--- slug: what-causes-the-seasons passed: 2026-10-14 by: the assay line (research/assay-line/cited-1014/), Codex fixer directed by claude-assaying-boyle-1014; source record by Codex, checked by Codex checked: 91 confirmed: 65 wrong: 24 unverifiable: 0 observed: 0 stale: 2 --- This was the directed cited-1014 repair pass for what-causes-the-seasons, read at 93ee4c270f. I independently re-read the evidence for all 26 triage items, reproduced the relevant page calculations, and followed the directing decisions: eight WRONG fixes, two dated metadata/interface items, and sixteen listed MINOR items left unchanged. The 65 CONFIRMED claims below carry forward Codex N2's source reread at 632d05207f, preserving its evidence and qualifications; they are not represented as a new independent audit of every source. MINOR lines count toward wrong in the frontmatter, so wrong: 24 means eight WRONG plus sixteen MINOR. The prior checker record's untriaged observations and unverifiable attributions are outside this repair pass. ## Claims - MINOR | [X1] "almost everyone" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | NASA describes a common belief without a measured near-unanimous proportion. Left as a listed rhetorical overstatement. - MINOR | [X2] "Nearly everyone" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | NASA does not quantify near unanimity. This repeats X1 and remains listed. - MINOR | [X3] "make the orbit a perfect circle and watch nothing change." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | Re-evaluating the page gives 483.031 to 498.851 W/m² at 40° N, day 172, when the orbit becomes circular. The strong seasonal cycle persists; the summary omits the smaller quantitative change. - MINOR | [X4] "make the orbit circular and nothing changes." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The Open Graph description repeats X3. The reproduced default energy changes from 483 to 499 W/m² when rounded. - MINOR | [X5] "make the orbit circular and nothing changes." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The Twitter description repeats X3. The reproduced annual maximum/minimum ratio changes from 3.098576 to 3.306696 at 40° N. - MINOR | [X6] "the seasons collapse to a flat line; make the orbit a perfect circle and nothing changes." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | Without tilt the annual ratio remains 1.069088, so flat needs a precision qualifier. The circle clause repeats X3; the directing triage lists this qualitative summary. - MINOR | [X7] "turn off the orbit's ellipticity (nothing happens)." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The markdown body repeats the circle-switch overstatement. The quantitative change is small relative to the preserved seasonal cycle. - MINOR | [X8] "turn off → circle, no distance change" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | distFactorFor returns 1 with the orbit switch off, but drawOrbit keeps ry=rx*0.78 and focus=rx*0.42. The listed issue is the illustration, not the constant-distance calculation. - MINOR | [X9] "152.1M km" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | At startup day 172 the code gives 152.027978 million km, displayed as 152.0M km. The 152.1M km static placeholder matches the July reset rather than the initial day. - MINOR | [X10] "96.7%" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | At startup the code gives 96.828797%, displayed as 96.8%. The 96.7% static placeholder is a small fallback/default mismatch. - MINOR | [X11] "15.0 h" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The initial geometric day length is 14.844361 hours, displayed as 14.8 h. The static 15.0 h placeholder is a small fallback precision mismatch. - STALE | [X12] "Reset to today (aphelion)" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html; https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | The handler selects day 187, July 6. USNO dates 2026 aphelion to July 6 at 17:30 UT; today was applicable on the publication date, not October 14. The label is now explicitly dated. - WRONG | [X13] "With tilt on, the curve swings by a factor of three between summer and winter." | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The original accessible description always said factor of three. Direct evaluation gives 3.098576 at 40° N but 1.137731 at the equator with both switches on. It now follows the selected latitude, switches, and annual ratio. - WRONG | [X14] "Tilt on, orbit elliptical:" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The original verdict kept the tilt-on and elliptical state label while recomputing for disabled switches. Its label now follows the controls; annual maximum/minimum wording covers the selectable latitudes and models. - MINOR | [X15] "never competing with it." | git show 93ee4c270f:research/seasons/verify.mjs | At the equator, tilt-only and distance-only annual swings are 35.749839 and 28.954942 W/m². The unqualified never extends the surrounding 40° N comparison too far; retained as a listed scope overstatement. - WRONG | [X16] "That page explains why spring warms at all" | git show 93ee4c270f:src/content/strata/a-thousand-springs.md | The original a-thousand-springs relation points to this seasons page. Reusing its That page sentence for the reverse card misattributes this page's explanation to Kyoto. This layer now authors a correctly directed Kyoto bloom-date relation and its card was regenerated. - MINOR | [X17] "take the myth everyone