---
slug: the-plant-that-stopped-flinching
passed: 2026-10-14
by: the assay line (research/assay-line/cited-1014b/), Codex fixer directed by claude-assaying-boyle-1014; source record by Codex, checked by Codex and a Claude agent
checked: 212
confirmed: 179 # includes 8 MINOR lines
wrong: 33
unverifiable: 0
observed: 0
stale: 0
---
This was the directed 2026-10-14 remediation pass on the 42-item triage in `research/assay-line/cited-1014b/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/triage.json`, against layer files verified identical to read revision `d1d7401ad4` before editing. The fixer reread the evidence for every triage item, fixed 33 WRONG items spanning ten errors within this layer, retained seven listed MINOR items, and rejected two findings with evidence. Each triage item has its own claim line below. The remaining CONFIRMED entries carry the earlier checkers' source reads from N1-sources.json, N2-codex.md and N2-claude.md, once per source-record entry; repaired copies are explicitly restated after correction rather than carrying forward false wording. Ten dated correction lines appear on the page and at the end of the markdown body. V1 records one additional MINOR verifier repair required by the instruction to correct false assertions; it adds no page line and does not resolve or edit K4's listed page sentence. MINOR lines count with confirmed for the gate, without changing their verdicts.
The 2026-10-14 repair review confirmed three remaining problems in copies outside this layer. Eight WRONG findings (X9, X10, X11, X18, X19, X22, X23 and K7) now carry open board notes, while retaining their completed local corrections. Claim counts are unchanged: 171 CONFIRMED + 8 MINOR + 33 WRONG = 212; findings comprise 26 fixed (25 WRONG and V1), 7 declined MINOR and 8 open WRONG.
## Claims
- MINOR | X1: "That second fact got retold, and retold, until "a leaf that stopped flinching" became "a plant that remembers."" | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X1 (body-1-3). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Sci.News supplies one headline, not a history of successive retellings, and learning/memory were already the original researchers' interpretation. This is loose narrative provenance, not a disproof of decrement or retention. The separate sentence is unchanged.
- WRONG | X2: "Cross-section of a Mimosa leaf hinge (pulvinus). An action potential travels along the petiole from the touch point to the hinge; the lower extensor motor cells lose their potassium and water and deflate while the upper flexor cells stay swollen, so the leaflet swings downward and folds." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X2 (body-5). Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- MINOR | X3: "= the turgor the extensor cell loses" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X3 (body-11). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The equality wording is compressed, but the page explicitly calls the calculation an ideal-dilute, isolated-solute estimate rather than a measured turgor trace. The review supports the turgor-loss model; neither the declared model nor its arithmetic is contradicted. The sentence is unchanged.
- WRONG | X4: "The turgor imbalance across the hinge swings the leaflet down. No nerve, no muscle" ... "a hydraulic collapse." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X4 (body-21). Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- MINOR | X5: "The turgor the cell loses is just the osmotic pressure of the ions that walked out the door." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X5 (body-23-30). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The equality wording is compressed, but the page explicitly calls the calculation an ideal-dilute, isolated-solute estimate rather than a measured turgor trace. The review supports the turgor-loss model; neither the declared model nor its arithmetic is contradicted. The sentence is unchanged.
- WRONG | X6: "The macro-chain" ... "mechanical stimulus → receptor potential → propagating action potential → voltage-gated K⁺/Cl⁻ efflux → osmotic water loss → extensor turgor collapse → fold" ... "is the consensus mechanism, laid out in the 2020 Plants review with the explicit "no nerves or muscles."" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X6 (body-28-38). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X7: "the explicit "no nerves or muscles."" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X7 (review-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X8: "Biegler concedes the point squarely: the finding that plants in low-light (energy-poor) conditions stopped folding faster is hard to pin on simple fatigue" ... "an energy-starved plant should tire more slowly, if anything." | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | X8 (body-36-60). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- WRONG | X9: "There are three separate claims in this story, of three completely different strengths" ... "and popular coverage quietly welds them into one triumphant headline." | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X9 (body-39-64). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- WRONG | X10: "Real pop-science coverage runs like this" ... "and every word of it fuses two different experiments on two different plants into one animal-shaped story:" | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X10 (body-40). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- WRONG | X11: ""Mimosa plants have long-term memory and can learn, biologists say" ... "trained like Pavlov's dogs, they remember for a month."" | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X11 (composite-headline). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- WRONG | X12: "Suggestive, not decisive on its own." | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | X12 (scorecard-3-biegler). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 33: he lists characteristic 3 among omitted tests. Replaced the invented suggestive/not-decisive assessment in his scorecard cell; the separately listed potentiation tag remains unchanged.
- WRONG | X13: "CONCEDES: this one resists a pure-fatigue story" ... "an energy-starved plant should tire more slowly, not faster." | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | X13 (scorecard-5-biegler). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- MINOR | X14: "The decrement should be SPECIFIC to the trained stimulus" ... "a genuinely different stimulus should still get a full response. This is one of the two tests that separate learning from a tired hinge." | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | X14 (scorecard-7-requires). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Rankin 2009 characteristic 7 asks for some stimulus specificity and comparison of decrements; it does not demand a full novel-stimulus response. The essential comparison remains, making this a precision overstatement. The requirement sentence is unchanged.
- WRONG | X15: "This is textbook plant electrophysiology. The macro-chain" ... "receptor potential → action potential → voltage-gated K⁺/Cl⁻ efflux → osmotic water loss → extensor turgor collapse → fold" ... "is the consensus mechanism, with the explicit “no nerves or muscles.” The one honest caveat is molecular: the exact primary mechanoreceptor and some channel identities are still active research." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X15 (ledger-mechanism). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X16: "with the explicit “no nerves or muscles.”" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X16 (ledger-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X17: "the full mechanism, review, explicit “no nerves or muscles”" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X17 (ledger-1-note-1). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X18: "A larger independent study could not reproduce it: no significant effect on the key comparison (n≈203, p=0.387)." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | X18 (ledger-pea-replication). Reread Markel 2020, Results and discussion before Figure 3: p=0.387 uses n=42+40=82. The four main groups total 61+60+42+40=203. Separated those denominators in this layer's active copies and recomputed both totals in the verifier and its published mirror. The Anatomy of Error card still conflates those counts and equates nonsignificance with no effect; see the open finding below.
- WRONG | X19: "When popular coverage says Mimosa was “trained like Pavlov’s dogs,” it has silently imported this pea result" ... "which failed." | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X19 (ledger-popular-conflation). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- WRONG | X20: "review with the full chain and explicit "no nerves or muscles":" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X20 (footer-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X21: "the full mechanism, review, explicit “no nerves or muscles”" | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | X21 (ledger-source-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | X22: "'Habituation' becomes 'memory,' and a Mimosa result gets welded to a different species' Pavlovian claim, until the fused headline feels true precisely because it has been repeated so often." | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | X22 (related-fused-headline). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- WRONG | X23: "Both pages keep the rebuttal and the reply on the same page and refuse to let a tidy story outrun its evidence." | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/who-discovered-the-expanding-universe/index.html | X23 (related-page-description-1). Reread the linked universe page main content and sources: it compares discovery evidence from multiple sources and has no paired rebuttal and reply. Corrected this layer's authored related note and its nearby rendered copy only.
- WRONG | X24: (added) ""Stimulus-intensity effect" is shown as "claimed met"." | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | X24 (added-intensity-status). Reread Gagliano 2014, Methods p. 65, and Biegler 2018, p. 33: the drop height was fixed at 15 cm; light manipulates energy reserves. Changed the intensity tag to not tested and distinguished the light treatment.
