--- slug: the-waning-of-merit passed: 2026-11-16 by: claims-pass agent (outside reader, did not write the page), one agent on oversight/claims-pass.md, every entry of assay/sources/the-waning-of-merit.json plus 7 claims it leaves out checked: 250 confirmed: 167 wrong: 2 unverifiable: 0 observed: 81 stale: 0 --- ## Claims - CONFIRMED | Gyan Chaupar: a Snakes and Ladders Board of about 1800, Played and Solved | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | collection record (kept HTML): "By a Maharashtra artist, ca. 1800 CE, possibly at Nagpur."; "Gyan Chaupar" is the family name (entry title-gyan) - CONFIRMED | Gyan Chaupar: a Snakes and Ladders Board of about 1800 | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyan_chauper | kept Wikipedia revision: "There is also a unique example of a 124-square board from Maharashtra." among gyan chaupar boards - CONFIRMED | The game of Heaven and Hell · Maharashtra, about 1800 | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "Design for the game of Snakes and Ladders. Finely drawn fig…" - CONFIRMED | A board for the game of Heaven and Hell | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - CONFIRMED | A board for the game of Heaven and Hell, painted by a Maharashtra artist about 1800 | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "By a Maharashtra artist, ca. 1800 CE, possibly at Nagpur. G…" - CONFIRMED | reached the Royal Asiatic Society in 1831 with two ivory dice | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | kept crop p. 85 says the dice "are of ivory"; that two came with the chart is the 1835 list ("also two Dice", April 16, 1831, kept crop p. lxi) and Pargiter p. 539 ("ivory men and dice ... given at the same time"); the excerpt cited here alone describes the dice, not the gift - CONFIRMED | and an account of its rules that has not been found | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | kept crop p. 85: "A translation of the inventor's account of the game accompanied it, and was read" and "instructions for playing the game". Not found: no later kept source mentions it, and this pass searched the Society's archive catalogue (royalasiaticarchives.org, 2026-11-16): "Trivingally" and "Shastree" no results; positive control "snakes and ladders" and "Heaven and Hell" return the file COLL5/7/2 - CONFIRMED | Its side compartment follows the Upanishads’ path of the fathers, with a cobra as the way out | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | Hume p. 163 read on the kept crop; the order holds (entry order-holds); "with a cobra as the way out" is the page's reading, said as one in the body - OBSERVED | read without one, as Pargiter read it in 1916, it would keep between 27% and 92% of all souls for good. | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | figures.json ranges.Nheaven [0.2705, 0.9160], recreated by the probe over the 72 readings with no way out; the published check recomputes the same range where the body prints it in spans, but does not read this copy in the dek (see Findings); build-page.mjs --check ties it to figures.json inside the repository - CONFIRMED | Every square of this chart has a name | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "On the accompanying paper is a diagram of the chart, giving…" - CONFIRMED | from the twenty-one hells at the bottom left, where you start | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "He starts from No. 1, which denotes the hells, at the bottom" - CONFIRMED | to square 124 near the top left, “deliverance into the Supreme Brahma” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Śrī-Para-Brahma-mokṣaḥ 124 (deliverance into the Supreme Br…" - OBSERVED | It is redrawn here from the Royal Asiatic Society’s photograph, each square named as F. E. Pargiter’s key of… | research/the-waning-of-merit/README.md | read README.md; agrees - OBSERVED | 124 numbered squares in three compartments, a side compartment at the right of the middle one | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/board.json | read board.json: The board's aria-label. board.json size.compartments (top, middle, bottom) and size.side…; agrees - OBSERVED | The throw is two long dice, and the other rules are the ones set out under The missing rules below; change th… | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/app.mjs | read app.mjs: app.mjs plays by engine.mjs DEFAULT_READING (die "pasa2", end "again", chain, side "wheel…; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | Dashed snakes and ladders are the two left as choices in the panel below. | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/app.mjs | read app.mjs: keyed/links.json choices: snake-19 and ladder-top.; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | On 16 April 1831, at a general meeting of the Royal Asiatic Society, the gifts announced for the library ende… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | kept whole-page crop p. 85: "A general meeting of the Society ... was held on the 16th April"; the gifts "For the Library" run to the game's entry, then "The donations to the museum were as follows" - CONFIRMED | “From Captain H. Dundas Robertson, of the Bombay army, a coloured drawing of the Shastree’s game of Heaven an… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | kept crop p. 85 read word for word, with the print's spaces before ":" and ";" - CONFIRMED | The Asiatic Journal and Monthly Register, new series, vol. V (May to August 1831), p. 85 | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n5.jpg | title page leaf n5 fetched 2026-11-16 and read: "VOL. V.—NEW SERIES. MAY.—AUGUST 1831. LONDON"; p. 85 is leaf n95 - CONFIRMED | Robertson was then, by the East-India Register for 1830, Collector and Magistrate of Ahmednuggur. | https://archive.org/download/eastindiaregister1830-2e/page/n518.jpg | kept crop p. 8: "Collectors and Magistrates of Zillahs. Ahmednuggur. Capt. H. D. Robertson"; the 1832 Register agrees (Major); his 1845 obituary (kept) says he "remained at Poonah until 1834", so the page is right to attribute this to the Register - CONFIRMED | The drawing is still there: RAS 051.001, gouache on paper mounted on cloth, 84 by 90 centimetres, by a Mahara… | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "Design for the game of Snakes and Ladders. Finely drawn fig…" - CONFIRMED | “possibly at Nagpur”, in the Society’s own catalogue | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "By a Maharashtra artist, ca. 1800 CE, possibly at Nagpur." - CONFIRMED | The dice and the men were gone by 1916, when F. E. Pargiter described the chart for the Society’s journal: | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The ivory men and dice used in playing the game, given at t…" - CONFIRMED | “The ivory men and dice used in playing the game, given at the same time, are not to be found now.” | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The ivory men and dice used in playing the game, given at t…" - CONFIRMED | He does not mention the inventor’s account, and nothing later that we could read does either. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "It was presented to the Society by Capt. H. D. Robertson on…" - OBSERVED | The board survives; the rules that came with it, so far as we can find, do not. | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/SCOUT-HISTORY.md | SCOUT-HISTORY.md 1(a); and this pass's archive-catalogue search (entry dek-account) found nothing under the author's name - CONFIRMED | It is a board for the game the Society files under snakes and ladders. | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "[RAS 051.001] Snakes and Ladders" - CONFIRMED | In 1895 G. R. Dampier, writing in North Indian Notes and Queries, described one of its 72-square cousins | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n37.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop dampier1895-ninq-v5-p25-whole-page-leaf37.jpg - CONFIRMED | Gyán Chausar, or the “Chess of Knowledge” | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n37.