world or time. | research/ouroboros/provinces/04-classical-authors/dossier.md; research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/dossier.md; the page's own dek | explainers begin c. AD 400 (Servius, Claudian); the eternity reading is in print by 1520 (Erasmus, crediting Horus) and 1577 (Mignault): about 1,100-1,200 years; the dek and frontmatter say "more than a thousand" - WRONG | added (timeline readout, app.mjs, box ticked): 45 sources whose own words say what the ring means, in 20 senses. In their own words, eternity first appears in: Claude Mignault on Alciato’s emblem 132, Antwerp 1584. | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/witnesses.json; recreated: engine.mjs tally/firstSaid over witnesses.json (45 sources, 20 senses); archive.org omniaandreaealc00alciat p.450 | counts recreated exactly; the first own-words eternity is not 1584 (see c003-1) - CONFIRMED | added (timeline readout, app.mjs, box unticked): 50 sources, with the meanings later readers gave them as hollow rings, in 20 senses. With later readers counted, eternity reaches back to: Papyrus of Her-Uben, Cairo, given by A. Piankoff and N. Rambova, 1957. | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/witnesses.json; recreated: engine.mjs over witnesses.json (50 sources, 20 senses); piankoff-rambova-1957-mythological-papyri-excerpts.txt p.73 | "the symbol of eternity" - WRONG | added (frontmatter body and plain; aw-plain meta): the first source whose own words give it the meaning eternity is Claude Mignault's commentary on Alciato, printed in 1584 / The first source we found that says eternity in its own words was printed in 1584. | https://archive.org/details/omniaandreaealc00alciat ; archive.org omniaandreaealc00alciat (Antwerp: Plantin 1577) p.450; omniaandreaealc00alci (1581) p.477; omniaandreaeal00alci (Paris 1583) pp.442-443 | Mignault's commentary carried the sentence by 1577, credited to "Orus Niliacus in ipso Hieroglyph. principio" - OBSERVED | [c127] In the older poetry we read, its tail is never in its mouth. Snorri is the only source we found that puts it… | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/dossier.md (A6, A7) | dossier: every skaldic stanza read (Bragi, Olvir, Eysteinn, Gamli, Ulfr) and Hymiskvida/Voluspa encircle, none bites; "the only one of them that has the tail in the mouth is Snorri's Gylfaginning" - CONFIRMED | [c128] Snorri Sturluson, 1179 to 1241 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snorri_Sturluson | Wikipedia (kept rev 1375528694; live same): "1179 – 23 September 1241" - CONFIRMED | [c129] ok ox sa ormr sva, at hann liɢr imiðiv hafinv of ꜹll lond ok bitr isporð ser. and that serpent grew so that i… | https://archive.org/details/edda-snorra-sturlusonar | FJ 1931 p. 34 as kept (page image), no variant for "ok bitr isporð ser"; translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c130-1] Isidore of Seville, who died in 636, copied his sentence almost word for word. | https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Isidore/5*.html | Isidore 5.36.2 differs from Servius only in "Sic ... apud" for "annus ... secundum"; Thilo's testimonia: "exscr. Isid. or. V 36, 2" - CONFIRMED | [c130-2] Isidore of Seville, who died in 636, copied his sentence almost word for word. | https://archive.org/download/invergiliicarmin01servuoft/page/n706_w1600.jpg | Servius on Aen. 5.85 (Thilo p. 603, kept from page image) is the sentence Isidore copies - CONFIRMED | [c130-3] Isidore of Seville, who died in 636, copied his sentence almost word for word. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isidore_of_Seville | Wikipedia (kept rev 1385558257; live same): "c. 560 – 4 April 636" - CONFIRMED | [c131] John Scottus, glossing Martianus, wrote DRACO Saturni solarem annum significat: Saturn's dragon signifies the… | https://archive.org/details/iohannisscottian00erig | Lutz 1939 p. 43: "DRACO Saturni solarem annum significat ... Cauda anni hiemale tempus est" - CONFIRMED | [c132-1] Notker of St Gall, around the year 1000, put it into German: a fiery dragon dér daz iâr bezéichenet, which si… | https://archive.org/details/dieschriftennot00capegoog | Piper 1882 p. 746: "dér daz iâr bezéichenet"; translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c132-2] Notker of St Gall, around the year 1000, put it into German: a fiery dragon dér daz iâr bezéichenet, which si… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notker_Labeo | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "Notker Labeo (c. 950 – 28 June 1022)": around the year 1000 - CONFIRMED | [c132-3] Notker of St Gall, around the year 1000, put it into German: a fiery dragon dér daz iâr bezéichenet, which si… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notker_Labeo | Wikipedia: "He went to the Abbey of Saint Gall when only a boy" - CONFIRMED | [c133-1] Boccaccio set Claudian's serpent in his chapter on Eternity and still read it as time: it devours its tail ut… | https://archive.org/details/200BoccaccioGenealogie1Si040 | Romano 1951 p. 16, chapter "De Eternitate": "temporis circularem lapsum ... anni unius finis principium est sequentis"; translation checked against the original: faithful - OBSERVED | [c133-2] Boccaccio set Claudian's serpent in his chapter on Eternity and still read it as time: it devours its tail ut… | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/sources/boccaccio-genealogie-1-1-eternitas-and-8-2-cronis-romano1951.txt | kept copy records the chapter title "De Eternitate" and that Boccaccio quotes Claudian there - CONFIRMED | [c134] CHRONICO, an engraving of the Ferrarese Tarocchi dated before 1467: a winged figure of Time holds up a dragon… | https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1924.432.32 | museum record (kept; live page has "before 1467"): Ferrara, engraving, CC0; image shows a winged youth holding a tail-biting dragon - CONFIRMED | [c135-1] When Aldus printed Horapollo's Greek in Venice in 1505, the two serpents were still apart: the cosmos is the… | https://archive.org/details/habenturhocuolum00aes | Aldine 1505 p. 111 (kept from page image): Πῶς κόσμον ... ὄφιν ... τὴν ἑαυτοῦ ἐσθίοντα οὐράν - CONFIRMED | [c135-2] When Aldus printed Horapollo's Greek in Venice in 1505, the two serpents were still apart: the cosmos is the… | https://archive.org/details/habenturhocuolum00aes | same page: αἰῶνα δ' ἑτέρως ... τὴν οὐρὰν ὑπὸ τὸ λοιπὸν σῶμα κρυπτομένην - CONFIRMED | [c136-1] Erasmus, in his Adages, describes the serpent with its tail in its mouth as the year, and adds that Horus say… | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_IALU3tjjWoEC | Venice 1520 f. 119v (kept): "Item annum hoc modo demonstrabant. Effingebant serpentem ..." - CONFIRMED | [c136-2] Erasmus, in his Adages, describes the serpent with its tail in its mouth as the year, and adds that Horus say… | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_IALU3tjjWoEC | same leaf: "serpentis scalptura non annum, sed aevum repraesentari tradit"; in context the carving is the tail-in-mouth serpent just described (selection.mjs models this as Erasmus, a later reader, crediting Horus) - MINOR | [c137-1] In 1543 Jacques Kerver printed Horapollo in French, with woodcuts. The chapter on the age and the years of ti… | https://archive.org/details/orusapollodeaegy00hora | all true but "Jacques Kerver printed": the colophon (kept) reads "Imprime a Paris pour Iaques Keruer libraire", printed FOR him; woodcut checked (cock-headed basilisk, tail in beak) - OBSERVED | [c137-2] In 1543 Jacques Kerver printed Horapollo in French, with woodcuts. The chapter on the age and the years of ti… | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/media/provenance.json; recreated: looked at public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/img/kerver-1543-basilisk.jpg | provenance: woodcut of book 1 ch. 1, leaf a ii verso (n15); the image shows a cock-headed serpent with its tail end in its beak - OBSERVED | [c138] Paris, 1543: the woodcut printed with the chapter that says the basilisk covers its tail with its body. Bosto… | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/media/provenance.json | Boston Public Library copy via Internet Archive orusapollodeaegy00hora n15; no rights field on the item, public domain as a work of 1543 - CONFIRMED | [c139-1] In 1556 Pierio Valeriano wrote that most people confuse the figures, the ring with its tail hidden and the ri… | https://archive.org/details/hieroglyphicasiu00vale | Basel 1556 f. 105r (kept): "plerosq[ue] figurã eius ... cõfundere"; translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c139-2] In 1556 Pierio Valeriano wrote that most people confuse the figures, the ring with its tail hidden and the ri… | https://archive.org/details/hieroglyphicasiu00vale | same: "Quaecunq[ue] de mundi anniq[ue] varietate ... per caudi morsum intelligunt[ur]"; translation checked against the original: faithful - WRONG | [c140] In 1584 Claude Mignault, explaining an emblem of Alciato's, wrote serpens in se revolutus, aeternitatem desig… | https://archive.org/download/omniaandreaealc00alciat/page/n453_w1400.jpg (Antwerp: Plantin 1577, p. 450) | the words are right (1584 p. 290 image checked) but the date is not when he wrote them: the 1577 Plantin edition already prints "Serpens in se revolutus, aeternitatem designat, ut docet Orus Niliacus in ipso Hieroglyph. principio", and the 1584 title page (kept) calls itself "Excerpta ex eiusdem ... maiorum vigiliarum commentariis" - CONFIRMED | [c141] In 1593 Cesare Ripa's Iconologia gave the ring to Eternity: Il Serpe in giro, dimostra, che l'eternità si pas… | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | Ripa 1593 p. 72 (kept): "Il Serpe in giro, dimostra, che l'eternità si pasce di se stessa" - CONFIRMED | [c142] The same book's entry for the Year still calls the serpent biting its tail antichissima figura dell'Anno, a m… | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | Ripa 1593 p. 15 (kept): "è antichissima figura dell'Anno" - OBSERVED | [c143-1] Mignault's sentence is the earliest place, in everything we read, where a source in its own words gives the t… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/selection.mjs (own('eternity') first at Mignault 1584); recreated: verifier A/D checks pass | true of what was read; but see c140: two readable earlier sources (Lyon: Rouillé 1566 p. 153, Antwerp: Plantin 1577 p. 450) say eternity in their own words, never fetched (08 robots.tsv) - OBSERVED | [c143-2] Mignault's sentence is the earliest place, in everything we read, where a source in its own words gives the t… | recreated: scan of research/ouroboros/catalogue.json (348 witnesses) for aetern-/aevum/αἰών/eternità/éternité/ewig/immortal before 1584 | no earlier witness gives the tail-biter eternity in its own voice: Erasmus credits Horus, Valeriano calls it a confusion, Cartari 1556/1571 and Boccaccio say time, Valeriano's "generum immortalitatem" is the nearest; claim holds for the catalogue, not for the readable record (see c140) - CONFIRMED | [c144] Isidore of Seville, about 560 to 636 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isidore_of_Seville | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "c. 560 – 4 April 636" - CONFIRMED | [c145] Sic enim apud Aegyptios indicabatur ante inventas litteras picto dracone caudam suam mordente, quia in se rec… | https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Isidore/5*.html | Lindsay text (kept; LacusCurtius live, FOUND); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c146-1] Notker Labeo, about 950 to 1022, who translated Martianus Capella | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notker_Labeo | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "Notker Labeo (c. 950 – 28 June 1022)" - CONFIRMED | [c146-2] Notker Labeo, about 950 to 1022, who translated Martianus Capella | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notker_Labeo | Wikipedia: "translated the works of earlier Latin writers such as Boethius and Martianus Capella" - CONFIRMED | [c147] trûog er án dero zéseuuun éinen fíurenten drácchen . dér daz iâr bezéichenet . sînen zágel slíndenten he carr… | https://archive.org/details/dieschriftennot00capegoog | Piper 1882 p. 746 (kept, from page image); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c148] Giovanni Boccaccio, 1313 to 1375 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giovanni_Boccaccio | Wikipedia (kept; live infobox 16 June 1313, 21 December 1375) - CONFIRMED | [c149] eumque dicit revoluto in caudam ore eam devorantem, ut ex hoc actu percipiamus temporis circularem lapsum. Na… | https://archive.org/details/200BoccaccioGenealogie1Si040 | Romano 1951 p. 16 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c150] Dated before 1467 by the museum | https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1924.432.32 | museum record: creation_date "before 1467" (live page has it) - CONFIRMED | [c151] In his right hand, Chronico holds up a dragon biting its own tail, an emblem of for "all-devouring Time." | https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1924.432.32 | museum text verbatim, its own typo "an emblem of for" included (live FOUND) - CONFIRMED | [c152] time, which eats what it brings, given by the Cleveland Museum of Art, in its record: all-devouring Time | https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1924.432.32 | same sentence: "all-devouring Time" - CONFIRMED | [c153] Printed by Aldus in Venice in 1505 | https://archive.org/details/habenturhocuolum00aes | kept copy: Venice, Aldus Manutius, 1505, colophon per the catalogue record - CONFIRMED | [c154] [Κ]όσμον βουλόμενοι γράψαι, ὄφιν ζωγραφοῦσι τὴν ἑαυτοῦ ἐσθίοντα οὐρὰν, ἐστιγμένον φολίσι ποικίλαις. Wishing t… | https://archive.org/details/habenturhocuolum00aes | Aldine p. 111 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c155] αἰῶνα δ' ἑτέρως γράψαι βουλόμενοι, ὄφιν ζωγραφοῦσιν, ἔχοντα τὴν οὐρὰν, ὑπὸ τὸ λοιπὸν σῶμα κρυπτομένην But wis… | https://archive.org/details/habenturhocuolum00aes | Aldine p. 111 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful (αἰών as eternity, as the page glosses it) - CONFIRMED | [c156] Read in the Venice printing of 1520 | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_IALU3tjjWoEC | the copy read is the Venice 1520 printing; the 1508 first edition is noted as not seen - CONFIRMED | [c157] Effingebant serpentem ita circumvolutum, ut caudam ore teneret insertam, innuentes annum semper iisdem vicibu… | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_IALU3tjjWoEC | f. 119v (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c158] Etiam si Horus Aegyptius, cuius extant duo super huiusmodi symbolis libri, serpentis scalptura non annum, sed… | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_IALU3tjjWoEC | f. 119v (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful ("Phoenicis" is Erasmus's own misreading of φοῖνιξ, palm) - MINOR | [c159] Printed in Paris by Jacques Kerver in 1543 | https://archive.org/details/orusapollodeaegy00hora | colophon (kept): "Imprime a Paris pour Iaques Keruer libraire": printed for Kerver, not by him; say "Printed in Paris for Jacques Kerver" - CONFIRMED | [c160] Aultrement ilz paignoient vng serpēt appelle Basilisque couurāt sa cueue du reste de sō cors Otherwise they p… | https://archive.org/details/orusapollodeaegy00hora | leaf a ii verso (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c161] Printed in Basel in 1556 | https://archive.org/details/hieroglyphicasiu00vale | kept: Basel [Michael Isengrin] 1556 - CONFIRMED | [c162] plerosq[ue] figurã eius in orbem circunducti, & caudã nunc occultantis, nunc admordentis, nunc depascẽtis, cõ… | https://archive.org/details/hieroglyphicasiu00vale | f. 105r (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c163] Quaecunq[ue] de mundi anniq[ue] varietate reciprocationeq[ue] dicta sunt, ea per caudi morsum intelligunt[ur]… | https://archive.org/details/hieroglyphicasiu00vale | f. 105r (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c164] Printed by Plantin in Antwerp in 1584 | https://archive.org/details/emblematavcandre00alci | the copy read: Antwerp, Plantin, 1584 (an epitome of the larger commentary, which already had the sentence in 1577: see c140) - CONFIRMED | [c165] serpens in se revolutus, aeternitatem designat. the serpent turned back on itself designates eternity. | https://archive.org/details/emblematavcandre00alci | p. 290 page image checked 2026-11-16: "serpens in se reuolutus, æternitatem designat."; translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c166] Printed in Rome in 1593 | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | kept: Rome, heirs of Gio. Gigliotti, 1593 - CONFIRMED | [c167] Il Serpe in giro, dimostra, che l'eternità si pasce di se stessa, nè si fomenta di cosa alcuna esteriore; The… | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | p. 72 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c168] Printed in Rome in 1593 | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | kept: Rome 1593 - CONFIRMED | [c169] Il Serpe posto in circolo, che morda la coda, è antichissima figura dell'Anno: The serpent set in a circle, b… | https://archive.org/details/iconologiaoverod00ripa | p. 15 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c170-1] Ibn Umayl, who lived in the tenth century, describes two birds, each seizing the other's tail with its beak,… | https://archive.org/details/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2 | Ruska 1936 pp. 312-313 (kept): "So bildeten die beiden Vögel einen einzigen Kreis, das Bild von Zwei in Einem." - CONFIRMED | [c170-2] Ibn Umayl, who lived in the tenth century, describes two birds, each seizing the other's tail with its beak,… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_Umayl | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "c. 900 to c. 960 AD" - CONFIRMED | [c171] A book printed in Paris in 1612 under the name of Nicolas Flamel says the ancient Egyptians painted ces Serpe… | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | Paris: Marette 1612 p. 68 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c172-1] Michael Maier, in 1618, reported that others read the tail-devouring dragon as the year, but that the philoso… | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | Oppenheim 1618 p. 66 (kept): "Quod licet alii exponant de anno ... serpentem, qui alium sui generis devoret" - CONFIRMED | [c172-2] Michael Maier, in 1618, reported that others read the tail-devouring dragon as the year, but that the philoso… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Maier | Wikipedia (kept; live infobox 1568, 1622) - CONFIRMED | [c173-1] And in a book printed at Erfurt in 1735 the single ring is what is left when ein Wurm den andern gefressen, o… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n13_w1400.jpg | Erfurt 1735 part 2 p. 8 (kept): "hat ein Wurm den andern gefressen, und kommet diese Figur heraus: N. 4" - CONFIRMED | [c173-2] And in a book printed at Erfurt in 1735 the single ring is what is left when ein Wurm den andern gefressen, o… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n16_w1400.jpg | p. 9 (kept): "HIer hast du nun diese 2. in eins gebracht" - CONFIRMED | [c174] Ibn Umayl lived from about 900 to about 960 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_Umayl | Wikipedia: "c. 900 to c. 960 AD" - CONFIRMED | [c175] abgeschnitten, der andere besass beide Flügel, und jeder der beiden Vögel fasste mit seinem Schnabel den Schw… | https://archive.org/details/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2 | Ruska p. 313 (kept); translation of Ruska's German faithful - CONFIRMED | [c176] Printed in Paris in 1612 | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | kept: Paris, Guillaume Marette, 1612 - CONFIRMED | [c177] Ce sont ces Serpens & Dragõs que les anciẽs Egyptiẽs ont peint en vn rõd, la teste mordãt sa queuë, pour dire… | https://archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.jpg | p. 