- WRONG | X25: (added) ""Frequency effect" is shown as "not tested"." | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | X25 (added-frequency-status). Reread Gagliano 2014, p. 65 and Figure 2 caption p. 67: 5- and 10-second intervals were compared, with an interval effect in low light (P<0.0001), but not high light (P=0.5). The row now says tested in part, without claiming the complete frequency criterion was established.
- MINOR | X26: (added) ""Potentiation of habituation" is shown as "claimed met"." | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | X26 (added-potentiation-status). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Gagliano 2014 p. 67 reports earlier reopening on retest, giving the retraining/savings claim a source, but not a systematic series of progressively faster train-rest cycles. The tag says claimed met rather than demonstrated; it is separate from the corrected Biegler cell and remains unchanged.
- MINOR | K1: The fold is settled physics you can compute. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K1 (body-2-4). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The review supports a consensus macroscopic electrical/osmotic model while retaining unresolved mechanisms. Settled is too categorical, but the page states idealisation and molecular caveats; the limited model is not thereby false. The lede sentence is unchanged.
- WRONG | K2: Cross-section of a Mimosa leaf hinge (pulvinus). An action potential travels along the petiole from the touch point to the hinge; the lower extensor motor cells lose their potassium and water and deflate while the upper flexor cells stay swollen, so the leaflet swings downward and folds. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K2 (body-5). Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- WRONG | K3: The turgor imbalance across the hinge swings the leaflet down. No nerve, no muscle - a hydraulic collapse. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K3 (body-21). Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- MINOR | K4: the verifier range-checks them against the primary reports and recomputes everything else. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | K4 (body-27-36). Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The verifier tests fixed anchors and encoded values; that does not establish the page's claimed source validation or recomputation of everything. The page sentence remains unchanged. The separate V1 finding corrects the verifier's numerical span assertions under the instruction to fix false verifier assertions; it does not resolve this scope overclaim.
- WRONG | K5: the explicit "no nerves or muscles." | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K5 (review-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | K6: Biegler concedes the point squarely: the finding that plants in low-light (energy-poor) conditions stopped folding faster is hard to pin on simple fatigue - an energy-starved plant should tire more slowly, if anything. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | K6 (body-36-60). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- WRONG | K7: "Mimosa plants have long-term memory and can learn, biologists say - trained like Pavlov's dogs, they remember for a month." | https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | K7 (composite-headline). Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from its introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate.
- CONFIRMED | K8: He concedes the light-environment effect resists a pure-fatigue account. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | K8 (body-48-83). REJECTED with evidence. Biegler's abstract leaves some data difficult for fatigue, and p. 35 identifies the 28-day light-swap result as potentially conflicting with exhaustion. His ceiling-effect suggestion is not a demonstrated resolution. This general reservation is defensible and remains unchanged; the false faster-low-light example is corrected separately.
- WRONG | K9: Suggestive, not decisive on its own. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | K9 (scorecard-3-biegler). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 33: he lists characteristic 3 among omitted tests. Replaced the invented suggestive/not-decisive assessment in his scorecard cell; the separately listed potentiation tag remains unchanged.
- WRONG | K10: CONCEDES: this one resists a pure-fatigue story - an energy-starved plant should tire more slowly, not faster. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | K10 (scorecard-5-biegler). Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- WRONG | K11: Not demonstrated in the 2014 study. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | K11 (scorecard-8-gagliano). Reread Gagliano 2014, Results p. 66, and Biegler 2018, pp. 33–34: the original authors called restored closure to shaking dishabituation; Biegler disputed that interpretation. Restored their claim in their column and retained his objection in his column.
- WRONG | K12: with the explicit “no nerves or muscles.” | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K12 (ledger-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- CONFIRMED | K13: A DIFFERENT plant - garden pea - can be Pavlovian-conditioned: learn that a breeze predicts light and grow toward the breeze. | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | K13 (ledger-3-title). REJECTED with evidence. Gagliano 2016, Results with Figure 2, reports 62% of the F+L group growing toward the fan; the F-vs-L group growing away does not falsify that reported result. In the page's failed-replication context, the summary does not claim that every treatment grew toward the fan. It remains unchanged.
- WRONG | K14: review with the full chain and explicit "no nerves or muscles": | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K14 (footer-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | K15: the full mechanism, review, explicit “no nerves or muscles” | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | K15 (ledger-source-no-nerves-quote). Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- WRONG | K16: (added) Scorecard: the row "Stimulus-intensity effect" carries the green tag "claimed met" | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf p.65; https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf p.33 | K16 (added intensity status). Reread Gagliano 2014, Methods p. 65, and Biegler 2018, p. 33: the drop height was fixed at 15 cm; light manipulates energy reserves. Changed the intensity tag to not tested and distinguished the light treatment.
- CONFIRMED | body-1-0: Brush a Mimosa pudica and it folds shut in a second - no nerves, no muscles, no brain. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-1-0: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals"; the additional physical paper says "can fold in about 1 s after reception of an external stimulus". Both parts are supported. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-1-1: A real electrical spike does it. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-1-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Mechanical stimulation generates receptor potential in the mechanoreceptor cells and the following action potential in the motor cells.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-1-2: Keep pestering the same plant with a harmless jolt and it stops bothering to fold. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-1-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "leaves were not only completely open by the end of a train but also stopped closing altogether.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-2-5: The memory is a live scientific argument with a rebuttal and a reply still on the table | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf; https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-2-5: Biegler concludes "The status of habituation in Mimosa remains uncertain.". The paired response is Gagliano, Abramson and Depczynski, "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it". Both are displayed in the pinned page. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-2-6: a claim that plants can be trained like Pavlov's dogs, that failed when someone larger tried to repeat it. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-2-6: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "This replication attempt used a larger sample size and fully blinded analysis.". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-4-8: A receptor potential at the contact point crosses a threshold and triggers a genuine action potential - the same kind of all-or-nothing electrical event a neuron fires, here running through ordinary plant tissue. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-4-8: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "These properties include the all-or-none law, threshold potentials and refractory periods.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-4-9: It travels down the leaf and reaches a swollen hinge at the base of each leaflet and each leaf: the pulvinus. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-4-9: The review places pulvini at "the junction of the leaflet-rachilla, rachilla-petiole, and petiole-stem" and describes propagation to the motor organ. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-4-10: When the spike arrives, the hinge lets go. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-4-10: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Mechanical stimulation generates receptor potential in the mechanoreceptor cells and the following action potential in the motor cells.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-12: How far the spike must travel down the petiole to reach the motor hinge. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-12: The review places pulvini at "the junction of the leaflet-rachilla, rachilla-petiole, and petiole-stem" and describes propagation to the motor organ. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-13: Measured at 2–3 cm/s (Fromm & Lautner 2007; Volkov 2010) - slow for a nerve, fast for a plant. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-13: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-14: K⁺ and Cl⁻ flood out through voltage-gated channels; water follows. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-14: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The electrolytes are transferred through voltage-dependent K + and Cl − channels, which are activated by the action potential.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-15: A fixed measured value (~150 mV, ~5 s wide) - shown here, not tunable, because it's a fact not a knob. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-15: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-16: The touch depolarises the membrane at the contact point past a threshold. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-16: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "generate a receptor potential in response to mechanical stimulation". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-17: An all-or-nothing ~150 mV spike, ~5 s wide, propagates at 2–3 cm/s toward the pulvinus. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-17: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-18: Arrival at the hinge throws open K⁺ and Cl⁻ channels in the extensor motor cells. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-18: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The electrolytes are transferred through voltage-dependent K + and Cl − channels, which are activated by the action potential.