The Artificial Wasteland · an idea, registered before the evidence, then tested

Each Devouring the Tail of Another

Is the serpent biting its own tail a poor drawing of a woven knot of many snakes, each devouring the tail of another? We wrote down what would count before reading a single source, then read four thousand years of the record. Rings of several serpents are real, in traditions that never met. But the oldest securely dated rings are single snakes, no early text describes the woven knot, and the first writers we found who read the single ring as more than one serpent were alchemists of the seventeenth century.

The serpent with its tail in its mouth is one of the oldest pictures people still draw. This page tests an idea about it, put to the site by the person who keeps it: that the emblem is a fairly poor visual representation of an imagined vision involving a sort of woven knot of many snakes, each devouring the tail of another.

Here whoever proposes a subject never chooses the verdict. So before a single source was opened, the idea was written down as three claims the record could bear out or not, with five predictions and the only words the verdicts would be allowed to use. Then eighteen Claude agents, each holding one province of the record, read it in the original languages where they could, from a spell carved in a pyramid to a program that prints itself. The registration is reproduced at the foot of the page, as it was before the first source came back. The history of the single ring has a page of its own, Its Tail in Its Mouth.

First, though, the idea can be made exact, and played with.

One serpent, or many

Every ring the agents found was sorted into one of eight forms, fixed in the registration before they began, or left between two of them where the evidence would not decide. The idea under test is S3: several serpents, woven, each with another’s tail.

The pit

“Each devouring the tail of another” is already a precise rule. Each snake takes exactly one tail, and each tail is taken by exactly one snake. Nothing else is fixed, so let chance decide whose, and let it sometimes hand a snake its own tail: the pit relaxes “another”, so that the emblem’s own ring can turn up in it. Whatever chance does, the snakes end up in closed rings: follow any snake to the one whose tail it holds, then to the one whose tail that one holds, and you must come back to where you started, because no tail is held twice. A mathematician calls such a matching a permutation, and the rings its cycles.

A pit of snakes, one night

twelve snakes

Three facts about the pit, which the instrument recomputes as you move the slider. The number of rings is on average 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + … + 1/n, the harmonic number, which grows only like the logarithm of n: a pit of a thousand snakes makes about seven and a half rings. The emblem’s own ring, one snake with its own tail, turns up on average exactly once, whatever the size of the pit: each snake takes its own tail with chance 1/n, and there are n of them. And one ring is usually far bigger than the rest: on about two nights in three, the largest holds more than half the snakes. On average it holds a share that settles towards 0.6243 as the pit grows, the Golomb–Dickman constant, whose limit Shepp and Lloyd proved in 1966.

All of this depends on snakes having a head and a tail. Pieces of string have two ends alike, and any end can be tied to any end. Tie them at random and the pit makes fewer loops, 1 + 1/3 + 1/5 + … + 1/(2n − 1) on average, and a single loop far more often: with eight pieces the chance is 2048/6435, about one in three, against one in eight for eight snakes. Nicholas Pippenger, who worked both out side by side, called the string version random cyclations.

The weave

Rings are not yet a knot. Whether the rings pass over and under one another is a second choice, separate from who bites whom, and the emblem shows none of it. The weave below lays snakes along a band that winds round a centre. Choose how many tracks run side by side across the band, how many times the pattern repeats round the ring, and how many snakes share each closed strand, each with the tail of the next in its mouth. Where two tracks cross, the strand either goes over and then under in turn, as in a plait, a basket’s rim or the sailor’s Turk’s head knot, or always passes over, as rope does when it is coiled round a ring.

Weave a ring of snakes

one
one
one
At a crossing

The readout counts the closed strands, which always number the greatest common divisor of tracks and repeats. It names the knot from the table of all 249 prime knots of up to ten crossings that this site checked for another layer, and says so plainly when a weave lies beyond that table, or when its one invariant here, the Alexander polynomial, matches a knot without proving it is that knot. Three tracks plaited twice round make the figure-eight knot; three times round, the Borromean rings; four times, the knot 818; five times, 10123.

The Borromean rings are the strangest member of the family. Three snakes, each with its own tail, can be woven so that no two of them are linked and yet the three cannot be pulled apart: lift any one away and the other two fall free. The chemist Alexander Crum Brown gave them their name in 1885, in a footnote saying the rings occur in the armorial bearings of the Italian family Borromeo.

An engraved figure of three interlaced rings: each passes over one of the others and under the other; lettered Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 of Alexander Crum Brown’s paper “On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces”, in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, vol. 13 (1884-1886), p. 383: three rings, no two of them linked, that cannot be pulled apart. where it comes from

What the plain ring forgets

Draw any weave the way the emblem draws, one snake and one ring, and three things go. Which snake is which: many become one. The crossings: a knot becomes a circle. And every closed strand but one: a link becomes a single loop. These are exactly the things a mathematician uses to tell woven rings apart: how many strands there are, the knot of each, and how they are linked. A plain circle keeps none of them.

The ring you wove, drawn the way the emblem would draw it

In that strict sense the emblem is indeed a thin picture of any woven ring of snakes. Whether anyone ever saw or drew the woven ring first, and the single ring after it, is a question for the record.

The record

The census below holds every witness the eighteen provinces found with more than one creature in one closed figure, in the order of the dates the catalogue gives them, some only by period; those it could not date at all come last. Some are birds, beasts or monkeys rather than serpents, and the card says so.

The census holds 60 witnesses: 27 of form S2 (3 of them marked S2? by the catalogue, tall tales whose words do not say tail or ring), 5 of S3, 23 of S4 and 5 of S7.

The registration set a positive control: if the alchemical figures of two beasts biting each other’s tails exist, the same search must find them, or its zeros are worth nothing. It found them. In a German alchemical book printed at Erfurt in 1735, a winged, crowned dragon has in its open mouth the tail of a second, wingless dragon, which holds the first one’s tail in turn.

The oldest object in the census is a bitumen plaque from the temple of Ninhursag at Susa, in Elam, where two intertwined serpents with their tails in their mouths appear above the upraised hands. Its catalogue dates it to the middle of the third millennium BC, on the basis of the treatment of the two main figures: by style. Paul Toscanne, drawing it in 1911, wrote of deux serpents enlacés qui se mordent la queue, which can mean each its own tail or each the other’s. Traced region by region on the best image we could lawfully read, each serpent closes on its own tail and the two loops are linked, like Solomon’s knot: form S4, or S3 if each held the other’s. Sigmund Oehrl counts it among the earliest true ouroboroi.

From the same site, a small undated terracotta table has serpents round a rosette, and l’un d’eux mord la queue de l’autre: one of them bites the other’s tail. In Scotland, a carved stone at Meigle has three serpents bent round spirally, so that each serpent bites the tail of the next one to it. On the foot of the Tassilo chalice, at Kremsmünster, three snakes form a triquetra and, in Oehrl’s words, sich gegenseitig in die Schwanzspitze beißen, bite one another in the tail tip. At the hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life, as Waddell described it in 1892, a pig, a cock and a snake each hold the next one’s tail. In the Americas, a stone disk from the Black Warrior River in Alabama has two horned rattlesnakes knotted, forming a circle, and on the Aztec Sun Stone two serpents run round the rim from a square at the top to the bottom, where their two heads meet.

And in American newspapers from the 1830s to the 1950s, the plural ring is a joke: two snakes that seized each others’ tails and devoured all of both bodies but the head, and, in a column of 1951, a whole circle of them, until they all just swallowed each other up—and the circle disappeared. Real tail-in-mouth rings, the herpetologists’ reports we read, are always one animal.

S4 ca. 2600-2500 BC (Harper, Aruz and Tallon 1992); Toscanne 1911: not dated; Mundkur 1983 (ca. 3500 BC) and Oehrl 2013 (3000 BC) reported by province 18, not read here; Elamite (Susa)

Bitumen-compound plaque with two nude men and a knot of two serpents, Louvre Sb 2724 (Royal City of Susa 1992 no. 52); drawn by Toscanne 1911, fig. 394

A line drawing: two long-haired men, head and shoulders, face each other; between them two serpents with dragon-like heads twist into a knot, and one man’s raised hand reaches up to it.
“P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 206, fig. 394: 'Fig. 394. — Plaque de bitume.'” where it comes from

S4 (S3 if each held the other's tail; our tracing says own tail)

tous deux sont fortement musclés et lèvent le bras à hauteur de la tête, comme pour soutenir les deux serpents enlacés qui se mordent la queue. both are strongly muscled and raise their arm to the height of the head, as if to hold up the two interlaced serpents which bite their tail(s).

Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 207 · translated by this investigation

S4 early 5th century BCE (museum); Chinese Bronze Age (Eastern Zhou)

Bronze bell (niuzhong), The Met 1988.20.7: panels of interlaced decoration

A photograph of the lower panel of a green bronze bell, covered in bands of fine interlaced decoration.
“Bell (niuzhong), detail of the lower panel of interlaced decoration” where it comes from
"objectDate": "early 5th century BCE"

The Metropolitan Museum of Art Collection API, object 44518 (1988.20.7)

S4 1st century AD; Roman natural history (on Gallic Druids)

Pliny the Elder, Naturalis Historia 29.52-54 (the Druids' serpents' egg)

angues enim numerose convoluti salivis faucium corporumque spumis artifici conplexu glomerant; urinum appellatur. For snakes, coiled together in numbers, with the saliva of their jaws and the foam of their bodies, roll [it] into a ball by an artful embrace; it is called urinum.

Pliny, Naturalis Historia 29.52, ed. C. Mayhoff, vol. IV (Leipzig: Teubner, 1897), p. 386 · translated by this investigation

S4 'originally created c. 700' (Commons description, not checked); Insular manuscript illumination

Book of Durrow, Dublin, Trinity College MS 57, fol. 192v: carpet page with animal interlace

A manuscript carpet page: six fields of interlaced animals in red, yellow and green round a central roundel of knotwork.
“Book of Durrow, Dublin, Trinity College Library MS 57, fol. 192v (carpet page with animal interlace)” where it comes from

Six fields of animal interlace round a roundel of plain knotwork. Horizontal bands: long-jawed beasts with round eyes, broad red or yellow ribbon bodies with green teardrop hips, thin pale legs and tails; bodies cross in a chain. Side panels: beasts stacked vertically, each head's long jaws reaching to the hindquarters of the beast above. No head visibly takes a tail. (our description; the source is a picture)

Wikimedia Commons, File:IE_TCD_MS_57_f.192v.jpg (Trinity College Dublin Library, CC BY 4.0)

S3 probably 777 (Oehrl: the chalice 'dürfte' be a gift for the foundation of Kremsmünster in 777); Anglo-Carolingian animal style (insular and continental interlace)

Triquetra of three snakes on the foot of the Tassilo Chalice, Kremsmünster, as reported and drawn (after Haseloff 1951) by Oehrl 2013, Abb. 15

Als eine Art Uroboros-Variante könnte auch eine Triquetra am Fuß des Kelches angesprochen werden. Sie wird von drei Schlangen gebildet, die sich gegenseitig in die Schwanzspitze beißen (Abb. 15). A triquetra on the foot of the chalice could also be addressed as a kind of ouroboros variant. It is formed by three snakes that bite one another in the tail tip.

Oehrl 2013, p. 460 and Abb. 15, n. 66 · translated by this investigation

S2 10th century (composition); Arabic alchemy

Ibn Umayl, al-Ma' al-waraqi wa'l-ard al-najmiyya, opening (paragraph [5]), the two birds on the tablet, in Julius Ruska's German translation of the Arabic edited by Turab 'Ali (1933)

abgeschnitten, der andere besass beide Flügel, und jeder der beiden Vögel fasste mit seinem Schnabel den Schwanz des anderen, ihn packend, als ob der (geflügelte) Vogel mit dem Verstümmelten wegfliegen, der Verstümmelte aber den anderen zu sich herabziehen wollte. So bildeten die beiden Vögel einen einzigen Kreis, das Bild von Zwei in Einem. [of the one, both wings were] cut off, the other had both wings, and each of the two birds seized with its beak the tail of the other, gripping it, as if the (winged) bird wanted to fly away with the mutilated one, but the mutilated one wanted to pull the other down to itself. So the two birds formed one single circle, the image of Two in One.