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop dampier1895-ninq-v5-p25-whole-page-leaf37.jpg - CONFIRMED | and closed with a piece of news: it “has, I am told, been lately introduced into England and, with ordinary d… | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n38.jpg | kept crop p. 26: "has, I am told, been lately introduced into England and, with ordinary dice for cowries and a somewhat revised set of rules, been patented there as a children's game,—G. R. Dampier, C. S." - CONFIRMED | Pargiter’s article came with a folding table that gives every square its name, in Sanskrit with an English gl… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "On the accompanying paper is a diagram of the chart, giving…" - OBSERVED | That table is the key the board above is labelled from. | research/the-waning-of-merit/build-data.mjs | read build-data.mjs; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | Pargiter inferred the rules of movement from the paint: ladders go up, and “if the player landed on a square… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The snakes therefore seem to mean that, if the player lande…" - CONFIRMED | read the board as “an epitome of man’s upward course in religious life” | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The game appears to have an educational value, giving as it…" - CONFIRMED | the hells at the bottom, physical and social states in the lowest compartment, moral and spiritual ones in th… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "compartment, containing squares 1—41, deals in its squares…" - CONFIRMED | with “no vices and no snakes” | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "In the third and highest compartment there are no vices and…" - CONFIRMED | Then he came to the block of squares at the right of the middle compartment, which has numbers of its own: | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "which contains two blocks of squares divided by a small scr…" - CONFIRMED | “The compartment on the right side appears to be a side-game developing out of the main game. Two ladders con… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The compartment on the right side appears to be a side-game…" - CONFIRMED | “Such characteristics may lead a man into the pursuit of a self-seeking existence, which may attain to the go… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | kept text layer reads "Brahma;"; the PDF page rendered at 300 dpi shows "Brahma ;", as the page prints it - CONFIRMED | F. E. Pargiter, “An Indian Game: Heaven or Hell”, Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, July 1916, pp. 540 an… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | Crossref 10.1017/S0035869X0004939X (fetched 2026-11-16): JRAS 48(3), issued 1916-07, pp. 539-542, F. E. Pargiter; quotes on pp. 540 and 542 - OBSERVED | Here are the side compartment’s squares in the order of their own numbers, as his table names them, beside a… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json; agrees - CONFIRMED | The passage is in Robert Ernest Hume’s translation of 1921, with the Sanskrit word for each station. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n6.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-title-page-n6.jpg - CONFIRMED | “But they who by sacrificial offering, charity, and austerity conquer the worlds, pass into the smoke [of the… | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 6.2.16, tr. R. E. Hume, The Thirteen Principal Upanishads (Oxford University Press, 19… | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n6.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-title-page-n6.jpg - OBSERVED | The side compartment in the order of its numbers, entered from square 31 and left, in the readings that leave… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: Links L-31-low-R1 and B-48-low-L3 (links-A.json L3: "Short diagonal ladder (3-4 rungs)").; agrees - CONFIRMED | The English is Hume’s translation of Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 6.2.16 | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | The board (number and name as Pargiter’s table prints them) | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/board.json | read board.json: Every name and gloss in the fathers, gods and key tables is board.json's (squares, sideCe…; agrees - CONFIRMED | The text (Hume, 1921) | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | the Sanskrit is the same section | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "atha ye yajñena dānena tapasā lokāñ jayanti te dh…" - OBSERVED | (main board: the ladder from here leads in) | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: L-31-low-R1.; agrees - OBSERVED | (the head of the cobra) | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: S-up-7-low-L1 starts in up-7.; agrees - OBSERVED | (the cobra’s tail) | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: S-up-7-low-L1 ends in low-L1.; agrees - OBSERVED | (main board, by the short ladder) | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: B-48-low-L3.; agrees - CONFIRMED | not in this passage | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | (the cobra’s body) | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: S-up-7-low-L1, from up-7 to low-L1; no cell stands for "space".; agrees - CONFIRMED | The order holds station by station, from the smoke to the earth. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | The square the side compartment is entered from, 31, is “sacrifice, the fires, interested action” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Yajñaḥ agnayaḥ sakāma-karma 31 (sacrifice, the fires, inter…" - CONFIRMED | the text’s “sacrificial offering” | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | Between the smoke and the earth, the one station the board leaves out is space. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | And where the text says “When that passes away for them”, the board has a square called the waning of merit,… | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | the board has a square called the waning of merit, Puṇya-kṣayaḥ, number 7 | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json; agrees - OBSERVED | and painted on it is the head of a cobra, whose tail hangs down into wind, the first square of the second ser… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links-A.json | read links-A.json: links-A.json S1: "the tail tip is in low-L1"; links-B.json S25: "blue hooded snake (cobra…; agrees - CONFIRMED | Pargiter does not mention this snake. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | whole kept text of pp. 539-542 read: the side compartment is "two series of the Nos. 1—3" and squares 4-10, reached by two ladders, "no exit"; no snake in it is mentioned - OBSERVED | the last cell’s name, which the table does not gloss | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json; agrees - CONFIRMED | begins with Pṛthvi, Pargiter’s spelling of pṛthvī, which Monier-Williams gives as a form of pṛthivī, the earth | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n687.jpg | kept crop p. 646: "Pṛithivī, f. (= pṛithvī, f. of pṛithu) the earth or wide world"; scan A shows the table's plain i in "Prthvi" - CONFIRMED | and a short ladder joins that cell to square 48, “of royal birth” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Rāja-yoniḥ 48 (of royal birth)" - OBSERVED | a short ladder joins that cell to square 48 | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links-B.json | read links-B.json: links-A.json L3 and links-B.json L6: ends in 48 and in low-L3, the earth cell.; agrees - CONFIRMED | the text’s “Thence they are born” | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | The board has nothing for the text’s “Again they are offered in the fire of man”. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | the road its own fourth cell names, Pitṛyāṇaḥ | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json; agrees - CONFIRMED | in Monier-Williams the path leading to the Pitṛs | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n667.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p626-pitr-yana-n667.jpg - CONFIRMED | the path leading to the Pitṛs, the fathers | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | and the cobra is the way out of it. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: S-up-7-low-L1: the only link leaving the upper block.; agrees - OBSERVED | Read this way, the side compartment is not a trap but a detour | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/readings.