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-19: K⁺ and Cl⁻ pour out of the cell into the wall space, dragging the cell's osmotic pressure down. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-19: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "water efflux osmotically driven by K + migration results in the turgor loss of the pulvinus". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-20: Water leaves osmotically; the extensor cells go slack while the upper flexor cells stay firm. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-20: The source reports "a redistribution of water from the extensor to the flexor half in the primary pulvinus after movement". The page explicitly declares its drawing of a fixed flexor to be an idealisation. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-22-26: The plant has no muscle to contract and no nerve in the animal sense; it moves by letting go of water pressure on one side of a hinge. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-22-26: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-22-27: The electrical spike is the trigger, potassium is the currency, and osmosis is the engine. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-22-27: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The electrolytes are transferred through voltage-dependent K + and Cl − channels, which are activated by the action potential.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-27-34: A motor cell's resting turgor is of order 0.5–1.0 MPa, so dumping the osmotic pull of ~100 mM KCl is enough to slacken it - the arithmetic and the collapse line up. | https://liphy-annuaire.univ-grenoble-alpes.fr/pages_personnelles/marc_joyeux/reprints/073.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-27-34: The physical paper says osmotic pressure "may reach 1 MPa". The 0.50 MPa isolated-solute result is of that order. This supports an order-of-magnitude illustration, not a measured 0.5–1.0 MPa resting-pressure interval for these particular plants. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-27-35: The 150 mV / ~5 s / 2–3 cm/s spike figures are measurements, not things you can derive from a desk; | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-27-35: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-28-40: The action potential is a real, membrane-based, all-or-nothing event; calling it "electrical signalling" is not a metaphor. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-28-40: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "These properties include the all-or-none law, threshold potentials and refractory periods.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-29-42: Real pulvini have both extensor and flexor populations whose antagonism sets the resting angle; | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-29-42: The source reports "a redistribution of water from the extensor to the flexor half in the primary pulvinus after movement". The page explicitly declares its drawing of a fixed flexor to be an idealisation. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-30-45: The exact primary mechanoreceptor - what physically senses the touch - and the precise identity of some channels are active research (mechanosensitive-channel work, e.g. 2021 Plant Physiology). | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8566232/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-30-45: "the pulvinule, which expresses a stretch-activated chloride-permeable mechanosensitive ion channel". The 2021 paper establishes channel activity and pharmacology, not a named Mimosa touch-sensor gene; current literature searches find the same open molecular question. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-30-46: "A channel opens" is safe; "this named gene is the touch sensor" is not yet. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8566232/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-30-46: "the pulvinule, which expresses a stretch-activated chloride-permeable mechanosensitive ion channel". The 2021 paper establishes channel activity and pharmacology, not a named Mimosa touch-sensor gene; current literature searches find the same open molecular question. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-30-47: The 2–3 cm/s and ~150 mV figures also vary by tissue (leaflet pinna vs. main pulvinus) and method; they are the primary measurements, not a universal constant. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-30-47: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-32-48: Drop a potted Mimosa a short, harmless distance and it folds. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-32-48: Methods specify "a 15-cm fall or drop", using a guided vessel and foam landing base; the recorded 60-drop excerpt alone omits that detail. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-32-49: After a while it stops folding - it has apparently decided this particular jolt is nothing to worry about, while still snapping shut if you genuinely threaten it. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-32-49: The full Results report "the habituated response returned to original baseline levels when the novel stimulus" was applied. The record excerpt describes the shake procedure; the result is confirmed in the full paper, while its interpretation remains disputed. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-32-50: In 2014, Monica Gagliano and colleagues reported exactly this, and that the plants stayed uninterested for up to ~28 days (Oecologia 175:63–72). | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-32-50: The paper reports "the habituated response of LL plants first re-tested after being held undisturbed for 28 days", after transfer to high light. It is a reported result, not an independent confirmation of learning; the page labels it contested. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-33-51: What Gagliano claimed is habituation - the simplest recognised form of non-associative learning | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: body-33-51: Rankin defines habituation as a response decrement excluding adaptation and fatigue; Gagliano's paper explicitly calls its reported behavior habituation. The discussion is about non-associative learning, not classical conditioning. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-33-52: and habituation is such a low bar that even brainless single cells clear it. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: body-33-52: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-33-53: The protist Stentor stops contracting to a repeated poke. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: body-33-53: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-33-54: "It has no brain" refutes nothing, because habituation never required one. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: body-33-54: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-34-55: So the real question is narrow and technical, and it is genuinely unsettled: is the decline Gagliano saw actually habituation, or is it motor fatigue? | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-34-55: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-34-56: A tired hinge and a habituated one both stop responding. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: body-34-56: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "does not involve sensory adaptation/sensory fatigue or motor fatigue". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-34-57: Learning theory has a standard toolkit for telling them apart - the Thompson & Spencer (1966) criteria. | https://www.cns.nyu.edu/~david/courses/perceptionGrad/Readings/ThompsonSpencer-PsychRev1966.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-34-57: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "the same 9 parametric relations for stimulus and training variables". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-34-58: Two of them do the decisive work. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: body-34-58: Rankin lists dishabituation and stimulus specificity, and also frequency-dependent spontaneous recovery. The two highlighted here are the two tests at issue in Biegler's critique, not an exhaustive list of every possible discriminator. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-35: Of the two criteria that separate a learning brain-free system from a merely tired one, dishabituation - where a sudden strong, novel stimulus should snap the response back - was never demonstrated, and the control that would nail down stimulus specificity was, Biegler argues, not adequately run. Without those two, most of the 2014 data are equally consistent with a hinge that simply ran low on the water pressure to keep folding. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-35: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-36-61: Gagliano's 2018 reply - "Plants learn and remember: let's get used to it" | https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-36-61: The reply exists with the printed title "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it", by Monica Gagliano, Charles I. Abramson and Martial Depczynski, DOI 10.1007/s00442-017-4029-7; 2018 issue, online acceptance/copyright in 2017. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-37-62: Habituation is a low bar even a brainless cell can clear. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: body-37-62: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-37-63: The open question isn't whether a plant could learn this way - it's whether this decline, in this experiment, is learning or a tired hinge. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-37-63: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-39-65: Worse, two of them are about different species. | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: body-39-65: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Here we show that this type of learning occurs in the garden pea, Pisum sativum.". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-42-69: The month-long result traces to the 2014 Mimosa habituation study. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | After the X11/K7 headline repair, the month-long phrase is a description of the study rather than part of a fabricated quotation. The 28-day test is in Methods and Results. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | body-42-70: Real experiment, but contested (Biegler's rebuttal, Gagliano's reply, no independent replication) | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-42-70: Visually checked the cited review's Table 2, p. 58: the 2014 Mimosa row has "Habituation", "Positive", "No" in the skill/result/replication columns. The adjacent 2016 row names "Markel (2020)" as its replication, a positive control. Gagliano 2014 supplies the 28-day detail; Biegler and the reply establish the dispute. Current targeted searches found the original and critical literature, not an independent repetition of that 28-day result. The review table alone is dated evidence, not an exhaustive 2026 registry. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-42-71: and it's retention tested to ~28 days, not "memory" in any rich sense. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-42-71: The paper reports "the habituated response of LL plants first re-tested after being held undisturbed for 28 days", after transfer to high light. It is a reported result, not an independent confirmation of learning; the page labels it contested. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-43: The separate 2016 pea associative-learning claim failed to replicate in a larger study; it is not part of the January 2014 Sci.News headline. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML; https://www.sci.news/biology/science-mimosa-plants-memory-01695.html | After the shared headline repair. Markel reports the failed replication; the complete Sci.News article covers Mimosa and contains no pea experiment. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | body-44: Learning and memory are the researchers' interpretation of the Mimosa response decrement; the dispute is habituation versus fatigue. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf; https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | After the shared headline repair. The original Results interpret the decrement as habituation; Biegler disputes that interpretation. The earlier checker confirmation is superseded for the removed promotion-to-intelligence wording. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | body-46-75: The 2014 habituation work is Mimosa pudica. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-46-75: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "leaves were not only completely open by the end of a train but also stopped closing altogether.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-46-76: The 2016 associative-learning work is Pisum sativum - garden pea. | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: body-46-76: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Here we show that this type of learning occurs in the garden pea, Pisum sativum.". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-46-77: They are different organisms, different experiments, and different strengths of claim. | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: body-46-77: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Here we show that this type of learning occurs in the garden pea, Pisum sativum.". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-47-78: Habituation is a textbook form of non-associative learning that aneural cells demonstrably show; nothing here rules out a plant habituating. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: body-47-78: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-47-79: this particular 2014 dataset lacks the two tests that would separate its decline from motor fatigue, | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-47-79: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-47-80: and the one associative-learning result that did claim Pavlovian conditioning failed independent replication. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: body-47-80: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "This replication attempt used a larger sample size and fully blinded analysis.". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-48-81: Three prongs: (1) no demonstrated dishabituation; (2) the experimental condition needed to establish stimulus specificity was missing; (3) motor fatigue adequately explains most - his word - of the data. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-48-81: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-48-82: most - his word - of the data. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-48-82: Biegler's abstract literally says "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The word "most" is quoted correctly. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-48-84: Caricaturing him as "it's all just fatigue" is not what he wrote. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: body-48-84: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-fromm: Fromm & Lautner, "Electrical signals and their physiological significance in plants," Plant, Cell & Environment 30:249–257 (2007) | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-fromm: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Fromm J. & Lautner S. (2007) Electrical signals and their physiological significance in plants. Plant, Cell & Environment 30, 249–257.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-volkov: Volkov et al., "Signal transduction in Mimosa pudica: biologically closed electrical circuits," Plant, Cell & Environment 33:816–827 (2010) | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-volkov: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Signal transduction in Mimosa pudica: biologically closed electrical circuits". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-review: "Mechanical Signaling in the Sensitive Plant Mimosa pudica L.," Plants 9(5):587 (2020) | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: citation-review: Publisher metadata gives "Mechanical Signaling in the Sensitive Plant Mimosa pudica L.", Plants 9(5), article 587, 2020, DOI 10.3390/plants9050587. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-gagliano: Gagliano, Renton, Depczynski & Mancuso, "Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower…," Oecologia 175:63–72 (2014) | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-gagliano: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower in environments where it matters". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-biegler: Biegler, "Insufficient evidence for habituation in Mimosa pudica. Response to Gagliano et al. (2014)," Oecologia (2018) | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-biegler: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Oecologia (2018) 186:33–35". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-reply: Gagliano et al., "Plants learn and remember: let's get used to it," Oecologia (2018). | https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-reply: The reply exists with the printed title "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it", by Monica Gagliano, Charles I. Abramson and Martial Depczynski, DOI 10.1007/s00442-017-4029-7; 2018 issue, online acceptance/copyright in 2017. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-thompson: Thompson & Spencer, "Habituation: a model phenomenon…," Psychological Review 73:16–43 (1966) | https://www.cns.nyu.edu/~david/courses/perceptionGrad/Readings/ThompsonSpencer-PsychRev1966.pdf | N2-codex.md: citation-thompson: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "the same 9 parametric relations for stimulus and training variables". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-rankin: Rankin et al., "Habituation revisited," Neurobiology of Learning and Memory 92:135–138 (2009). | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: citation-rankin: The article has "Issue date 2009 Sep." and volume 92(2), pages 135–138. Its 2008 online-publication date does not make the page's 2009 issue citation wrong. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-pea: Gagliano et al., "Learning by association in plants," Scientific Reports 6:38427 (2016) | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: citation-pea: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Learning by Association in Plants. Sci. Rep. 6, 38427". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | citation-markel: Markel, "Lack of evidence for associative learning in pea plants," eLife 9:e57614 (2020) | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: citation-markel: Publisher metadata gives Kasey Markel, "Lack of evidence for associative learning in pea plants", eLife 9:e57614, 2020, DOI 10.7554/eLife.57614. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-1-requires: Repeated stimulation makes the response progressively weaker - usually a negative-exponential decline. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-1-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The decrease is usually a negative exponential function of the number of stimulus presentations.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-1-gagliano: Seen: leaves stopped folding over repeated drops. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-1-gagliano: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "leaves were not only completely open by the end of a train but also stopped closing altogether.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-1-biegler: Agreed it happened - but this alone can’t tell habituation from fatigue; both look like this. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-1-biegler: Biegler writes "Gagliano et al.’s data clearly show that response decrement", then explains why resource exhaustion must be excluded. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-2-requires: After a rest, the response comes back. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-2-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "the response recovers at least partially over the observation time". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-2-gagliano: Partial recovery after rest; the decrement held up to ~28 days in low-light plants. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-2-gagliano: The Results show partial recovery after six days in high light, and 28-day retention in plants initially trained in low light and then transferred to high light. "Low-light plants" must be read as the training cohort, not unchanged lighting throughout. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-2-biegler: A tired hinge also recovers after rest, so recovery per se doesn’t decide it. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-2-biegler: Biegler recognizes "spontaneous recovery of the response over time, here 6 days", and still requires distinguishing learning from resource exhaustion. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-3-requires: Repeated train–rest cycles make each subsequent decline faster/deeper. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-3-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "the response decrement becomes successively more rapid and/or more pronounced". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-3-gagliano: Re-training went faster, consistent with retained learning. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-3-gagliano: The original paper reports plants that "reopened them following just two to three drops", compared with four to six initially. The claim is supported by that Results paragraph; the record instead cites Biegler's statement that characteristics 3–6 were omitted. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-4-requires: More frequent stimulation produces faster/greater habituation. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-4-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "more frequent stimulation results in more rapid and/or more pronounced response decrement". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-4-gagliano: Compared 5- and 10-second intervals between drops: an interval effect in low light (P<0.0001), but not high light (P=0.5). | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | After X25: Methods p. 65 and Figure 2 caption p. 67 supply both intervals and P values. No direction or complete criterion is inferred from that caption. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-5-requires: A weaker stimulus should produce more habituation than a strong one. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-5-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Within a stimulus modality, the less intense the stimulus, the more rapid and/or more pronounced the behavioral response decrement.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-5-gagliano: Drop height was fixed at 15 cm. Low light changed the energetic environment, not the drop intensity. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf; https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | After X24/K16: Methods p. 65 supplies the standard drop; Biegler p. 33 distinguishes light manipulation from the criteria. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-6-requires: Stimulation continued past the point of no response still affects later recovery. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-6-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "This effect of stimulation beyond asymptotic levels can alter subsequent behavior". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-6-gagliano: Not tested. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-6-gagliano: Biegler says testing omitted "characteristics 3–6" and "characteristics 9 and 10". The full original paper provides the positive controls of actual training, shake, and retention tests. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-7-gagliano: Claimed the plants still folded to a mechanically different stimulus (shaking vs. dropping). | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-7-gagliano: The full Results report "the habituated response returned to original baseline levels when the novel stimulus" was applied. The record excerpt describes the shake procedure; the result is confirmed in the full paper, while its interpretation remains disputed. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-7-biegler: The experimental condition needed to ESTABLISH specificity was missing/inadequate - so the claim isn’t nailed down. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-7-biegler: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "They could have tested that possibility by counterbalancing which stimulus was the habituating stimulus and which the dishabituating stimulus". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-8-requires: A sudden strong, novel stimulus should RESTORE the habituated response. This is the classic test that rules OUT fatigue - a tired hinge can’t be snapped back on by novelty. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-8-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Presentation of a different stimulus results in an increase of the decremented response to the original stimulus.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-8-biegler: ABSENCE of demonstrated dishabituation is the core gap - without it, fatigue is not excluded. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-8-biegler: Biegler reads the post-shake response to the original drop, rather than response to the shake, and concludes "an absence of dishabituation". These lines use that interpretation; Gagliano's disagreement is separately linked. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-9-requires: The dishabituation response itself should wane with repetition. | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/ | N2-codex.md: scorecard-9-requires: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Upon repeated application of the dishabituating stimulus, the amount of dishabituation produced decreases". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | scorecard-9-gagliano: Not tested. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: scorecard-9-gagliano: Biegler says testing omitted "characteristics 3–6" and "characteristics 9 and 10". The full original paper provides the positive controls of actual training, shake, and retention tests. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-1-title: The fold is a real action potential opening K⁺/Cl⁻ channels, and water follows osmotically until turgor collapses. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: ledger-1-title: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The electrolytes are transferred through voltage-dependent K + and Cl − channels, which are activated by the action potential.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-1-cite-1: Plants 9(5):587 (2020) | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: ledger-1-cite-1: Publisher metadata gives "Mechanical Signaling in the Sensitive Plant Mimosa pudica L.", Plants 9(5), article 587, 2020, DOI 10.3390/plants9050587. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-1-cite-2: Fromm & Lautner (2007); Volkov (2010) | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-1-cite-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-1-note-2: the AP: ~150 mV, ~5 s, 2–3 cm/s (measured, tissue-dependent) | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-1-note-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-title: The same plant, drop-trained, stops folding to a harmless jolt and stays uninterested for weeks - i.e. it habituates. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-title: The paper reports "the habituated response of LL plants first re-tested after being held undisturbed for 28 days", after transfer to high light. It is a reported result, not an independent confirmation of learning; the page labels it contested. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-habituation-study: ONE study reports this (retention tested TO ~28 days, not “forever”), it drew a formal rebuttal, and the author replied - all three are on the record and it has not been independently replicated. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-habituation-study: Visually checked the cited review's Table 2, p. 58: the 2014 Mimosa row has "Habituation", "Positive", "No" in the skill/result/replication columns. The adjacent 2016 row names "Markel (2020)" as its replication, a positive control. Gagliano 2014 supplies the 28-day detail; Biegler and the reply establish the dispute. Current targeted searches found the original and critical literature, not an independent repetition of that 28-day result. The review table alone is dated evidence, not an exhaustive 2026 registry. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-stentor: Habituation itself is a low bar (even aneural Stentor clears it) | https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6569516/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=PMC6569516&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: ledger-stentor: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "The contractile protozoan Stentor coeruleus habituates during repetition of the mechanical stimulus used to elicit the initial contractions.". The PMC page returned a challenge and fullTextXML returned HTTP 500; Europe PMC's exact PMCID metadata supplied the matching original abstract. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-dispute: the dispute is narrowly whether THIS decline is habituation or motor fatigue, which turns on the two missing tests above. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-dispute: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-cite-1: Gagliano et al., Oecologia 175:63–72 (2014) | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-cite-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower in environments where it matters". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-note-1: the habituation + ~28-day retention claim | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-note-1: The paper reports "the habituated response of LL plants first re-tested after being held undisturbed for 28 days", after transfer to high light. It is a reported result, not an independent confirmation of learning; the page labels it contested. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-cite-2: Biegler, Oecologia (2018) | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-cite-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Oecologia (2018) 186:33–35". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-note-2: rebuttal: no dishabituation, specificity unestablished, fatigue explains most | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-note-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-cite-3: Gagliano et al., Oecologia (2018) | https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-cite-3: The reply exists with the printed title "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it", by Monica Gagliano, Charles I. Abramson and Martial Depczynski, DOI 10.1007/s00442-017-4029-7; 2018 issue, online acceptance/copyright in 2017. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-2-note-3: reply: “Plants learn and remember: let’s get used to it” | https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-2-note-3: The reply exists with the printed title "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it", by Monica Gagliano, Charles I. Abramson and Martial Depczynski, DOI 10.1007/s00442-017-4029-7; 2018 issue, online acceptance/copyright in 2017. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-pea-distinct: This is a much STRONGER claim (associative learning, not mere habituation) and a DIFFERENT SPECIES - it has nothing to do with Mimosa. | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: ledger-pea-distinct: Gagliano 2016 explicitly uses "the garden pea, Pisum sativum" and a fan/light classical-conditioning paradigm. Growth followed the trained light-predicting relation, including the opposite-fan condition; the page describes one of those conditions and labels the claim as failing replication. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-3-cite-1: Gagliano et al., Scientific Reports 6:38427 (2016) | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: ledger-3-cite-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Learning by Association in Plants. Sci. Rep. 6, 38427". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-3-note-1: the original pea associative-learning claim | https://www.nature.com/articles/srep38427 | N2-codex.md: ledger-3-note-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Learning by Association in Plants. Sci. Rep. 6, 38427". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-3-cite-2: Markel, eLife 9:e57614 (2020) | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: ledger-3-cite-2: Publisher metadata gives Kasey Markel, "Lack of evidence for associative learning in pea plants", eLife 9:e57614, 2020, DOI 10.7554/eLife.57614. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-3-note-2: Markel: 203 across four main groups; F vs L comparison n=82, p=0.387, not significant. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | After X18: Results before Figure 3 gives 61+60 and 42+40 for separate comparisons. The latter comparison has p=0.387. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | meta-description-0: Touch a Mimosa pudica and it folds in a second, with no nerves and no muscles. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: meta-description-0: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals"; the additional physical paper says "can fold in about 1 s after reception of an external stimulus". Both parts are supported. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-description-1: A real 150 mV electrical spike races down the leaf at 2–3 cm/s, throws open potassium channels, and water drains out of the cells until they go soft. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: meta-description-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-description-3: Then meet the harder question: when the plant stops folding to a harmless jolt, is that memory, or just a tired hinge? | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: meta-description-3: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-description-4: See exactly where the evidence for 'plants learn' reaches, and where it stops, with the rebuttal and the reply both on the page. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf; https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf | N2-codex.md: meta-description-4: Biegler concludes "The status of habituation in Mimosa remains uncertain.". The paired response is Gagliano, Abramson and Depczynski, "Plants learn and remember: lets get used to it". Both are displayed in the pinned page. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-og-description-0: A Mimosa leaf folds with no nerves and no muscles: a real 150 mV spike dumping potassium until the cell goes soft. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: meta-og-description-0: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-og-description-2: Then see exactly where 'habituation' ends and the borrowed word 'memory' begins. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: meta-og-description-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-twitter-description-0: A leaf folds with no nerves, no muscles: a 150 mV spike dumping potassium until the cell goes soft. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: meta-twitter-description-0: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | meta-twitter-description-2: Then watch where 'habituation' ends and 'memory' begins. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: meta-twitter-description-2: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-0: Brush a Mimosa pudica and it folds shut in a second, with no nerves, no muscles, no brain. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: frontmatter-dek-0: "plants do not possess the nerves and muscles that facilitate movement in most animals"; the additional physical paper says "can fold in about 1 s after reception of an external stimulus". Both parts are supported. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-1: A real ~150 mV action potential races down the leaf at 2–3 cm/s, throws open potassium channels in the hinge, and water drains out of the motor cells until they go slack. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | N2-codex.md: frontmatter-dek-1: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "an amplitude of 150 mV, a 5 s duration time and a speed of 2–3 cm s–1". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-3: Then the harder question: keep pestering the plant with a harmless jolt and it stops folding. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: frontmatter-dek-3: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "leaves were not only completely open by the end of a train but also stopped closing altogether.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-5: Walk to the live edge of the argument, with the Thompson–Spencer criteria as a scorecard, Biegler's three-pronged rebuttal, Gagliano's reply, and (kept strictly separate) the failed replication of the different, stronger 'peas learn like Pavlov's dogs' claim, all on one page. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf; https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf; https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf; https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: frontmatter-dek-5: Read the 2014 original, the Biegler rebuttal, the 2018 reply, the habituation criteria, and Markel's separate pea replication. Markel explicitly says "This replication attempt used a larger sample size and fully blinded analysis."; the page keeps the two species distinct. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | structured-description-0: A Mimosa pudica leaf folds in a second with no nerves and no muscles: a genuine ~150 mV action potential, propagating at 2–3 cm/s, opens voltage-gated K+/Cl- channels in the pulvinus, water follows the ions out osmotically, and the motor cells collapse. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7284940/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: structured-description-0: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Mechanical stimulation generates receptor potential in the mechanoreceptor cells and the following action potential in the motor cells.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | structured-description-2: Then the harder question - when the plant stops folding to a harmless jolt, is that habituation or a tired hinge - walked to its live edge with Gagliano 2014, Biegler's 2018 rebuttal, Gagliano's reply, and the failed pea-learning replication (Markel 2020) all on the page. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf; https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf; https://r.jordan.im/download/plants/gagliano2018.pdf; https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2754195/; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7311169/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: structured-description-2: Read the 2014 original, the Biegler rebuttal, the 2018 reply, the habituation criteria, and Markel's separate pea replication. Markel explicitly says "This replication attempt used a larger sample size and fully blinded analysis."; the page keeps the two species distinct. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | world-osmosis-relation: Osmotic pressure is the van 't Hoff relation Π = i·c·R·T | https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/11-4-colligative-properties | N2-codex.md: world-osmosis-relation: OpenStax gives the dilute-solution osmotic-pressure equation and defines the van't Hoff factor as "the ratio of solute particles in solution to the number of formula units dissolved". The page explicitly uses an ideal-dilute model; a dissociated KCl formula unit supplies two ions. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | world-kcl-factor: i=2 for KCl splitting into K⁺ and Cl⁻ | https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/11-4-colligative-properties | N2-codex.md: world-kcl-factor: OpenStax gives the dilute-solution osmotic-pressure equation and defines the van't Hoff factor as "the ratio of solute particles in solution to the number of formula units dissolved". The page explicitly uses an ideal-dilute model; a dissociated KCl formula unit supplies two ions. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | replication-absence: it has not been independently replicated. | https://digibuo.uniovi.es/dspace/bitstream/handle/10651/62941/Where%20association%20ends_proof.pdf?sequence=1 | N2-codex.md: replication-absence: Visually checked the cited review's Table 2, p. 58: the 2014 Mimosa row has "Habituation", "Positive", "No" in the skill/result/replication columns. The adjacent 2016 row names "Markel (2020)" as its replication, a positive control. Gagliano 2014 supplies the 28-day detail; Biegler and the reply establish the dispute. Current targeted searches found the original and critical literature, not an independent repetition of that 28-day result. The review table alone is dated evidence, not an exhaustive 2026 registry. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | only-one-study: ONE study reports this (retention tested TO ~28 days, not “forever”) | https://digibuo.uniovi.es/dspace/bitstream/handle/10651/62941/Where%20association%20ends_proof.pdf?sequence=1 | N2-codex.md: only-one-study: Visually checked the cited review's Table 2, p. 58: the 2014 Mimosa row has "Habituation", "Positive", "No" in the skill/result/replication columns. The adjacent 2016 row names "Markel (2020)" as its replication, a positive control. Gagliano 2014 supplies the 28-day detail; Biegler and the reply establish the dispute. Current targeted searches found the original and critical literature, not an independent repetition of that 28-day result. The review table alone is dated evidence, not an exhaustive 2026 registry. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-molecular-caveat: The one honest caveat is molecular: the exact primary mechanoreceptor and some channel identities are still active research. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8566232/fullTextXML | N2-codex.md: ledger-molecular-caveat: "the pulvinule, which expresses a stretch-activated chloride-permeable mechanosensitive ion channel". The 2021 paper establishes channel activity and pharmacology, not a named Mimosa touch-sensor gene; current literature searches find the same open molecular question. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | ledger-retention-bound: retention tested TO ~28 days, not “forever” | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: ledger-retention-bound: The paper reports "the habituated response of LL plants first re-tested after being held undisturbed for 28 days", after transfer to high light. It is a reported result, not an independent confirmation of learning; the page labels it contested. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-reflex-brain: The patellar reflex genuinely bypasses cognition | https://openstax.org/books/anatomy-and-physiology-2e/pages/14-3-motor-responses | N2-codex.md: related-reflex-brain: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "Simple somatic reflexes do not include the higher centers discussed for conscious or voluntary aspects of movement.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-plant-brain: the Mimosa fold also needs no brain, yet the open question here is whether the plant's *declining* response is a form of learning at all. | https://nutrisoil.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Insufficient_evidence_for_habi-1.pdf | N2-codex.md: related-plant-brain: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "most of their data can be explained by motor fatigue". The claim is read in its attributed and contested/failed-replication context, not as a new assertion that plant learning is established. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-tickle-model: The animal nervous system's trick for not flinching at its own touch is a forward model - efference copy predicting the sensation away. | https://www.nature.com/articles/nn1198_635 | N2-codex.md: related-tickle-model: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "the cerebellum is involved in predicting the specific sensory consequences of movements". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-plant-no-machinery: A brainless plant has no such machinery, yet it too can stop responding to a repeated, harmless stimulus. | https://www.esalq.usp.br/lepse/imgs/conteudo_thumb/Experience-teaches-plants-to-learn-faster-and-forget-slower-in-environments-where-it-matters.pdf | N2-codex.md: related-plant-no-machinery: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "leaves were not only completely open by the end of a train but also stopped closing altogether.". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-neural-contrast: prediction-driven attenuation with a cerebellum, versus habituation with no neurons at all | https://www.nature.com/articles/nn1198_635 | N2-codex.md: related-neural-contrast: Blakemore and colleagues report cerebellar prediction of self-produced touch. The plant half is supported separately by the Mimosa studies and its contested-habituation context, not by the human fMRI paper alone. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-repetition: repetition turns a careful word into a confident one. | https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=EXT_ID:26301795&format=json&resultType=core | N2-codex.md: related-repetition: Read the excerpt and full source; supporting text: "repeated statements are easier to process, and subsequently perceived to be more truthful, than new statements". Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | related-universe-priority: There, the priority for the expanding universe is split honestly across Slipher, Hubble and Lemaître; | https://arxiv.org/pdf/1212.5499 | N2-codex.md: related-universe-priority: The historical paper credits Slipher's velocities and identifies Lemaître as "the first to connect the recession of the spiral nebulae with a relativistic expansion of space-time", while distinguishing theory from Hubble's empirical relation. This supports a distribution of contributions, not identical discovery roles. Also CONFIRMED by N2-claude.md.