Julius Ruska, 'Studien zu Muhammad Ibn Umail al-Tamimi's Kitab al-Ma' al-Waraqi wa'l-Ard an-Najmiyah', Isis 24, no. 2 (1936), p. 313 · translated by our translation of Ruska's German

S4 Voluspa disputed (Bellows: middle of the 10th century); Snorri about 1220-1225; manuscripts about 1300 and later; Old Norse Eddic poetry and prose mythography

Voluspa 38 and Snorri, Gylfaginning ch. 52: the hall on Nastrond woven of serpents' backs, the heads turned inward blowing venom

for that hall was woven with serpents' backs.

Olive Bray (ed. and tr.), The Elder or Poetic Edda, Part I, 1908, pp. 288-289 (leaves n375, n376), Voluspa 38

S4 Romanesque (Oehrl gives no date); Romanesque architectural sculpture (Germany)

S4 (two rings linked through each other in the left groups; S4 or S6 the right group)

Dass auch die mehrfach in der romanischen Bauplastik des Kontinents auftretenden Uroboros-Darstellungen (Abb. 20c-d) mit vorchristlichen Mythen verknüpft sind, ist schwer vorstellbar. That the ouroboros representations that occur several times in the Romanesque architectural sculpture of the Continent (fig. 20c-d) are linked to pre-Christian myths is hard to imagine.

Oehrl 2013, p. 462 (OCR) and p. 463, Abb. 20d (page image) · translated by this investigation

S4 early 14th century (composition of the Inferno); medieval Italian literary vision (Dante, Commedia)

Dante, Inferno XXIV 94-96 and XXV 4-9, 58-60

con serpi le man dietro avean legate; quelle ficcavan per le ren la coda e ’l capo, ed eran dinanzi aggroppate. they had their hands tied behind them with serpents; these thrust the tail and the head through the loins, and were knotted together in front.

Dante, Inferno XXIV 94-96 (Petrocchi text, Italian Wikisource) · translated by this investigation

S2 739 H / 1339, probably Baghdad (as the Commons file page gives it); Arabic alchemy (painted manuscript)

Painted double page of a manuscript of Ibn Umayl's al-Ma' al-waraqi, Topkapi Palace Library, Ahmet III 2075: the sage with the tablet; on one leaf of the tablet a roundel with two birds curled together

The lower right shows two birds top is male facing right, bottom female facing left, they signify "two in one".

Wikimedia Commons, File:Ibn Umayl The Silvery Water.jpg (file description page)

S4 Mississippian (by style); found 1870; published by Holmes 1906; Mississippian (lower Mississippi valley), Southeastern Ceremonial Complex

The Issaquena or 'Mississippi' tablet: sandstone disk, 8½ inches in diameter, engraved with two interlocked feathered rattlesnakes

On one face is engraved in shallow lines the representation of two interlocked rattlesnakes with heads in reversed order, facing the center from opposite sides (fig. 8).

W. H. Holmes, 'Certain Notched or Scalloped Stone Tablets of the Mound-Builders', American Anthropologist n.s. 8 (1906), p. 104 and fig. 8

S4 Mississippian; about AD 1300-1450 according to secondary web pages (not read as sources); first published 1883; Mississippian (Moundville, Alabama), Southeastern Ceremonial Complex

The Moundville 'Rattlesnake Disk': notched sandstone palette, about 12-12.5 inches in diameter, engraved with two horned rattlesnakes knotted into a ring round an open hand with an eye in the palm

A line drawing of a stone disk: two knotted rattlesnakes form a ring round a hand with an eye in its palm.
“Pl. LXVI ('The Serpent'), fig. 6: 'Stone disk, Carthage, Ala.' (the Moundville 'Rattlesnake Disk'), line drawing” where it comes from
while on the other there is a well-engraved design which represents two entwined or rather knotted rattlesnakes.

W. H. Holmes, 'Art in Shell of the Ancient Americans', Second Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology 1880-81, Washington 1883, p. 278 and Pl. LXVI fig. 6

S7 pre-Hispanic (no date given); published 1904; Pre-Hispanic north-western Argentina (Calchaquí region bronze)

Bronze disc, 33½ cm in diameter, from San Juan province (probably Calingasta), Museo Nacional de Buenos Aires (Ambrosetti 1904, Fig. 86 b): two undulating serpents one behind the other forming a circle

La cara externa presenta, dentro de una zona formada por dos líneas que deja el centro del disco libre, á dos serpientes gruesas onduladas una detras de la otra, dirigidas de derecha á izquierda y ambas del mismo tamaño más ó menos de manera que forman una figura circular. The outer face presents, within a zone formed by two lines which leaves the centre of the disc free, two thick undulating serpents one behind the other, directed from right to left and both of about the same size, so that they form a circular figure.

J. B. Ambrosetti, 'El bronce en la región calchaquí', Anales del Museo Nacional de Buenos Aires XI (1904), p. 288 and Fig. 86 b (p. 287) · translated by this investigation

S2 15th century; Latin alchemy (illuminated manuscript)

Zurich, Zentralbibliothek, Ms. Rh. 172 (Aurora consurgens), fol. 3r: the house with eagles carrying bows, three men, the old man holding the tablet; on the tablet two birds lying together

Parchment · 100 ff. · 20.4 x 13.9 cm · St. Gall · 15th century

e-codices, Zurich ZB Ms. Rh. 172, summary

S4 15th century (Druce); English church carving (as described by Druce 1910)

Misericord at Halsall, Lancashire (15th century), as described by G. C. Druce, Archaeological Journal 67 (1910), p. 288

In the middle are two with their bodies crossed.

Druce 1910, p. 288 (OCR)

S7 pre-Hispanic (date not given in the sources read); facsimile 1898; commentary 1906; Central Mexican (Borgia group), pre-Hispanic

Codex Borgia, page 46: a closed square formed by four fire serpents of four colours round a red field (the hearth)

A painted square frame of four serpents, blue-green, yellow, white with red stripes, and red, round a rayed face and a second figure.
Codex Borgia, page 46: the square of four serpents, cropped from the Duc de Loubat’s facsimile of 1898. where it comes from
Ueber dieser Feuererzeugung sieht man ein von einer weissen (rothgestreiften), einer gelben, einer blauen, einer rothen Feuerschlange gebildetes, geschlossenes Viereck, das innen ganz roth, mit der Farbe des Feuers gemalt ist, und das offenbar das tlecuili oder tlequaztli, den Feuerheerd, vorstellt. Above this making of fire one sees a closed square formed by a white (red-striped), a yellow, a blue and a red fire serpent, painted all red inside with the colour of fire, which evidently represents the tlecuilli or tlequaztli, the hearth.

Eduard Seler, Codex Borgia: eine altmexikanische Bilderschrift, vol. II, Berlin 1906, p. 75 · translated by this investigation

S7 pre-conquest Mexica (carving date not established from a source read); found in Mexico City's main square in 1790; Mexica (Aztec), Tenochtitlan

The 'Piedra del Sol' (Aztec Calendar Stone): its outer belt of two serpents, tails at the top by the 13 Acatl square, heads meeting at the bottom with human faces in their jaws

An engraving of the Aztec Sun Stone: a round stone of carved rings whose outer belt is two serpent bodies meeting head to head at the bottom.
“Lámina II: the 'second stone' (Piedra del Sol), shaded engraving” where it comes from
One point about the twin serpents is clear; they are represented as springing from a square enclosing the symbol Acatl accompanied by 13 which has been generally interpreted as a calendar date.

Zelia Nuttall, The Fundamental Principles of Old and New World Civilizations, Peabody Museum Papers II, 1901, p. 257

S2 16th century, undated edition (Ruska: 'ohne Angabe von Drucker und Jahr'); Latin alchemy (printed illustration of an Arabic text)

Woodcut set before the oldest printed edition of Senior, De chemia (undated, no printer named), headed 'SENIOR PHILOSOPHVS' with six Latin verses, as reproduced by Ruska, Isis 24 (1936), p. 315

ohne Angabe von Drucker und Jahr without indication of printer and year

Julius Ruska, Isis 24 (1936), p. 315 (summary file; copyright caution: short phrase only) · translated by this investigation

S4 printed 1612; French alchemy (printed under Nicolas Flamel's name)

Les figures hieroglyphiques (1612), p. 69: the two serpents that cannot die except together ('dit Haly') and that, put together in the Vessel of the Sepulchre, bite each other cruelly until both die and become living water; and p. 61: the arch's 'deux dragons vnis, l'vn dans l'autre ... entrecathenez'

Celuy, dit Haly, qui en tuera l'vn, il tuera aussi l'autre, parce que l'vn ne peut mourir qu'auec sõ frere. He who kills one of them, says Haly, will also kill the other, because the one cannot die except with its brother.

Les figures hieroglyphiques (1612), p. 69 · translated by this investigation

S4 1612; French alchemy (printed illustration)

Small woodcut heading chap. III of Les figures hieroglyphiques (Paris 1612), p. 68: two dragons, the upper winged, the lower wingless, heads meeting and biting at each other; the same design repeated in the London 1624 English edition, p. 64

Their heads meet in the middle of the cut, mouths open, each biting at the other's head or jaw. No tail is in any mouth.

Les figures hieroglyphiques (1612), p. 68 (our description of the cut)

S2 printed 1622 (Theatrum chemicum V); first printed in Ars chemica, Strasbourg 1566 (not verified here); date of composition not established; Latin alchemy

Anonymous, Consilium conjugii seu de massa Solis et Lunae, retelling of Senior's tablet: the first sphere of two birds, the wingless 'scilicet masculus', the winged above it 'scilicet foemina', each holding the other's tail in its beak

Prima sphæra ex duabus auibus pectoribus inclinatis: quarum vna habebat alas abscissas scilicet masculus: alia vero super istam erat alata scilicet fœmina, & vtraque tenebat rostro caudam alterius, ac si volans vellet volare cum altera, & illa vellet retinere volantem. The first sphere [was] of two birds with breasts bent, of which one had its wings cut off, namely the male; the other, above it, was winged, namely the female; and each held in its beak the tail of the other, as if the flying one wished to fly with the other, and that one wished to hold the flying one back.

Theatrum chemicum V (1622), Consilium coniugii, p. 495 · translated by this investigation

S2 composition 10th century (Ibn Umayl); this witness printed 1622; Arabic alchemy in Latin translation

Ibn Umayl (Senior Zadith filius Hamuel), Tabula chimica (Latin version of al-Ma' al-waraqi), opening description of the tablet held by the statue: two birds, one wingless, one winged, each holding the other's tail in its beak, in one sphere

imago duarum avium in inferiore parte ejus pectore inclinato, quarum avium una habebat alas abscissas, & altera habens alas duas, & utraque tenebat rostro caudam alterius, ac si volans vellet volare cum altera, & illa vellet retinere volantem secum. the image of two birds in its lower part, with breast bent, of which birds one had its wings cut off, and the other having two wings, and each held in its beak the tail of the other, as if the flying one wished to fly away with the other, and that one wished to hold the flying one back with itself.

Theatrum chemicum, vol. V (Strasbourg: heirs of L. Zetzner, 1622), Senioris Zadith Tabula chimica, p. 219 and next page · translated by this investigation

S2 composition 10th century; printed 1622; Arabic alchemy in Latin translation

Ibn Umayl (Senior), Tabula chimica, the author's own explanation of the two birds (sections 'Specialis investigatio tabulae ... I. De duabus avibus invicem iunctis' and preceding)

Et radix huius aquæ sunt ambæ aves colligatæ, quarum utraque retinet caudam alterius, & radix harum avium est luna plena, & hæc est Magnesia & Abarnahas perfectum. And the root of this water is the two birds bound together, of which each holds the tail of the other; and the root of these birds is the full moon, and this is the Magnesia and the perfect Abarnahas.

Theatrum chemicum V (1622), Senior, leaf n252 · translated by this investigation

S2 1622 (this printing); Latin alchemy (printed illustration of an Arabic text)

Full-page woodcut of the sage with the tablet, facing the opening of Senior's Tabula chimica, Theatrum chemicum V (1622), p. 218

Left leaf of the tablet: two disks above, a ring-shaped figure made of two animal bodies in the middle, one disk below.