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); ring heaven 0 in all 72 ring readings - CONFIRMED | Pargiter read the ladder at 48 the other way, as a second way in | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "Two ladders connect it with the latter, namely, from square…" - OBSERVED | and the paint leans his way: the ladder rises from 48 to the earth | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links-A.json | read links-A.json: links-A.json L3: "lower-left end over L1's rails in 48 ..., upper-right end in low-L3" (e…; agrees - CONFIRMED | and, as he says, “a ladder implies ascent” | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "There are ladders connecting certain squares, as 12 and 49,…" - CONFIRMED | Read with the text, it is the way down to birth. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | The page computes both. | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/readings.json | read readings.json: side "none1916" (48 leads in) and "line" and "wheel" (the ladder leads out to 48).; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - CONFIRMED | The same Upanishad gives the other road one section earlier | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | the top compartment’s second square, 90 | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/board.json | read board.json: board.json: 89 (Brahma-lokaḥ Dhanvantarī) is row 0, column 0 of the top compartment and 9…; agrees - MINOR | carries the name the Chāndogya Upaniṣad gives that road: Devayānaḥ | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_chAndogyopaniSad-comm.txt | ChU 5.10.2 "eṣa devayānaḥ panthā" (kept GRETIL) is right, but the page's own Upaniṣad names both roads in the same brāhmaṇa: BĀU 6.2.2 "vettho devayānasya vā pathaḥ pratipadaṃ pitṛyāṇasya vā" (GRETIL file sha256 12f861f8..., line 4121, the file the kept excerpt was cut from); the record's notes (dek-fathers, this entry) say the BĀU does not name it, which is true only of 6.2.15-16 - CONFIRMED | in Hume’s translation “the way leading to the gods”. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n252.jpg | kept crop Hume p. 233: "He leads them on to Brahma. This is the way leading to the gods." - CONFIRMED | “Those who know this, and those too who in the forest truly worship (upāsate) faith (śraddhā), pass into the… | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 6.2.15, tr. Hume (1921), p. 163 | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | Squares 90 to 98 of the top compartment beside Hume’s translation of Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 6.2.15 | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | The text (Hume, 1921) | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | the Sanskrit is the same section | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "te ya evam etad vidur ye cāmī araṇye śraddhāṃ sat…" - OBSERVED | Nine squares beside the text’s stations, in its order, 97 and 98 sharing one. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json: The gods table: eight rows of the text beside the nine squares 90-98, 97 and 98 in one ro…; agrees - OBSERVED | Two of Pargiter’s glosses read differently beside it. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json: Cells 91 ("ah !") and 97-98 ("Lake Mānasa", "the primeval Male").; agrees - CONFIRMED | He glossed 91, Ahahaḥ, as “ah !” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Ahahaḥ 91 (ah !)" - CONFIRMED | He glossed 91, Ahahaḥ, as “ah !”, an exclamation | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n166.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p125-ahaha-n166.jpg - CONFIRMED | where the text’s station between the flame and the waxing moon is ahaḥ, the day. | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "te ya evam etad vidur ye cāmī araṇye śraddhāṃ sat…" - CONFIRMED | is ahaḥ, the day | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n165.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p124-ahan-ahar-n165.jpg - CONFIRMED | And he glossed 97 and 98 as “Lake Mānasa” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Mānasaṁ 97 (Lake Mānasa)" - CONFIRMED | and “the primeval Male” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Puruṣaḥ 98 (the primeval Male)" - CONFIRMED | where the text has, at that point, one figure in two words: puruṣo mānasa, “A Person (puruṣa) consisting of m… | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | one figure in two words: puruṣo mānasa | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "te ya evam etad vidur ye cāmī araṇye śraddhāṃ sat…" - CONFIRMED | Both of his readings are words | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n166.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p125-ahaha-n166.jpg - CONFIRMED | Both of his readings are words | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n851.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p810-manasa-n851.jpg - CONFIRMED | Both of his readings are words | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n678.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p637-purusa-n678.jpg - CONFIRMED | “Of these there is no return”, says the text of the path of the gods. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | On the board it has no snakes, which Pargiter noticed. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "In the third and highest compartment there are no vices and…" - CONFIRMED | Of the path of the fathers the text says that they “cycle round again”, and the board puts a snake on it. | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - CONFIRMED | The stations are the Upanishad’s, in its order, but four squares name them with words its two sections do not… | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "atha ye yajñena dānena tapasā lokāñ jayanti te dh…" - CONFIRMED | The bright and the dark fortnight, śukla and kṛṣṇa, and the sun’s northern and southern course, uttarāyaṇa an… | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "agnir jyotir ahaḥ śuklaḥ ṣaṇmāsā uttarāyaṇam" - CONFIRMED | are the words of the Bhagavad Gītā, which gives the two paths in two verses. | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "dhūmo rātris tathā kṛṣṇaḥ ṣaṇmāsā dakṣiṇāyanam" - CONFIRMED | And square 90 names the first station twice: Agniḥ, fire, the Gītā’s word, and Arciḥ, flame, the Upanishad’s. | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Devayānaḥ Agniḥ Arciḥ 90 (path to the gods, fire, ray of li…" - CONFIRMED | “The fire, the flame, the day, the bright fortnight, the six months of the northern solstice, departing (from… | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n96.jpg | kept crops pp. 80 and 81 read: "The fire, the flame, the day, the bright fortnight, ... the devotee goes to the lunar light and returns" (footnote marks left out) - CONFIRMED | Bhagavad Gītā 8.24 and 8.25, tr. K. T. Telang, Sacred Books of the East vol. VIII (Oxford, 1882), pp. 80 and… | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n10.jpg | kept title page (Clarendon Press 1882) and series title page "VOL. VIII" - CONFIRMED | Where the Upanishad has the gods feeding on the dead in the moon | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n182.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-p163-bau-6.2.15-16-n182.jpg - OBSERVED | the board’s upper block has a heaven: the gods’ council with Indra, the forest Nandana, the nectar, five apsa… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json: Cells up-8 "the gods’ council : Indra", up-9 "forest Nandana", up-10 "nectar", up-apsaras…; agrees - CONFIRMED | The Gītā has that heaven too, a chapter later, and it ends where the cobra begins: | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | “Those who know the three (branches of) knowledge, who drink the Soma juice, whose sins are washed away, offe… | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | Bhagavad Gītā 9.20 and 9.21, tr. Telang (1882), p. 84 | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | “That great heavenly world” is svargalokaṃ viśālaṃ | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | “That great heavenly world” is svargalokaṃ viśālaṃ | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "te taṃ bhuktvā svargalokaṃ viśālaṃ; kṣīṇe puṇye m…" - CONFIRMED | and “when (their) merit is exhausted” is kṣīṇe puṇye | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | and “when (their) merit is exhausted” is kṣīṇe puṇye | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "te taṃ bhuktvā svargalokaṃ viśālaṃ; kṣīṇe puṇye m…" - OBSERVED | on the board, Puṇya-kṣayaḥ, the waning of merit, with the cobra’s head on it. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json: keyed/links.json S-up-7-low-L1.; agrees - CONFIRMED | “Those who wish for objects of desire” are kāmakāmā | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n99.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-p84-bhg-9.20-21-n99.jpg - CONFIRMED | “Those who wish for objects of desire” are kāmakāmā | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "evaṃ trayīdharmam anuprapannā; gatāgataṃ kāmakāmā…" - CONFIRMED | the square the side compartment is entered from, 31, ends in sakāma-karma, Pargiter’s “interested action” | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Yajñaḥ agnayaḥ sakāma-karma 31 (sacrifice, the fires, inter…" - CONFIRMED | both words are built on kāma. | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "evaṃ trayīdharmam anuprapannā; gatāgataṃ kāmakāmā…" - OBSERVED | Read beside both texts, the board looks like the Upanishad’s two paths told in the Gītā’s words. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json: The page's own reading, resting on the entries gita-four, gita-words-824, gita-words-825,…; agrees - OBSERVED | The painter also set an arch of three cells over the side compartment. | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links-B.json | read links-B.json: keyed/table.json cells arch-1, arch-2, arch-3; board.json sideCells; links-B.json S25: "H…; agrees - OBSERVED | Pargiter’s table names them without glosses | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | read table.json; agrees - CONFIRMED | the first is Agasti-sthānaṁ, the station of Agasti, a name Monier-Williams gives as one with Agastya | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n45.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p4-agasti-agastya-n45.png - CONFIRMED | and the second is a station of eighty-eight thousand (Aṣṭāśīti-sahasra-devarṣi-sthānaṁ) | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Deva-lokaḥ aṣṭāśīti-sahasra-maharṣi-sthānaṁ 94 (place of th…" - CONFIRMED | Agastya is the star Canopus, and the Viṣṇu Purāṇa uses it to place the fathers’ road in the sky: | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n323.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-p226-road-of-the-pitris-n323.jpg - CONFIRMED | “On the north of Agastya, and south of the line of the Goat, exterior to the Vaiswánara path, lies the road o… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n323.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-p226-road-of-the-pitris-n323.jpg - CONFIRMED | The Vishńu Puráńa, tr. H. H. Wilson (London, 1840), p. 226, where Wilson’s note adds: “Agastya is Canopus” | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n323.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-p226-road-of-the-pitris-n323.jpg - CONFIRMED | The Vishńu Puráńa, tr. H. H. Wilson (London, 1840), p. 226 | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n0.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-title-page-n0.jpg - CONFIRMED | Its path of the gods, on the next page, is where “eighty-eight thousand of these chaste beings tenant the reg… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n324.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-p227-path-of-the-gods-n324.jpg - CONFIRMED | the board’s square 94, on its own path of the gods, is in Pargiter’s gloss “place of the 88,000 maharṣis”. | https://archive.org/download/dli.ministry.15639/page/n555.jpg | folding table scans (kept) and table.json: "Deva-lokaḥ aṣṭāśīti-sahasra-maharṣi-sthānaṁ 94 (place of th…" - CONFIRMED | The inventor’s account, with its instructions for playing, was read at the Society’s meeting in 1831 and has… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | kept crop p. 85: "A translation of the inventor's account of the game accompanied it, and was read" ... "instructions for playing the game"; not found: as entry dek-account (no later kept source; nothing under "Trivingally" or "Shastree" in the Society's archive catalogue, positive-controlled) - OBSERVED | Everything a computer needs that the paint does not show has to be chosen, and each choice below is a reading… | research/the-waning-of-merit/README.md | read README.md; agrees - OBSERVED | computes every combination of them; the figures here are for the one you pick, from the first square, worked… | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: README: "3 x 3 x 2 x 3 x 2 x 2 = 216 readings, every one in readings.json".; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | The upper block is walked round and round, as its numbers run, until the token lands on the waning of merit;… | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: board.json side.wheel and side.fall.; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | As the ring, but a token thrown past the waning of merit stays among the gods for good. | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | Entered from 31 and from 48, never left. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "Two ladders connect it with the latter, namely, from square…" - CONFIRMED | no way out (Pargiter, 1916) | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "for there appears to be no exit from it." - CONFIRMED | Two, as came with the chart in 1831 | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - CONFIRMED | each marked 1, 2, 5 and 6 as the long dice of chaupar and chausar are described | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.32526/page/n365.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop ain-i-akbari-blochmann1873-vol1-p303-chaupar-dice-dli-leaf-n365.jpg - MINOR | thrown together and added, which no source describes. | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/SCOUT-HISTORY.md | SCOUT-HISTORY.md says "No source found describes ..."; the page says "which no source describes". The sources the page names do add dice for one piece in particular throws: Āʾīn p. 303 "A throw consisting of a six, a five, and a one ... every single piece twelve fields"; Falkener p. 264 "if given to a single piece it moves only twice the throw". None describes two dice thrown together and added as the ordinary throw - CONFIRMED | As Dampier describes for his board in 1895: move as many squares as fall mouth upward. | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n37.jpg | kept crop p. 25: "According to the numbers of cowries that fall upside down ... with the mouth of the shell upward, so is the number of squares, which the player can move" (five chit from sq. 1 to sq. 6); no special rule for none - OBSERVED | Each shell is taken as even odds | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: faces weighted choose(9, k): each shell up or down with even odds.; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | which no source gives. | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/SCOUT-HISTORY.md | SCOUT-HISTORY.md 4(a) "Dampier gives no probabilities"; the kept p. 25 crop confirms Dampier gives none. The Dauenhauers (cited on the page) assume even odds; an assumption, not a source for them - CONFIRMED | The modern game’s. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakes_and_ladders | kept wikipedia-snakes-and-ladders-rev1384204868.html: "Players take turns rolling a single die to move their token…" - CONFIRMED | Dampier’s rule for his board: “if his throw takes him beyond sq. No. 72, he must start all over again from sq… | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n37.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop dampier1895-ninq-v5-p25-method-of-playing-leaf37.jpg - CONFIRMED | As in one variant of the modern game. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakes_and_ladders | kept wikipedia-snakes-and-ladders-rev1384204868.html: "Variants exists where a player must roll the exact number t…" - CONFIRMED | A token set down where another snake or ladder starts takes that one too: Dampier’s “lands in a square contai… | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n37.