repeats" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | NASA describes a common belief, not a universal one. The relates note repeats the rhetorical overstatement in X1 and X2. - STALE | [X18] ""datePublished":"2026-07-06","dateModified":"2026-07-06"" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The JSON-LD kept July 6 despite the September 27 placard and October 1 image-alt modifications in git history. dateModified is now October 14 for this revision; datePublished remains July 6. - WRONG | [X19] "sun to the south" | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | At latitude 0 on day 172, declination is +23.438645 degrees. NWS places the June-solstice subsolar point north of the equator. The old south branch was reversed; the direction now follows latitude relative to declination. - WRONG | [X20] "sun overhead-ish" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | At 90° N on day 172, the model noon height is 23.438645 degrees, about 66.6 degrees below the zenith. The replacement reports direction and reserves overhead for a 90-degree height. - WRONG | [X21] "pole upright" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | The old axis vector always used EPS=23.44 even with tilt off. The vector now uses zero tilt when disabled, matching the upright caption and zero-declination numerical state. - MINOR | [X22] (added) "Mar 21" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | The model labels day 80, March 21, as equinox. USNO gives March 20 at 14:46 UT in 2026. The directing triage lists this one-day precision issue in the stated first-order model. - MINOR | [X23] (added) "Jul 5" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | The condition N>=186 && N<=188 labels July 5, 6 and 7 as aphelion. USNO gives July 6 at 17:30 UT. This is the listed imprecise event window. - MINOR | [X24] (added) "Jul 7" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | July 7 is the aphelion date in AEST, but the control labels three consecutive days without a time zone. This repeats the event-window issue in X23 and does not establish that July 7 is impossible locally. - WRONG | [X25] (added) "79.0×" | git show 93ee4c270f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | At 90° N the computed annual minimum is 0 and maximum 524.192989 W/m². Excluding zeros gave 79.048351. The minimum now includes zero and the verdict states that no finite ratio exists; an entirely unlit pole is also handled. - WRONG | [X26] (added) "±3.3% about the mean" | git show 93ee4c270f:research/seasons/verify.mjs | The verifier endpoints give 100*(152.0878-147.10)/(152.0878+147.10)=1.667113%. Both the source and the published reader copy now compute and print ±1.7% about the endpoint mean. - CONFIRMED | "What Causes the Seasons? It's the Tilt, Not the Distance" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [001 title-cause] NASA: "Earth's tilted axis causes the seasons." The claim concerns the dominant cause of ordinary seasonal contrasts. - CONFIRMED | "Farthest in July" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [002 farthest-july] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "Earth is farthest from the Sun in July, during northern summer." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [003 meta-july] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "Earth is farthest from the Sun during northern summer." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [004 meta-summer] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "Summer is not caused by the Earth being nearer the Sun: northern summer falls at the farthest point of the whole orbit." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [005 plain-distance] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "When it's summer in the north the Earth is at its farthest point of the whole orbit." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [008 dek-north] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "When it's summer in New York, London, and Tokyo, the Earth is at its farthest point of the entire orbit." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [009 intro-cities] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "Earth is closest to the Sun in January and farthest in July" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [010 intro-closest] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "the very day Earth reached aphelion" | https://earthsky.org/astronomy-essentials/earth-farthest-from-sun-for-year-in-early-july/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [012 aphelion-day] EarthSky: "at 12:30 p.m. CDT (17:30 UTC) on July 6." and "Earth will be 94,502,961 miles (152,087,774 km) from the sun." USNO independently gives "Aphelion", "2026 July 6", "17:30". - CONFIRMED | "its greatest distance from the Sun all year, in the middle of northern summer." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [013 aphelion-definition] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "The real cause is the 23.4° tilt of Earth's axis" | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [014 intro-tilt] NASA Earth Fact Sheet: "Obliquity to orbit (deg) 23.44". Rounded to 23.4 degrees where appropriate. NASA Space Place independently establishes causation. - CONFIRMED | "The cause is the 23.4° tilt of the axis" | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [015 plain-tilt] NASA Earth Fact Sheet: "Obliquity to orbit (deg) 23.44". Rounded to 23.4 degrees where appropriate. NASA Space Place independently establishes causation. - CONFIRMED | "the seasons are caused by Earth's axial tilt, not by its changing distance from the Sun." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [016 body-cause] NASA: "Earth's tilted axis causes the seasons." The claim concerns the dominant cause of ordinary seasonal contrasts. - CONFIRMED | "the axis keeps a fixed direction in space" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [031 axis-fixed] NASA: "As Earth orbits the Sun, its tilted axis always points in the same direction." It also distinguishes the North Pole leaning toward the Sun around June and the South Pole around December. Fixed direction is the stated single-year approximation. - CONFIRMED | "Earth's rotation axis points the same direction in space all year, so the northern hemisphere leans toward the Sun near July's aphelion and away near January's perihelion." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [032 orbit-aria] NASA: "As Earth orbits the Sun, its tilted axis always points in the same direction." It also distinguishes the North Pole leaning toward the Sun around June and the South Pole around December. Fixed direction is the stated single-year approximation. - CONFIRMED | "Top-down view of Earth's orbit around the Sun." | git show 632d05207f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [033 orbit-overhead] drawOrbit() draws the Sun and positions around an ellipse, with a constant axis direction. This is a schematic overhead illustration with deliberately exaggerated eccentricity. It does not supply accurate scale or a separate measured orbit. - CONFIRMED | "Day of year June 21" / "solstice" | git show 632d05207f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html; https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [034 day-labels] The static span says "June 21" and the script supplies "Jun 21" with "solstice". USNO gives "Solstice", "2026 June 21", "08:24" in UT. - CONFIRMED | "which for the north peaks in January." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [052 verdict-january] NASA: "aphelion (when Earth is farthest from the Sun) occurs in July, and perihelion (when we are closest) occurs in January." Northern summer includes aphelion; the orbit does not remain at its maximum throughout summer. - CONFIRMED | "The seasons are the tilt." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [053 verdict-cause] NASA: "Earth's tilted axis causes the seasons." The claim concerns the dominant cause of ordinary seasonal contrasts. - CONFIRMED | "a faint ripple of a few percent that, for the Northern Hemisphere, is strongest in January, the depth of winter." | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [055 distance-ripple] NASA Milankovitch article: "about 6.8 percent more incoming solar radiation reaches Earth than it does each July." The page's more precise 2026 constants independently give (152.0878/147.10)^2 - 1 = 0.06896481344, which rounds to 6.9%. This is a justified rounding/input difference, not a contradiction. - CONFIRMED | "One switch controls the seasons." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [057 one-switch] NASA: "Earth's tilted axis causes the seasons." The claim concerns the dominant cause of ordinary seasonal contrasts. - CONFIRMED | "other barely matters" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [058 distance-unimportant] NASA: "While that is a difference of over 3 million miles, relative to the entire distance, it isn’t much." The fact sheet gives eccentricity 0.0167. The claim is supported in the page's ordinary midlatitude seasonal comparison. - CONFIRMED | "The tilt changes sunlight two ways at once, and they compound." | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [059 two-effects] NWS: "For every place north of the Tropic of Cancer, the sun is at its highest point in the sky and this is the longest day of the year." The source also states that winter solstice has the shortest day. The explanation applies to the midlatitude example, with tropical qualifications supplied by the source. - CONFIRMED | "In your summer, your hemisphere leans toward the Sun, so the noon Sun climbs higher" | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [060 summer-higher] NWS: "For every place north of the Tropic of Cancer, the sun is at its highest point in the sky and this is the longest day of the year." The source also states that winter solstice has the shortest day. The explanation applies to the midlatitude example, with tropical qualifications supplied by the source. - CONFIRMED | "its rays strike the ground closer to straight-on instead of smearing across a slanted surface" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [061 direct-rays] NASA: "the Sun's rays hit that part of Earth more directly than at any other time of the year." This supports the geometric concentration of sunlight on a horizontal surface. - CONFIRMED | "the day is longer, so that stronger sunlight falls for more hours." | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [062 longer-days] NWS: "For every place north of the Tropic of Cancer, the sun is at its highest point in the sky and this is the longest day of the year." The source also states that winter solstice has the shortest day. The explanation applies to the midlatitude example, with tropical qualifications supplied by the source. - CONFIRMED | "High sun × long day is summer. Low sun × short day is winter." | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [063 