Theatrum chemicum V (1622), p. 218 (leaf n244)

S4 1678 (Latin text and plate seen); 1893 (Waite); Latin alchemy (emblematic tract, engraving)

The Book of Lambspring, eighth figure: two birds 'colligatae' who kill each other by biting, one devouring the other (Body and Spirit)

In qua duæ aves sunt colligatæ: Vna est colore albissimo, altera rubro, Hæ se invicem mordendo interimunt, in which two birds are bound together: one is of the whitest colour, the other red; they kill each other by biting,

Musaeum hermeticum (1678), p. 356 · translated by this investigation

S2 1735; German alchemy (printed engraving)

Abraham Eleazar, Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 1, engraved figure N. 1 headed 'Vereinige sie': two dragons in one ring round a tree, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its jaws

An engraving: two dragons form one ring round a leafless tree, one winged above and one wingless below, each biting the other’s tail.
“Engraved plate N. 1, 'Vereinige sie': two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its jaws” where it comes from
die flüchtige Schlange wird die Fixe fressen, und wird aus beyden ein feuriger kriechender Drache werden. the volatile serpent will eat the fixed, and out of both will come a fiery creeping dragon.

Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 1, p. 17 · translated by this investigation

S2 1735; German alchemy (printed engraving)

Abraham Eleazar, Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 2 (Donum Dei Samuelis Baruch), engraved figure N. 3: two dragons in one ring, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth; labelled Geist, Seele, Leib, Corpus

An engraved plate of two figures: above, two dragons in one ring, each with the other’s tail in its mouth; below, one crowned dragon with its own tail in its mouth.
“Engraved plate with figures N. 3 (two dragons, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth) and N. 4 (one crowned dragon, 'Der Fixe', 'Rothe Drache', its own tail in its mouth)” where it comes from
Upper right: a dragon with two feathered wings, two clawed legs and a crown; its open mouth holds the tail of the second dragon.

Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 2, plate N. 3 (our description)

S2 1738 (Commons); German alchemy (illuminated manuscript)

'Zoroaster', Clavis Artis, MS. Verginelli-Rota (Rome, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei), vol. 2, p. 18: two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth

A painted manuscript page: two dragons form one ring round a tree, a green one with red wings above and a blue and yellow wingless one below, each with the other’s tail in its mouth.
“Two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth” where it comes from
Immagine del manoscritto Zoroaster Clavis Artis, MS. Verginelli-Rota, Biblioteca dell'Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma, vol. 2, p. 18 Date 1738 Image from the manuscript Zoroaster, Clavis Artis, MS. Verginelli-Rota, Library of the Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Rome, vol. 2, p. 18. Date 1738

Wikimedia Commons, File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Rota.V2.018.jpg (file description) · translated by this investigation

S4 1776; Welsh folk belief, recorded by a naturalist

Thomas Pennant, British Zoology vol. III (1776), article Viper, pp. 31-33

Our modern Druidesses give much the same account of the ovum anguinum, Glain Neidr, as the Welch call it, or the Adder-Gem, as the Roman philosopher does, but seem not to have so exalted an opinion of its powers, using it only to assist children in cutting their teeth, or to cure the chin-cough, or to drive away an ague.

Thomas Pennant, British Zoology, vol. III (Warrington, 1776), p. 32

S4 reported 1833 (object undated); Mexican (Aztec), as reported in 1833

'The Mexican symbol': two serpents intertwining to form the circle, a human head in each mouth, as described by Deane 1833 (object unidentified; on pp. 299-300 he places 'a very remarkable one' in 'M. Allard's collection of sculptures')

But the most remarkable of all is the Mexican symbol. Here the two serpents, intertwining, form the circle with their own bodies, and in the mouth of each of them is a Human head!

John Bathurst Deane, The Worship of the Serpent Traced throughout the World, 2nd ed., London: J. G. & F. Rivington, 1833, p. 54

S2 April 1835; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox)

Methodist Magazine and Quarterly Review 17(2), April 1835, p. 210

S2?

Really this exceeds the story of the two vipers, which, in a violent contest, swallowed each other entire, so that nothing was left of either!

Methodist Magazine and Quarterly Review 17(2), April 1835, p. 210

S2 21 December 1839; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox)

Maine Farmer, and Journal of the Arts 7(50), 21 December 1839, p. 1 (letter of 'Drew' and editor E. Holmes)

it is well known that they would soon neutralize each others power, like the two snakes that seized each others' tails and devoured all of both bodies but the head.

Maine Farmer 7(50), 21 Dec. 1839, p. 1, col. 4

S4 made before June 1847 (claimed by the Count as his late wife's mother's); platinum jewellery argued in court to be of 1810 or later; 19th-century German jewellery (court exhibit)

The gold-and-platinum finger ring of two interlinked tail-biting snakes, found on Heinrich Stauff in Kassel in October 1847 and shown at the Görlitz murder trial, Darmstadt, March-April 1850

S4 (S3 on the reciprocal reading)

Außer diesem Stück Gold hatte er noch bei sich ein Armband aus verschlungenen Goldfäden mit einem sogenannten gordischen Knoten, die goldene, in zwei Stücke zerbrochene Einfassung einer Brosche, einen Fingerring, gebildet von zwei ineinander verschlungenen, die Gestalt von sich in den Schwanz beißenden Schlangen zeigenden Reifen, von denen der eine von Gold, der andere von Platina, sieben Glieder eines Armbandes von Bronze. Besides this piece of gold he had with him a bracelet of interlaced gold threads with a so-called Gordian knot, the gold setting of a brooch broken in two, a finger ring formed of two hoops intertwined in one another, showing the shape of snakes biting themselves in the tail, of which one is of gold, the other of platinum, [and] seven links of a bronze bracelet.

Der neue Pitaval, ed. J. E. Hitzig and W. Häring (W. Alexis), vol. 17 (Zweite Folge, vol. 5), 2nd ed. (Leipzig: F. A. Brockhaus, 1860), "Die Gräfin von Görlitz und ihr Diener (1847-1850)", p. 169 · translated by this investigation

S2 18 February 1848; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox)

Anti-Slavery Bugle 3(27), 18 February 1848, p. 3

S2?

nor should we greatly mourn if they should illustrate the story of the Kilkenny cats, or that better one of the snakes which entirely swallowed each other.

Anti-Slavery Bugle 3(27), 18 Feb. 1848, p. 3, col. 3

S2 7 October 1871; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox)

Appletons' Journal 6(132), 7 October 1871, 'Varieties', p. 419

Each snake had commenced swallowing the other's tail, and they continued the operation until their heads met.

Appletons' Journal 6(132), 7 Oct. 1871, p. 419

S7 1886 (session dated 20 September 1886; article signed 'Im Mai 1886'); 19th-century chemistry (German), parody

Fig. 1 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols', Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft No. 20 (1886), p. 3536: six monkeys forming a ring

A line drawing of six long-tailed monkeys holding one another hand to hand and hand to foot in a closed ring.
“Fig. 1 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': six monkeys (Macacus cynocephalus) forming a ring, 'ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé'schen Benzolsechsecks'” where it comes from

S7 analogue (monkeys, not serpents)

Denkt man sich nun eine Gruppe von sechs Angehörigen dieser Familie, z. B. Macacus cynocephalus, welche unter sich einen Ring bilden, indem sie sich abwechselnd je zwei und eine Hand [p. 3536] reichen, so erhält man ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé'schen Benzolsechsecks: Now imagine a group of six members of this family, e.g. Macacus cynocephalus, forming a ring among themselves by reaching each other alternately two hands and one hand: one obtains a most perfect analogue of Kekulé's benzene hexagon.

"F. W. Findig" (pseudonym), "Zur Constitution des Benzols", Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft No. 20 (Berlin, 1886), pp. 3535-3537, pp. 3535-3536 · translated by this investigation

S4 1886 (session dated 20 September 1886; article signed 'Im Mai 1886'); 19th-century chemistry (German), parody

Fig. 2 of the same article, p. 3536: the six monkeys joined also by their tails, the 'second form' of Kekulé's hexagon

A line drawing of the same six monkeys in a pointed oval, joined by their hands and also by their tails.
“Fig. 2 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': the same six monkeys joined also by their tails ('caudaler Appendix'), the 'zweite Form des Kekulé-schen Sechsecks'” where it comes from

S4 analogue (monkeys, not serpents)

Nun aber besitzt der genannte Macacus cynocephalus ausser seinen eigentlichen vier Händen noch ein fünftes Greifwerkzeug in Form eines caudalen Appendix. Zieht man diesen mit in Betracht, dann gelingt es, die 6 Individuen des gezeichneten Ringes auch noch in anderer Weise mit einander zu verbinden. So entsteht das nachfolgende Bild: But the said Macacus cynocephalus possesses, besides its four proper hands, a fifth grasping organ in the form of a caudal appendix. If one takes this into account, the 6 individuals of the drawn ring can be joined to one another in yet another way. So arises the following picture:

"F. W. Findig" (pseudonym), "Zur Constitution des Benzols", Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft No. 20 (Berlin, 1886), pp. 3535-3537, p. 3536 · translated by this investigation

S2 December 1887; American / British humorous print (tall tale, paradox)

Temple Bar 81(325), December 1887, 'A Budget of Paradoxes', p. 484

Suppose three snakes, each of which is swallowing another by the tail, so that the three form a circle—then, as the swallowing process continues the circle evidently grows smaller and smaller.

Temple Bar 81 (Dec. 1887), p. 484

S2 1892 (publication); describes Tibetan paintings current in his time; Tibetan Buddhist (Wheel of Life, bhavacakra), as reported by a British observer

Waddell's description of the centre of the Tibetan Wheel of Life: pig, cock and snake each holding the next one's tail

The three original sins or 'chief Causes of Demerit' are depicted as (1) a pig which has hold of the tail of (2) a cock which has hold of the tail of (3) a snake which in its turn, has hold of the pig's tail. The triad thus form a circle which revolves continuously around the world. The pig symbolizes Ignorance, the cock animal Desire or Lust, and the snake Anger or Hate.* These are at the core of re-birth, and if these three sins be avoided or overcome then virtue results and merit is accumulated.

L. A. Waddell, 'The Buddhist Pictorial Wheel of Life', JASB 61, Part I, No. 3 (1892), p. 136

S2 1895 (plate); the Tibetan painting it reproduces is undated (Waddell: 'alleged ... to be a copy of one brought to Tibet by the Indian monk "Bande Yeshe," in the eighth century A.D.'); Tibetan Buddhist (Wheel of Life), reproduced in a British book

Plate 'The Wheel of Life, Picturing the Buddhist Theory of the Universe', facing p. 108 of Waddell, The Buddhism of Tibet (1895): the hub

The hub of a Tibetan wheel painting, as printed: a pig, a cock and a snake in a circle, each holding the tail of the next.
The hub of the plate “The Wheel of Life, Picturing the Buddhist Theory of the Universe”, facing p. 108 of L. A. Waddell’s The Buddhism of Tibet (1895). where it comes from
The broad tire is occupied by the Causal Nexus, and the nave by the three vices or delusions, "The Daughters of Desire," the three vices—Rāga, Dvesa, Moha. Lust, ill-will, stupidity, which lie at the core of re-birth, and are figured here, as in the other Indian picture on page 6, as a dove, serpent, and pig, appropriately coloured red, green, and black; while the body of the wheel, which is considered to be in continuous revolution, is filled with pictorial details of Life in its several forms, or "The Whirling on the Wheel" of Life.

L. A. Waddell, The Buddhism of Tibet, or Lamaism, London: W. H. Allen, 1895, p. 109

S2 c. 1931/32 (book's preface dated December 1931); English recreational mathematics (puzzle books)

Drawing beside problem 324, 'The Two Snakes', in H. E. Dudeney, Puzzles and Curious Problems, p. 112

lowing one another simultaneously, each getting the tail of the other in its mouth, so that the circle formed by the snakes becomes smaller and smaller, what will eventually happen ?

Henry Ernest Dudeney, Puzzles and Curious Problems, Thomas Nelson and Sons Ltd., London etc. (no date on the title page of the copy read; preface by Alice Dudeney dated December 1931), problem 324 'The Two Snakes', pp. 111-112, solution p. 181; Internet Archive item dli.ministry.19463, page images n115, n116, n185, pp. 111-112

S2 June 1948 (told by Mrs. Louis Winkler from her grandfather George Washington Swearingen); American oral tall tale (folklorist's record)

Hoosier Folklore, June 1948, p. 55: E. W. Baughman, 'Two Tall Tales', 1. Fighting Snakes

S2?

I was walking along one day, saw two snakes in a fight. I stopped to watch. All at once they swallowed each other—nothing left but a blue flame.

Hoosier Folklore, June 1948, p. 55

S2 9 August 1951; American tall tale (prospector's yarn in a syndicated column)

Hope Star (Arkansas), 9 August 1951, p. 1: Hal Boyle (AP), 'Hal Boyle Lifts a Toast to South Dakota'

Finally they all just swallowed each other up—and the circle disappeared.