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop dampier1895-ninq-v5-p25-method-of-playing-leaf37.jpg - OBSERVED | the snake whose head lies on the line between 19 and 2 | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/decisions.json | read decisions.json: Options "from 19 down to 1" (default) and "from 2 down to 1"; and "which way the ladder i…; agrees - OBSERVED | Read as Pargiter read it, with no way out, it ends the game for 89.4% of all souls when the other rules are a… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); ranges.Nheaven [0.2705, 0.9160], N.heaven 0.8938 - OBSERVED | With the cobra as the way out and the upper block walked as a ring, no soul stays there under any reading; wa… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); ring heaven 0 in all 72 ring readings (not in a span: the probe), line [0.0632, 0.4103] - CONFIRMED | The summary of the account printed in 1831 says the board “contains two heavens and two hells”; it does not s… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - OBSERVED | No throw of two long dice makes 1. | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: Two such dice added make 2 to 12 but never 1, 5 or 9 (README, "The dice"); checked by han…; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | Under the exact-throw rule, a variant of the modern game | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakes_and_ladders | kept wikipedia-snakes-and-ladders-rev1384204868.html: "Variants exists where a player must roll the exact number t…" - OBSERVED | a soul on 123 can never move again: with the other rules as the panel first sets them, 31.3% of souls end the… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); the only stuck square under any reading is 123, and only with two long dice and the exact ending - OBSERVED | If the dice of 1831 were long dice marked like those and thrown together, the inventor’s rule for the end was… | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/readings.json | read readings.json: readings.json: with two long dice added and the exact-throw rule, between 11.4% and 31.5%…; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Dampier’s rule, back to the first square, finishes every game in the end, but slowly: 165.9 throws on average… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); stuck 0 in all 72 readings with the "again" ending - OBSERVED | A soul is thrown back from near the top to the first square, the twenty-one hells, 3.92 times on average. | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: D.back 3.9237.; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Half of all throws of two long dice come to six, seven or eight | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: Checked by hand: of the 16 equally likely pairs, 6 comes 2 ways, 7 four ways and 8 two wa…; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | and from 118 upward most throws pass 124 | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/engine.mjs | read engine.mjs: Checked by hand: from 118 a throw over 6 (7, 8, 10, 11, 12) passes 124, 10 of 16; from 11…; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | with one cubical die a soul is thrown back 1.03 times. | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: cube.back 1.0250.; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Where any throw that reaches 124 is enough, a game takes 33.7 throws on average. | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: pass.throws 33.688.; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | At least 14 of the snakes end on the head of another, so it matters whether a token set down on a snake’s hea… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: board.tailsOnHeads 14. Counted by hand from keyed/links.json: 14 among the 24 snakes not…; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Under the first settings a soul takes 90.2 snakes in a game; taking one link to a throw, 15.7, and the game l… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: D.snakes 90.18; single.snakes 15.69; single.throws 71.70.; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Because the game can be solved, each snake and ladder can be priced: how many throws, on average, landing on… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.mjs | read figures.mjs; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | The table follows the rules chosen above. Under readings in which some souls stay among the gods for good, it… | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/app.mjs | read app.mjs; read the code: agrees - OBSERVED | Under the first settings the dearest square on the board is the foot of a ladder. The ladder from 61 to 85 ad… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); probe: L-61-85 +34.07 is the dearest main-board link; L-68-124 -158.36 - OBSERVED | The dearest snakes, from 57 and from 62, cost 22.0 and 21.9 throws, each the start of a chain of snakes down… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); probe: S-57-56 +22.01 and S-62-60 +21.86 are the two dearest snakes; chains 57-56-42 and 62-60-54-42 in board.json - OBSERVED | Snakes that shorten the journey (on the modern board, Althoen, King and Schilling found that adding one can):… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); probe: S-46-44 -0.2697 is the only snake with a negative price - CONFIRMED | (on the modern board, Althoen, King and Schilling found that adding one can) | https://www.futilitycloset.com/2018/09/21/for-what-its-worth-5/ | kept futilitycloset-2018-09-21-for-what-its-worth.html: "And adding a snake from square 29 to square 27 shortens the…" - OBSERVED | The cobra in the side compartment, priced the same way, saves 8.0 throws. | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); probe: S-up-7-low-L1 -8.0000 (saves) - OBSERVED | Change the rules in the panel and the table changes with them. | public/strata/the-waning-of-merit/app.mjs | read app.mjs; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | The meeting of 1831 heard that the souls of the good reach the Great Heaven “by two different roads : one of… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - OBSERVED | The account has not been found, so we cannot say which squares those roads were. | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/SCOUT-HISTORY.md | SCOUT-HISTORY.md 1(a): the report does not give the squares or the rules; the account itself is not found (entry dek-account) - OBSERVED | board does have two ways into square 124: the long ladder from 68 | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: L-68-124; and any throw onto 124.; agrees - CONFIRMED | which Pargiter read as “teaching that a man who attains to the excellence of loving faith in Viṣṇu proceeds a… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | p. 541 rendered at 600 dpi from the kept PDF: "Viṣṇu" with both dots; the text layer's "Visnu" is the OCR - OBSERVED | and the climb through the top compartment, the path of the gods, with no snakes on it (though its one ladder,… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | read links.json: No snake's head in 89-124; the top compartment's one ladder is the choice ladder-top, 117…; agrees - OBSERVED | Under the first settings 44.8% of the freed reach 124 up the ladder from 68, and the rest by a throw at the e… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: D.share 0.4483; ranges.share [0.0816, 0.7787].; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - OBSERVED | Under Dampier’s rule the ladder is a main road because the climb ends in a gamble; where any throw that reach… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | read figures.json: pass.share 0.0910.; the published check recomputes it (27 passed) - CONFIRMED | Which of the two was Capila’s short road and which Patanjali’s long one, if either, the board does not say. | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - OBSERVED | Every rule above is a reading. Three of the readings come from a different board, Dampier’s, described almost… | research/the-waning-of-merit/README.md | read README.md: From Dampier (1895): nine cowries, back to square 1, and snake onto snake taken (README,…; agrees - OBSERVED | The figures that change with the readings are given with the reading they belong to, and the ones that hold u… | research/the-waning-of-merit/build-page.mjs | read build-page.mjs; read the code: agrees - CONFIRMED | The 1831 report says only that there were two, of ivory, “about two inches in length, and square”. | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n95.