68 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c178] Printed in 1618 | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | kept: Oppenheim, 1618 - CONFIRMED | [c179] Quod licet alii exponant de anno in se redeunte & circulum referente, tamen primitus à philosophis suis rebus… | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.jpg | p. 66 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c180] Printed in Erfurt in 1735 | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n13_w1400.jpg | kept: Erfurt, Crusius, 1735 - CONFIRMED | [c181] Koche dieses Feuer mit Feuer, bis es stehend bleibet, so hast du das Fixeste, welches alle Dinge durchdringet… | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n13_w1400.jpg | p. 8 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c182] HIer hast du nun diese 2. in eins gebracht: Here you have now brought these 2 into one: | https://archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n16_w1400.jpg | p. 9 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c183-1] In India, a Vedic verse compares a rite to aher iva sarpaṇaṃ, the creeping of a snake, and names no tail; the… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ernet.104121/page/n98_w1400.jpg | Aufrecht p. 88 (kept): the verse "aher iva sarpaṇaṃ ṣākalasya" names no tail - CONFIRMED | [c183-2] In India, a Vedic verse compares a rite to aher iva sarpaṇaṃ, the creeping of a snake, and names no tail; the… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ernet.104121/page/n310_w1400.jpg | Aufrecht p. 300 (kept): Sayana "mukhena puchasya daṅsanaṃ kṛitvā valayākāro bhavati" - CONFIRMED | [c183-3] In India, a Vedic verse compares a rite to aher iva sarpaṇaṃ, the creeping of a snake, and names no tail; the… | https://archive.org/download/historyofsanskri00macduoft/page/n290_w1400.jpg | Macdonell 1900 p. 275 (kept): "He died in 1387" - CONFIRMED | [c184] In Tibet, the hub of the Wheel of Life, as L. A. Waddell described it in 1892, is a pig which has hold of the… | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | JASB 61 p. 136 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c185] In Dahomey in 1864 Richard Burton saw girls waving white flags upon which were horned and rainbow-coloured se… | https://archive.org/download/missiontogelelek18642burt/page/n61_w1400.jpg | Burton 1864 II p. 52 (kept); the procession of 2 January 1864 (p. 28) - CONFIRMED | [c186] Melville Herskovits, in 1938, recorded that the snake Aido Hwedo lies coiled underneath the earth, supporting… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.36395/page/n107_w1400.jpg | Herskovits 1938 I p. 67 n. 1 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c187-1] In Mexico, the ring often called an Aztec ouroboros goes back to an engraving printed in Naples in 1699, from… | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n98_w1100.jpg | Gemelli p. 73: the figure of the Mexican century owed to Sigüenza, "che mi fece dono"; catalogue C-check and dossier F12 (Clavigero 1780) trace the "Aztec ouroboros" image to it - CONFIRMED | [c187-2] In Mexico, the ring often called an Aztec ouroboros goes back to an engraving printed in Naples in 1699, from… | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n83_w1100.jpg | Gemelli 1699 p. 60 (kept): "Era un circolo, intorno al quale s'aggirava un serpente" - CONFIRMED | [c187-3] In Mexico, the ring often called an Aztec ouroboros goes back to an engraving printed in Naples in 1699, from… | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n98_w1100.jpg | Gemelli p. 73 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c188] In 1792 Antonio de León y Gama read its mouth taking the end of its last loop as donde terminaba un Ciclo all… | https://archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n25_w1600.jpg | León y Gama 1792 p. 16 (kept): "en cuya boca entraba la extremidad de la última inflexîon" - CONFIRMED | [c189] Sayana died in 1387 | https://archive.org/download/historyofsanskri00macduoft/page/n290_w1400.jpg | Macdonell 1900 p. 275 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c190] 5. aher iva / ṣākalaṣabdaḥ sarpaviṣeshavācī / ṣākalanāmno 'heḥ sarpaviṣeshasya yathā sarpaṇaṃ gamanaṃ tathaiv… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ernet.104121/page/n310_w1400.jpg | Aufrecht p. 300 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c191-1] Printed in Naples in 1699; read by Antonio de León y Gama in 1792 | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n83_w1100.jpg | kept: Naples, Roselli, 1699 (other copies 1700) - CONFIRMED | [c191-2] Printed in Naples in 1699; read by Antonio de León y Gama in 1792 | https://archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n25_w1600.jpg | León y Gama 1792 names Gemelli's print - CONFIRMED | [c192] Era un circolo, intorno al quale s'aggirava un serpente. Il corpo del serpente contenea quattro divisioni. It… | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n83_w1100.jpg | p. 60 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c193] Circunscribian á este periodo de años una culebra que hacia quatro inflexîones ó vueltas, una en cada quadran… | https://archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n25_w1600.jpg | p. 16 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c194] an end that is a beginning, given by Antonio de León y Gama, 1792: donde terminaba un Ciclo allí comenzaba el… | https://archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n25_w1600.jpg | p. 16 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c195] Printed in 1864 | https://archive.org/download/missiontogelelek18642burt/page/n61_w1400.jpg | kept: London, Tinsley, 1864 - CONFIRMED | [c196] Then came two girls, waving round and round small white flags,upon which were horned and rainbow-coloured ser… | https://archive.org/download/missiontogelelek18642burt/page/n61_w1400.jpg | p. 52 (kept), verbatim incl. "flags,upon" - CONFIRMED | [c197] Published in 1892 | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | kept: JASB 61 (1892) - CONFIRMED | [c198] The three original sins or 'chief Causes of Demerit' are depicted as (1) a pig which has hold of the tail of… | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | p. 136 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c199] Printed in 1938 from fieldwork in Dahomey | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.36395/page/n107_w1400.jpg | kept: New York, Augustin, 1938; fieldwork date in the catalogue (date_basis: Dahomean Narrative 1958 p. 2, "recorded in 1931 in Dahomey") - CONFIRMED | [c200] Aido Hwedo (also referred to here as Dą) is the snake deity who, coiled underneath the earth, is envisaged as… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.36395/page/n107_w1400.jpg | p. 67 n. 1 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c201] In 1890 August Kekulé told how the atoms had once danced before his eyes in long rows, twisting like snakes,… | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | Berichte 23 p. 1306 (kept): "Eine der Schlangen erfasste den eigenen Schwanz" - CONFIRMED | [c202-1] He does not use the word ouroboros, and in the printed report of the celebration nobody does. | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | p. 1306 (kept): the speech has no "ouroboros" - OBSERVED | [c202-2] He does not use the word ouroboros, and in the printed report of the celebration nobody does. | recreated: archive.org kekules-dreams-1890 _djvu.txt (113,919 bytes) grep -i ourobor/uroboros/orobor/alchem/drache | no hit; positive control "Schwanz" 1, "Schlangen" 1, "schlangenartig" 1 (dossier F5 says the same) - CONFIRMED | [c203] The earliest English use we found is in a chemistry textbook of 1897, where G. D. Hinrichs points to the Ouro… | https://archive.org/download/introductiontoge00hinr/page/n391_w1400.jpg | Hinrichs 1897 p. 382 (kept), verbatim; catalogue leads_killed (13): King, Blavatsky, Mead, Budge editions searched, no earlier "ouroboros" - CONFIRMED | [c204] In 1899 Paul Gibier wrote of the Ouroboros (the serpent which feeds on itself, and is rolled in a circle, wit… | https://archive.org/download/psychismanalysis00gibi/page/n234_w1400.jpg | Gibier 1899 p. 235 (kept), quotes verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c205-1] Printed in 1890; Kekulé lived from 1829 to 1896 | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | kept: Berichte 23 (1890) - CONFIRMED | [c205-2] Printed in 1890; Kekulé lived from 1829 to 1896 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/August_Kekul%C3%A9 | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "7 September 1829 – 13 July 1896" - CONFIRMED | [c206] Wieder gaukelten die Atome vor meinen Augen. Kleinere Gruppen hielten sich diesmal bescheiden im Hintergrund.… | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | p. 1306 (kept); translation checked against the original: faithful - CONFIRMED | [c207] Published in 1897 | https://archive.org/download/introductiontoge00hinr/page/n391_w1400.jpg | kept: St. Louis 1897 - CONFIRMED | [c208] Also the Ouroborus on the first page of this book and here at its close. | https://archive.org/download/introductiontoge00hinr/page/n391_w1400.jpg | p. 382 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c209] Published in New York in 1899 | https://archive.org/download/psychismanalysis00gibi/page/n234_w1400.jpg | kept: New York, Bulletin Publishing, copyright 1899 - CONFIRMED | [c210] That is what has been figured by the ancient initiated ones in the Ouroboros (the serpent which feeds on itse… | https://archive.org/download/psychismanalysis00gibi/page/n234_w1400.jpg | p. 235 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c211-1] In E. R. Eddison's novel The Worm Ouroboros, of 1922, a king wears the worm on his thumb, which doctors have… | https://archive.org/download/eddisonworm/page/n213_w1400.jpg | Eddison 1922 p. 196 (kept) verbatim; p. 83: the king's thumb ring "in the semblance of the worm Ouroboros" - CONFIRMED | [c211-2] In E. R. Eddison's novel The Worm Ouroboros, of 1922, a king wears the worm on his thumb, which doctors have… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._R._Eddison | Wikipedia (kept; live same): "The Worm Ouroboros (1922)" - CONFIRMED | [c212] Erich Neumann made the uroboros the symbol of the pre-ego epoch, and hence of the prehistoric world. | https://archive.org/download/originsandhistor017897mbp/page/n34_w1400.jpg | Hull tr. vol. II p. 281 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c213] C. G. Jung saw in it the thought of devouring oneself and turning oneself into a circulatory process. | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.138777/page/n387_w1400.jpg | CW 14 p. 365 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c214-1] And Yusuke Endoh's Quine Relay is a Ruby program that generates a program in another language, which generate… | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README (kept; live 2026-11-16 same): "is a Ruby program that generates" - CONFIRMED | [c214-2] And Yusuke Endoh's Quine Relay is a Ruby program that generates a program in another language, which generate… | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README: "...