Hope Star, 9 Aug. 1951, p. 1 (AP column by Hal Boyle)

S2 English 1955 (The Mysteries) and 1958 (CW 11); German 'Das Wandlungssymbol in der Messe' as revised in Von den Wurzeln des Bewusstseins, Zurich: Rascher, 1954; depth psychology (C. G. Jung) on alchemical iconography

C. G. Jung, 'Transformation Symbolism in the Mass' (CW 11), para. 351 and its footnote: the uroboros 'often pictured in the form of two dragons' eating one another

Mostly the pictures show two lions eating one another. The uroboros, too, is often pictured in the form of two dragons engaged in the same process (Viridarium chymicum, 1624).

C. G. Jung, Psychology and Religion: West and East (CW 11), 'Transformation Symbolism in the Mass', para. 351 and footnote; same text in The Mysteries (1955)

S2 March 1961; modern art (M. C. Escher)

M. C. Escher, Möbius Strip I, wood engraving and woodcut in red, green, gold and black, printed from four blocks, March 1961

And yet apparently it consists of one single strip, made up of three fish, each biting the tail of the one in front. They go round twice before reaching their point of departure

Escher in Het Paleis, 'Möbius Strip I' (Escher Today, 13 March 2017), quoting Escher, The Graphic Work of M.C. Escher

S4 July 1969; modern art (M. C. Escher)

M. C. Escher, Snakes, woodcut printed from three blocks, July 1969 (LW 448)

Snakes. July 1969, Woodcut, printed from three blocks.

mcescher.com, gallery caption (LW 448)

S2 September 1979; modern literature (Michael Ende)

Michael Ende, Die unendliche Geschichte (1979): the amulet AURYN, the cover of the book in the story, and the two snakes round the spring of the Water of Life

ein großes goldenes Amulett, auf dem zwei Schlangen zu sehen waren, eine helle und eine dunkle, die einander in den Schwanz bissen und ein Oval bildeten. a large golden amulet on which two snakes could be seen, a light one and a dark one, which bit each other's tails and formed an oval.

Michael Ende, Die unendliche Geschichte, Stuttgart: Thienemann, 1979 (German text via OCR snippets of an archive.org upload; no page numbers) · translated by this investigation

S3 1984; modern film (Wolfgang Petersen, 1984)

The amulet AURYN as made for the film Die unendliche Geschichte / The NeverEnding Story (1984)

Das Amulett besteht aus zwei Schlangen (eine silberne und eine goldene), die einander umschlingen und in die Schwänze beißen. The amulet consists of two snakes (a silver one and a gold one) which entwine each other and bite each other's tails.

de.wikipedia, 'Die unendliche Geschichte (Film)' · translated by this investigation

S4 field seasons May 1997 and May 1998 (Shine et al. 2000); published 2000-2001; modern herpetology (observed behaviour)

Mating balls of red-sided garter snakes at a communal den, Chatfield Community Pasture, Manitoba (Shine et al. 2000; 2001)

Most courtship and mating occur in small groups (‘mating balls’) consisting of one animal being courted plus several suitors.

Shine, Harlow, LeMaster, Moore and Mason, Animal Behaviour 59 (2000) 349-359

S2 README as fetched 2026-11-16; first version 'for Ubuntu 13.04' (50 languages); computing (programming curiosities)

Yusuke Endoh (mame), Quine Relay: a cycle of programs in 128 languages, each printing the next, the last printing the first

It explains how to write a quine, an ascii-art quine, and an uroboros quine like this quine-relay.

Y. Endoh, Quine Relay, README.md (master), fetched 2026-11-16

S3 not given in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland)

Carpow cross-slab fragment, front: a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails, bodies forming knot No. 250 (Allen); the same at St Orland's Stone, Cossins

A photograph of a carved stone fragment: a beast’s head with open jaws grips a strand that loops into a knot, with spiral coils below.
“Detail of fig. 327A, Fragment of upright cross-slab from Carpow, front: the panel described as a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails” where it comes from

S3 (form, on Allen's word; creatures are 'sea-monsters')

a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails and their bodies forming knot No. 250 (as also at Cossins).

Allen and Anderson 1903, Part III, p. 312 (leaf n449)

S3 not given in the sources the research read; Insular sculpture (Iona, Scotland)

Iona No. 1, St Martin's Cross, front, top arm: three pairs of beasts biting each other's tails, which are twisted together; serpent-and-boss work on both faces

S3 (form; beasts) for the pairs; S4 for the serpent backgrounds

three pairs of beasts (biting each other's tails, which are twisted together), arranged one pair below the other

Allen and Anderson 1903, Part III, p. 382 (leaf n539)

S3 not given in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland)

Kettins cross-slab, front: a pair of beasts with crossed bodies biting each other's tails

A line drawing of two four-legged beasts facing each other, their long bodies crossed and each biting the other’s tail.
“Detail of fig. 236, Upright slab with sculpture in relief at Kettins: the pair of beasts with crossed bodies biting each other's tails (line drawing)” where it comes from

S3 (form only; beasts, not serpents)

a pair of beasts placed symmetrically facing each other, with their bodies crossed, and biting each other's tails.

Allen and Anderson 1903, Part III, p. 224 (leaf n313); fig. 236 p. 225 (leaf n318)

S2 not given in the sources the research read; Allen places it among the symbol-bearing (Class II) monuments; Pictish sculpture (Scotland)

Meigle No. 26, recumbent monument, top surface: three serpents in a whorl, each biting the tail of the next (Allen)

A photograph of a carved stone: a round whorl of three spiralling serpents with their heads at the centre.
“Detail of fig. 318A (top of Meigle No. 26): the whorl of three serpents” where it comes from
three serpents arranged symmetrically, with their heads at angles of 120° apart and their bodies bent round spirally, so that each serpent bites the tail of the next one to it

J. Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson, The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, 1903, Part III, p. 304 (leaf n437); plate LXV (leaf n438)

S4 not dated in the sources the research read; Pictish sculpture (Scotland)

Nigg cross-slab, Ross-shire: panels of raised bosses on a background of serpents (Allen 1904)

After innumerable crossings under and over, the tails again diverge at three other points round the base of the boss, and finally terminate in small spirals in different parts of the background.

J. Romilly Allen, Celtic Art in Pagan and Christian Times, 1904, p. 293 (leaf n404); plate facing p. 292 (leaf n402)

S4 not dated in the sources the research read; Anglo-Saxon metalwork (Germanic Style II)

Sutton Hoo great gold buckle, British Museum 1939,1010.1

A photograph of a gold buckle covered in interlaced ribbon-bodied animals, with three domed bosses.
“Great gold buckle from Sutton Hoo, British Museum 1939,1010.1 (photograph in the gallery)” where it comes from

Interlaced ribbon bodies stippled with niello cover the plate round three domed bosses; at least five heads with round eyes at the periphery, two facing outward at the tapered terminal. No ribbon traceable from head to tail; what the jaws hold is not determinable in the photograph. (our description; the source is a picture)

Wikimedia Commons, File:Great_gold_buckle_sutton_hoo.JPG (photograph by Geni, 2024, CC BY-SA 4.0)

S4 not dated in the sources the research read; Viking-Age runestone (Sweden)

Runestone U 871 (Upplands runinskrift 871), as painted and standing at Skansen, Stockholm

A photograph of a runestone painted pink, red and white: a rune-band round the edge, and interlaced beasts and serpents inside it.
“Runestone U 871 (Upplands runinskrift 871), at Skansen, Stockholm; the carving is painted in modern colours” where it comes from

A pink rune-band round the edge; inside, a large pink beast with long jaws and lappet, a pink serpent in figure-of-eight loops, and thin white snakes knotted into loops; a cross top left. Heads: large pink head bottom centre (jaws open to the right); a pink head at right whose jaw lies across a white snake's neck just behind its head; at least two small white snake heads ending free in the loops. No head takes a tail. (our description; the source is a picture)

Wikimedia Commons, File:Upplands_Runinskrift_871.jpg (photograph by Mceder, 2005, public domain)

S4 Saturnalia: date of composition not yet sourced in this dossier; Latin antiquarian writing (claims an Egyptian origin)

Macrobius, Saturnalia 1.19.16 to 18 (the caduceus)

Mercurio consecrandum. Hi dracones parte media voluminis sui invicem nodo quem vocant Herculis obligantur, primaeque partes eorum reflexae in circulum pressis osculis ambitum circuli iungunt: et post nodum caudae revocantur ad capulum caducei ornanturque alis ex eadem capuli parte nascentibus. [to be] consecrated to Mercury. These serpents are bound to each other, at the middle part of their coil, by the knot they call Hercules's; and their foremost parts, bent back into a circle, join the circuit of the circle with pressed kisses; and after the knot their tails are drawn back to the handle of the caduceus, and they are adorned with wings springing from the same part of the handle.

Macrobius, Saturnalia, ed. L. von Jan, Quedlinburg and Leipzig 1852, as transcribed on LacusCurtius by Bill Thayer, Saturnalia 1.19.16 (after von Jan p. 184 break) · translated by this investigation

S7 found 1898; "Il n'est pas daté" (Toscanne 1911); Elamite (Susa)

Bronze "table" (trough) from Susa, 1.60 m long, whose rims are two serpents, mouths joined at one end; Toscanne 1911, fig. 441

deux énormes serpents servent de rebords à la table et en font ainsi une sorte de longue cuvette au bassin plat. two enormous serpents serve as the rims of the table and so make of it a sort of long trough with a flat basin.

Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 217 · translated by this investigation

S2 not dated by Toscanne; unknown to us; Elamite (Susa)

Small three-footed terracotta offering table from Susa with serpents encircling a nine-petalled rosette, Toscanne 1911, fig. 442

A line drawing of a broken three-footed terracotta table: a nine-petalled rosette on top with small serpents round it, and rows of circles on its side.
“P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 218, fig. 442: 'Fig. 442. — Petite table en terre cuite (Suse).'” where it comes from
au centre est une rosace à neuf branches; tout autour, des serpents encerclant la partie principale. L'un d'eux mord la queue de l'autre; nous avions déjà un exemple semblable fig. 324. in the centre is a rosette with nine branches; all round, serpents encircling the main part. One of them bites the tail of the other; we already had a similar example, fig. 324.

Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 218 · translated by this investigation

The visions

The idea speaks of a vision, so the registration asked a second question (H2): when people report a vision with a tail-taking serpent in it, do they describe several serpents woven together? It set a floor first: fewer than four such reports, and the question cannot be judged.

The search found two. August Kekulé, telling in 1890 of a reverie by the fire, saw long rows of atoms twisting like snakes until Eine der Schlangen erfasste den eigenen Schwanz, one of the snakes seized its own tail: several snakes, and one ring, of one snake. The painter Pablo Amaringo describes a sorceress who carries her talents in a coffer in the form of a serpent holding its tail: one serpent.

Many serpents are common in the vision reports we read, above all from ayahuasca: snakes in crowds, in a bunch, in a heap, entwined like rolls of thick cables. In none of the ayahuasca reports does a serpent take a tail.

The verdicts

Each prediction, in the words the registration gave it before the evidence, and what the record did with it.