summer-winter] NWS: "For every place north of the Tropic of Cancer, the sun is at its highest point in the sky and this is the longest day of the year." The source also states that winter solstice has the shortest day. The explanation applies to the midlatitude example, with tropical qualifications supplied by the source. - CONFIRMED | "a factor of three, all from the tilt." | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [065 all-from-tilt] The computed ratio is 3.099 with distance variation, versus 3.307 with a circular orbit. Tilt supplies the large summer-over-winter contrast; the distance effect reduces it. Read as the source of the large contrast, "all from the tilt" is supported, not an assertion that eccentricity has zero effect. - CONFIRMED | "The distance, meanwhile, varies the total sunlight by only about 6.9% across the year" | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [066 distance-percent] NASA Milankovitch article: "about 6.8 percent more incoming solar radiation reaches Earth than it does each July." The page's more precise 2026 constants independently give (152.0878/147.10)^2 - 1 = 0.06896481344, which rounds to 6.9%. This is a justified rounding/input difference, not a contradiction. - CONFIRMED | "its off-roundness is about 1 part in 60" | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [067 eccentricity] NASA Earth Fact Sheet: "Orbit eccentricity 0.0167". 1/60 = 0.0166667, so the stated approximation is sound. - CONFIRMED | "the orbit is very nearly a circle" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [068 nearly-circle] NASA: "While that is a difference of over 3 million miles, relative to the entire distance, it isn’t much." The fact sheet gives eccentricity 0.0167. The claim is supported in the page's ordinary midlatitude seasonal comparison. - CONFIRMED | "Earth happens to be closest in January, that small effect actually makes northern winters a touch milder and southern summers a touch fiercer" | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [069 milder-fiercer] NASA: "This makes Southern Hemisphere summers hotter and moderates Northern Hemisphere seasonal variations." This is the insolation contribution, not a claim that southern surface summers are globally hotter regardless of ocean area. - CONFIRMED | "Q = (S₀/π)·(a/r)²·[H₀·sinφ·sinδ + cosφ·cosδ·sinH₀]" | https://www.atmos.albany.edu/facstaff/brose/classes/ATM623_Spring2015/Notes/Lectures/Lecture11%20--%20Insolation.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [072 formula] Albany Lecture 11, "Daily average insolation", gives the same S0/pi, inverse-square distance factor, and hour-angle expression. This verifies the formula independently of the repository; it does not verify the Hartmann equation number. - CONFIRMED | "the pole in midsummer out-receives the equator (24-hour daylight)." | https://av.tib.eu/api/v0/videos/16204/transcription/498040 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [076 pole-more] TIB automatic transcript at 00:16:47.430 says "524 watts per square meter at the North Pole during the summer solstice,". The recreated equator value that day is 384.865 W/m²; the model gives 24-hour polar daylight. The transcript is machine generated, as the source record correctly states. - CONFIRMED | "Perihelion vs aphelion sunlight → +6.9%, peaking in January for the north" | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [078 peri-aphelion-flux] NASA Milankovitch article: "about 6.8 percent more incoming solar radiation reaches Earth than it does each July." The page's more precise 2026 constants independently give (152.0878/147.10)^2 - 1 = 0.06896481344, which rounds to 6.9%. This is a justified rounding/input difference, not a contradiction. - CONFIRMED | "Full computation, sources, and the honest limits: research/seasons/verify.mjs and research/seasons/facts.md." | git show 632d05207f:research/seasons/facts.md | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [080 full-computation] Both named files exist at the pin. facts.md has sections "Orbital constants", "Cross-checks that pin the formula", and "What the page does NOT claim / honest limits". This verifies availability and subject matter, not every attribution in that file. - CONFIRMED | "S₀ = 1361 W/m² (Kopp & Lean 2011)" | https://www.atmosp.physics.utoronto.ca/people/strong/phy392/Kopp_Lean_solar_irradiance_GRL_38_L01706_2011.pdf | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [081 solar-constant] Opened the PDF after a local TLS-chain failure using curl -k, then pdftotext. Page 1 says "Greg Kopp" and "Judith L. Lean", "published 14 January 2011", and "1360.8 ± 0.5 W m" with exponent -2. The page's 1361 is a proper rounding of the paper's 2008 solar-minimum estimate. - CONFIRMED | "tilt 23.44°" | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [082 tilt-constant] NASA Earth Fact Sheet: "Obliquity to orbit (deg) 23.44". Rounded to 23.4 degrees where appropriate. NASA Space Place independently establishes causation. - CONFIRMED | "aphelion 152.09M km on 6 Jul 2026 (EarthSky / In-The-Sky.org)" | https://earthsky.org/astronomy-essentials/earth-farthest-from-sun-for-year-in-early-july/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [083 aphelion-constant] EarthSky: "at 12:30 p.m. CDT (17:30 UTC) on July 6." and "Earth will be 94,502,961 miles (152,087,774 km) from the sun." USNO independently gives "Aphelion", "2026 July 6", "17:30". - CONFIRMED | "perihelion 147.10M km (NASA)." | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [084 perihelion-constant] NASA Earth Fact Sheet: "Perihelion (106 km) 147.095". Rounded to two decimal places in millions of kilometres, this is 147.10. - CONFIRMED | "Real surface temperature lags the sunlight by weeks (why the hottest days come after the June solstice, not on it)" | https://www.weather.gov/cle/seasons | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [087 temperature-lag] NWS: "There is a lag between the longest day of the year and the warmest average temperatures for most mid and high-latitude locations." It gives "nearly 3 weeks later in mid-July" for northern Ohio and northwest Pennsylvania. This supports the typical northern seasonal lag, not the date of every individual hot day. - CONFIRMED | "is shaped by oceans, air, and reflectivity." | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/; https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/climate-and-earths-energy-budget/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [088 temperature-controls] The two record excerpts separately cover reflection and ocean heat capacity, but do not individually establish the complete three-part claim. Supplemental NASA energy-budget source states "The atmosphere and ocean work non-stop to even out solar heating imbalances" and discusses surface reflection and greenhouse warming. The full claim is supported after supplementation. - CONFIRMED | "is shaped by oceans, air, and reflectivity." | https://starchild.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/StarChild/questions/question53.html; https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/climate-and-earths-energy-budget/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [089 temperature-oceans] The two record excerpts separately cover reflection and ocean heat capacity, but do not individually establish the complete three-part claim. Supplemental NASA energy-budget source states "The atmosphere and ocean work non-stop to even out solar heating imbalances" and discusses surface reflection and greenhouse warming. The full claim is supported after supplementation. - CONFIRMED | "Berger (1978), insolation" | https://web.elic.ucl.ac.be/index.php?id=83 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [096 berger-reference] The author's institutional bibliography states "Berger A., 1978. Long-term variations of daily insolation and Quaternary climatic changes. J. Atmos. Sc., 35(12), 2362-2367." This confirms the reference. - CONFIRMED | "Kopp & Lean (2011), solar constant" | https://www.atmosp.physics.utoronto.ca/people/strong/phy392/Kopp_Lean_solar_irradiance_GRL_38_L01706_2011.pdf | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [097 kopp-reference] Opened the PDF after a local TLS-chain failure using curl -k, then pdftotext. Page 1 says "Greg Kopp" and "Judith L. Lean", "published 14 January 2011", and "1360.8 ± 0.5 W m" with exponent -2. The page's 1361 is a proper rounding of the paper's 2008 solar-minimum estimate. - CONFIRMED | "NASA Earth Fact Sheet (orbit)" | https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [098 nasa-reference] The cited official page is headed "Earth Fact Sheet" and includes "Orbital parameters" with the constants used. - CONFIRMED | "EarthSky and In-The-Sky.org (aphelion 2026)." | https://in-the-sky.org/news.php?id=20260706_07_100 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [099 sky-reference] In-The-Sky prints "Tue, 07 Jul 2026 at 03:30 AEST" and "17:30 UTC". This is July 6 in UTC, consistent with EarthSky and USNO. The source record correctly distinguishes local and UTC dates. - CONFIRMED | "Two instruments, one orbital model." | git show 632d05207f:public/strata/the-suns-crooked-clock/index.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [106 two-instruments] The sibling computes an equation-of-time model using eccentricity and obliquity; seasons computes insolation from the same Earth-orbit ingredients. The implementations differ in approximation and are not a shared software module. "one orbital model" is read as the same physical system. - CONFIRMED | "Both turn on the 23.4° axial tilt." | git show 632d05207f:src/content/strata/the-star-that-wont-stay-north.md | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [107 both-tilt] The sibling frontmatter says "Earth's axis leans 23.4°". Its subject is axial precession; the seasons page uses EPS=23.44. The shared tilt is supported. - CONFIRMED | "There the tilt slowly swings around a circle (precession, moving the pole star);" | https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/climate-science/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [108 precession-note] NASA: "The trend in the direction of this wobble relative to the fixed positions of stars is known as axial precession." The same source describes changing pole stars. This supports the long-term distinction from the single-year seasons model. - CONFIRMED | "here it stays fixed in space across a single year, leaning toward the Sun in July and away in January" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [109 fixed-year-note] NASA: "As Earth orbits the Sun, its tilted axis always points in the same direction." It also distinguishes the North Pole leaning toward the Sun around June and the South Pole around December. Fixed direction is the stated single-year approximation. - CONFIRMED | "here they set the seasons, there they bend clock-time into the