- CONFIRMED | body-4-11: Press the button and run the real clock. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#12 body-4-11] inline script: frame() advances a clock and the spike arrives at travelTime(dist, vel)
- CONFIRMED | body-8: = distance ÷ conduction speed | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#14 body-8] travelTime(dCm, vCms){ return dCm / vCms; }
- CONFIRMED | body-10: 0.50 MPa · 4.96 bar | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#15 body-10] recreated: 2 x 100 x 8.314 x 298 = 495514.4 Pa = 0.4955 MPa = 4.955 bar
- CONFIRMED | body-22-28: Two numbers on this page are computed live from the sliders and nothing else: | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#29 body-22-28] updateReadouts(): exactly two computed readouts, travelTime(dist, vel) and vanHoffPa(conc)
- CONFIRMED | body-23-29: The spike's travel time is just distance over speed. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#30 body-23-29] return dCm / vCms
- CONFIRMED | body-24: Travel time is t = d / v. Osmotic pressure is the van 't Hoff relation Π = i·c·R·T - the pressure a dissolved solute exerts (i=2 for KCl splitting into K⁺ and Cl⁻, R=8.314, T=298 K). For your current sliders: | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#32 body-24] R = 8.314, T = 298, i_KCl = 2, vanHoffPa = i*c*R*T; OpenStax 11.4 gives the dilute-solution relation
- CONFIRMED | body-25: t = 4.0 cm ÷ 2.5 cm/s = 1.60 s | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#33 body-25] recreated: 4.0 / 2.5 = 1.60
- CONFIRMED | body-26: Π = 2 · 100 mol/m³ · 8.314 · 298 = 495 514 Pa = 0.50 MPa = 4.96 bar | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#34 body-26] recreated: 495514.4 Pa, 0.4955 MPa, 4.955 bar
- CONFIRMED | body-27-37: Run it: node research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs → 26/26 PASS. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#38 body-27-37] recreated: curl of https://artwaste.land/checks/research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs into an empty directory, node verify.mjs prints "26/26 PASS", exit 0; byte-identical to the repository copy
- CONFIRMED | body-29-41: The animation is a schematic of one hinge, not a finite-element model. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#42 body-29-41] draw() paints one hinge with two cell stacks; no mechanical solver
- CONFIRMED | body-29-43: we draw the extensor collapse and hold the flexor firm, which is the direction of the effect but not a full mechanical solve. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#44 body-29-43] extensor cells shrink (exH = cellH * (1 - 0.78*ff)); the flexor stack is drawn "turgid"
- CONFIRMED | body-29-44: The Π figure is the osmotic pressure of the moved ions in isolation (van 't Hoff, ideal-dilute), an order-of-magnitude bookkeeping of the turgor at stake, not a measured pressure trace. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#45 body-29-44] vanHoffPa uses the ideal i = 2; the page labels it ideal-dilute
- CONFIRMED | body-39-66: The ledger below keeps them apart. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#67 body-39-66] LEDGER array with species bands and a "species firewall" line
- CONFIRMED | body-45: The verifier enumerates three statuses, two species, nine criteria and three rebuttal prongs, and checks the Markel group total of 203 separately from the F vs L comparison n=82, p=0.387. | research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | After the X18 repair: source code checks both group sums and the significance threshold. This is a code check, not independent validation of the scientific statuses. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | body-49-85: The 2014 and 2016 studies are weighed here on evidence - Biegler and Markel are the load-bearing counters - not by pointing at the author's more mystical popular writing. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monica_Gagliano | N2-claude.md: [#86 body-49-85] Wikipedia: "Gagliano has also trained with Peruvian plant shamans, following established shamanic protocols to learn how to communicate directly with plants"; book "Thus Spoke the Plant" (North Atlantic Books, 2018). The record sourced this to the page itself, which cannot support a claim about the author
- CONFIRMED | body-50-96: Numbers recomputed in research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#97 body-50-96] the verifier recomputes the page's arithmetic
- CONFIRMED | body-52-97: This layer's check works the answer out again from scratch, independently of this page. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#98 body-52-97] the verifier imports nothing and reads no file; it recomputes the arithmetic and holds the empirical values as constants
- CONFIRMED | body-52-98: It can settle the finding; it cannot notice a figure that drifted on this page. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#99 body-52-98] no page reads in the verifier
- CONFIRMED | body-52-99: It is published, and it runs on its own: one file, and Node. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#100 body-52-99] recreated: one file, run with node from an empty directory, no dependencies
- CONFIRMED | meta-description-2: Fire the spike yourself and watch the whole electro-osmotic chain, every number computed live. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#154 meta-description-2] both readouts recompute on slider input; the 150 mV value is a fixed, disabled control
- CONFIRMED | meta-og-description-3: Every number recomputed live. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#159 meta-og-description-3] live readouts
- CONFIRMED | meta-twitter-description-3: Numbers recomputed live. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#162 meta-twitter-description-3] live readouts
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-2: Fire the spike yourself and watch the whole electro-osmotic chain, both live numbers computed from the sliders. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#165 frontmatter-dek-2] two live readouts
- CONFIRMED | frontmatter-dek-6: Every number recomputed by the verifier. | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#168 frontmatter-dek-6] recreated 26/26
- CONFIRMED | markdown-every-number: Every number is recomputed by `research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs` (26/26). | git show 67088387e0:research/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/verify-the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.mjs | N2-claude.md: [#169 markdown-every-number] recreated 26/26
- CONFIRMED | control-dist: Touch-to-hinge distance - 4.0 cm | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#170 control-dist]
- CONFIRMED | control-vel: Conduction speed - 2.5 cm/s | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#171 control-vel]
- CONFIRMED | control-conc: Potassium that leaves the cell - 100 mM | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#172 control-conc]
- CONFIRMED | control-amp: Spike amplitude 150 mV | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#173 control-amp]
- CONFIRMED | structured-description-1: Fire the spike and watch the electro-osmotic chain, every number recomputed live. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#175 structured-description-1] live readouts
- CONFIRMED | structured-datePublished: "datePublished":"2026-07-03" | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#177 structured-datePublished] "datePublished":"2026-07-03"
- CONFIRMED | structured-dateModified: JSON-LD dateModified is 2026-10-14. | public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | Updated for the supported corrections. The dated Corrected lines date the revision; this is not a separate STALE finding. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | related-page-description-0: One page shows a reflex that is only ever a reflex; this one shows where 'just a reflex' stops being a refutation. | git show 67088387e0:src/content/strata/the-jerk-that-skips-your-brain.md | N2-claude.md: [#194 related-page-description-0] the linked layer describes the knee-jerk loop closing in the spinal cord
- CONFIRMED | related-page-description-2: One page examines the repetition illusion; this one asks how far the plant-learning evidence reaches. | src/content/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching.md; src/content/strata/repeated-until-true.md | After X22: the related note no longer asserts an observed case of fused headlines. The linked page describes the illusory-truth effect. Restates the checker-confirmed entry after correcting its shared copy.
- CONFIRMED | related-three-plant-claims: here, three claims about plant 'memory' are pried apart by how far each one's evidence actually reaches - the mechanism, the contested habituation, and the failed pea-learning replication. | git show 67088387e0:public/strata/the-plant-that-stopped-flinching/index.html | N2-claude.md: [#197 related-three-plant-claims] three ledger rows: established, contested, failed replication
- CONFIRMED | nearby-rubisco-description: Both turn plant physiology into an instrument, but at different scales: one follows an electrical signal through a moving leaf, while this one follows an enzyme tradeoff… | git show 67088387e0:src/content/strata/rubisco-crossover.md | N2-claude.md: [#199 nearby-rubisco-description] its dek is the C3/C4 enzyme tradeoff
- CONFIRMED | extra-link-check: (added) Page links: PubMed 24390479, PubMed 29214474, PMC7284940, PMC7311169 and nature.com/articles/srep38427 for Gagliano 2014, Biegler 2018, the Plants review, Markel 2020 and the pea paper | https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=24390479,29214474 | N2-claude.md: esummary: 24390479 "Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower..." Oecologia 175:63-72; 29214474 "Insufficient evidence for habituation in Mimosa pudica..." Oecologia 186:33-35; PMC7284940 and PMC7311169 titles match
- MINOR | V1: The verifier called 50–200 mV and 1–10 s reported spans. | https://www.uni-weimar.de/kunst-und-gestaltung/wiki/images/Plant_Cell_Environment_-_2010_-_VOLKOV_-_Signal_transduction_in_Mimosa_pudica_biologically_closed_electrical_circuits.pdf | Ancillary verifier assertion repair, not a change to the listed K4 page sentence. Reread p. 817: Volkov gives a literature amplitude range of 16–210 mV and electrical-signal duration range of 1.2–2000 s. The duration range is not confined to one AP type or tissue. Both verifier copies now use and cite those ranges.