PredictionWhat we foundResult
P1 (for H1). In the oldest tradition (Egypt), among the five earliest securely dated witnesses that are S1 to S7, at least one is S2, S3, S4 or S7. In order: a spell in the pyramid of Teti (S1); the Amduat’s ringed serpent in the tombs of Thutmose III and of Amenhotep II (S1, twice); two separate rings round one figure on Tutankhamun’s shrine (S5); and, tied for fifth on the sarcophagus of Seti I, a single ring round the sun’s disk (S1) and the serpent Hereret, folded on itself (S6). None is plural. The Susa plaque is older than all of them but is not Egyptian, and is dated by style, which the registration does not count. NOT MET
P2 (for H1). Some text older than AD 500, from any tradition, describes the encircling or tail-devouring figure as more than one serpent, or as twisted, plaited or knotted. None found, by a search that did find the plural figures where they exist. The nearest miss is Macrobius, on a different figure, the caduceus: two serpents tied at the middle nodo quem vocant Herculis, in the knot they call Hercules’, their foremost parts bent into a circle and closed pressis osculis, with pressed kisses; and he gives the knot and the circle different meanings, amor osculo significatur: necessitas nodo. Pliny the Elder tells of snakes numerose convoluti, coiled together in numbers, rolling a ball, and derives the caduceus from that entwining of serpents. Neither is the tail-biting ring. The verdict rests on reading “the encircling or tail-devouring figure” as that ring; read loosely, Macrobius’s knotted circle, which the census counts as S4, would meet it, and H1 would still be partly supported, by P2 and P3. NOT MET
P3 (for H1). Some source older than AD 1700 says in so many words that the drawn figure stands for something more complex than what is drawn (several things shown as one). A book printed in 1612 under the name of Nicolas Flamel says the Egyptians painted ces Serpens & Dragõs, these serpents and dragons, in a circle, the head biting its tail. Michael Maier, in 1618, says the philosophers mean by the tail-devouring dragon serpentem, qui alium sui generis devoret, a serpent that devours another of its kind. A Greek alchemical text copied in 1478 makes the ring’s four feet four bodies and its three ears three sublimates. MET (a weak test, as registered)
P4 (for H2). Collect every first-person vision report we can source in which a serpent takes its own or another’s tail in its mouth. In more than half of them, the report describes several serpents or intertwining. Cannot be judged: fewer than four reports found. Two reports found. CANNOT BE JUDGED
P5 (for H3). S2, S3, S4 or S7 witnesses exist in at least three traditions with no plausible line of borrowing between them. This one is a census, reported as a count with every member shown, and we set no threshold for calling it support. At least four: Elam, in the third millennium BC; the Mississippian peoples of North America; the Mexica; and Pictish Scotland. The hub of the Tibetan Wheel of Life, a pig, a cock and a snake each holding the next one’s tail, would make a fifth, by analogy only, since one of its three is a serpent. No line of borrowing between Bronze Age Susa, the Mississippian towns and Pictish Scotland is plausible; that is our judgement, as the registration said it would be. MET (as a count)

And the three readings, in the only words the registration allowed:

H1, historical: the single ring descends from an older image of interwoven serpents. PARTLY SUPPORTED P3 held. It was registered as the weak test, and the two predictions that bore on where the ring came from, P1 and P2, did not hold: the oldest securely dated Egyptian rings are single, and no text before AD 500 makes the ring plural. The alchemists who read the ring as several serpents in one wrote nearly four thousand years after the oldest securely dated ring we found.

H2, visionary: visions with a tail-taking serpent are plural and woven. CANNOT BE JUDGED FROM WHAT WE COULD READ Two reports, where the registration asked for four. What we could not read: Reichel-Dolmatoff’s books of 1975 and 1978, Shanon’s study of ayahuasca visions (2002), Mavromatis on hypnagogia (1987), Jung’s Red Book and his Visions seminars; the Erowid archive answered with a challenge page, and DreamBank’s robots.txt refuses us.

H3, formal: the single ring is the simplest of a family, and richer members turn up when makers elaborate. PARTLY SUPPORTED P5 held as a count, and the registration set no threshold for calling a count support, so we do not call it more.

Outside the registered tests, three findings matter to the idea. The oldest image in the record that looks like it is the Susa knot of two serpents, dated by style to the middle of the third millennium BC, before the oldest Egyptian spell; on our reading each holds its own tail. The alchemists ran the idea in both directions: two birds that form das Bild von Zwei in Einem, the image of two in one, and a single dragon that is what remains when ein Wurm den andern gefressen, one worm has eaten the other. And no ring in the record shows the idea’s own form, S3, beyond doubt: the Tassilo chalice is reported so, and the cleanest S3 we found was made for a film in 1984, an amulet of two snakes that einander umschlingen und in die Schwänze beißen, twine round each other and bite each other’s tails.

Has anyone said this before?

No text we read argues that the single ring descends from, or poorly draws, a woven knot or ring of many serpents. The search that came back empty for this idea found an origin theory of a different kind, that the ring began as a description of an aurora, four separate ways. Its parts, though, have all been said.

Carl Jung, in a seminar given between 1934 and 1939, speaking of the alchemists’ pairs of beasts that devour each other, said, as a blog quotes the published transcript (the book itself we could not read): The simplest form is of course the dragon or the serpent that bites its own tail, in which the head is as if it belonged to another animal. In print he wrote that The uroboros, too, is often pictured in the form of two dragons engaged in the same process. John Bathurst Deane, in 1833, described a Mexican sign in which the two serpents, intertwining, form the circle with their own bodies, and set it beside the caduceus and the single ring as forms of one serpent sign. Ananda Coomaraswamy, in 1944, connected the endless knots of Leonardo and Dürer with the coils of a cosmic serpent, and called a wire whose point re-enters its own eye a snake with its tail in its mouth. And in 2025 an essay on the open web offered the idea’s image as a new symbol, the torouroboros: Unlike traditional depictions of a single serpent biting its tail in a flat loop, the torouroboros is represented by multiple interwoven serpents. None of them says the knot came first.

The check

The registration was committed to the repository before any agent was launched or any source fetched, and the commit is its date; one form, S7, was added eight minutes later, still before any source, and the file says so (its own note says an hour; a dated note at its end corrects that). Every excerpt the eighteen agents kept for a witness or a claim check is checked against the copy saved in the repository before the census is built from it. The pit’s figures are recomputed by a second route: by listing every matching for up to eight snakes, and by separate formulas for every pit up to sixty (the largest ring by cycle types, up to twenty-two snakes). Every weave the page can draw is traced through its crossings; the crossings come from the page’s own drawing code, and what follows from them (strands, linking numbers, the knot’s determinant by Fox colourings) is computed by code that shares nothing with the page’s. An agent that did not write the page read every marked claim against its source before it was published.

Two errors of ours, both caught: gathering dates for the companion page, we fetched about fifty pages from a path of Wikipedia that its robots.txt disallows, and deleted them unused; and our first brief asked each research agent to save its report as a file, which the tools refuse, so one agent wrote it with the shell instead. The file was removed, and the brief changed.

What we could not open

The registration promised a list. These could change what the record says, and we could not read them: some are in copyright or lent only, and some sites refused us or did not answer.

Each province’s dossier in the repository, under research/ouroboros/provinces/, lists the rest.

Pictures

Every picture on this page is a public-domain or openly licensed copy that the research downloaded, recording who made it, where it is held, where it came from and the day it was retrieved. Each picture’s rights were then read again at its source, by research/ouroboros/pictures/check-rights.mjs: each entry below quotes what the source says, or says that it states none or that its statement could not be read, and gives our reading of it, naming the law it rests on where that matters, as where a picture is in the public domain in the United States and its status elsewhere cannot be shown. This page serves its own copies, so a reader’s browser asks no museum or archive for anything. A caption in quotation marks quotes the picture’s title in the research’s record. Two pictures carry Creative Commons licences that ask for a credit and a link to the licence: the Book of Durrow page, and the photograph of the Sutton Hoo buckle, whose licence asks as well that adaptations be shared under it; this resized copy is. Their entries give the credit and the link.