analemma." | https://maths.ucd.ie/~plynch/Publications/Analemma-BIMS.pdf | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [110 analemma-note] Opened the PDF and read section 5: "We now combine the effects of eccentricity (1) and obliquity (3)". It then constructs the analemma from the accumulated time difference and solar declination. - CONFIRMED | "then refute it by recomputing the real physics live and showing the numbers point the other way." | git show 632d05207f:src/content/strata/moon-cannonball.md | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [111 sibling-method] The sibling describes a simulator integrating "velocity-Verlet on F = G·M·m/r²" and checking orbital and surface accelerations. This supports the shared method of recalculating physical quantities to address a misconception. - CONFIRMED | "just as the 'tallest mountain' answer comes from which datum" | git show 632d05207f:src/content/strata/is-everest-the-tallest-mountain.md | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [113 datum-neighbor] The sibling distinguishes "Highest above sea level", "Tallest base to peak", and "Farthest from Earth's centre". That directly supports the claim that the answer depends on the chosen datum. - CONFIRMED | ""distance makes the seasons"" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [114 distance-slogan] NASA supports the common misconception with "Many people believe that Earth is closer to the Sun in the summer". The page presents a slogan, not words attributed verbatim to NASA. The record's kind="quote" and quote field are inappropriate: neither slogan occurs in NASA's text, while the control "Many people believe" does. No page misquotation is established. - CONFIRMED | "'closer means summer'" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [115 closer-slogan] NASA supports the common misconception with "Many people believe that Earth is closer to the Sun in the summer". The page presents a slogan, not words attributed verbatim to NASA. The record's kind="quote" and quote field are inappropriate: neither slogan occurs in NASA's text, while the control "Many people believe" does. No page misquotation is established. - CONFIRMED | "'no gravity in space'" | https://www.nasa.gov/learning-resources/for-kids-and-students/what-is-microgravity-grades-5-8/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [116 gravity-slogan] NASA: "Some people think that there is no gravity in space." The quoted short misconception is a genuine substring, and the page uses it as a slogan without attributing a speaker. - CONFIRMED | "This markdown file exists so the layer appears on the ground and in the sitemap; its body is not rendered." | git show 632d05207f:src/content/strata/what-causes-the-seasons.md; git show 632d05207f:src/pages/strata/[...slug].astro; git show 632d05207f:src/pages/sitemap.xml.ts; git show 632d05207f:src/pages/index.astro | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [119 markdown-role] Supplemental pinned code confirms the claim: src/pages/strata/[...slug].astro filters out entries with href; src/pages/index.astro includes non-draft collection entries; src/pages/sitemap.xml.ts uses s.data.href for their URL. The record's self-description alone would not establish build behavior. - CONFIRMED | "aphelion (Jul)" | git show 632d05207f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [128 canvas-aphelion] The labels identify the correct months. NASA independently says aphelion occurs in July and perihelion in January. The cartoon places them alongside the solstice sides and is approximate, as its code comments disclose. - CONFIRMED | "perihelion (Jan)" | git show 632d05207f:public/strata/what-causes-the-seasons/index.html | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [129 canvas-perihelion] The labels identify the correct months. NASA independently says aphelion occurs in July and perihelion in January. The cartoon places them alongside the solstice sides and is approximate, as its code comments disclose. - CONFIRMED | (added) "Jan 3" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [calendar-perihelion] Calendar label is paired with "perihelion". USNO: "Perihelion", "2026 January 3", "17:15". - CONFIRMED | (added) "Sep 23" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [calendar-september] Calendar label is paired with "equinox". USNO: "Equinox", "2026 September 23", "00:05" UT. - CONFIRMED | (added) "Dec 21" | https://aa.usno.navy.mil/calculated/seasons?dst=false&tz=0.00&tz_label=false&tz_sign=-1&year=2026 | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [calendar-december] Calendar label is paired with "solstice". USNO: "Solstice", "2026 December 21", "20:50" UT. - CONFIRMED | (added) "Jun · N summer" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [canvas-northern-summer] NASA: "It is summer in June in the Northern Hemisphere". This checks the canvas month/hemisphere anchor. - CONFIRMED | (added) "Dec · N winter" | https://spaceplace.nasa.gov/seasons/en/ | Carried forward from N2 source reread: [canvas-northern-winter] NASA: "It is winter in December in the Northern Hemisphere". This checks the canvas month/hemisphere anchor. ## Findings - [declined] X1, listed MINOR, unchanged: NASA describes a common belief without a measured near-unanimous proportion. Left as a listed rhetorical overstatement. Directing triage reason: The checker quotes NASA as saying "Many people believe", with no measured proportion supporting "almost everyone". Retain MINOR for the rhetorical