(through 128 languages in total)..." (live same) - CONFIRMED | [c214-3] And Yusuke Endoh's Quine Relay is a Ruby program that generates a program in another language, which generate… | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README: "the original Ruby code again." (live same); live README credits "Yusuke Endoh (@mametter)" - CONFIRMED | [c214-4] And Yusuke Endoh's Quine Relay is a Ruby program that generates a program in another language, which generate… | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README: "an uroboros quine like this quine-relay" (live same) - CONFIRMED | [c215] Published in 1922 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._R._Eddison | Wikipedia (live same) - CONFIRMED | [c216] Rightfully, having such a timeless life, this King weareth on his thumb that worm Ouroboros which doctors hav… | https://archive.org/download/eddisonworm/page/n213_w1400.jpg | p. 196 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c217] Quoted from the 1962 printing of R. F. C. Hull's English | https://archive.org/download/originsandhistor017897mbp/page/n34_w1400.jpg | kept: Harper Torchbooks 1962 - CONFIRMED | [c218] It is the symbol of the pre-ego epoch, and hence of the prehistoric world. | https://archive.org/download/originsandhistor017897mbp/page/n34_w1400.jpg | p. 281 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c219] Quoted from the English edition of 1963 | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.138777/page/n387_w1400.jpg | kept: Routledge 1963 - CONFIRMED | [c220] In the age-old image of the uroboros lies the thought of devouring oneself and turning oneself into a circula… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.138777/page/n387_w1400.jpg | p. 365 (kept), verbatim - CONFIRMED | [c221] Its README, as read in November 2026 | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README live 2026-11-16 - CONFIRMED | [c222] It explains how to write a quine, an ascii-art quine, and an uroboros quine like this quine-relay. | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README live, line 368 - CONFIRMED | [c223] ...(through 128 languages in total)... | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md | README live, line 10 - CONFIRMED | [c224-1] Plato described the ouroboros (English Wikipedia, in revisions of 2006 and 2014). | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros?oldid=639695197&action=raw | rev 639695197 (live raw FOUND): "[[Plato]] described the Ouroboros as the first living thing ..." - CONFIRMED | [c224-2] Plato described the ouroboros (English Wikipedia, in revisions of 2006 and 2014). | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros?oldid=97082044&action=raw | rev 97082044 (live raw FOUND): "[[Plato]] described a self-eating, circular being ..." - CONFIRMED | [c225-1] The Timaeus describes the body of the world as one creature that feeds on its own waste, αὐτὸ γὰρ ἑαυτῷ τροφὴ… | https://archive.org/download/platonisopera04platuoft/page/n457_w1400.jpg | Burnet Tim. 33c (kept, page image): no ὄφις/δράκων, no tail or mouth; "no organ" to take food - CONFIRMED | [c225-2] The Timaeus describes the body of the world as one creature that feeds on its own waste, αὐτὸ γὰρ ἑαυτῷ τροφὴ… | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1572/pg1572.txt | Jowett (Gutenberg live FOUND): "his own waste providing his own food" - CONFIRMED | [c226-1] His tail-eater means the cosmos; his serpent for eternity hides its tail under its body. | https://archive.org/download/hieroglyphicsofh00hora/page/n24_w1400.jpg | Cory 1840 p. 7 (kept): 1.2 tail-eater = κόσμος - CONFIRMED | [c226-2] His tail-eater means the cosmos; his serpent for eternity hides its tail under its body. | https://archive.org/download/hieroglyphicsofh00hora/page/n23_w1400.jpg | Cory 1840 pp. 5-6 (kept): 1.1 aion serpent, tail hidden - CONFIRMED | [c227] Tutankhamun's shrine shows the First known representation of the ouroboros (English Wikipedia's caption). | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros | Wikipedia Ouroboros rev 1385148772 (live 2026-11-16): caption present - CONFIRMED | [c228-1] The Amduat in the tomb of Thutmose III, a century older, has a ringed serpent whose caption says his tail in… | https://www.sbl-site.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Netherworld.pdf | SBL PDF (reference fetch once; sha256 f9e70c18… matches the kept record) p. 192: "He exists in this fashion—his tail in his mouth."; Thutmose III 1479–1425 BC - CONFIRMED | [c228-2] The Amduat in the tomb of Thutmose III, a century older, has a ringed serpent whose caption says his tail in… | https://www.zora.uzh.ch/server/api/core/bitstreams/b98aa8f3-f5a3-468e-bb04-437a6d0e0a7d/content | Darnell 2004 p. 380 n. 33 (kept): Hornung 1977 "ein ikonographischer Vorläufer" - CONFIRMED | [c229] On the shrine the two serpents are holding their tails in their mouths (English Wikipedia). | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros | Wikipedia (live): "holding their tails in their mouths" - MINOR | [c230] The tails do literally touch the mouths; they are not shown inside them. | https://www.sbl-site.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Netherworld.pdf | Darnell and Darnell p. 192 n. 97 says "the tails do literally touch the mouths"; "not shown inside them" is the investigation's own look at facsimiles (catalogue C1), not in the cited source: mark it obs: or say "touch" - CONFIRMED | [c231] On the shrine The whole divine figure represents the beginning and the end of time. (English Wikipedia) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros | Wikipedia (live): "The whole divine figure represents the beginning and the end of time." - CONFIRMED | [c232] John Darnell: the arrest of time is most likely not an aspect of the nature of the giant deity on the first s… | https://www.zora.uzh.ch/server/api/core/bitstreams/b98aa8f3-f5a3-468e-bb04-437a6d0e0a7d/content | Darnell 2004 p. 384 (kept), verbatim; note: it answers Piankoff's "arrest of time", the catalogue C4 note (label read "Adoration of the circling one") carries the rest of the UNSUPPORTED verdict - CONFIRMED | [c233] In Egypt the serpent biting its tail is the symbol of eternity (Piankoff and Rambova, 1957). | https://archive.org/details/PiankoffRambovaMythologicalPapyriTexts | P&R 1957 p. 73 (kept): "a serpent biting its tail—the symbol of eternity" - CONFIRMED | [c234-1] The Egyptian captions we read do not say eternity: one speaks of The new year of Re, and in the book against… | https://archive.org/details/PiankoffRambovaMythologicalPapyriTexts | P&R p. 73 (kept): "The new year of Re in the barge of Re in the sky." - CONFIRMED | [c234-2] The Egyptian captions we read do not say eternity: one speaks of The new year of Re, and in the book against… | https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.70998 | Faulkner 1938 p. 44 (kept): "thy tail shall be placed in thy mouth" (a curse on Apep) - CONFIRMED | [c235] The Venice alchemical manuscript Marcianus graecus 299 is of the 6th or 7th centuries (English Wikipedia, The… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodoros_Pelecanos | Wikipedia Theodoros Pelecanos (live FOUND): "of the 6th or 7th centuries" - CONFIRMED | [c236] Sherwood Taylor, 1930: it is of the tenth or eleventh century. | https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.70877 | Taylor 1930 p. 112 (kept): "is of the tenth or eleventh century" - CONFIRMED | [c237] Berthelot, 1885: folio 196 has three bands, red, yellow and green; folio 279 has two, rouge et vert. | https://archive.org/details/lesoriginesdelal00bertuoft | Berthelot 1885 p. 59 n. 3 (kept): "fol. 196 (trois cercles : rouge, jaune et vert) et fol. 279 (deux cercles rouge et vert)" - CONFIRMED | [c238-1] Only Snorri's Edda, from the thirteenth century, has it bite its tail; the older poems we read call it the gi… | https://archive.org/details/edda-snorra-sturlusonar | Snorri 1931 p. 34 (kept): "ok bitr isporð ser" - OBSERVED | [c238-2] Only Snorri's Edda, from the thirteenth century, has it bite its tail; the older poems we read call it the gi… | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/dossier.md (A6, A7) | umbgjǫrð allra landa (Ǫlvir), umbgjǫrð neðan allra landa (Hymiskviða); no tail in any pre-Snorri text read - CONFIRMED | [c239] In the Aitareya Brahmana the Vedic rituals are compared to a snake biting its own tail. (English Wikipedia) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros | Wikipedia rev 1385148772 (live): compared to "a snake biting its own tail." - CONFIRMED | [c240-1] The verse speaks of a snake's creeping; the tail-biting ring is the commentator Sayana's gloss, made in the f… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ernet.104121/page/n98_w1400.jpg | Aufrecht p. 88 (kept): creeping, no tail - CONFIRMED | [c240-2] The verse speaks of a snake's creeping; the tail-biting ring is the commentator Sayana's gloss, made in the f… | https://archive.org/download/dli.ernet.104121/page/n310_w1400.jpg | Aufrecht p. 300 (kept); Sayana wrote under Bukka I and Harihara (1350-99): fourteenth century - CONFIRMED | [c241] The Hongshan pig-dragon, a 6,000-year-old grave amulet, may be the precursor to the OUROBOROS (White Snake Pr… | https://www.whitesnakeprojects.org/zhulong/ | White Snake Projects post of 14 October 2015 (live): sentence present - OBSERVED | [c242] On the Musée Guimet's piece the tail lies below the snout, separated from it by a slit cut through the stone;… | recreated: looked at the museum photograph https://www.guimet.fr/sites/default/files/styles/width_1220px/public/2023-10/dragon-cochon.jpg | the rounded end lies below the snout across a cut slit; mouth closed, nothing in it - CONFIRMED | [c243-1] Herskovits, 1938: the serpent supports the earth from underneath, and when the iron fails the serpent will be… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.36395/page/n107_w1400.jpg | Herskovits p. 67 n. 1 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c243-2] Herskovits, 1938: the serpent supports the earth from underneath, and when the iron fails the serpent will be… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.36395/page/n107_w1400.jpg | same footnote - CONFIRMED | [c244-1] The image is the engraving Gemelli printed in 1699; on the Sun Stone, Twin serpents, whose heads and tails al… | https://archive.org/download/girodelmondodeld06geme/page/n98_w1100.jpg | Gemelli p. 73 (kept); dossier F12 - CONFIRMED | [c244-2] The image is the engraving Gemelli printed in 1699; on the Sun Stone, Twin serpents, whose heads and tails al… | https://archive.org/details/fundamentalprinc00nutt | Nuttall 1901 p. 26 (kept, OCR): "Twin serpents, whose heads and tails almost meet" - CONFIRMED | [c245] His words are Eine der Schlangen erfasste den eigenen Schwanz, one of the snakes seized its own tail; the nam… | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | p. 1306 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c246] The word's first known use in English is 1921 (Merriam-Webster). | https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ouroboros | Merriam-Webster live 2026-11-16 still: "1921, in the meaning defined at sense 1" - CONFIRMED | [c247-1] It is in print as Ouroborus in 1897 and Ouroboros in 1899. | https://archive.org/download/introductiontoge00hinr/page/n391_w1400.jpg | Hinrichs 1897 p. 382 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c247-2] It is in print as Ouroborus in 1897 and Ouroboros in 1899. | https://archive.org/download/psychismanalysis00gibi/page/n234_w1400.jpg | Gibier 1899 p. 235 (kept) - CONFIRMED | [c248] The commentary on that page of the Talmud is Rashbam's, and it gives the encircling to the female Leviathan. | https://www.sefaria.org/api/v3/texts/Rashbam_on_Bava_Batra.74b | Sefaria API live: Rashbam "עקלתון - לויתן נקבה שמקיף את כל העולם"; the commentary at Bava Batra 74b is Rashbam's - CONFIRMED | [c249] Southwestern Iran is a second early center of the ouroboros (van der Sluijs and Peratt, 2009). | https://mythopedia.info/vanderSluijs-Peratt-JFR-46-1.pdf | PDF read with pdftotext: "Southwestern Iran is a second early center of iconography" (of ourobóros iconography, in context) - CONFIRMED | [c250-1] The authors widen the word to take in enclosing serpents in general; the one figure they cite that we could o… | https://mythopedia.info/vanderSluijs-Peratt-JFR-46-1.pdf | PDF: "is extended to the concept of enclosing serpents in general" - OBSERVED | [c250-2] The authors widen the word to take in enclosing serpents in general; the one figure they cite that we could o… | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/dossier.md (Toscanne 1911 fig. 351) | dossier: "The tail is nowhere near the mouth"; Mahdihassan 1963 and Amiet 1966 not read - CONFIRMED | [c251] By the translation of its statute that Wikipedia quotes, the dragon is bent into a circle, its tail winding a… | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_the_Dragon | Wikipedia Order of the Dragon (live): "incurved into the form of a circle, its tail winding around its neck" - OBSERVED | [c252-1] Eighteen research agents each took one province of the record and read what the house's rules let them reach:… | recreated: 18 provinces in catalogue.json, 18 provinces/*/robots.tsv (156 to 429 lines each) | every host of the 59 kept copies in my share is in its province robots.tsv - OBSERVED | [c252-2] Eighteen research agents each took one province of the record and read what the house's rules let them reach:… | research/ouroboros/briefs/researcher.md §2 | the brief requires robots-policy.mjs before any fetch and every verdict appended to robots.tsv - OBSERVED | [c253] Every excerpt they kept is checked against the copy saved in the repository, and the catalogue that this page… | recreated: in a scratch copy, changed "aeternitatem designat" in the kept Alciato copy; build-catalogue.mjs --check exit 1, build-page.mjs --check throws "excerpt not in its kept copy" | catalogue today: 1024 excerpts found, 0 missing, 0 problems (strictly, build-catalogue lists the excerpt as a problem; --check and the record builder refuse it) - OBSERVED | [c254] The cards, the timeline's data and this page's source record are built from that catalogue by one script, so… | recreated: node research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/build-page.mjs --check at 749d9bb131 (verifier C passes) | page blocks, witnesses.json and the record are what the script makes - OBSERVED | [c255-1] One error of ours: while gathering the dates of kings and authors, we fetched about fifty pages from a path o… | research/ouroboros/SYNTHESIS-NOTES.md lines 619-622; commit 181b4ead81 | "fifty Wikipedia summaries from /api/rest_v1/, which robots.txt disallows ... deleted unused ... re-read the articles from /wiki/" - OBSERVED | [c255-2] One error of ours: while gathering the dates of kings and authors, we fetched about fifty pages from a path o… | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/fetch-dates.mjs header; sources/dates/robots.tsv | all 44 kept date files say "Robots: allowed (en.wikipedia.org, /wiki/ path)"; robots.tsv: 86 allowed; none from rest_v1 - CONFIRMED | [added, index.html l. 433, unmarked] For a thousand years after Servius, the Latin West kept his meaning. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json; the section's own sources: Isidore 5.36.2, Eriugena on Martianus 1.70, Notker p. 746, Boccaccio Genealogie 1.1 (kept copies) | all read the ring as the year or the circling of time, c. 400 to the 1370s; needs a data-src - MINOR | [added, l. 443, unmarked] The steps before it are on paper: a printer's picture that contradicts its text, and a scholar who calls the result a confusion. | https://archive.org/download/omniadandalciat00alci/page/n158_w1400.jpg ; https://archive.org/download/omniaandreaealc00alciat/page/n453_w1400.jpg | Kerver 1543 and Valeriano 1556 are as described, but the eternity reading is in words before the 1584 printing: Lyon 1566 epimythion "Anguis in sese revolutus, aeternitatem"; Mignault 1577 "... aeternitatem designat, ut docet Orus Niliacus in ipso Hieroglyph. principio" (HIGH finding) - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 535, unmarked] The alchemists of the Arabic and Latin traditions read the ring as more than one thing, in both directions. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json; Ruska 1936 p. 313; Flamel 1612 p. 68; Maier 1618 p. 66; Eleazar 1735 pp. 8-9 (kept copies) | two birds make one circle; one worm eats the other, two brought into one: a fair summary - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 536, unmarked] These are alchemists explaining a figure they had inherited. They say nothing certain about where it came from. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json; Flamel 1612 p. 68; Maier 1618 p. 66 (kept) | they assert origins ("les anciens Egyptiens", "primitus à philosophis") without evidence; a fair judgment - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 576, unmarked] There the tail-eating is the end of the world, not its endlessness. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json; Herskovits 1938 I p. 67 n. 1 (kept) | "when the iron fails the serpent will begin to eat his tail and the earth will fall into the sea" - MINOR | [added, l. 693, unmarked] Claims about the ouroboros that we met again and again | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json, claimchecks where_it_is_made | Horapollo row: "not yet traced to a page read (open)" (province 08's own lead); folio-196 row: the research prompt plus an unfetched snippet; Aido Hwedo row: first "where" is "the lead given to this agent (from a language model's memory)" - UNVERIFIABLE | [added, l. 699, unmarked] Horapollo says the serpent biting its tail means eternity. (as a thing usually said) | tried: catalogue claimcheck 04-cc-horapollo-ouroboros-eternity; live https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros rev 1385148772 (no "Horapollo") | no instance in the record or on the page I read; the verdict beside it (c226) is right - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 705, unmarked] The famous red-and-green ouroboros of Paris grec 2327 is on folio 196. (as said) | https://libguides.brooklyn.cuny.edu/magicancientworld/closing_circle (reference fetch 2026-11-16, sha256 70784c5e…) | "Drawing by Theodoros Pelecanos, in a 1478 copy … - Fol. 196 of Codex Parisinus graecus 2327" - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 706, unmarked] The Norse world serpent is an ancient pagan ouroboros. (as said) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros rev 1385148772 | "In Norse mythology, the ouroboros appears as the serpent Jörmungandr ... grasp its tail in its teeth" - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 