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop asiatic-journal-ns-vol5-1831-p85-robertson-gift-passage-leaf-n95.jpg - CONFIRMED | The marking 1, 2, 5, 6 is how the long dice of chaupar and chausar are described in the sources named below;… | https://archive.org/download/chessplayingcard00culi/page/n222.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop culin1898-p825-pasa-long-dice-leaf-n222.jpg - CONFIRMED | those sources describe chaupar and chausar, played with three | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.32526/page/n365.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop ain-i-akbari-blochmann1873-vol1-p303-chaupar-dice-dli-leaf-n365.jpg - CONFIRMED | those sources describe chaupar and chausar, played with three | https://archive.org/download/gamesancientorie00falkuoft/page/n299.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop falkener1892-p264-chausar-dice-faces-leaf-n299.jpg - CONFIRMED | The photograph the Society publishes is 1,000 pixels wide. | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept record's structured data has "width":1000,"height":949 (slashes escaped, inside a script the online tool strips, hence its NOT FOUND); the copy on disk (git-ignored) is 1000 x 949, sha256 f4e10903...c438 - OBSERVED | Two readers, working apart, found the same 34 snakes and ladders on it; three of their ends were settled by j… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | recreated: links-A.json and links-B.json compared by script (34 links each, identical; Pargiter's six: 4 each); table-A/B recount 146 cells, 140 alike (9 apostrophes only), 6 differ; settled 3 (13, 60, 113 ends), choices 2 - OBSERVED | The squares are named here as Pargiter’s table prints them, keyed twice from two scans of it; nobody read the… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/DECISIONS.md | read DECISIONS.md; agrees - CONFIRMED | Pargiter says the Sanskrit on the board has “some mistakes”. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "The language is Sanskrit, with, however, some mistakes ;" - CONFIRMED | Andrew Topsfield has written on these boards (in Artibus Asiae, 1985 and 2006, and in the Society’s journal,… | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.2307/3250203 | Crossref 10.2307/3250203 (fetched 2026-11-16): Artibus Asiae 46(3), 1985, p. 203, Andrew Topsfield (the tool's NOT FOUND is the excerpt's reformatting) - CONFIRMED | Andrew Topsfield has written on these boards (in Artibus Asiae, 1985 and 2006 | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.61342/FRPQ3561 | Crossref 10.61342/FRPQ3561: Artibus Asiae 66(1), 2006, pp. 143-179 - CONFIRMED | and in the Society’s journal, online in 2021) | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1017/S1356186321000547 | Crossref 10.1017/S1356186321000547: JRAS 32(4), online 2021-09-06, print 2022-10 - CONFIRMED | Jacob Schmidt-Madsen’s doctoral thesis on gyan chaupar in western India (Copenhagen, 2019) | https://asiandynamics.ku.dk/english/calendar/game-of-knowledge | kept ku-asiandynamics-schmidt-madsen-defence-2019.html: "The Game of Knowledge Playing at Spiritual Liberation in 18…" - CONFIRMED | became a book in 2026, The Game of Knowledge (Delhi: Primus Books) | https://list.indology.info/pipermail/indology/attachments/20260819/650bda4b/attachment.pdf | kept text of the book's front matter: "PRIMUS BOOKS ... Delhi 110 009", "© Jacob Schmidt-Madsen, 2026", "First published 2026"; kept cover image: "The Game of Knowledge: Playing at Spiritual Liberation in Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Western India"; the thesis had the same title (Copenhagen event page, defended 24 May 2019) - CONFIRMED | whose contents list a chapter called “Simulation and Narrative” | https://list.indology.info/pipermail/indology/attachments/20260819/650bda4b/attachment.pdf | kept text of the contents: "5. Simulation and Narrative 173" - OBSERVED | Beyond the abstract of Topsfield’s 2021 note and the book’s front matter, we have read none of them: the jour… | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/SCOUT-HISTORY.md | SCOUT-HISTORY.md item 5: JSTOR answered with a challenge page; cambridge.org refused (robots-policy.mjs today: "it refuses AI agents acting for a person"); the Copenhagen portal refused by the helper; only the book's front matter read (kept) - OBSERVED | Two readers worked apart on the Society’s photograph, each told nothing of what the squares are called; a thi… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/DECISIONS.md | keyed/DECISIONS.md and git: links-C.json first committed 00:25 (9586ddc9e1) with PLAN.md, links-A/B 02:01 (da1da79cad); briefs/key-links.md withholds the names - OBSERVED | Each blind reader found 9 ladders and 25 snakes, and they gave the same two squares for all 34. Of the six li… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/links.json | recreated: links-A.json and links-B.json compared by script (34 links each, identical; Pargiter's six: 4 each); table-A/B recount 146 cells, 140 alike (9 apostrophes only), 6 differ - OBSERVED | Three of their ends are not taken as they read them. In two squares, 13 and 60, both put the foot of a ladder… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/DECISIONS.md | read DECISIONS.md; agrees - CONFIRMED | 12, the square Pargiter names | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | in the kept text of pp. 539-542: "There are ladders connecting certain squares, as 12 and 49,…" - OBSERVED | And both put the top of the ladder from 68 in 113, by a pixel or two. Its rails run the whole height of 113,… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/DECISIONS.md | read DECISIONS.md; agrees - CONFIRMED | Pargiter, who had the chart in front of him, says it “reaches directly up to 124”. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | p. 541: "square 68, from which a ladder reaches directly up to 124 ;" - OBSERVED | Read as 113, no soul would be freed by that ladder, and the average game under the first settings would last… | research/the-waning-of-merit/figures.json | recreated: AW_DIR=public/strata/the-waning-of-merit node verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (exit 0, 27 passed, 0 failed; --mutate 35 passed, 8 of 8 faults caught) and a probe built from the same file (prices, ranges, stuck squares); probe: byLadder 0, 262.12 throws - OBSERVED | Two links are left as choices in the panel: the snake whose head lies on the line between 19 and 2, and the d… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/decisions.json | read decisions.json; agrees - CONFIRMED | and avataraṇa is “descending” in Monier-Williams’s dictionary. | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n140.