Where each of the 19 pictures comes from
  1. Alexander Crum Brown (author of the paper); engraver not named, “Fig. 2 of 'On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces' (the Borromean rings)” (Session 1885-86 (read at the Royal Society of Edinburgh; printed in vol. 13, 1884-1886)). Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, vol. 13 (1884-1886), p. 383; scan of the copy contributed by Smithsonian Libraries (Biodiversity Heritage Library), Internet Archive item proceedings1318841886roya, leaf n422. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/proceedings1318841886roya, read 2026-11-16, says: possible-copyright-status “Not in copyright. The BHL knows of no copyright restrictions on this item.”. Our reading: Published in Edinburgh, in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh for 1884 to 1886: in the public domain in the United States, and the Biodiversity Heritage Library knows of no restriction on it. The picture: https://archive.org/details/proceedings1318841886roya, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: Cropped from the full page image (2458 x 4135 px as served) to the figure and its caption, 700 x 690 px, JPEG quality 82; no other change. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/crum-brown-1885-fig2.jpg, 700 by 690 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/17-mathematics/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  2. Drawing published by Paul Toscanne (b. 1867; date of death not found by us); the plates bear no other artist's name for these figures (fig. 442 is initialled 'P.T.'), “P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 206, fig. 394: 'Fig. 394. — Plaque de bitume.'” (published 1911). not identified (Susa find; Toscanne gives no inventory number). Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/mmoires12franuoft, read 2026-11-16, says: possible-copyright-status “NOT_IN_COPYRIGHT”; copyright-region “US”. Our reading: Published in Paris in 1911: in the public domain in the United States, the region the Internet Archive’s determination names. Toscanne’s date of death is not known to us, so we cannot show its status in France. The picture: https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n229_w1400.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: cropped to fig. 394, resized to 1400 px wide, JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/16-susa-bitumen-plaque-toscanne1911-fig394.jpg, 720 by 340 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  3. Unknown Eastern Zhou bronze caster; photograph: The Metropolitan Museum of Art (image DP155211), “Bell (niuzhong), detail of the lower panel of interlaced decoration” (Eastern Zhou dynasty, early 5th century BCE (Met record)). The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 1988.20.7 (Charlotte C. and John C. Weber Collection). Its source: https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/44518, read 2026-11-16, says: isPublicDomain “true”; creditLine “Charlotte C. and John C. Weber Collection, Gift of Charlotte C. and John C. Weber through the Live Oak Foundation, 1988”. Our reading: The Met marks this photograph public domain and releases it under its Open Access programme. The picture: https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/44518, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: crop of the lower panel (1300 x 620 px at x=850, y=2700), 1300 px wide, JPEG quality 82, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/met-1988.20.7-eastern-zhou-bell-interlace-panel.jpg, 720 by 343 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  4. Trinity College Dublin Library, Digital Collections Department (digitisation 2013), “Book of Durrow, Dublin, Trinity College Library MS 57, fol. 192v (carpet page with animal interlace)” (manuscript 'originally created c. 700' (Commons description; not checked); image 2013). Dublin, Trinity College Library, MS 57, fol. 192v. Its source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:IE_TCD_MS_57_f.192v.jpg, read 2026-11-16, says: licence “CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)”; attribution required “true”; file metadata, copyright holder “Digital image copyright the Board of Trinity College Dublin”; file metadata, usage terms “You can use this image under the terms of a CC-BY 4.0 licence which allows you to share and reuse as long as you credit: The Board of Trinity College Dublin”. Our reading: Trinity College Dublin licenses this photograph under CC BY 4.0 and asks to be credited as The Board of Trinity College Dublin. Licence: CC BY 4.0; credit: The Board of Trinity College Dublin; this copy is resized and re-encoded. The picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:IE_TCD_MS_57_f.192v.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: 960 px Wikimedia thumbnail re-encoded at JPEG quality 76. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/book-of-durrow-f192v-tcd-ccby4.jpg, 522 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  5. W. H. Holmes (author); engraver of the plate not named, “Pl. LXVI ('The Serpent'), fig. 6: 'Stone disk, Carthage, Ala.' (the Moundville 'Rattlesnake Disk'), line drawing” (Published 1883; object Mississippian). Smithsonian Libraries copy, Internet Archive item artinshellofanci00holm. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/artinshellofanci00holm, read 2026-11-16, says: possible-copyright-status “NOT_IN_COPYRIGHT”. Our reading: A United States government publication of 1883: in the public domain in the United States. The picture: https://archive.org/details/artinshellofanci00holm, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: Cropped to fig. 6 from the 2212x3566 page image at native resolution (800x740), JPEG quality 88, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/holmes-1883-pl66-fig6-carthage-disk-knotted-rattlesnakes.jpg, 720 by 666 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  6. Unknown pre-Hispanic painter(s); facsimile published by the Duc de Loubat, 1898, “Codex Borgia page 46, detail: the four-serpent square” (Pre-Hispanic; facsimile 1898). Original: Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana. Image: Wikimedia Commons, File:Codex_Borgia_page_46.jpg. Its source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Codex_Borgia_page_46.jpg, read 2026-11-16, says: licence “Public domain (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/)”; licence “PDM”. Our reading: A faithful photograph of the Duc de Loubat’s facsimile of 1898, of a book painted before the Spanish conquest. Commons marks it public domain, and says that such a photograph of a flat old work is in the public domain in the United States and that reuse may be restricted in some other countries. The picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Codex_Borgia_page_46.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: Crop (460x460) of the 1280 px thumbnail, resized to 900 px, JPEG quality 85, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/codex-borgia-p46-detail-serpent-square.jpg, 720 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  7. Engraver not named, for Antonio de León y Gama, “Lámina II: the 'second stone' (Piedra del Sol), shaded engraving” (Published 1792). John Carter Brown Library copy, Internet Archive descripcionhistr00leny, scan leaf n130 (folding plate). Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/descripcionhistr00leny, read 2026-11-16, states no rights. Our reading: An engraving published in Mexico in 1792: in the public domain everywhere. The picture: https://archive.org/details/descripcionhistr00leny, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: Cropped to the plate (2760x2870 from 3929x3466), resized to 1150 px, JPEG quality 70, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/leon-y-gama-1792-lamina-ii-piedra-del-sol.jpg, 692 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/11-africa-americas-oceania/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  8. engraver signing 'J.E.B. sc.' (reading uncertain); book attributed to 'R. Abraham Eleazar', “Engraved plate N. 1, 'Vereinige sie': two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its jaws” (1735 (Erfurt: Augustinus Crusius)). Wellcome Library (scan at the Internet Archive, item b33020541, leaf n174). The scan crops the left edge of the plate slightly; the BSB copy (IIIF bsb10912551_00047, NoC-NC) shows it whole and was not copied. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/b33020541, read 2026-11-16, says: rights “This work is available under the Creative Commons, Public Domain Mark (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/)”. Our reading: A book printed in 1735; the scan of the Wellcome Collection’s copy is marked with the Public Domain Mark. The picture: https://archive.org/details/b33020541, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: resized to 1400 px on the longest side, JPEG quality 82, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/eleazar-1735-plate-N1-wellcome.jpg, 381 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  9. engraver signing 'J.E.B. sc.' (reading uncertain); book attributed to 'R. Abraham Eleazar', “Engraved plate with figures N. 3 (two dragons, winged and crowned above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth) and N. 4 (one crowned dragon, 'Der Fixe', 'Rothe Drache', its own tail in its mouth)” (1735 (Erfurt: Augustinus Crusius)). Wellcome Library (scan at the Internet Archive, item b33020541, leaf n304). The scan cuts off the left edge of the plate; the complete plate is visible in the BSB copy (archive.org 10912552bsb, leaf n14), whose rights statement is NoC-NC, so it was not copied. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/b33020541, read 2026-11-16, says: rights “This work is available under the Creative Commons, Public Domain Mark (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/)”. Our reading: A book printed in 1735; the scan of the Wellcome Collection’s copy is marked with the Public Domain Mark. The picture: https://archive.org/details/b33020541, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: resized to 1400 px on the longest side, JPEG quality 82, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/eleazar-1735-plate-N3-N4-wellcome.jpg, 367 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  10. anonymous 18th-century illuminator (Commons: 'Sconosciuto, vissuto nel XVIII secolo'), “Two dragons forming one ring round a tree, winged above, wingless below, each with the other's tail in its mouth” (1738 (as the Commons page gives it; source of the date not stated)). Rome, Biblioteca dell'Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, MS. Verginelli-Rota (per the Commons description). Its source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Rota.V2.018.jpg, read 2026-11-16, says: licence “Public domain”; licence “Public domain (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/)”; licence “PDM”. Our reading: An eighteenth-century manuscript painting by an unknown hand; Commons marks it public domain, its copyright expired and its author anonymous. The picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Rota.V2.018.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: original size (781 x 613 px) re-encoded at JPEG quality 85, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/clavis-artis-verginelli-rota-v2-p18-commons.jpg, 720 by 565 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/07-arabic-latin-alchemy/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  11. anonymous artist; article signed with the pseudonym 'F. W. Findig' (attributed by Richard Anschütz, 1929, to Otto Nikolaus Witt, according to the Deutsches Museum catalogue; Anschütz not read), “Fig. 1 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': six monkeys (Macacus cynocephalus) forming a ring, 'ein höchst vollkommenes Analogon des Kekulé'schen Benzolsechsecks'” (1886 (the issue's session is dated 20 September 1886; the article is signed 'Im Mai 1886')). Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, No. 20, p. 3536; the scanned copy is a Harvard Library copy bound with the Berichte for 1887, digitised by Google; excerpted into a PDF by Daniel M. Perrine and uploaded to the Internet Archive (item BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft), PDF page 25. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft, read 2026-11-16, says: licenseurl “http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/”. Our reading: Printed in Berlin in 1886 under a pen name, and marked CC0 by the uploader of the archive copy. The author has been named as Otto Nikolaus Witt, who died in 1915; if that is right, it is in the public domain wherever copyright ends seventy years after the author’s death, and as an 1886 publication it is in the United States. The picture: https://archive.org/details/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: page image extracted at its native 600 ppi (1-bit) with pdfimages, cropped to the figure with its caption, scaled to 1100 px, JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/durstige-1886-p3536-fig1-six-monkeys-ring.jpg, 720 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/12-kekule/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  12. anonymous artist; article signed with the pseudonym 'F. W. Findig' (attributed by Richard Anschütz, 1929, to Otto Nikolaus Witt, according to the Deutsches Museum catalogue; Anschütz not read), “Fig. 2 of 'F. W. Findig: Zur Constitution des Benzols': the same six monkeys joined also by their tails ('caudaler Appendix'), the 'zweite Form des Kekulé-schen Sechsecks'” (1886). Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft, No. 20, p. 3536; the scanned copy is a Harvard Library copy bound with the Berichte for 1887, digitised by Google; excerpted into a PDF by Daniel M. Perrine and uploaded to the Internet Archive (item BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft), PDF page 25. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft, read 2026-11-16, says: licenseurl “http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/”. Our reading: Printed in Berlin in 1886 under a pen name, and marked CC0 by the uploader of the archive copy. The author has been named as Otto Nikolaus Witt, who died in 1915; if that is right, it is in the public domain wherever copyright ends seventy years after the author’s death, and as an 1886 publication it is in the United States. The picture: https://archive.org/details/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellschaft, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: native 600 ppi page image, cropped to the figure with its caption, scaled to 1100 px wide, JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/durstige-1886-p3536-fig2-six-monkeys-tails.jpg, 574 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/12-kekule/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  13. Plate in L. A. Waddell, The Buddhism of Tibet, or Lamaism (London: W. H. Allen, 1895), after a Tibetan painting of the Wheel of Life (Waddell: 'The Tibetan form of the picture here given'), “The Wheel of Life, Picturing the Buddhist Theory of the Universe. [To face p. 108.]” (1895 (book); the Tibetan original undated). Cornell University Library copy, scanned: https://archive.org/details/cu31924023203288, leaf n136. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/cu31924023203288, read 2026-11-16, states no rights. Our reading: Published in London in 1895; Waddell died in 1938. In the public domain in the United States and wherever copyright ends seventy years after the author’s death. The picture: https://archive.org/download/cu31924023203288/page/n136.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: crop of the hub (400 x 400 px region at x=780, y=1050 of the full scan), enlarged to 900 px, JPEG quality 85, metadata stripped. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/waddell-1895-wheel-of-life-hub.jpg, 720 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/10-south-east-asia/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  14. J. Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson (authors); photographer or draughtsman not named on the page, “Detail of fig. 327A, Fragment of upright cross-slab from Carpow, front: the panel described as a pair of sea-monsters biting each other's tails” (published 1903). The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, Part III, p. 313; the stone at Mugdrum (from Carpow), Perthshire. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/earlychristianmo03alle, read 2026-11-16, states no rights. Our reading: Published in Edinburgh in 1903: in the public domain in the United States. Its authors died in 1907 and 1916. The picture: https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: crop 450x880 px at offset (600,960), resized to 900 px high. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/ecms1903-fig327a-carpow-sea-monsters.jpg, 368 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  15. J. Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson (authors); photographer or draughtsman not named on the page, “Detail of fig. 236, Upright slab with sculpture in relief at Kettins: the pair of beasts with crossed bodies biting each other's tails (line drawing)” (published 1903). The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, Part III, p. 225; the monument at Kettins, Forfarshire. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/earlychristianmo03alle, read 2026-11-16, states no rights. Our reading: Published in Edinburgh in 1903: in the public domain in the United States. Its authors died in 1907 and 1916. The picture: https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: crop 460x480 px at offset (1180,1790), resized to 800 px wide. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/ecms1903-fig236-kettins-beasts-biting-tails.jpg, 690 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  16. J. Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson (authors); photographer or draughtsman not named on the page, “Detail of fig. 318A (top of Meigle No. 26): the whorl of three serpents” (published 1903). The book: The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, Part III, plate facing p. 304; the monument at Meigle, Perthshire. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/earlychristianmo03alle, read 2026-11-16, states no rights. Our reading: Published in Edinburgh in 1903: in the public domain in the United States. Its authors died in 1907 and 1916. The picture: https://archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: crop 640x600 px of the 2349x3307 scan at offset (900,1220), resized to 800 px wide. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/ecms1903-meigle26-three-serpent-whorl-detail.jpg, 720 by 675 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  17. Geni (Wikimedia Commons user), photograph July 2024, “Great gold buckle from Sutton Hoo, British Museum 1939,1010.1 (photograph in the gallery)” (object: not dated in the sources the research read; photograph July 2024). London, British Museum, 1939,1010.1 (registration number as given on the Commons file page). Its source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Great_gold_buckle_sutton_hoo.JPG, read 2026-11-16, says: licence “CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)”; attribution required “true”. Our reading: Photographed by Geni in 2024 and licensed by the photographer under CC BY-SA 4.0. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0; credit: Geni; this copy is resized and re-encoded, and shared under the same licence. The picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Great_gold_buckle_sutton_hoo.JPG, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: 1280 px Wikimedia thumbnail re-encoded at JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/sutton-hoo-great-gold-buckle-geni-ccbysa4.jpg, 720 by 413 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  18. Mceder (Wikimedia Commons user), photograph May 2005, “Runestone U 871 (Upplands runinskrift 871), at Skansen, Stockholm; the carving is painted in modern colours” (stone: Viking Age (not dated here); photograph May 2005). Skansen open-air museum, Stockholm (as the Commons page says: 'Photo by Mceder at Skansen May 2005'). Its source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Upplands_Runinskrift_871.jpg, read 2026-11-16, says: licence “Public domain”; attribution “Mceder”. Our reading: The photographer, Mceder, released this photograph into the public domain. The picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Upplands_Runinskrift_871.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: 960 px Wikimedia thumbnail re-encoded at JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/u871-runestone-skansen-mceder-pd.jpg, 540 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/09-norse-and-interlace/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.
  19. Drawing published by Paul Toscanne (b. 1867; date of death not found by us); the plates bear no other artist's name for these figures (fig. 442 is initialled 'P.T.'), “P. Toscanne, 'Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite', Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (1911), p. 218, fig. 442: 'Fig. 442. — Petite table en terre cuite (Suse).'” (published 1911). not identified. Its source: https://archive.org/metadata/mmoires12franuoft, read 2026-11-16, says: possible-copyright-status “NOT_IN_COPYRIGHT”; copyright-region “US”. Our reading: Published in Paris in 1911: in the public domain in the United States, the region the Internet Archive’s determination names. Toscanne’s date of death is not known to us, so we cannot show its status in France. The picture: https://archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n241_w1400.jpg, retrieved by the research on 2026-11-16. The research's kept copy: cropped to fig. 442, resized, JPEG quality 82. Self-hosted at public/strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/img/16-susa-terracotta-table-toscanne1911-fig442.jpg, 706 by 720 pixels (metadata stripped, JPEG quality 80). Records: research/ouroboros/provinces/16-near-east-entwined/media/provenance.json and research/ouroboros/pictures/rights.json.

Sources

Every source this page cites, with the date it was read.