## Findings
- [declined] X1: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Sci.News supplies one headline, not a history of successive retellings, and learning/memory were already the original researchers' interpretation. This is loose narrative provenance, not a disproof of decrement or retention. The separate sentence is unchanged.
- [fixed] X2: Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- [declined] X3: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The equality wording is compressed, but the page explicitly calls the calculation an ideal-dilute, isolated-solute estimate rather than a measured turgor trace. The review supports the turgor-loss model; neither the declared model nor its arithmetic is contradicted. The sentence is unchanged.
- [fixed] X4: Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- [declined] X5: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The equality wording is compressed, but the page explicitly calls the calculation an ideal-dilute, isolated-solute estimate rather than a measured turgor trace. The review supports the turgor-loss model; neither the declared model nor its arithmetic is contradicted. The sentence is unchanged.
- [fixed] X6: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] X7: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] X8: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- [open note:ce448f] X9: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. The historical rating explanations at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3285 and :3286 still present the unsupported fusion premise without an adjacent correction. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [open note:ce448f] X10: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. The historical rating explanations at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3285 and :3286 still present the unsupported fusion premise without an adjacent correction. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [open note:ce448f] X11: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. The historical rating explanations at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3285 and :3286 still present the unsupported fusion premise without an adjacent correction. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [fixed] X12: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 33: he lists characteristic 3 among omitted tests. Replaced the invented suggestive/not-decisive assessment in his scorecard cell; the separately listed potentiation tag remains unchanged.
- [fixed] X13: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- [declined] X14: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Rankin 2009 characteristic 7 asks for some stimulus specificity and comparison of decrements; it does not demand a full novel-stimulus response. The essential comparison remains, making this a precision overstatement. The requirement sentence is unchanged.
- [fixed] X15: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] X16: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] X17: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [open note:ce448f] X18: Reread Markel 2020, Results and discussion before Figure 3: p=0.387 uses n=42+40=82. The four main groups total 61+60+42+40=203. Separated those denominators in this layer's active copies and recomputed both totals in the verifier and its published mirror. The headline at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3281 still associates n≈203 with p=0.387 and calls the result no effect. It needs a sourced override stating n=82 for that comparison, 203 across the four main groups, and no statistically significant difference. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [open note:ce448f] X19: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. The historical rating explanations at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3285 and :3286 still present the unsupported fusion premise without an adjacent correction. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [fixed] X20: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] X21: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [open note:47b196] X22: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. public/strata/there-here/index.html:250 and research/lineage-edge-grammar/page.json:1 still display the old related note without an adjacent correction. Preserve the historical quotation and annotate its unsupported fusion premise through that layer's copy-corrections mechanism. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [open note:0400c6] X23: Reread the linked universe page main content and sources: it compares discovery evidence from multiple sources and has no paired rebuttal and reply. Corrected this layer's authored related note and its nearby rendered copy only. public/strata/there-here/index.html:250 and research/lineage-edge-grammar/page.json:1 still display the old rebuttal/reply comparison without an adjacent correction. Preserve the historical quotation and annotate the false comparison through that layer's copy-corrections mechanism. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [fixed] X24: Reread Gagliano 2014, Methods p. 65, and Biegler 2018, p. 33: the drop height was fixed at 15 cm; light manipulates energy reserves. Changed the intensity tag to not tested and distinguished the light treatment.
- [fixed] X25: Reread Gagliano 2014, p. 65 and Figure 2 caption p. 67: 5- and 10-second intervals were compared, with an interval effect in low light (P<0.0001), but not high light (P=0.5). The row now says tested in part, without claiming the complete frequency criterion was established.
- [declined] X26: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. Gagliano 2014 p. 67 reports earlier reopening on retest, giving the retraining/savings claim a source, but not a systematic series of progressively faster train-rest cycles. The tag says claimed met rather than demonstrated; it is separate from the corrected Biegler cell and remains unchanged.
- [declined] K1: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The review supports a consensus macroscopic electrical/osmotic model while retaining unresolved mechanisms. Settled is too categorical, but the page states idealisation and molecular caveats; the limited model is not thereby false. The lede sentence is unchanged.
- [fixed] K2: Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- [fixed] K3: Reread Hagihara and Toyota 2020, section 2: the leaf drops and leaflets fold upward. Corrected the canvas description, chain step and inline drawing comments.
- [declined] K4: Listed MINOR under the triage's Tier C rule. The verifier tests fixed anchors and encoded values; that does not establish the page's claimed source validation or recomputation of everything. The page sentence remains unchanged. The separate V1 finding corrects the verifier's numerical span assertions under the instruction to fix false verifier assertions; it does not resolve this scope overclaim.
- [fixed] K5: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] K6: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- [open note:ce448f] K7: Reread the complete Sci.News article dated 16 January 2014. Its headline is Mimosa Plants Have Long Term Memory, Can Learn, Biologists Say; the article covers the Mimosa study and contains no Pavlov clause or pea experiment. Restored the headline and removed the asserted fusion from this layer's introductions, explanation, ledger, related note and README. This does not assert that all popular coverage keeps the studies separate. The historical rating explanations at public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3285 and :3286 still present the unsupported fusion premise without an adjacent correction. That other layer is outside this repair's scope.
- [fixed] K9: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 33: he lists characteristic 3 among omitted tests. Replaced the invented suggestive/not-decisive assessment in his scorecard cell; the separately listed potentiation tag remains unchanged.
- [fixed] K10: Reread Biegler 2018, p. 35: faster low-light decline is compatible with exhaustion. His qualified reservation concerns equal folding after the 28-day light swap, with a possible ceiling effect. Corrected body, scorecard and README without inventing a cause.
- [fixed] K11: Reread Gagliano 2014, Results p. 66, and Biegler 2018, pp. 33–34: the original authors called restored closure to shaking dishabituation; Biegler disputed that interpretation. Restored their claim in their column and retained his objection in his column.
- [fixed] K12: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] K14: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] K15: Reread the review abstract: the short phrase was a paraphrase presented as an explicit quotation. Restored its exact words in the body, footer, ledger text, ledger source note and README.
- [fixed] K16: Reread Gagliano 2014, Methods p. 65, and Biegler 2018, p. 33: the drop height was fixed at 15 cm; light manipulates energy reserves. Changed the intensity tag to not tested and distinguished the light treatment.
- [fixed] V1: Corrected the verifier's source-attributed range assertions to Volkov 2010 p. 817: 16–210 mV and 1.2–2000 s, identifying the latter as electrical-signal durations. Updated the published mirror. This is a MINOR verifier repair, recorded without a page correction line; K4's broader page overclaim remains listed and unchanged.
## Not done
- X22: `public/strata/there-here/index.html:250` and `research/lineage-edge-grammar/page.json:1` retain the fused-headline account. The open finding above awaits a board note; the repair report supplies its text and the required adjacent correction.
- X23: the same corpus copies retain the false rebuttal/reply comparison. The open finding above awaits a board note; the repair report supplies its text and the required adjacent correction.
- X9, X10, X11, X18, X19 and K7: `public/strata/the-anatomy-of-error/data.json:3281`, `:3285` and `:3286` retain the incorrect sample-size association, the no-effect assertion and the unsupported fusion premise. The open findings above await a board note; the repair report supplies its text, the sourced headline override and the required annotation of the historical rating explanations. No other-layer or shared-file change was made by this repair.