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-p99-avatarana-n140.jpg - OBSERVED | Pargiter’s table was keyed twice, blind, from two scans of it. Of its 146 cells, 140 were read alike (9 of th… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table.json | recreated: links-A.json and links-B.json compared by script (34 links each, identical; Pargiter's six: 4 each); table-A/B recount 146 cells, 140 alike (9 apostrophes only), 6 differ - OBSERVED | The reasons for every decision are in the apparatus (keyed/DECISIONS.md). | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/DECISIONS.md | read DECISIONS.md; agrees - OBSERVED | Spelled as the table prints them. Where the scans show a word printed without a mark it needs, or with a wron… | research/the-waning-of-merit/keyed/table-decisions.json | keyed/table-decisions.json; this pass read cells 6, 34, 38, 44 and side 3 on scan A at 2x: "Manusya", "cāndrāyana", "(tree from egotism", "Markatah", "Prthvi" as printed - WRONG | The Artificial Wasteland’s check for this page rebuilds the game from the rules as this page states them, wit… | verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs | the check reads the 32 figures and compares the description across five places; it does not compute the dek's "27% and 92%" or the literal figures and words "from 118 upward", "six, seven or eight", "123", "dearest", "saves", "worth", "from 46 to 44". Scratch copies of the served files with 27% changed to 37% in all five description places, "saves" changed to "costs", or "from 46 to 44" changed to "from 52 to 45" all pass (exit 0, 27 passed). Every one of those words is true today (probe) - OBSERVED | It downloads the board, the table of readings and this page, and writes nothing else. | verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (repository root) | read verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs lines 45-55: downloads index.html, board.json, readings.json into ./the-waning-of-merit-files/; nothing else written (with AW_DIR it downloads nothing) - OBSERVED | Add --mutate and it also plants faults in copies of them (a snake’s tail moved one square, a ladder taken awa… | verify-the-waning-of-merit.mjs (repository root) | recreated: --mutate run, "8 of 8 planted faults behaved as they must", among them those the page names - CONFIRMED | The gift: The Asiatic Journal and Monthly Register, new series vol. V (London, 1831), p. 85, read on the Inte… | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.500628/page/n5.jpg | title page leaf n5 fetched 2026-11-16 and read: "THE ASIATIC JOURNAL AND MONTHLY REGISTER ... VOL. V.—NEW SERIES. MAY.—AUGUST 1831. LONDON: PARBURY, ALLEN, AND CO. ... 1831." - CONFIRMED | Transactions of the Royal Asiatic Society, vol. III (London, 1835), Appendix IV, p. lxi | https://archive.org/download/transactionsofro03asia/page/n6.jpg | title page leaf n6 and p. xxxv leaf n682 fetched 2026-11-16 and read: "VOL. III. LONDON ... 1835"; "APPENDIX, No. IV. DONATIONS" - CONFIRMED | “A coloured Drawing or Plan of the Shastree’s Game of Heaven and Hell ; also two Dice, and five carved ivory… | https://archive.org/download/transactionsofro03asia/page/n708.jpg | kept crop p. lxi read word for word: "By Major HENRY DUNDAS ROBERTSON ... April 16, 1831. A coloured Drawing or Plan of the Shastree's Game of Heaven and Hell ; also two Dice, and five carved ivory Men, used in playing that Game." - CONFIRMED | The board: the Royal Asiatic Society’s collection record for RAS 051.001 | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/ras-051-001-snakes-and-ladders/ | kept ras-collections-051-001.html: "[RAS 051.001] Snakes and Ladders" - CONFIRMED | its photograph of the chart | https://royalasiaticcollections.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/051.001a-1.jpg | the record's structured data names the file; the copy on disk matches the sha256; see Findings on the copy still reachable in this checkout's remote-tracking ref - CONFIRMED | its blog post “Snakes and Ladders” of 13 July 2017. | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/snakes-and-ladders/ | kept HTML: "Snakes and Ladders 13 July 2017" (the live URL answered the online tool HTTP 409) - CONFIRMED | The key: F. E. Pargiter, “An Indian Game: Heaven or Hell”, Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, July 1916, p… | https://royalasiaticsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/an-indian-game-heaven-or-hell.pdf | Crossref: pp. 539-542; the table faces p. 539 on both IA scans (kept) - CONFIRMED | Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, July 1916 | https://www.royalasiaticarchives.org/index.php/snakes-and-ladders | kept archive record: "offprint from the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, July 1916"; Crossref issued 1916-07 - OBSERVED | read on two Internet Archive scans of the volume (dli.ministry.15639 and in.ernet.dli.2015.70563) and the cop… | research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/FETCH-LOG.tsv | FETCH-LOG.tsv rows 2, 9 and 14: the Society's PDF (195,430 bytes), scan B leaf n555 (3,513,102) and scan A leaf n555 (1,383,728) - CONFIRMED | G. R. Dampier, “A Primitive Game”, North Indian Notes and Queries, vol. V no. 2 (May 1895), pp. 25 and 26. | https://archive.org/download/ninq_v5/page/n31.jpg | kept masthead "VOL. V.] MAY, 1895. [NO. 2."; the title "22. A Primitive Game." read on the kept p. 25 crop; signed on p. 26 - CONFIRMED | The Upaniṣads: R. E. Hume, The Thirteen Principal Upanishads (Oxford University Press, 1921) | https://archive.org/download/thirteenprincipa00hume/page/n6.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop hume1921-title-page-n6.jpg - CONFIRMED | F. Max Müller, The Upanishads, Sacred Books of the East vols. I (1879) | https://archive.org/download/upanishads01ml/page/n8.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop muller-sbe1-1879-title-page-n8.jpg - CONFIRMED | Sacred Books of the East vols. I (1879) and XV (1884) | https://archive.org/download/upanishads02ml/page/n8.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop muller-sbe15-1884-title-page-n8.jpg - CONFIRMED | the Sanskrit from the Göttingen Register of Electronic Texts in Indian Languages (GRETIL), BĀU (Kāṇva) and Ch… | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-…" - CONFIRMED | BĀU (Kāṇva) and ChU, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/corpustei/transformations/plaintext/sa_chAndogyopaniSad-comm.txt | kept GRETIL lines: "Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-…" - CONFIRMED | The long dice: The Āʾīn-i Akbarī of Abū’l-Faẓl, tr. H. Blochmann, vol. I (Calcutta, 1873), p. 303 | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.32526/page/n5.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop ain-i-akbari-blochmann1873-vol1-title-page-dli-leaf-n5.jpg - CONFIRMED | Edward Falkener, Games Ancient and Oriental (London, 1892), p. 264 | https://archive.org/download/gamesancientorie00falkuoft/page/n299.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop falkener1892-p264-chausar-dice-faces-leaf-n299.jpg - CONFIRMED | Stewart Culin, Chess and Playing-Cards (Washington, 1898), pp. 825 and 855. | https://archive.org/download/chessplayingcard00culi/page/n222.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop culin1898-p825-pasa-long-dice-leaf-n222.jpg - CONFIRMED | Monier Monier-Williams, A Sanskrit-English Dictionary (Oxford, 1899), read in the 1960 reprint from the sheet… | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n9.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop mw1899-litho1960-title-verso-imprint-n9.jpg - MINOR | ahan, áhar and Ahaḥ p. 124; ahaha p. 125; mānasa p. 810; puruṣa p. 637; avataraṇa p. 99. | https://archive.org/download/sanskritenglishd00moniuoft/page/n165.jpg | the five pages are right (kept crops pp. 124, 125, 810, 637, 99), but the body also rests on Monier-Williams p. 4 (agasti, Agastya), p. 626 (pitṛ-yāṇa) and p. 646 (pṛthivī), which this list omits - CONFIRMED | Earlier mathematics: S. C. Althoen, L. King and K. Schilling, “How long is a game of snakes and ladders?”, Th… | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.2307/3619261 | Crossref 10.2307/3619261: The Mathematical Gazette 77(478), 1993-03, pp. 71-76, S.C. Althoen, L. King, K. Schilling - CONFIRMED | (read in Futility Closet’s summary, 21 September 2018) | https://www.futilitycloset.com/2018/09/21/for-what-its-worth-5/ | kept futilitycloset-2018-09-21-for-what-its-worth.html: "(S.C. Althoen, L. King, and K. Schilling, “How Long Is a Ga…" - CONFIRMED | Eleanor A. Dauenhauer and Paul J. Dauenhauer, “Quantifying the Vices and Virtues of Snakes and Ladders Throug… | https://api.crossref.org/works/10.2478/bgs-2024-0001 | Crossref 10.2478/bgs-2024-0001: Eleanor A. and Paul J. Dauenhauer, Board Game Studies Journal 18(1), 2024, pp. 1-38 (the online tool's DOI MISMATCH misreads the middle initial "A.") - CONFIRMED | The donor: The East-India Register and Directory for 1830 (second edition), Bombay, “Judges, Collectors, &c.”… | https://archive.org/download/eastindiaregister1830-2e/page/n518.jpg | kept crop p. 8 heading; archive.org item record (fetched 2026-11-16): "The East-India Register and Directory for 1830, 2nd edition" - CONFIRMED | The Bhagavad Gītā: K. T. Telang, The Bhagavadgîtâ, Sacred Books of the East vol. VIII (Oxford, 1882), pp. 80,… | https://archive.org/download/thebhagavadgaita00kaasuoft/page/n10.