overstatement of prevalence and list under tier C. This sentence is separate from the dek sentence about the switches. - [declined] X2, listed MINOR, unchanged: NASA does not quantify near unanimity. This repeats X1 and remains listed. Directing triage reason: The checker quotes NASA as saying "Many people believe". That supports a common misconception but supplies no basis for near unanimity. Retain MINOR for the rhetorical degree of prevalence and list under tier C; this repeats X1. - [declined] X3, listed MINOR, unchanged: Re-evaluating the page gives 483.031 to 498.851 W/m² at 40° N, day 172, when the orbit becomes circular. The strong seasonal cycle persists; the summary omits the smaller quantitative change. Directing triage reason: I read the pinned index.html at 632d05207f, lines 8, 331-350 and 505-536, and evaluated its physics functions. At 40 degrees N on day 172, switching to a circle changes 483 to 499 W/m² and the annual ratio from 3.1 to 3.3. The strong tilt-driven seasonal cycle remains. In this qualitative summary, "nothing change" is loose wording for the preservation of that cycle, omitting the small quantitative change. Retain MINOR and list under tier C; X4-X7 repeat this overstatement. - [declined] X4, listed MINOR, unchanged: The Open Graph description repeats X3. The reproduced default energy changes from 483 to 499 W/m² when rounded. Directing triage reason: The pinned index.html, line 20, repeats X3 in the Open Graph description. I read its physics and update code and reproduced 483 W/m² with the elliptical orbit and 499 W/m² with a circle at the default setting. The seasonal cycle persists; the wording omits its small change in amplitude. Retain MINOR and list under tier C, using the same error label as X3. - [declined] X5, listed MINOR, unchanged: The Twitter description repeats X3. The reproduced annual maximum/minimum ratio changes from 3.098576 to 3.306696 at 40° N. Directing triage reason: The pinned index.html, line 28, repeats X3 in the Twitter description. Evaluating the code gives an annual maximum/minimum ratio of 3.1 with the elliptical orbit and 3.3 with a circle at 40 degrees N. This is the same loose description of an essentially preserved seasonal cycle. Retain MINOR and list under tier C. - [declined] X6, listed MINOR, unchanged: Without tilt the annual ratio remains 1.069088, so flat needs a precision qualifier. The circle clause repeats X3; the directing triage lists this qualitative summary. Directing triage reason: I read src/content/strata/what-causes-the-seasons.md:4 and the pinned page physics at 632d05207f. With tilt off and distance variation retained, the annual maximum/minimum ratio is 1.06908755, so "flat" needs the precision qualifier "nearly". Making the orbit circular leaves the strong seasonal cycle but changes the default energy from 483 to 499 W/m². Retain MINOR for this qualitative summary and list under tier C. The circle clause repeats X3-X5 and X7. - [declined] X7, listed MINOR, unchanged: The markdown body repeats the circle-switch overstatement. The quantitative change is small relative to the preserved seasonal cycle. Directing triage reason: I read src/content/strata/what-causes-the-seasons.md:23-28 at 632d05207f and evaluated the page physics. "nothing happens" omits the small change from 483 to 499 W/m² and from a 3.1 to a 3.3 annual ratio at 40 degrees N, while the tilt-driven seasonal cycle persists. Retain MINOR for the loose summary and list under tier C, sharing the X3-X6 error label. - [declined] X8, listed MINOR, unchanged: distFactorFor returns 1 with the orbit switch off, but drawOrbit keeps ry=rx*0.78 and focus=rx*0.42. The listed issue is the illustration, not the constant-distance calculation. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:161-163, 349, 379-388 and 515-519. The numerical claim is correct: "distFactorFor" returns 1 with the orbit off and the distance readout becomes a constant 149.6M km. The note nevertheless establishes a minor mismatch in the accompanying illustration: "ry=rx*0.78" and "focus=rx*0.42" are unconditional, so its exaggerated ellipse remains. Retain MINOR and list that illustration mismatch under tier C; the constant-distance calculation is supported. - [declined] X9, listed MINOR, unchanged: At startup day 172 the code gives 152.027978 million km, displayed as 152.0M km. The 152.1M km static placeholder matches the July reset rather than the initial day. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:148, 169, 515-518 and 559-566. The static placeholder is 152.1M km, while startup calls update() for day 172 and produces 152.0M km. The checker also identifies 152.1 as the July reset value. Retain MINOR for this small fallback/default precision mismatch and list under tier C; the live calculation uses the selected date. - [declined] X10, listed MINOR, unchanged: At startup the code gives 96.828797%, displayed as 96.8%. The 96.7% static placeholder is a small fallback/default mismatch. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:148, 171, 349, 519 and 559-566. The static 96.7% placeholder is immediately replaced at startup by 96.8% for day 172, as reproduced from the code. Retain MINOR for the small fallback/default mismatch and list under tier C. - [declined] X11, listed MINOR, unchanged: The initial geometric day length is 14.844361 hours, displayed as 14.8 h. The static 15.0 h placeholder is a small fallback precision mismatch. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:148-152, 175, 344-348 and 525-526. Its geometric day-length calculation gives 14.8 h for the initial 40 degrees N, June 21 setting; the static placeholder is 15.0 h. Retain MINOR for the fallback precision mismatch and list under tier C. The live readout is updated by the calculation. - [dated] X12: Replaced today with 6 July 2026, preserving the reset date; added one Updated 2026-10-14 line explaining when today applied and naming the assay line, mirrored in markdown. - [fixed] X13: Replaced the fixed factor-of-three chart description with a description driven by the latitude, switch states, and annual ratio; added the chart Corrected notice in HTML and markdown. - [fixed] X14: Made the verdict name the selected tilt and orbit states and compare annual extrema; added the verdict Corrected notice with X25 in HTML and markdown. - [declined] X15, listed MINOR, unchanged: At the equator, tilt-only and distance-only annual swings are 35.749839 and 28.954942 W/m². The unqualified never extends the surrounding 40° N comparison too far; retained as a listed scope overstatement. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:216-222 and research/seasons/verify.mjs:82-101, and evaluated the shared physics at the equator. Tilt-only and distance-only annual swings are about 35.750 and 28.955 W/m² there. The surrounding explanation establishes the much larger tilt effect at 40 degrees N, but "never competing" extends that qualitative comparison without a latitude qualifier. Retain MINOR for this loose scope and list under tier C. This prose sentence is separate from the verdict and Sun-label sentences being fixed. - [fixed] X16: Added this layer's own Kyoto bloom-date relation and regenerated only its nearby block using the unchanged generator in an isolated temporary tree; added the nearby-link Corrected notice in HTML and markdown. - [declined] X17, listed MINOR, unchanged: NASA describes a common belief, not a universal one. The relates note repeats the rhetorical overstatement in X1 and X2. Directing triage reason: The checker quotes NASA as saying "Many people believe", which gives no support for the universal "everyone repeats". Retain MINOR for the rhetorical prevalence overstatement and list under tier C, sharing the label used for X1 and X2. - [dated] X18: Set JSON-LD dateModified to 2026-10-14 and preserved datePublished. This is the explicit metadata exception in the directing instructions; the other notices date the revision, with no separate Updated line for this field. - [fixed] X19: Corrected north/south logic using observer latitude and solar declination; added the Sun-readout Corrected notice with X20 in HTML and markdown. - [fixed] X20: Removed overhead-ish and report overhead only at a 90-degree model noon height; added the Sun-readout Corrected notice with X19 in HTML and markdown. - [fixed] X21: Made the drawn axis upright when tilt is off and updated its accessible description; added the drawn-axis Corrected notice in HTML and markdown. - [declined] X22, listed MINOR, unchanged: The model labels day 80, March 21, as equinox. USNO gives March 20 at 14:46 UT in 2026. The directing triage lists this one-day precision issue in the stated first-order model. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:352-359 and its first-order-model qualification at 255-256, and fetched the USNO 2026 table: "Equinox | 2026 March 20 | 14:46" in Universal Time. The generic day-of-year control places its equinox marker at day 80, March 21. Retain MINOR for this one-day calendar precision issue in the approximate model and list under tier C; an eventual refinement can identify the marker as approximate or provide a year and time zone. - [declined] X23, listed MINOR, unchanged: The condition N>=186 && N<=188 labels July 5, 6 and 7 as aphelion. USNO gives July 6 at 17:30 UT. This is the listed imprecise event window. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:354-359 and fetched the USNO 2026 table, which gives aphelion on July 6 at 17:30 Universal Time. The condition "N>=186&&N<=188" marks July 5, 6 and 7 alike. Retain MINOR for the loose near-event calendar marker in the stated first-order model and list under tier C. The three-day band needs an approximate or near-aphelion qualifier; it is not three separate aphelion events. X24 is the same error. - [declined] X24, listed MINOR, unchanged: July 7 is the aphelion date in AEST, but the control labels three consecutive days without a time zone. This repeats the event-window issue in X23 and does not establish that July 7 is impossible locally. Directing triage reason: I read pinned index.html:354-359 and fetched the USNO 2026 table: aphelion is July 6 at 17:30 Universal Time. July 7 is valid in AEST, but the control uses the same aphelion label for July 5, 6 and 7 without a time zone. The supported concern is the imprecise three-day event window, shared with X23. Retain MINOR and list under tier C; this does not establish that July 7 is an impossible local date for the event. - [fixed] X25: Included zero minima and replaced the finite polar multiplier with an explicit no-finite-ratio explanation, also handling zero sunlight throughout the year; added the verdict Corrected notice with X14 in HTML and markdown. - [fixed] X26: Derived the printed half-range percentage from the existing distance endpoints in research/seasons/verify.mjs and refreshed public/checks/research/seasons/verify.mjs; added the numerical-check Corrected notice in HTML and markdown.