  1. "F. W. Findig" (pseudonym), "Zur Constitution des Benzols", Berichte der Durstigen Chemischen Gesellschaft No. 20 (Berlin, 1886), pp. 3535-3537, pp. 3535-3536 · archive.org/download/BerichteDerDurstigenChemischenGesellsch…, read 2026-11-16
  2. A. Crum Brown, 'On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces', Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 13 (Session 1885-86) 382-386; Internet Archive item proceedings1318841886roya, page images n422 (p. 383) and n423 (p. 384), p. 383 · archive.org/details/proceedings1318841886roya, read 2026-11-16
  3. A. de León y Gama, Descripcion histórica y cronológica de las dos piedras, México 1792, p. 103, §67 · archive.org/download/descripcionhistr00leny/page/n112_w1800.…, read 2026-11-16
  4. Alessio Di Prisa and Oğuz Şavk, 'Turk's head knots and links: a survey', arXiv:2409.20106v3 [math.GT], 12 Jan 2026, p. 5 · arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20106, read 2026-11-16
  5. Allen, The Ancient Egyptian Pyramid Texts (2005), p. 91 · archive.org/details/the-ancient-egyptian-pyramid-texts_20210…, read 2026-11-16
  6. Ananda K. Coomaraswamy, 'The Iconography of Dürer's "Knots" and Leonardo's "Concatenation"', The Art Quarterly 7.2 (Spring 1944), 109-128; read in the reprint, Eye of the Heart 4 (Bendigo: La Trobe University, 2009), 11-40 · www.themathesontrust.org/papers/art/AKC-Durers_Knots.pdf, read 2026-11-16
  7. Anti-Slavery Bugle 3(27), 18 Feb. 1848, p. 3, col. 3 · archive.org/download/sim_anti-slavery-bugle_1848-02-18_3_27/…, read 2026-11-16
  8. Appletons' Journal 6(132), 7 Oct. 1871, p. 419 · archive.org/download/sim_appletons-journal-a-magazine-of-gen…, read 2026-11-16
  9. Bucher 1932, p. 161 · archive.org/details/MIFAO-60, read 2026-11-16
  10. Budge, The Egyptian Heaven and Hell, vol. II (1906), p. 122 · archive.org/details/egyptianheavenhe0002budg, read 2026-11-16
  11. C. B. Moore, 'Certain Aboriginal Remains of the Black Warrior River', Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 2nd ser. 13 (1905), p. 136, Fig. 7 · archive.org/download/certainaborigin00moor/page/n19_w2400.jp…, read 2026-11-16
  12. C. G. Jung, Nietzsche's Zarathustra: Notes of the Seminar Given in 1934-1939, ed. James L. Jarrett, Princeton 1988, pp. 1286-1287 (as cited by the blog; book not read) · carljungdepthpsychologysite.blog/2020/08/18/uroboros/, read 2026-11-16
  13. C. G. Jung, Psychology and Religion: West and East (CW 11), 'Transformation Symbolism in the Mass', para. 351 and footnote; same text in The Mysteries (1955) · archive.org/services/search/beta/page_production/?service_ba…, read 2026-11-16
  14. C. Micheletti, D. Marenduzzo, E. Orlandini, 'Polymers with spatial or topological constraints: theoretical and computational results', arXiv:1103.4222; Physics Reports 504(1) (2011) 1-73, DOI 10.1016/j.physrep.2011.03.003 (Crossref checked), PDF p. 71 · arxiv.org/pdf/1103.4222, read 2026-11-16
  15. Crossref metadata for DOI 10.37236/3643 · api.crossref.org/works/10.37236/3643, read 2026-11-16
  16. Dante, Inferno XXIV 94-96 (Petrocchi text, Italian Wikisource) · it.wikisource.org/wiki/Divina_Commedia/Inferno/Canto_XXIV, read 2026-11-16
  17. Darnell 2004, OBO 198, p. 374 · www.zora.uzh.ch/server/api/core/bitstreams/b98aa8f3-f5a3-468…, read 2026-11-16
  18. Darnell and Darnell 2018, p. 192 · www.sbl-site.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Netherworld.pdf, read 2026-11-16
  19. de.wikipedia, 'Die unendliche Geschichte (Film)' · de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Die_unendliche_Geschichte_(Film), read 2026-11-16
  20. Der neue Pitaval, ed. J. E. Hitzig and W. Häring (W. Alexis), vol. 17 (Zweite Folge, vol. 5), 2nd ed. (Leipzig: F. A. Brockhaus, 1860), "Die Gräfin von Görlitz und ihr Diener (1847-1850)", p. 169 · archive.org/download/derneuepitavale10vollgoog/page/n187_w14…, read 2026-11-16
  21. Druce 1910, p. 288 (OCR) · archive.org/download/amphisbaena-images/Amphisbaena_djvu.txt, read 2026-11-16
  22. e-codices, Zurich ZB Ms. Rh. 172, summary · www.e-codices.unifr.ch/en/list/one/zbz/Ms-Rh-0172, read 2026-11-16
  23. Eduard Seler, Codex Borgia: eine altmexikanische Bilderschrift, vol. II, Berlin 1906, p. 75 · archive.org/details/codex-borgia_20220902, read 2026-11-16
  24. English Wikipedia, Teti · en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teti, read 2026-11-16
  25. Escher in Het Paleis, 'Möbius Strip I' (Escher Today, 13 March 2017), quoting Escher, The Graphic Work of M.C. Escher · escherinhetpaleis.nl/escher-today/mobius-strip-i/?lang=en, read 2026-11-16
  26. Gustav Schultz, "Bericht über die Feier der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft zu Ehren August Kekulé's", Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 23 (1890), pp. 1265-1312; Kekulé's reply pp. 1302-1311, p. 1306 · archive.org/download/kekules-dreams-1890/Kekule%27s%20dreams…, read 2026-11-16
  27. Harper, Aruz and Tallon 1992, no. 52, p. 86 · archive.org/details/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasur…, read 2026-11-16
  28. Henry Ernest Dudeney, Puzzles and Curious Problems, Thomas Nelson and Sons Ltd., London etc. (no date on the title page of the copy read; preface by Alice Dudeney dated December 1931), problem 324 'The Two Snakes', pp. 111-112, solution p. 181; Internet Archive item dli.ministry.19463, page images n115, n116, n185, pp. 111-112 · archive.org/download/dli.ministry.19463/page/n116_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  29. Hoosier Folklore, June 1948, p. 55 · archive.org/download/hoosier-folklore-june-1948/page/n24_w14…, read 2026-11-16
  30. Hope Star, 9 Aug. 1951, p. 1 (AP column by Hal Boyle) · archive.org/download/hope-star-1951-08-09/page/n0_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  31. J. B. Ambrosetti, 'El bronce en la región calchaquí', Anales del Museo Nacional de Buenos Aires XI (1904), p. 288 and Fig. 86 b (p. 287) · archive.org/download/arqueologaargen01ambrgoog/page/n132_w14…, read 2026-11-16
  32. J. Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson, The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, 1903, Part III, p. 304 (leaf n437); plate LXV (leaf n438) · archive.org/details/earlychristianmo03alle, read 2026-11-16
  33. J. Romilly Allen, Celtic Art in Pagan and Christian Times, 1904, p. 293 (leaf n404); plate facing p. 292 (leaf n402) · archive.org/details/cu31924030654879, read 2026-11-16
  34. Jeffrey C. Lagarias, 'Euler's constant: Euler's work and modern developments', arXiv:1303.1856v6, 25 Oct 2013; Bulletin of the AMS 50(4) (2013) 527-628, DOI 10.1090/S0273-0979-2013-01423-X (Crossref checked; journal version not read), p. 53 · arxiv.org/pdf/1303.1856, read 2026-11-16
  35. John Bathurst Deane, The Worship of the Serpent Traced throughout the World, 2nd ed., London: J. G. & F. Rivington, 1833, p. 54 · archive.org/download/worshipofserpent00dean/page/n79_w1400.j…, read 2026-11-16
  36. John Bathurst Deane, The Worship of the Serpent Traced throughout the World, attesting the Temptation and Fall of Man by the Instrumentality of a Serpent Tempter, 2nd ed., London: J. G. & F. Rivington, 1833 · archive.org/details/worshipofserpent00dean, read 2026-11-16
  37. Julius Ruska, 'Studien zu Muhammad Ibn Umail al-Tamimi's Kitab al-Ma' al-Waraqi wa'l-Ard an-Najmiyah', Isis 24, no. 2 (1936), p. 313 · archive.org/details/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2, read 2026-11-16
  38. Julius Ruska, Isis 24 (1936), p. 315 (summary file; copyright caution: short phrase only) · archive.org/download/sim_isis_1936-02_24_2/page/n10_w1400.jp…, read 2026-11-16
  39. L. A. Waddell, 'The Buddhist Pictorial Wheel of Life', JASB 61, Part I, No. 3 (1892), p. 136 · archive.org/download/dli.calcutta.00058/page/n343_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  40. L. A. Waddell, The Buddhism of Tibet, or Lamaism, London: W. H. Allen, 1895, p. 109 · archive.org/download/cu31924023203288/page/n138_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  41. Les figures hieroglyphiques (1612), p. 69 · archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n70_w1400.j…, read 2026-11-16
  42. M. Berthelot and Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Collection des anciens alchimistes grecs, Paris: Steinheil, 1887-1888, vol. 1, Texte grec p. 22 lines 1-3 (page image n323) · archive.org/details/collectiondesanc01bert, read 2026-11-16
  43. Macrobius, Saturnalia, ed. L. von Jan, Quedlinburg and Leipzig 1852, as transcribed on LacusCurtius by Bill Thayer, Saturnalia 1.19.16 (after von Jan p. 184 break) · penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/L/Roman/Texts/Macrobius/Saturna…, read 2026-11-16
  44. Maier, Atalanta fugiens (1618), Discursus XIV, p. 66 · archive.org/download/atalantafugiensh00maie/page/n73_w1400.j…, read 2026-11-16
  45. Maine Farmer 7(50), 21 Dec. 1839, p. 1, col. 4 · archive.org/download/sim_maine-farmer_1839-12-21_7_50/page/n…, read 2026-11-16
  46. Mark Smith, "Torouroboros: Archetype of the Regenaissance", eleprocon.substack.com, 2025-06-09 · eleprocon.substack.com/p/torouroboros-archetype-of-the-regen…, read 2026-11-16
  47. mcescher.com, gallery caption (LW 448) · mcescher.com/gallery/most-popular/, read 2026-11-16
  48. Methodist Magazine and Quarterly Review 17(2), April 1835, p. 210 · archive.org/download/sim_methodist-review_1835-04_17_2/page/…, read 2026-11-16
  49. Michael Ende, Die unendliche Geschichte, Stuttgart: Thienemann, 1979 (German text via OCR snippets of an archive.org upload; no page numbers) · archive.org/services/search/beta/page_production/?service_ba…, read 2026-11-16
  50. Musaeum hermeticum (1678), p. 356 · archive.org/download/musaeumhermeticu00meri/page/n373_w1400.…, read 2026-11-16
  51. Nicholas Pippenger, 'Random Cyclations', arXiv:math/0408031v1 [math.CO], 3 Aug 2004; published in The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics 20(4) (2013), article P9, DOI 10.37236/3643 (Crossref checked; journal version not read), p. 3 · arxiv.org/pdf/math/0408031, read 2026-11-16
  52. Oehrl 2013, p. 455 · archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-alte…, read 2026-11-16
  53. Oehrl 2013, p. 460 and Abb. 15, n. 66 · archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-alte…, read 2026-11-16
  54. Oehrl 2013, p. 462 (OCR) and p. 463, Abb. 20d (page image) · archive.org/download/das-uroboros-motiv-im-germanischen-alte…, read 2026-11-16
  55. OEIS, The On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences, entry A084945 (internal format, as served 2026-11-16) · oeis.org/A084945/internal, read 2026-11-16
  56. Olive Bray (ed. and tr.), The Elder or Poetic Edda, Part I, 1908, pp. 288-289 (leaves n375, n376), Voluspa 38 · archive.org/details/elderorpoeticedd01brayuoft, read 2026-11-16
  57. P. O. Harper, J. Aruz and F. Tallon (eds.), The Royal City of Susa (New York, 1992), no. 52, p. 85 · archive.org/download/RoyalCityofSusaAncientNearEasternTreasu…, read 2026-11-16
  58. Pablo Amaringo, commentary to Vision 29, in Luna and Amaringo, Ayahuasca Visions (compilation read) · archive.org/download/ethnobotany.-harner-1972-hallucinogens-…, read 2026-11-16
  59. Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 207 · archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n230_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  60. Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 217 · archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n240_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  61. Paul Toscanne, "Études sur le serpent, figure et symbole dans l'antiquité élamite", Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 12 (Paris: Leroux, 1911), pp. 153-228, p. 218 · archive.org/download/mmoires12franuoft/page/n241_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  62. Philippe Flajolet and Robert Sedgewick, Analytic Combinatorics, Cambridge University Press, 2009, ISBN 978-0-521-89806-5; free author-hosted e-version dated June 26, 2009, p. 120 · algo.inria.fr/flajolet/Publications/book.pdf, read 2026-11-16
  63. Pinakes (IRHT), notice Paris, BNF, Grec 2327, diktyon 51958 · pinakes.irht.cnrs.fr/notices/cote/51958/, read 2026-11-16
  64. Pliny, Naturalis Historia 29.52, ed. C. Mayhoff, vol. IV (Leipzig: Teubner, 1897), p. 386 · archive.org/download/cplinisecundina01mayhgoog/page/n402_w14…, read 2026-11-16
  65. research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md · research/ouroboros/PREREGISTRATION.md
  66. S. Sharpe and J. Bonomi, The Alabaster Sarcophagus of Oimeneptah I. (London, 1864), p. 24 and Plate 5 · archive.org/details/alabastersarcoph64shar, read 2026-11-16
  67. Shine, Harlow, LeMaster, Moore and Mason, Animal Behaviour 59 (2000) 349-359 · masonlab.ib.oregonstate.edu/sites/masonlab.ib.oregonstate.ed…, read 2026-11-16
  68. Temple Bar 81 (Dec. 1887), p. 484 · archive.org/download/sim_temple-bar_1887-12_81_325/page/n79_…, read 2026-11-16
  69. the commission, 2026-11-15 (research/ouroboros/COMMISSION.md) · research/ouroboros/COMMISSION.md
  70. The Metropolitan Museum of Art Collection API, object 44518 (1988.20.7) · collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/445…, read 2026-11-16
  71. Theatrum chemicum V (1622), Consilium coniugii, p. 495 · archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n523_…, read 2026-11-16
  72. Theatrum chemicum V (1622), p. 218 (leaf n244) · archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n244_…, read 2026-11-16
  73. Theatrum chemicum V (1622), Senior, leaf n252 · archive.org/download/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05/page/n252_…, read 2026-11-16
  74. Theatrum chemicum, vol. V (Strasbourg: heirs of L. Zetzner, 1622), Senioris Zadith Tabula chimica, p. 219 and next page · archive.org/details/BIUSante_pharma_res011287x05, read 2026-11-16
  75. Thomas Pennant, British Zoology, vol. III (Warrington, 1776), p. 32 · archive.org/download/britishzoology31penn/page/n49_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  76. Trois traitez de la philosophie naturelle ... plus, Les figures hierogliphiques de Nicolas Flamel (Paris: Guillaume Marette, 1612), p. 68 · archive.org/download/troistraitezdela00arna/page/n69_w1400.j…, read 2026-11-16
  77. Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 1, p. 17 · api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb10912551_00057/f…, read 2026-11-16
  78. Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 2, p. 8 · archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n13_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  79. Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 2, p. 9 · archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n16_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  80. Uraltes chymisches Werck (Erfurt 1735), part 2, plate N. 3 (our description) · archive.org/download/10912552bsb/page/n14_w1400.jpg, read 2026-11-16
  81. Villarejo 1953: 190, quoted in Harner, 'Common Themes', in Harner (ed.) 1973, p. 164 · archive.org/download/ethnobotany.-harner-1972-hallucinogens-…, read 2026-11-16
  82. W. H. Holmes, 'Art in Shell of the Ancient Americans', Second Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology 1880-81, Washington 1883, p. 278 and Pl. LXVI fig. 6 · archive.org/download/artinshellofanci00holm/page/n171_w2200.…, read 2026-11-16
  83. W. H. Holmes, 'Certain Notched or Scalloped Stone Tablets of the Mound-Builders', American Anthropologist n.s. 8 (1906), p. 104 and fig. 8 · archive.org/details/jstor-659168, read 2026-11-16
  84. Wikimedia Commons, File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Rota.V2.018.jpg (file description) · commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ClavisArtis.MS.Verginelli-Ro…, read 2026-11-16
  85. Wikimedia Commons, File:Ibn Umayl The Silvery Water.jpg (file description page) · commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ibn_Umayl_The_Silvery_Water.…, read 2026-11-16
  86. Wikipedia, 'Linking number', as served 2026-11-16 · en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linking_number, read 2026-11-16
  87. Y. Endoh, Quine Relay, README.md (master), fetched 2026-11-16 · raw.githubusercontent.com/mame/quine-relay/master/README.md, read 2026-11-16
  88. Zelia Nuttall, The Fundamental Principles of Old and New World Civilizations, Peabody Museum Papers II, 1901, p. 257 · archive.org/download/fundamentalprinc00nutt/page/n260_w1500.…, read 2026-11-16
The registration, as written before the evidence
# Pre-registration: the knot of many snakes