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop telang-sbe8-1882-title-page-n10.jpg - CONFIRMED | the Sanskrit from GRETIL’s text of the critical edition. | https://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/1_sanskr/2_epic/mbh/ext/bhgce__u.htm | kept GRETIL lines: "Text based on the BORI edition of the Mahabharata" - CONFIRMED | The Viṣṇu Purāṇa: H. H. Wilson, The Vishńu Puráńa (London, 1840), pp. 226 and 227. | https://archive.org/download/in.ernet.dli.2015.283854/page/n0.jpg | read by eye on the kept crop wilson-vp1840-title-page-n0.jpg - MINOR | plain (shown by the site's plain-words button): "Its side compartment follows an ancient text's journey of the dead square by square ... Solved under every version of the missing rules" | src/content/strata/the-waning-of-merit.md | the body says "The order holds station by station": five of the side compartment's thirteen cells are "not in this passage" and the text's "space" has no square; the page computes "every combination" of its own readings, and README.md lists rules it does not model (an entry throw; the 84-square board's ladder on a later 1) - WRONG | og:image:alt: "a side compartment at the right, red snakes and wooden ladders across them" | public/og/the-waning-of-merit.png | the card, re-shot when the snakes took their painted colours (5b6c50abeb), shows green, orange, yellow, blue, pink and brown snakes; text from research/the-waning-of-merit/page/text.json "ogAlt" - MINOR | social card text: "played and solved under every reading of its missing rules" | research/the-waning-of-merit/og/shoot-og.mjs | line 44; as the plain text above: every reading the page offers, not every reading (README.md, "Not modelled") - CONFIRMED | relates note: "That page solves a board printed for it" (the-board-that-loiters-at-sixty) | src/content/strata/the-board-that-loiters-at-sixty.md | its dek: "This page prints its own board ... then solves the chain exactly" - CONFIRMED | relates note: "A game with no decisions, asked whether it can go on for ever. Here ... a token on square 123 can never finish" | src/content/strata/the-game-that-may-never-end.md | its dek: beggar-my-neighbour, "a deal exists that never ends"; 123 confirmed by the probe - CONFIRMED | relates note: "Galileo sized Dante's hell" | src/content/strata/how-big-is-dantes-inferno.md | its dek: Galileo "lectured the Florentine Academy on exactly that" (the size of Dante's Inferno) - CONFIRMED | relates note: "that page sets Telang beside seven others on a single verse" | src/content/strata/the-act-alone.md | its dek: "Eight English versions between 1785 and 1897" of Gītā 2.47, "Telang 1882" among them ## Findings - [fixed] The check box says the check "checks every figure in the sentences above against what it found" (index.html line 573, from page/text.json line 181). It reads only the 32 span figures and whether the description matches in its five places. Scratch copies of the served files pass (exit 0, 27 passed) with the dek's 27% changed to 37% in all five description places, with "saves" changed to "costs" before the cobra's 8.0, and with "from 46 to 44" changed to "from 52 to 45". The words and figures it cannot see ("27% and 92%" in the dek, "from 118 upward", "six, seven or eight", "123", "dearest", "adds", "worth", "saves", "from 46 to 44") are all true today. Fix: narrow the sentence, or have the check read the dek's range against R.Nheaven and assert the signs and identities in the prices template (page/text.json line 178). Changed (the author, after re-reading the check): the sentence now says the check holds every figure the sentences print from the solution, with the direction their words give it, and the two figures in the description; and the check now does both: each figure whose sentence calls it a cost or a saving carries data-sign and is held to that sign, and the description's figures are named in an aw:description-figures meta tag and recomputed. Two new planted faults, "a figure in the description changed everywhere the description is stated" and "a saving made a cost in its sentence", are caught (10 of 10). - [fixed] og:image:alt says "red snakes and wooden ladders across them" (index.html line 25, from page/text.json line 4 "ogAlt"); the card (public/og/the-waning-of-merit.png, re-shot in 5b6c50abeb) shows green, orange, yellow, blue, pink and brown snakes. Fix: "snakes in their painted colours". Changed: og:image:alt now says "snakes in their painted colours and wooden ladders across them" (page/text.json ogAlt). - [fixed] The panel says two long dice are "thrown together and added, which no source describes" (index.html line 312). The scouts found none ("No source found describes ..."), but the page's own dice sources combine dice for one piece in particular throws: Āʾīn p. 303 "A throw consisting of a six, a five, and a one ... every single piece twelve fields"; Falkener p. 264 "if given to a single piece it moves only twice the throw". README.md line 79's "each die's throw used on its own" is contradicted by the same passages. Suggest "which none of these sources describes for two dice: they throw three, and add them for one piece only in particular throws". Changed: the panel now says "thrown together and added; the sources for these dice throw three, and add them for one piece only in particular throws"; README's dice paragraph now names the Ā'īn's khám and Falkener's doublets; the source record pairs the sentence with both passages. - [fixed] "carries the name the Chāndogya Upaniṣad gives that road: Devayānaḥ" (index.html line 245) is true, but BĀU 6.2.2 names both roads: "vettho devayānasya vā pathaḥ pratipadaṃ pitṛyāṇasya vā" (GRETIL sa_bRhadAraNyakopaniSadkANva-recension-comm.txt line 4121, the file the kept excerpt was cut from). The credit moved to the Chāndogya in 4c63e318a4 on the source record's note that the kept sections 6.2.15-16 do not name the road. Consider crediting the same Upaniṣad, which also names Pitṛyāṇaḥ (line 238). Changed: square 90 now "carries its name: Devayānaḥ, the word the Upanishad uses for it at the start of the chapter (6.2.2) and the Chāndogya Upaniṣad uses in words Hume translates “the way leading to the gods”", and Pitṛyāṇaḥ is "the Upanishad’s own word for it (6.2.2)"; the GRETIL text of BĀU 6.2.2 is kept as sources/texts/gretil-bau-kanva-6.2.2.excerpt.txt (fetched 2026-11-16 through tools/fetch.mjs). - [fixed] Summary texts say more than the body: the plain text (src/content/strata/the-waning-of-merit.md line 6; index.html line 134) "follows an ancient text's journey of the dead square by square" and "Solved under every version of the missing rules"; the social card (og/shoot-og.mjs line 44) and the relates note (.md line 12) "under every reading of its missing rules". The body says "station by station" and computes "every combination" of its own readings; README.md lists rules not modelled. Changed: the plain text now says "station by station" and "Solved under each reading of the missing rules it sets out"; the social card says "under every reading of its missing rules that the page sets out" (card re-rendered); the relates note says "that it sets out". - [fixed] The Sources entry for Monier-Williams (index.html line 596, page/text.json line 182) omits p. 4 (Agastya, line 289), p. 626 (pitṛ-yāṇa, line 238) and p. 646 (pṛthivī, line 234), on which body sentences rest; the crops are kept. Changed: the Monier-Williams source line now lists pp. 4, 99, 124, 125, 626, 637, 646 and 810. - [fixed] Apparatus, not the page: README.md lines 45-48 say the Society's photograph is not committed and the two work-in-progress commits holding it were rewritten. In this checkout origin/claude/serene-sagan-iwto7t (head 822ecc3a6d) still holds research/the-waning-of-merit/sources/ras/ras-051-001-photograph-1000px.jpg in four commits (4631f43d3d added it). Check whether the remote still has that branch (git ls-remote origin refs/heads/claude/serene-sagan-iwto7t), and correct "two". Changed: README now says the photograph was added in the branch's second commit and carried by the next three, all pushed to the branch on the remote, that those commits were rewritten before anything reached main, and that the rewritten branch replaces the remote one when the work lands (publish.sh pushes it). The remote branch still held the old commits when this pass ran; publishing replaces it, and the hand-off records whether it did.