709, unmarked] The Fon serpent Aido Hwedo lies coiled round the earth with its tail in its mouth. (as said) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayida-Weddo rev 1383954961 | "the vodun symbol for Damballah is the circular serpent devouring its own tail (commonly called ouroboros)"; said in substance - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 710, unmarked] The Aztecs had the ouroboros, as the symbol of their 52-year cycle. (as said) | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json; León y Gama 1792 p. 16; Nuttall 1901 p. 26 (kept) | León y Gama reads Gemelli's snake round the 52-year cycle as tail in mouth; no modern instance in the record - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 711, unmarked] Kekulé dreamed of the ouroboros. (as said) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/August_Kekul%C3%A9 rev 1384990507 | "a reverie or day-dream of a snake seizing its own tail (this is an ancient symbol known as the ouroboros)" - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 713, unmarked] Rashi says Leviathan encircles the whole world. (as said) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros rev 1385148772 | "Rashi on Baba Batra 74b describes it as 'twisting around and encompassing the entire world'" - CONFIRMED | [added, l. 715, unmarked] The badge of the Order of the Dragon (1408) is an ouroboros. (as said) | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_the_Dragon rev 1383389200 | "the order's symbols of the ouroboros and the red cross" - MINOR | [added, l. 723, unmarked] Every claim on the page is marked with its source | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/index.html at 749d9bb131 and at 4852244217 | not so: lines 433, 443, 535, 536, 576, 693, 725 and the eight "What is said" cells (699, 705, 706, 709-711, 713, 715) carry no data-src - OBSERVED | [added, l. 725, unmarked] What we could not read is listed in each province's dossier in the repository, under research/ouroboros/provinces/. | recreated: grep -i for could not, not read, unreadable, refused, controlled lending, not seen, unverified over the 18 dossier.md files | 14 to 50 such entries in every dossier (12-kekule has "## What could not be read (and what was tried)"); the page gives no link to the repository - CONFIRMED | c004-1: The ring of meanings. The serpent’s body is this page’s time axis, from 2400 BC at its neck to 2030 at the tail in its mouth, stretched where the record is thick: a century after 1850 takes seven times as much of the body as a century before 1000 BC. Each number marks the earliest source on the timeline that gives a meaning in its own words, placed where the timeline places it within its dates; the key gives that source, and its date as its card states it. | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/witnesses.json | pictures pass: marks, key and caption recomputed from witnesses.json and engine.mjs; the stretch is 33.8 against 4.83 degrees a century, seven times; re-checked - CONFIRMED | c004-2: The ring of meanings. The serpent’s body is this page’s time axis, from 2400 BC at its neck to 2030 at the tail in its mouth, stretched where the record is thick: a century after 1850 takes seven times as much of the body as a century before 1000 BC. Each number marks the earliest source on the timeline that gives a meaning in its own words, placed where the timeline places it within its dates; the key gives that source, and its date as its card states it. | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/ring.mjs | pictures pass: marks, key and caption recomputed from witnesses.json and engine.mjs; the stretch is 33.8 against 4.83 degrees a century, seven times; re-checked - CONFIRMED | c004-3: The ring of meanings. The serpent’s body is this page’s time axis, from 2400 BC at its neck to 2030 at the tail in its mouth, stretched where the record is thick: a century after 1850 takes seven times as much of the body as a century before 1000 BC. Each number marks the earliest source on the timeline that gives a meaning in its own words, placed where the timeline places it within its dates; the key gives that source, and its date as its card states it. | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/engine.mjs | pictures pass: marks, key and caption recomputed from witnesses.json and engine.mjs; the stretch is 33.8 against 4.83 degrees a century, seven times; re-checked - CONFIRMED | c038: “Commons file 'Horus-Harpocrates in the Sun.jpg': the child in the sun disk ringed by a serpent, on the lions of the horizon; identified by us as scene 3 of the papyrus of Her-Uben A (Piankoff and Rambova 1957, pap. no 1; Niwinski's Cairo 91)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/02-egypt-later/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c060: “C. Densmore Curtis, 'The Bernardini Tomb', Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome 3 (1919), Plate 21, fig. 2: '2, Detail from inside of No. 25. (See p. 39).'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c064: “Jasper intaglio: Seated Serapis on crocodile (the Met's title); obverse, figure inside a serpent ring” | research/ouroboros/provinces/03-greek-word-magic/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c076: “F. Cumont, Textes et monuments figurés relatifs aux mystères de Mithra II (1896), p. 208, fig. 36” | research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c090-1: Venice, 1571: Claudian’s cave as Vincenzo Cartari’s Imagini pictured it, with one long serpent along the foreground taking the end of its tail in its jaws. Cartari’s text says the serpent round the cave shows “l’effetto del tempo”, the effect of time. | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_q2rUgJmE2-oC | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c090-2: Venice, 1571: Claudian’s cave as Vincenzo Cartari’s Imagini pictured it, with one long serpent along the foreground taking the end of its tail in its jaws. Cartari’s text says the serpent round the cave shows “l’effetto del tempo”, the effect of time. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c090-3: Venice, 1571: Claudian’s cave as Vincenzo Cartari’s Imagini pictured it, with one long serpent along the foreground taking the end of its tail in its jaws. Cartari’s text says the serpent round the cave shows “l’effetto del tempo”, the effect of time. | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c104: The same book: Horapollo, active about the fifth century AD | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horapollo | pictures pass: the date line made to stand alone in the ring key; the same source as the card before it - CONFIRMED | c112-1: The page headed Cleopatra’s gold-making (Κλεοπάτρης Χρυσοποιία) in Marcianus gr. 299, fol. 188 verso, a manuscript probably of the tenth century, as Berthelot reproduced it in 1887. The serpent ring at the lower left holds the words ἓν τὸ πᾶν, one is the all. Berthelot read the three circles at the top as the serpent too, because the outer one runs out into a tail. | https://zenodo.org/records/6450098 | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c112-2: The page headed Cleopatra’s gold-making (Κλεοπάτρης Χρυσοποιία) in Marcianus gr. 299, fol. 188 verso, a manuscript probably of the tenth century, as Berthelot reproduced it in 1887. The serpent ring at the lower left holds the words ἓν τὸ πᾶν, one is the all. Berthelot read the three circles at the top as the serpent too, because the outer one runs out into a tail. | https://archive.org/details/collectiondesanc01bert | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c112-3: The page headed Cleopatra’s gold-making (Κλεοπάτρης Χρυσοποιία) in Marcianus gr. 299, fol. 188 verso, a manuscript probably of the tenth century, as Berthelot reproduced it in 1887. The serpent ring at the lower left holds the words ἓν τὸ πᾶν, one is the all. Berthelot read the three circles at the top as the serpent too, because the outer one runs out into a tail. | https://archive.org/details/collectiondesanc01bert | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c112-4: The page headed Cleopatra’s gold-making (Κλεοπάτρης Χρυσοποιία) in Marcianus gr. 299, fol. 188 verso, a manuscript probably of the tenth century, as Berthelot reproduced it in 1887. The serpent ring at the lower left holds the words ἓν τὸ πᾶν, one is the all. Berthelot read the three circles at the top as the serpent too, because the outer one runs out into a tail. | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c116-1: Paris, BnF grec 2327, a manuscript of 1478, fol. 279: the second drawing of the serpent in that book, a four-legged, eared dragon whose body runs round the page and comes back, tapering, between its open jaws. The Greek text is written inside the ring. | https://archive.org/details/collectiondesanc01bert | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c116-2: Paris, BnF grec 2327, a manuscript of 1478, fol. 279: the second drawing of the serpent in that book, a four-legged, eared dragon whose body runs round the page and comes back, tapering, between its open jaws. The Greek text is written inside the ring. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c116-3: Paris, BnF grec 2327, a manuscript of 1478, fol. 279: the second drawing of the serpent in that book, a four-legged, eared dragon whose body runs round the page and comes back, tapering, between its open jaws. The Greek text is written inside the ring. | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c118: “Detail of FIGURE 11. — Chrysopée de Cléopâtre: the small ring-serpent with ἓν τὸ πᾶν (lower left of the page)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/06-greek-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c120-1: His text’s oldest manuscript is Marcianus graecus 299, probably of the tenth century | https://zenodo.org/records/6450098 | pictures pass: Roberts 2022 "probably the tenth century" (triple-circle#7) and the catalogue, oldest manuscript M = Marcianus gr. 299 - CONFIRMED | c120-2: His text’s oldest manuscript is Marcianus graecus 299, probably of the tenth century | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: Roberts 2022 "probably the tenth century" (triple-circle#7) and the catalogue, oldest manuscript M = Marcianus gr. 299 - CONFIRMED | c135: The same book, possibly written between the third and fourth centuries AD | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pistis_Sophia | pictures pass: the date line made to stand alone in the ring key; the same source as the card before it - CONFIRMED | c144-1: Thor and the giant Hymir fishing, with Jörmungandr, the serpent round all lands, on the hook: an Icelandic manuscript drawing that Wikimedia Commons dates to 1765-1766 and gives to Jakob Sigurðsson (Reykjavík, SÁM 66, fol. 79v). | research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c144-2: Thor and the giant Hymir fishing, with Jörmungandr, the serpent round all lands, on the hook: an Icelandic manuscript drawing that Wikimedia Commons dates to 1765-1766 and gives to Jakob Sigurðsson (Reykjavík, SÁM 66, fol. 79v). | https://archive.org/details/proseedda00snor | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c156-1: The next woodcut in the same book, for the chapter on how they signified the world: a scaly serpent in loose loops on the ground, its head appearing to hold the thin end of its tail. An unclear shape with an eye at the lower left may be a second head, or a rock or a root. | https://archive.org/details/orusapollodeaegy00hora | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c156-2: The next woodcut in the same book, for the chapter on how they signified the world: a scaly serpent in loose loops on the ground, its head appearing to hold the thin end of its tail. An unclear shape with an eye at the lower left may be a second head, or a rock or a root. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c156-3: The next woodcut in the same book, for the chapter on how they signified the world: a scaly serpent in loose loops on the ground, its head appearing to hold the thin end of its tail. An unclear shape with an eye at the lower left may be a second head, or a rock or a root. | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c197-1: Oppenheim, 1618: Emblem XIV of Michael Maier’s Atalanta fugiens, “Hic est Draco caudam suam devorans”, this is the dragon devouring its tail. A winged dragon lies curled in a ring with the end of its own tail in its mouth; the Science History Institute, whose copy this is, credits the engraving to Matthaeus Merian. | https://archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n72_w1400.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c197-2: Oppenheim, 1618: Emblem XIV of Michael Maier’s Atalanta fugiens, “Hic est Draco caudam suam devorans”, this is the dragon devouring its tail. A winged dragon lies curled in a ring with the end of its own tail in its mouth; the Science History Institute, whose copy this is, credits the engraving to Matthaeus Merian. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c197-3: Oppenheim, 1618: Emblem XIV of Michael Maier’s Atalanta fugiens, “Hic est Draco caudam suam devorans”, this is the dragon devouring its tail. A winged dragon lies curled in a ring with the end of its own tail in its mouth; the Science History Institute, whose copy this is, credits the engraving to Matthaeus Merian. | research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c205: “Engraved plate with figures N. 3 (two dragons, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth) and N. 4 (one crowned dragon, 'Der Fixe', 'Rothe Drache', its own tail in its mouth)” | research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c215-1: The hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life in the plate L. A. Waddell published in 1895: a pig, a cock and a snake, each holding the next one’s tail, their bodies not crossing. In 1892 Waddell wrote that the pig symbolizes ignorance, the cock desire or lust, and the snake anger or hate; his 1895 book calls the three vices lust, ill-will and stupidity and says they are figured as a dove, a serpent and a pig. The bird in the plate is a cock. | https://archive.org/download/cu31924023203288/page/n138_w1400.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c215-2: The hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life in the plate L. A. Waddell published in 1895: a pig, a cock and a snake, each holding the next one’s tail, their bodies not crossing. In 1892 Waddell wrote that the pig symbolizes ignorance, the cock desire or lust, and the snake anger or hate; his 1895 book calls the three vices lust, ill-will and stupidity and says they are figured as a dove, a serpent and a pig. The bird in the plate is a cock. | https://archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c215-3: The hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life in the plate L. A. Waddell published in 1895: a pig, a cock and a snake, each holding the next one’s tail, their bodies not crossing. In 1892 Waddell wrote that the pig symbolizes ignorance, the cock desire or lust, and the snake anger or hate; his 1895 book calls the three vices lust, ill-will and stupidity and says they are figured as a dove, a serpent and a pig. The bird in the plate is a cock. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c215-4: The hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life in the plate L. A. Waddell published in 1895: a pig, a cock and a snake, each holding the next one’s tail, their bodies not crossing. In 1892 Waddell wrote that the pig symbolizes ignorance, the cock desire or lust, and the snake anger or hate; his 1895 book calls the three vices lust, ill-will and stupidity and says they are figured as a dove, a serpent and a pig. The bird in the plate is a cock. | research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c219: “Folding plate 'SECOLO MEXICANO' (52-year wheel encircled by a looped serpent), marked 'Par. 6 Pag. 68'” | research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c231-1: Berlin, 1886: six monkeys hold one another in a closed ring, in a joke issue of the Berichte, the Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, signed with the pen name F. W. Findig: “ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé’schen Benzolsechsecks”, a most perfect analogue of Kekulé’s benzene hexagon. Their tails touch nothing. Kekulé told of his reverie four years later. | https://archive.org/download/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft/InternetArchiveBerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaftDankHarvard-googleAusBer1887.jahg.20Mit4Weinglser.pdf | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c231-2: Berlin, 1886: six monkeys hold one another in a closed ring, in a joke issue of the Berichte, the Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, signed with the pen name F. W. Findig: “ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé’schen Benzolsechsecks”, a most perfect analogue of Kekulé’s benzene hexagon. Their tails touch nothing. Kekulé told of his reverie four years later. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c231-3: Berlin, 1886: six monkeys hold one another in a closed ring, in a joke issue of the Berichte, the Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, signed with the pen name F. W. Findig: “ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé’schen Benzolsechsecks”, a most perfect analogue of Kekulé’s benzene hexagon. Their tails touch nothing. Kekulé told of his reverie four years later. | research/ouroboros/provinces/12-kekule/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c231-4: Berlin, 1886: six monkeys hold one another in a closed ring, in a joke issue of the Berichte, the Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, signed with the pen name F. W. Findig: “ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé’schen Benzolsechsecks”, a most perfect analogue of Kekulé’s benzene hexagon. Their tails touch nothing. Kekulé told of his reverie four years later. | https://archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams%20%281890%29.pdf | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c237: “Ouroboros with 'ἓν τὸ πᾶν' (called 'the Ouroborus' in the text), foot of p. 382, Lecture 100” | research/ouroboros/provinces/13-modern/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes (the caption quotes the record’s title) - CONFIRMED | c245-1: Paris, about 1789: Jean-Jacques-François Le Barbier’s painting of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. At the top centre, hanging from the cornice above the two tablets, is a gold ring formed by one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with a garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. The painting does not say what the ring means. Musée Carnavalet, P809. | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Declaration_of_the_Rights_of_Man_and_of_the_Citizen_in_1789.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c245-2: Paris, about 1789: Jean-Jacques-François Le Barbier’s painting of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. At the top centre, hanging from the cornice above the two tablets, is a gold ring formed by one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with a garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. The painting does not say what the ring means. Musée Carnavalet, P809. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c245-3: Paris, about 1789: Jean-Jacques-François Le Barbier’s painting of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. At the top centre, hanging from the cornice above the two tablets, is a gold ring formed by one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with a garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. The painting does not say what the ring means. Musée Carnavalet, P809. | research/ouroboros/provinces/08-medieval-renaissance-emblems/media/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c246-1: The ring at the size of the 1920-pixel copy on Commons, not enlarged: one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with the garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Declaration_of_the_Rights_of_Man_and_of_the_Citizen_in_1789.jpg | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c246-2: The ring at the size of the 1920-pixel copy on Commons, not enlarged: one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with the garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - CONFIRMED | c246-3: The ring at the size of the 1920-pixel copy on Commons, not enlarged: one serpent, its tail at or in its mouth, with the garland through it and the red Phrygian cap below. | research/ouroboros/pictures/provenance.json | pictures pass: the picture looked at against this caption, the catalogue witness and the provenance record; re-checked after the fixes - WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass] each apparatus entry printed "Rights, in the source’s words" over the research’s own notes (14 entries); two had never been read at the source | research/ouroboros/provinces/*/media/provenance.json; archive.org metadata | fixed: rights read again at each source (research/ouroboros/pictures/check-rights.mjs, rights.json) and quoted, or "states no rights", or "could not be read"; our reading printed apart (readings.mjs) - WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass] Cartari entry: "The Internet Archive record for this item has no rights field" | https://archive.org/metadata/bub_gb_q2rUgJmE2-oC | fixed: the item has licenseurl http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/, now quoted - WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass, pre-existing] the timeline caption: "the axis is stretched where the record is thin" | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/engine.mjs STRETCHES | fixed: "thick"; a century after 1850 takes seven times the width of one before 1000 BC; the verifier now checks both captions agree - WRONG | [first pass] the ring caption: "Each number marks the date of the first source we read that gives a meaning in its own words" | research/its-tail-in-its-mouth/selection.mjs (Olympiodorus year: null); research/ouroboros/catalogue.json | fixed: Olympiodorus, who gives "an end that is a beginning" in his own words, was off the timeline only for want of a year; he is now placed at his oldest manuscript (Marcianus gr. 299, probably tenth century) and the caption says "the earliest source on the timeline" - WRONG | [added, unmarked, first pass] the Her-Uben card picture’s alt text: "(P&R line drawing)", "tail tip at the open mouth" | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json caveats | fixed: the picture is a colour photograph on which the join cannot be seen; every card picture now has a hand-written alt (selection.mjs CARD_ALT) - MINOR | [first pass] the ring key printed each mark’s placement year (e.g. "AD 455" for Horapollo 1.59) as if it were a date | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/witnesses.json | fixed: the key gives each source’s date line as its card states it - MINOR | [first pass] the Waddell plate caption listed the animals and "lust, ill-will and stupidity" in parallel, reading pig = lust | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json (10-south-east-asia-waddell-1892-wheel-hub-text#0: Waddell 1892, JASB p. 136) | fixed: the 1892 mapping (pig ignorance, cock desire or lust, snake anger or hate) and the 1895 book’s dove are given - MINOR | [first pass] the Monde plate caption said "one scaly serpent", dropping the record’s caveat about the eyed shape at lower left | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json 08-horapollo-kerver-1543-monde-woodcut | fixed: the caveat is in the caption - MINOR | [first pass] the Chrysopoeia caption cited triple-circle#0 for Berthelot’s tail sentence and dated the manuscript "tenth or eleventh century" beside the card’s "probably the tenth" | research/ouroboros/catalogue.json 06-marcianus-299-f188v-triple-circle#2, #7 | fixed: cites #2 and #7; "probably of the tenth century" - MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] apparatus links: the Thor source link cut at the first comma (404); the CC0 links ended in """ | research/ouroboros/lib/pictures.mjs linkify | fixed: addresses are found before escaping; all 106 links checked well-formed - MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] the Pictures intro: "word for word", "smaller copies", every picture "public-domain" without saying where | public/strata/its-tail-in-its-mouth/index.html | fixed: rewritten; US-only cases named; the Le Barbier detail was an enlarged crop and is now cut at native size from the 1920-pixel copy - MINOR | [added, unmarked, first pass] internal notes printed in apparatus entries ("Flag for the orchestrator", "For review by the orchestrator", "this agent", "the brief allows") | research/ouroboros/provinces/*/media/provenance.json | fixed: the records’ reasoning fields are no longer printed; record wording corrected with dated notes ## Findings - [fixed] HIGH (both checkers): the page said no source we could read gives the tail-biting ring eternity in its own words before 1584 (Mignault's 1584 epitome). The same reading is printed in Alciato's emblems with the glosses added at Lyon in 1566 ("Anguis in sese reuolutus, aeternitatem", p. 153) and in Mignault's full commentary, Antwerp 1577, p. 450, where he credits Horapollo's opening chapter (the serpent of eternity that hides its tail). Page images of both title pages and both passages re-read by the coordinator; both added to province 08 with kept transcriptions; dek, description, plain card, frontmatter, the eternity section, the timeline cards and the verifier now give 1566, and the check section says the pass found it. - [fixed] MED (both checkers): the meta description said "For two thousand years" where the dek said "more than a thousand"; now both say "more than a thousand", and the verifier asserts that they agree. - [fixed] MED: the copy of the verifier published at /checks/ was older than the page and failed from an empty directory; public/checks was regenerated (scripts/publish-checks.mjs) and the published copy run from an empty directory against a copy of the page before landing. - [fixed] MINOR: the Amduat serpent's heads (Bucher five, the Darnells four) and the Darnells' note that the drawing is "not that of a true uroboros as described in the annotation" are now both on the page. - [fixed] MINOR: Claudian's line 426 ("inmensi spelunca aevi") is now quoted, and the summary of the late antique writers says that he sets the serpent round the cave of aevum and that his translator Platnauer glossed it "Eternity, in the sense of endless time" (a later reader on the timeline). - [fixed] MINOR: Lydus now carries "time" in his own words, from the sentence before the quoted one ("ἴδιον τοῦ χρόνου εἰς ἑαυτὸν ἀναστρέφοντος"). - [fixed] MINOR: the Leiden heliotrope recipe's "ἀδιάλιπτος ὁ κύκλος" is about the finger-ring, not the drawn serpent; the sentence and the card no longer give it to the serpent, and the card's own-words "guard" is removed. - [fixed] MINOR: the Tutankhamun card no longer pins Wikipedia's "beginning and the end of time" (a sentence about the whole figure) on the serpents as a later reading. - [fixed] MINOR: Kenyon's "concludes with a diagram" is about the group of charms on the recto, not the whole papyrus; reworded. - [fixed] MINOR: the Horapollo 1.2 card's English ran a clause past the quoted Greek; Cory's translation is now cut where the Greek ends (province 04 record, with a note). - [fixed] MINOR: Martianus's "nomine" restored in the prose ("by its name"). - [fixed] MINOR: the Olympiodorus sentence now gives "the beginning in the end" to Agathodaimon, as the Greek does. - [fixed] MINOR: "each with the words of its source" now reads "each with its source's words, or a picture of it, kept in the repository" (eight witnesses are pictures). - [fixed] MINOR: the 1543 French Horapollo was printed for Jacques Kerver, not by him; prose and card corrected. - [fixed] MINOR: "the tails are not shown inside them" is now marked as the investigation's own look at the drawings and photographs, apart from the Darnells' "touch". - [fixed] MINOR: the table's lead no longer says the claims were "met again and again"; some came from the research's own leads, and it now says so. - [fixed] MINOR: "Every claim on the page is marked with its source" replaced by what is true (the page's claims about the world are marked); the unmarked factual sentences found were marked. - [fixed] UNVERIFIABLE: the table row "Horapollo says the serpent biting its tail means eternity" now names where it is said: Erasmus's Adages (1520 printing) and Mignault's commentary (1577). - [fixed] note: the Reemes abstract's record entry now names its kept copy (scholarship entry 18-historiography/s2). - [fixed] HIGH (pictures pass): the ring of meanings said each mark is "the first source we read" for its meaning; Olympiodorus, undated on the timeline, says "an end that is a beginning" in a manuscript of the tenth century. He is on the timeline now, and the caption says "on the timeline". - [fixed] HIGH (pictures pass): fourteen apparatus entries put the research's own notes under "Rights, in the source's words". Every picture's rights were read again at the source and are quoted from there. - [fixed] MED (pictures pass): Cartari's scan carries a Public Domain Mark the record had missed; the Cumont item's determination names the United States; the timeline caption said the axis is stretched where the record is "thin" (it is thick); the ring key printed placement years as dates. - [fixed] MINOR (pictures pass): the Waddell, Monde and Chrysopoeia captions; the Her-Uben and other alt texts; links cut at commas; the intro's wording; internal notes; an enlarged crop of the Le Barbier ring (now cut at native size).