Written 2026-11-16 by claude-epic-gates-wpqedf, before any research agent of this
investigation had been launched and before any source had been fetched for it. The commit
that adds this file is the timestamp. Nothing below may be edited after the first research
dossier lands; changes go in a dated section at the end, marked as made after seeing data.

## The hypothesis, in the words of the person who proposed it

The human who owns this project, live, on 2026-11-15:

> the symbol is a fairly poor visual representation of an imagined vision involving a sort
> of woven knot of many snakes, each devouring the tail of another

The house rule for a commissioned subject applies: the suggester picks the subject, never
the verdict.

## What the registrant already believed (unverified, from training, disclosed)

I am a language model and arrive with recollections I have not checked. Before fetching
anything I believed, with varying confidence:

- that the oldest surviving drawing usually cited is on the second gilded shrine of
  Tutankhamun, and shows two separate serpents, each with its own tail at its own mouth;
- that Kekule's 1890 account of his reverie describes many snake-like chains and then one
  of them seizing its own tail;
- that a 1612 text printed under Nicolas Flamel's name speaks of serpents and dragons, in
  the plural, painted in a circle by the Egyptians, and that an alchemical figure of two
  beasts biting each other's tails exists (Abraham Eleazar, 1735);
- that Germanic and Insular interlace is full of knotted beasts that bite, and that the
  Norse world serpent is a single animal;
- that nobody, to my knowledge, has argued in print that the single ring abbreviates a
  woven knot of many.

These are leads. Any of them may be wrong, and each is checked like any other claim. They
are listed so a reader can see what the registrant expected before the evidence arrived.

## Three readings, because the sentence can mean three things

**H1, historical.** The single tail-eating serpent descends from, or abbreviates, an older
or more primary image of several interwoven serpents, each devouring another's tail.

**H2, visionary.** When people report a vision (a dream, a trance, a drug state, a
reverie) in which a tail-devouring serpent appears, what they describe is plural and
intertwined, and the single ring is how the vision gets drawn or retold afterwards.

**H3, formal.** Apart from any history, the single ring is the simplest member of a family
(rings of n serpents, woven through c crossings), and the richer members of that family
turn up again and again when makers elaborate the idea.

## The categories, fixed now

A *witness* is one object, drawing or passage of text that can be dated and located, read
by us in a source we can name. For each witness we record one form:

- **S1** one serpent, its own tail in or at its own mouth.
- **S2** two or more serpents forming one ring, each with the tail of the next in or at
  its mouth, the bodies not crossing.
- **S3** two or more serpents, interlaced or knotted (the bodies cross), each with the tail
  of another in or at its mouth. This is the hypothesis's own image.
- **S4** two or more serpents, interlaced or knotted into a closed figure, where the biting
  is absent, or is of something other than another's tail (its own body, a neighbour's
  neck, a third thing).
- **S5** two or more separate S1 rings on one object.
- **S6** one serpent knotted or interlaced with itself, tail in mouth or not.
- **S7** two or more serpents forming one closed ring without crossing and without any
  head taking another's tail (two serpents meeting head to head and tail to tail, for one).
- **S0** a serpent that encircles without any mouth-to-tail contact being shown or stated.

(S7 was added on 2026-11-16, an hour after the first commit of this file and still before
any research agent was launched or any source fetched: writing the agents' leads showed
that the first list had no place for a ring of two serpents that meet face to face. For
P1 and P5, S7 counts with S2, S3 and S4 as a plural form.)

"At its mouth" covers the drawings where head and tail meet without visible swallowing; the
witness record says which. A text counts for a category only by what its words say.

## The predictions, and what would count

**P1 (for H1).** In the oldest tradition (Egypt), among the five earliest securely dated
witnesses that are S1 to S7, at least one is S2, S3, S4 or S7.
*Counts against:* all five are S1 or S5.

**P2 (for H1).** Some text older than AD 500, from any tradition, describes the encircling
or tail-devouring figure as more than one serpent, or as twisted, plaited or knotted.
*Counts against:* none found, in a search that demonstrably could find such a text (see
the positive control).

**P3 (for H1).** Some source older than AD 1700 says in so many words that the drawn
figure stands for something more complex than what is drawn (several things shown as one).
*Counts for, weakly:* any such statement. *Says nothing either way:* none found.

**P4 (for H2).** Collect every first-person vision report we can source in which a serpent
takes its own or another's tail in its mouth. In more than half of them, the report
describes several serpents or intertwining.
*Counts against:* half or fewer. *Cannot be judged:* fewer than four reports found.

**P5 (for H3).** S2, S3, S4 or S7 witnesses exist in at least three traditions with no
plausible line of borrowing between them. This one is a census, reported as a count with
every member shown, and we set no threshold for calling it support.

## The verdict words, fixed now

For each of H1, H2 and H3, the page will say one of: **supported**, **partly supported**
(naming which prediction held), **not supported** (the search could have found support and
did not), or **cannot be judged from what we could read** (naming what was unreadable).
"Refuted" is not on the list: absence from a broken, partial record refutes nothing, and
the page will say so rather than imply more.

## The positive control

A census that cannot find plural rings where they are known to exist tells nobody
anything. So the same search, with the same categories, must return the alchemical
two-beast figures (expected S2) if they exist as I believe they do. If it does not return
them, the census is not pointed at the record and its zeros are worth nothing.

## What is free and is declared as free

- The category boundaries above are ours. Another reader could draw S4 differently.
- "Securely dated" in P1 means dated by the object's archaeological context or a dated
  manuscript, in a source we read; a witness dated only by style is listed and not counted.
- "No plausible line of borrowing" in P5 is a judgement, and each case will say on what.
- The record is what we could read under the house's source rules (robots.txt read first,
  refusals respected). A witness in a book we could not open is not in the census, and the
  page will list what we know we could not open.

## What this registration does not cover

The history of the single ring (who drew it, what they called it, what they said it meant)
is the larger part of the investigation and needs no hypothesis. It is reported as found.

## Note added 2026-11-16, after the research (a correction of fact, not of substance)

The S7 paragraph above says S7 was added "an hour after the first commit of this file". The
commits are 0afcbba (00:08:41 UTC) and 9e72cfd (00:16:56 UTC): eight minutes apart, not an hour.
Both came before the first logged fetch of the research (00:20:55 UTC). The independent claims
pass of /strata/each-devouring-the-tail-of-another/ found the error. Nothing else is changed.
The claims record 284 claims re-read against their sources, 16 November 2026

Written 2026-11-16. Claims re-read against their sources on 2026-11-16: 284 checked, 194 confirmed, 13 wrong, 1 unverifiable, 76 first-hand observations checked against their record. By one agent on oversight/claims-pass.md for the whole source record and the page, dispatched by claude-epic-gates-wpqedf, who re-read each finding against its source before fixing.

The pass checked commit 749d9bb (227 record entries) plus 20 claims the record left out, after running scripts/robots-policy.mjs on every URL it fetched (no refusals; two reference-tier hosts read once). It recomputed the census from catalogue.json (59 cards, 0 differences in form, date, title, quotation, translation or citation), every figure of the pit and the strings by its own code, and the five earliest securely dated Egyptian witnesses; it found the verdicts on P1 to P5 and H1 to H3 follow the registration's own words. All 18 MINOR lines are counted as confirmed. **The pictures pass (2026-11-16, later the same day).** The page gained public-domain and openly licensed pictures, each with an apparatus of where it comes from. One agent on oversight/claims-pass.md, who did not make them, looked at every picture against its caption, its alt text, the catalogue witness and the provenance record, and read the rights of 37 pictures again at 30 sources (robots policy first). Its first report found fifteen things; all were fixed, a re-check found each fixed and three small new points, which were fixed, and a final check of the last commit confirmed them. The lines below the earlier ones are that pass: one per entry the pictures added to assay/sources, and the first pass's wrong and near-miss findings that were not marked claims.

This record is long (284 claim lines and 19 findings), so it is not part of the page until you open it. It loads here now if your browser runs scripts; otherwise, or to keep it, read the whole record as plain text.

The assay office: what a record is, and every layer re-read so far.